10 Video Game Franchises That ALWAYS Get It Wrong

How does it always go so wrong?

By James Metcalfe /

Making a video game is no small feat. From the expectations that come from publishers to the difficulties in managing development teams often spread across different timezones.

Advertisement

Actually having something hit shelves - physical or otherwise - is an achievement in itself.

Couple that with all the creative and technical requirements that come with actually making a game good. But, nail all of those things, and the rewards are huge. Unlike something like the film industry, franchises become so beloved so quickly and command such loyal fanbases that they can continue on even with a flop in their back pocket.

And yet for some video game franchises it feels as though the development team live permanently under the shadow of a literal curse.

Even if the enduring popularity of main characters and past glories are enough to see sequels continue to get the green light, they never seem to grasp where anything has been going wrong, and what fans actually want from one of their titles.

10. Duke Nukem

Despite some solid sales and an infamous reputation amongst gamers, Duke Nukem has always felt like a franchise decades behind everyone else. The two 2D side-scrollers that kicked off the series were hardly revolutionary in their day, and even the franchise's high point in Duke Nukem 3D came with just as much controversy as success.

Advertisement

Having been accused of promoting everything from pornography to murder, Gearbox were forced to release censored versions of the game and were even banned in certain countries.

And this unapologetically brash tone would plague the franchise for well over a decade as Gearbox struggled to release a new entry.

For fifteen years the Duke Nukem series would be stuck in development hell, during which time its already polarising themes became even more repugnant with gamers. When Duke Nukem Forever finally dropped in 2011, it quickly became clear the developers hadn't taken the time to realise this.

It's quite an achievement to have overly-simplistic gameplay that still feels unpolished, but that's what Forever managed to nail following its release. Couple this with an abundance of dated references and toilet humour, and it's a recipe for a franchise-killer.

9. Mega Man

The history of the Mega Man series is a tale of diverting from a winning formula, bleeding the living daylights out of it, and then continuing to pump titles out afterwards.

Advertisement

With the main series kicking off in 1987, the first few entries on the Nintendo Entertainment System became known for some of the most unforgiving platforming in the business, trailblazing a spot for Mega Man alongside the likes of Mario and Sonic.

But, as gaming became more mainstream and titles found ways of appealing more to the masses, Mega Man gave up its biggest selling point. Stripping back gruelling elements that never felt ridiculously unfair in favour of little games that were pure guesswork, Capcom would continue to pump out at least one game every year across the '90s, before hitting the brakes and waiting nearly a decade to continue with Mega Man 9.

To be fair this was a solid return to form for the series, however, the follow-up to it, Mega Man 10, was a stark reminder that the developers still hadn't learned their lesson.

Gameplay was overly similar, and level design had infuriating difficulty spikes that screamed 'unintuitive experience'.

Just like old times.

8. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater

For a certain demographic, the Tony Hawk Pro Skater games were the reason why 'professional skateboarder' became a popular career aspiration in the mid-2000s. Whilst I was perfectly happy just aimlessly skating around back in the day, early games like Tony Hawk's Underground proved a strong storyline could accompany arcade-style gameplay.

Advertisement

Sadly though, this winning formula wouldn't be something the franchise would be keen on continuing. Starting with Tony Hawk's Downhill Jam, a strange 2006 racing title, the series would rack up a long list of entries that all seemed to insist on being unlike what gamers had come to know the franchise for.

As its heyday on the PS2 gave way to more releases on more contemporary hardware, the developers would fall back to simplistic gameplay mechanics and a new line of bland characters to play as.

Perhaps the best example of Activision not understanding what was needed for the series on modern equipment is 2012's Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD. An arcade-style title designed to bring the feel of the first two entries in the franchise, the game felt incredibly lacklustre and eventually found itself delisted from Steam in 2017.

These classic first two entries in the series would end up getting a more-than-solid remake in 2020, however, when it was revealed developers Vicarious Visions would be merging with Blizzard and no further remasters would be on the horizon, it was another reminder that Activision still don't really know what they're doing with the IP.

To not have a remake of Tony Hawk 3, one of the greatest video games of all time, immediately following on the heels of 1+2's remastering is the biggest crime to skateboaring since the last time this article's author picked up a board for himself.

7. Mario Sports Titles

Super Mario Kart did the impossible and showed the gaming world that their favourite mascots would still be able to shift thousands of units, even outside of the confines of the genre they were known for.

Advertisement

Gamers that would never have considered picking up certain genres now would, just because they had Mario and his friends on the cover.

The Mario Sports franchise has been a story of undervaluing the games people have always loved, whilst absolutely flogging the living hell out of the ones they don't. As an example: there have been 16(!) Mario Tennis and Golf titles in total, but only 6 Strikers and Baseball games.

The Sports franchise is often used as a way for Nintendo to capitalise on holiday sales, without ever having to put any effort into making a game that is... actually finished. Mario Sports Mix only featured four playable sports, Mario Tennis Ultra Smash only featured one court to play on, Mario Strikers Battle League only came with ten playable characters and no real campaign. It's an infuriating cycle.

Reused character graphics and animations in the same sports being pumped out with next-to-nothing new introduced? Nice corner-cutting, Nintendo.

6. Resident Evil

Coming off one of the most defining releases of its day in Resident Evil 4, Capcom made the decision to strip the series of its survival horror roots and gothic settings in favour of increasingly action-packed, cinematic entries in RE5 and RE6. And their ratings tanked because of it.

Advertisement

It threw Capcom into a five-year rethink, resulting in Resident Evil 7: Biohazard.

Biohazard singlehandedly put the series back at the forefront of the industry, with its small collection of characters, one single location and stripped-back survival horror gameplay creating an authentic and genuinely scary experience.

Its sequel, Resident Evil Village, was hotly anticipated and looked set to expand on the formula set out by Biohazard in a creepy gothic European setting. The best part of Village comes during the opening sequences when players are forced to navigate through various buildings and dilapidated village areas, terrified of every bird or scarecrow because they are so vulnerable.

And yet, even in these "high" points for the franchise, Capcom still had to throw in grandiose encounters no one asked for.

In Biohazard, players are forced to face off against an overly mutated version of Jack Baker. In Village, even the elegant Lady Dimitrescu was turned into a giant winged-dragon creature for her final battle. Not only do these two fights feel out of place with the characters and the tones of their respective titles, but they are easily amongst the most polarising moments in the games amongst fans.

Too bad Capcom still haven't learned big guns and big monsters don't equal more fun.

5. Castlevania

Bursting onto the scene on the Nintendo Family Computer Disk System, Castlevania has been entrenched in the video game industry for over thirty-five years now. Like Mega Man, the series garnered a solid reputation amongst gamers for its gruelling difficulty, but sadly, Konami would lose sight of its gothic side-scrolling roots the longer the series went on.

Advertisement

1997's Symphony of the Night was the defining point of the franchise, trailblazing the Metroidvania genre but changing the landscape for entries going forward.

With spin-offs, remakes and remasters all spawning from the success of the Castlevania name, the brakes were well and truly ripped off and tossed aside. Unfortunately, that has led to a slew of titles making their way onto shelves that have fallen well short of standards.

The likes of Castlevania Chronicles, Lords Of Shadow 2, Harmony Of Despair and Judgement have all been released on different systems and have all attempted to do something different. But, from games coming without Ayami Kojima's distinct art style, to being ported so much that the shine has been eroded entirely, Castlevania is one of those names that has become synonymous with taking its eyes off the ball.

4. Assassin's Creed

Remember when Assassin's Creed was the one game EVERYONE loved?

Advertisement

With the release of Assassin's Creed Brotherhood in 2010, Ubisoft boasted a franchise that sold well, was received well and pioneered the way in which video games were marketed online. However, from that entry onwards, it's been a frustrating series of hit-or-miss titles that have failed to match the magic of the franchise's heyday.

The company's rigid approach to one main entry being released annually led to games like Assassin's Creed Revelations, AC III, Unity and Syndicate hitting shelves and being painfully lacking in original content, with an unhealthy amount of technical bugs.

This increasingly lukewarm reception led to Ubisoft reassessing their 'title every year' policy, with a reboot of sorts in Assassin's Creed Origins. Origins introduced more RPG elements and felt like something fresh, but its two successors showed that the company hadn't fully learned their lesson about pumping out overly-similar games.

Both Assassins Creed Odyssey and Valhalla just didn't have the same acclaim behind them as earlier entries in the franchise, and both still contained elements of repetitive gameplay and technical issues the likes of Unity and Syndicate became so polarising off the back of.

3. FIFA

If there's one series that has taken to releasing video games at a near-racketeering level, it's Fifa.

Advertisement

With at least one title in the series released every year since 1993, Fifa has become the go-to game for fans of the beautiful game. Reflecting the updates to every team's squad, kits and competitions they're competing in, EA have players over a barrel. If they want the most up-to-date experience, they have to buy the latest game each year.

Unfortunately, this has led to an infamous reputation amongst gamers that the Fifa franchise is a continuous cycle of pumping out essentially the same game and demanding £50 each time for good measure.

What's more, fans have become increasingly vocal over what they perceive as EA's true priority when it comes to developing the series. Microtransactions through Ultimate Team packs and promos have become the order of the day, whilst upgrades to other modes like Career Mode or fixes to things like scripting remain ever-present.

EA can harp on about Hypermotion technology all they want, Fifa has largely felt the same since 2008.

2. Crash Bandicoot

Crash Bandicoot had become the face of the PlayStation brand in the late '90s, with the first three entries in the franchise cementing the mascot alongside the likes of Mario and Sonic. But, as the series moved across to new platforms and new systems, a conga line of mediocre releases took the sparkle off everything.

Advertisement

2001's Wrath of Cortex was the first instance of a Crash game not being acclaimed upon release. The game had been criticised for playing things too safe, which resulted in the different companies developing the franchise going forward going too hard on the flip side.

Twinsanity, Crash of the Titans and Mind over Mutant were all very unique titles in their own right, but just so much so that they hardly felt like a Bandicoot game at all. Development swapped hands frequently which, coupled with the constant switch-ups in tone and direction, meant actually making these games became huge tasks, often completed with a slew of cut content and technical problems.

Throw all of this in with some strange decisions over character designs and voice acting, and it resulted in Crash going back to the drawing board with nearly a decade without a new entry. When The N Sane Trilogy and Crash 4: It's About Time did arrive, however, they landed with a hefty amount of acclaim behind them, so perhaps all is not lost for Activision's favourite Bandicoot just yet.

1. Sonic The Hedgehog

If there were ever a TED talk on how to continually ruin one of the most legendary characters of all time, SEGA would surely be in the running as its keynote speaker.

Advertisement

At one point legitimately seen as a solid competitor to Nintendo and Super Mario, the early Sonic the Hedgehog titles were always the games cool older brothers would play. Filled with blistering levels and a swagger his Italian plumber rival could never hope to match, SEGA's main mascot dominated the early part of the 1990s.

However, since then, the Sonic series has been a long and frustrating timeline of poorly-made games and baffling creative directions. The struggle of transitioning the franchise from 2D platformer to 3D led to the dark age of the mid-2000s, where SEGA manic brainstorming led to everything from Shadow being kitted out with a machine gun to Sonic being smooched by an anime princess.

In more recent times, the failed Sonic Boom reboot managed to find a way of being a tone-deaf and poorly made game, whereas most people wait for buses for a longer time than it takes to complete Sonic Forces.

Even the most recent addition to the franchise, Sonic Frontiers, is not a title most fans are ready to shout about and recommend in its entirety. Whilst it is easily the best entry since Generations, there are still a number of glitches and instances where it struggles with severe pop-in, even on Xbox Series X and PS5, reminding gamers that SEGA aren't able to smash out a 10/10 title with the Blue Blur just yet.

Advertisement