10 Video Game Franchises That Need To Die
Press X to pay respects.
Franchises are a staple of the gaming world. Why make one game that everybody loves when you could make two? Why make two when you could make three? And so it goes.
But as time starts to move on and gaming changes, companies need to adapt their product so that it stays fresh. They need to justify to the gamer that their new game (with its hefty price tag) is going to bring them something the previous titles couldn't - be that new characters and storylines or a switch-up of gameplay mechanics.
By retreading old storylines, failing to update their gameplay or simply releasing broken games, franchises can often damage their selling power with instalments that attempt to cash in on their past successes. Some even double down on these issues by ignoring criticism of their games in favour of churning out sequels year after year.
Make no mistake, franchises exist for a reason - they often have a winning formula. Franchises don't start if there isn't a market for their games, but while some series continue to garner critical and commercial success, others are failing to bring in either...
10. Five Nights At Freddy's
While this franchise is certainly on thin ice, it's not dead yet.
The first Five Nights At Freddy's became common amongst the Let's Play community for it's refreshing take on survival horror. But after releasing five games in just over two years, the franchise simply wore out the player base.
The issue with Five Nights At Freddy's is that it can't really go anywhere. It relies on jump-scares and constantly ratcheting up the tension, but beyond these gameplay loops, never really changes. By the time the fourth game was released, all this repetitive gameplay had grown stale.
This showed in a sharp downturn in its critical reception, and the FNAF 4 received the lowest rating in the series.
Although there was an uptick in approval for the fifth release, FNAF 5 was becoming more of a chore than an enjoyable experience. The custom creations had been removed, along with difficulty options. This seriously harmed its replay value, and produced only mediocre reviews.
While creator Scott Cawthon has temporarily halted any further sequels due to personal reasons, the potential for another instalment isn't warming any hearts in the community right now.
9. The Sim Franchise
It's hard to improve a game that has little in the way of defined goals aside from "make money" and "impersonate humans." The developers of The Sims clearly realised this, because they didn't even bother trying to change anything.
Although the series started to wear on gamers, nothing destroyed its reputation more than SimCity. The inability to connect to servers meant many reviews were delayed, but when they were finally released, they were damning. The forced multiplayer and online requirements created a game that was inherently broken.
This was followed up by a half-hearted Sims 4, but it was nothing more than a rehash of Sims 3. The new outputs in the Sims series are largely just DLC packages, hoping to cash in by spitting out bits and pieces, but adding nothing of interest to the main games, which are stale at their best, and completely broken at worst.
It's definitely time to finish The Sims off, just not in the elaborate manner that most gamers have done.
8. Total War
This series has been hit-and-miss for years.
The first few releases of the Total War series shocked players with its epic nature. Gamers were offered the chance to rule the known world, and it was no surprise that the series gained a strong following. Things started getting shaky with the release of the bug-ridden Total War: Empire.
Shogun 2 was a great game, in spite of the simplistic campaign pitting near-identical factions against one another. It created the impression that the prior releases were merely a fly in the ointment. Then Rome 2 happened. With shoddy AI and unwelcome changes to the user interface, it looked like a simple .
While there have been recent improvements in the latest shift towards the Warhammer universe, it looks more akin to a cash-in attempt than a desire to make a good game. Players were actively limited in the main goal of taking over territories, which was a core tenant of every game since the series began.
The biggest problem with the Total War series is that it completely controls its market segment. It can afford to lose players, which means it isn't as accountable to its base as other games in a more competitive environment. While it's unlikely that this series ever will end, it most certainly should.
7. Metal Gear
When Hideo Kojima broke with Konami in a blaze of controversy, he took the soul of the Metal Gear franchise with him. It is true that there is an entire team of people that worked tirelessly behind the scenes to create Kojima's vision, and they certainly deserve to be applauded for their efforts.
Kojima was always the face of the series, though. It was always his vision, and he has written, directed, produced, and designed every single one of the Metal Gear Solid games.
The upcoming Metal Gear Survive appears to be little more than a generic zombie game, and it's clear that without Kojima at the helm of the franchise, Konami is stepping into the easy money-maker of zombie survival games.
This leaves questions over how the two main Metal Gear series, Metal Gear Solid and Metal Gear Rising, will be treated in Kojima's absence. Metal Gear has always produced games with intricate moral questions woven into their storylines, and it's questionable - based on Survival - whether or not Konami will be able to do justice to the franchise.
Konami could feasibly continue to work on Metal Gear Rising, a series that Kojima didn't work on to the same extent as the Metal Gear Solid series, and it's likely his involvement wouldn't be quite so sorely missed. But Metal Gear Solid was always Kojima's brainchild, and it should start, and end, with him.
6. The Witcher
Put down the pitchforks, I'm going to clarify something here.
The Witcher 3 tied up Geralt's story beautifully, and there's really nothing more to add to it. No plot points were left unresolved, no characters were left without an arc. It really was a perfect way to say goodbye.
If CD Projekt RED tried to keep Geralt, they would have to move to the books that precede the games. There, they would see their creative talents hemmed in by the confines of a writing style that doesn't lend itself to a video game setting.
Instead, they should look forwards, and the future of The Witcher doesn't have Geralt in it.
When the final game first introduced Ciri in the final game, she was an instant hit. She's a compelling character in her own right, and deserves to have her own section of the franchise, but she needs to leave Geralt behind. If Ciri does make another appearance in the series, CD Project Red shouldn't have to push it as a part of Geralt's story.
He's had his time, and it's been incredible, but let Ciri take the reins from now on.
5. World Of Warcraft
With increasing evidence of diminishing popularity, the boom period of World Of Warcraft is certainly over. Following the rise of the intensely fast eSports scene, Blizzard struck gold with Overwatch. But the success of that game is the final nail in the coffin of their former flagship franchise.
Overwatch is everything that World Of Warcraft isn't. It's fast, punchy, character-driven. It never needed a complicated backstory, just a handful of characters to bond with. World Of Warcraft requires time, and there are far more compelling games for players to spend that time on.
The dwindling popularity is best seen in the loss of the player base. In November 2014, about 12 million individual subscribers had a World Of Warcraft account. By September of the following year, it had fallen to less than half that number.
The simple fact of the matter is that in today's gaming environment, World Of Warcraft no longer belongs. The MMORPG genre has been dying off for years, it just took longer to really hit the biggest kid in the playground.
With its attention now firmly focussed on Overwatch, Blizzard seems likely to let World Of Warcraft whither away. Killing it now might cut off a huge amount of income to the company, but it will have to happen at some point.
4. Sonic
Sonic was fun and inventive in the era of platformers, but in the modern gaming environment, the spiky smurf couldn't hack it. Although he undoubtedly has the speed to match the moneymakers like Overwatch and Call of Duty, Sonic lost its selling power with its recent incarnations.
The issue clearly isn't the genre. Some of the most interesting games released in the past few years have been platformers, but where Limbo and Ori And The Blind Forest provided intriguing stories or gave us gorgeous visuals, Sonic tried to bring back the days of old.
Throwing in weird, unconvincing romances to try and liven up the gameplay, the Sonic games of today are doing nothing but tarnishing the name of what used to be a great franchise.
The developers are clearly still relying on the name, hoping that it can draw a casual player base back through nostalgic appeal. Instead of seeing what's working in today's platformer genre, they're rehashing the same gameplay that made the series popular in its heyday in the 1990s and early 2000s.
Which is exactly where the series should have stayed.
3. Mass Effect
Mass Effect: Andromeda wasn't a bad game, but it wasn't good enough to live up to the expectations placed on it. The writing and polish of the previous games had vanished like Ryder dropping through the floor of the Tempest.
But more than the well-crafted scripting or the compelling characters was the heart of the series. It was incredibly refreshing to see something other than the depressing destruction of the original series. Mass Effect: Andromeda clearly wanted to do something new, and it tried extremely hard to do that.
The new characters were fun, but they couldn't step out of the long shadows cast by Shepard and his misfits. The only major improvement to the series was the combat, but it was to the detriment of the plot and, infamously, the animations.
With most of BioWare's efforts seemingly focussed on Anthem and the next instalment of the Dragon Age series, it's unlikely that a sequel could achieve the success needed to bring this franchise back from the brink of death.
2. Call Of Duty
When a company churns out games faster than you would achieve orgasm with Scarlett Johansson, it begins to wear out in terms of quality and overexposure. Critics love to hate on Call Of Duty for exactly this reason, and the constant hatred of the series is almost as grating as the beast itself.
Since the success of Call of Duty 4, the series has attempted to recreate the winning formula by changing absolutely nothing in ten years. Occasionally it changes the setting, but nothing there's no substantial difference.
That's like saying that a serial killer is changing because he kills on Friday instead of Wednesday.
And yes, that's a weird analogy.
There can't be a massive overhaul of Call Of Duty's gameplay, because it's simply the way that first-person-shooters are. The best thing that the developers could do is take the obvious talent that they have for making games and put it to use in another series, because Call Of Duty is going nowhere but off a cliff right now.
1. Assassin's Creed
Peaking with the release of Assassin's Creed 2, the franchise has been forever marred its name by producing sequels with boring characters, or by being unplayably broken. The impact of the bug-ridden Assassin's Creed: Unity had a noticeable impact on its later instalment, Syndicate, which became the second-worst selling game in the franchise.
The developers of the series clearly recognised this, and scraped together a script for a film to boost the sales of the franchise. But the main problem with Assassin's Creed isn't its story, it's that it's never shown particularly inspiring gameplay.
Although it appeared innovative to begin with, the combat system with its enemies politely attacking one-by-one quickly drew the ridicule of the gaming community. The enemies were so magnificently outclassed that it's simpler to massacre everyone than attempt to sneak past guards with the laughable "stealth" system.
For a series about assassins, the series spends remarkably little time being stealthy, or eliminating enemies in ways other than walking up behind them and insta-killing them. The issue with Assassin's Creed is that it's had years to fix the issues that hampered it, but it opted to churn out sequel after sequel, carrying on in the face of increasingly vocal critics.
Assassin's Creed could have been improved so many times if it took just another year to release a game, but it never made that decision, instead continuing to try for easy money.
After this issue came to a head in Unity, it's unlikely that the series will never truly recover.