10 Video Game Franchises That Have Lost Their Way

By Shaun Munro /

It's always disheartening when a video game franchise starts out stunning, but owing to commercial concerns, greed, or simple creative bankruptcy, begins to founder, somewhat ruining the fond memories you might have of the stellar earlier instalments. Still, some of these franchises aren't past redemption if the developers pull their socks up, and we'll keep our fingers crossed, as many of them have new instalments emerging in the current months.

10. The Sims

The Sims series has been chugging along for 12 years now, and though many might object to its placement in this list - as they will argue that the series never found its way in the first place - the three interstitial Sims games are great fun, if ostensibly better-pitched towards casual and non-gamers. The problem comes with the maddening, countless number of spin-offs that EA continues to release, usually without much publicity, because they're aware of their dedicated fanbase, who will throw down cash for the latest expansion no matter what the content (recently moving on to peculiar gimmick packs like "Medieval" to keep ardent fans interested). Is a new Sims game every 3 or 4 years not enough for EA? Apparently not; but what began as a novel concept has been well and truly run into the ground, such that while we still enjoyed The Sims 3, we're not the least bit fussed about a fourth game, unless EA and Maxis somehow rejuvenate the formula significantly, rather than just enhancing the graphics a bit.

9. SOCOM

The first two SOCOM games on the PS2 were game-changers, and made it clear what audiences wanted out of their consoles. The ambitious titles were among the first PS2 games to really harness the console's online capabilities, and though the PS2 was hardly the smoothest and slickest online experience of its period, the game's exceptional design and focus on team-play - through the use of microphones - made them two of the best multiplayer games of their era. In the present day, though, its aspirations as a tactical shooter above blind firing and Rambo-like tactics is somewhat lost; in a post-Call of Duty world, is there really an audience for such a deliberate approach? The mammoth sales of Activision's frantic shooter suggest otherwise, and SOCOM 4's attempt to go the more arcade-based route proved troublesome, resulting in negative reviews and a poor commercial turnout. Studio Zipper Interactive were essentially damned if they did and damned if they didn't; they would either alienate their core fanbase - as they did - or satisfy them but face potential financial ruin, which they seemingly did anyway, as the studio is now closed.

8. Guitar Hero

When the Guitar Hero franchise exploded in 2005, it seemed like the franchise that absolutely could not be toppled; with its increasing array of instruments and shrewdly-selected collection of popular songs, few of us expected that the bubble would burst quite so fast. By 2010, the series was well on the decline, and last year, it was put on an indefinite hiatus, owing to disappointing sales of the last game. The problem became over-saturation; by the late 2000s, Activision had settled into a comfortable niche of releasing a new numbered game every October, with a bunch of new songs, for a £40 price tag. The problem is that while the songs remained great fun, the formulaic repetition for the same cost didn't feel like value, and some crassly-priced DLC hardly helped either. It's a difficult conundrum because how do you shake things up for a game that is so simple and not at all reliant on story? The solution would probably have been to divert to a DLC-only approach, whereby a number of songs were released each week - at a reasonable price, mind - but greed, as it usually does, corrupted an initially brilliant franchise and made it quite banal.

7. Tony Hawk

Once upon a time, the Tony Hawk's Pro Skater series was untouchable; it was a unique take on a sport rarely featured in the world of video games, and Hawk himself made for a likable, cheeky face on which to promote the product. With its alternative soundtrack, quirky sense of humour, and increasing pushing of the boundaries - allowing players to create their own parks and so on - it was a series that had a firm grasp on how to evolve, and how to keep fans coming back for more. That was, at least, until Activision took the momentous - and thoroughly misguided - gamble to introduce peripherals into the game, in a fashion not dissimilar from their aforementioned Guitar Hero games. A skateboard device - which would reflect your orientation and hopping on-screen - proved awkward and clumsy despite having sure potential, and was almost universally panned by critics, which was reflected in its poor sales, and eventual cause of the series' demise.

6. Tomb Raider

The Tomb Raider series was a smash hit when it first arrived on our screens in 1996, both in terms of demonstrating the potential for a tight 3D platformer, and heralding the onset of the strong - if dimensionally exaggerated - female protagonist in video games. The first four games in the series were enjoyable in different ways, introducing various gimmicks and flourishes into play, but after Lara's apparent death at the end of the fourth game, her abrupt resurrection in Tomb Raider: Chronicles signalled what would be the beginning of the series' downfall. Three years later, 2003's The Angel of Darkness was released to significant fan outcry and critical backlash, with the rushed nature of its production becoming painfully apparent through the disgraceful number of glitches, a poor combat system, and frustrating camera. Though with the series being taken away from Core Design and given to Crystal Dynamics, it did regain its footing somewhat with sequels Legend, Anniversary and Underworld, it will be down to the next instalment - a 2013 reboot, simply titled Tomb Raider - as to whether Lara Croft still has a place in the video game world. Though footage - which appears to be heavily inspired by the Uncharted games - looks promising, we won't get too excited yet...

5. Final Fantasy

Hear us out before you start getting antsy. The Final Fantasy series has been going strong for so long, that one can't be too surprised that it has eventually started to falter. Final Fantasy VII is frequently cited as one of the greatest games ever made, and so it's none-too-surprising that subsequent games have failed to live up to that legacy, specifically those from the PS2 era and beyond. Perhaps the most egregious addition is the horrible inclusion of soppy, maudlin storylines that feel derived from particularly sentimental anime, and while the series may have been guilty of this prior to FFX, the use of whiny voice acting rather than a text scrawl makes it a whole lot more apparent. The problem is that, at this point, the series is just coasting on its former glory; the storylines are unimaginative, repetitive and dull, which is a particular shame because the newest games look so visually stunning. Though the gameplay has been streamlined extremely well, it's the thin story that really underwhelms, yet the series continues to bring in fantastic returns because it's fortunate enough to be blessed with a strong fanboy contingent. While one doesn't want the series to go away, I just want Square Enix to put some thought into telling an original story.

4. Call of Duty

While in its early days, Call of Duty was a niche shooter of sorts, its leap to consoles certainly helped broaden its appeal, and by the time Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare rolled around, the series was gearing up to become a box office juggernaut. With a more cinematic approach than any similar game, as well as superb set-pieces, and most of all, a game-changing multiplayer component, Modern Warfare kick-started the annual release pattern of the Call of Duty games, that has seen four subsequent annual releases, with a fifth, Black Ops 2, due for release in just a short number of weeks. While each CoD game so far has raked in more cash than the one before it, surely that trend is going to come to an end soon, given the formulaic nature of the series, crassly resembling a FIFA or WWE game, in as much as it leaves its central mechanics in place and simply updates the graphics, characters and so on. That's not all, though; exorbitantly overpriced DLC, a subscription service called Elite, and giving away Double XP rewards to those who purchase the game in preferred stores all reek of a series that has well and truly gotten out of hand. Of course, it's a fine business model for Activision for now - because the CoD games have a hugely broad appeal, and casual gamers in particular can't wait to get their hands on them. That said, Black Ops 2 is at least taking something of a risk by setting itself in the future, a move that I expect might dent its financials more than Activision is expecting. But given their success so far, I'm probably wrong.

3. Silent Hill

The first three Silent Hill games in particular were masterpieces of suspense and survival horror, placing an every-man - or every-woman - protagonist in a terrifying situation, and having them fight through a literal and existential abyss for their own survival. Lately, however, perhaps driven by the decline of survival horror as a genre - what with Resident Evil having becoming far more action-orientated since the fourth canonical game - Silent Hill has drifted away from its roots, tending towards a similar focus on set-pieces and thrills over quiet, brooding suspense. Homecoming removed the nervous awkwardness of the previous protagonists, who were as a result far more relatable to ourselves, and made of our character a more efficient, confident killer, which diminishes the horror down to annoyingly bearable levels. Downpour was similarly problematic; villains were recycled throughout, and dodgy camera issues hampered the experience. There was nothing on the level of visceral or emotional involvement that the first three games mustered, and if this is the direction the series is going to continue along, Konami might as well just remake one of the first three games instead, as it'll be a lot more enjoyable.

2. Sonic the Hedgehog

You'll struggle to find a gamer born in the 1980s who didn't love Sonic the Hedgehog, what with its mix of splendid visuals - which have aged extremely well - frenetic, smart gameplay, and legitimate sense of challenge. Though a few recent Sonic games have brought us some fond memories of the good 'ol days - namely Sonic Generations and the truly retro Sonic the Hedgehog 4: Episode II - the post-Mega Drive era has on the whole not been too kind for the spiky blue guy. Take his first foray on the Dreamcast, Sonic Adventure, which not only transformed the series into 3D - something that has plagued it ever since - but gave Sonic his first opportunity in video game form to open his mouth. Though Sonic Adventure was a brave and often very good game - if mired by dodgy camera work - Sega has never truly returned us to the indomitable, flawless thrills of the original games, perhaps owing to Sonic now having to contend with a more complex time, in which the 2D platformer is essentially obsolete. Still, perhaps some more nostalgic Sonic episodes would sway us...

1. Resident Evil

Though the early Resident Evil games were not without their fair share of flaws - namely irritating tank controls, a lack of saves, a limited inventory and rigid cameras - a lot of these aspects, though stressful, did contribute to making the experience more terrifying. It had seemed by the time Resident Evil 4 rolled around, with its refined gameplay mechanics - altering camera, aiming, saving, inventory and so on - Capcom had successfully re-purposed the series for a new generation, and the game was thus met with massive critical and audience acclaim (although we bloody hated all that Ashley stuff). Resident Evil 5 was divisive because many felt it hewed too far away from the spirit of the series, but by the time Resident Evil 6 hit our shores a few short weeks ago, those complaints felt insignificant. Resident Evil 6 was met with a mixed critical response, with many praising the tripartite campaign yet criticising its myriad technical flaws, from an awkward inventory system, to a skittish camera, and a narrative which introduces enemies who are now even further away from the zombies of old, given that they can fire guns. It is an unfortunate by-product of the post-CoD era, that suspense takes a back-seat to all-out thrills, and it will likely only be something that gets worse in time (at least until CoD collapses). Are there any dying franchises we forgot? Let us know in the comments below.