10 Video Game Puzzles That Stopped EVERYONE

Silent Hill 3's Shakespeare puzzle can rot.

By Andy Murray /

Alongside battling enemies and overcoming tough boss fights, solving puzzles is another huge part of how video games like to challenge players.

Advertisement

Sometimes these puzzles can be as simple as finding a key to unlock a door or searching through nearby documents to uncover the combination to a safe. Other times they're more demanding, and require players to decipher riddles or think outside of the box to solve a supposedly "logical" scenario.

No matter how tough some of these conundrums may seem, the best and most rewarding puzzles will always nudge players in the right direction and have a solution which makes sense within the rules of the game.

However, there are other puzzles out there which offer no such courtesies. To reach the answers to these brain-benders, players will need to wrestle with some of the most obtuse and abstract logic ever conceived, or possess an in-depth knowledge of a niche subject.

With no clear hints about what to do, it's possible to get stuck at these sections for hours without making any sort of progress. Thankfully, online walkthroughs now exist, which are the only way that most players will figure out what they were supposed to do.

10. Waiting For A Cloud To Move - Braid (2008)

Coming from the mind of Johnathan Blow (the same developer behind the brain-bending puzzle game The Witness), Braid is a fascinating title that used its central time rewinding mechanic to form the basis of ingenious platforming puzzles, alongside weaving a fairytale story that was just as perplexing as everything else in the game.

Advertisement

The hardest of the platforming conundrums, however, involved collecting hidden stars scattered throughout the game. Obtaining any of them was a fiendishly challenging task that demanded mastery of the game’s mechanics, alongside solving cryptic levels that were borderline cruel.

It would be easy to miss any of these stars without a guide pointing you in the right direction, but the most elusive was the one located in level 2-2.

All that needs to be done is to use a cloud to travel from one side of the screen to the other, then hop over the wall to find the star. When the cloud takes literal hours to get to its destination, though, most players won’t even realise the piece of scenery is moving.

Thankfully, it only takes finding seven of the eight stars to unlock Braid's secret ending.

9. Show Your Humanity - Dark Souls 3 (2016)

Alongside their crushing levels of difficulty, the Dark Souls games are likewise known for being incredibly obtuse. Not only does this trilogy refuse to offer any guidance when it comes to puzzles, but the answers are often as incomprehensible as the series' lore.

Advertisement

One of the most bizarre comes in Dark Souls 3's Ringed City DLC, when player's stumble upon text on a statue that reads "Show your humanity".

Found near the City Streets bonfire, those familiar with the trilogy will recognise Humanity as the item used in the first game to reverse hollowing. Therefore, they may logically assume that the game wants them to use an Ember, this game's version of humanity. Doing so, though, does nothing.

What the game expects players to do is venture into the nearby swamp and use either a Young White Branch or cast the Chameleon spell. Normally, using these items transforms the character into a nearby object. Stand in the correct spot, though, and the Ashen One will turn into a giant humanity icon. Glide back to the statue and a ladder will appear.

With no logic to how this puzzle works, there's no way anyone would know to do it without using a guide.

8. The Goat - Broken Sword: Shadow Of The Templars (1996)

A puzzle so notorious, it has its own Wikipedia page, this aggravating brain-bender from '90s point-and-click game Broken Sword: Shadow Of The Templars tasks protagonist George Stobbart with sneaking into an Irish castle. Unfortunately for him, the entrance is guarded by an irritable goat who'll ram George every time he gets too close.

Advertisement

By this point in the game, players will have already chased down a terrorist dressed as a clown and solved some tricky ciphers, so dealing with a goat shouldn't be a problem.

However, each time players direct George to move towards some handily placed farm equipment at the other side of the courtyard, the goat would ram them. Although it seemed like doing anything without being interrupted by the animal was impossible, the only way to solve this puzzle was to let George be hit while approaching the machinery.

The only puzzle that required specific timing to complete, players needed to interact with the equipment before the goat got back. Its rope would subsequently get caught in the machinery when it next attacked, allowing George to pass.

Mercifully, the timing element was removed from this puzzle for the remaster.

7. The Shakespeare Anthology Puzzle - Silent Hill 3 (2003)

Solving puzzles has always been a core part of survival horror games in which players will spend large chunks of their time hunting for strange keys and solving logic problems in between fighting monsters.

Advertisement

One of the most infamous examples comes right at the start of Silent Hill 3 where players are tasked with finding a four-digit code to open a door in a bookstore. To get the code, they'll need to place volumes of Shakespeare anthologies on a shelf in the correct order, using the numbers on their spines to unlock the door.

Although cracking this code is straightforward on easier difficulties, the real headache comes when tackling this on the hardest riddle setting.

With the clue now being a list of obscure quotes from the bard's works, solving not only requires an in-depth knowledge of Shakespeare's writing to identify which play each line is from, but it also meant that players would need to know which anthology that play was part of too.

Even with the books in the right order, the solution involved solving another riddle by multiplying the numbers on the spines to get the final code.

... This was only the first puzzle.

6. The Gnome's Name - Kings Quest (1984)

At one point in 1984 adventure game King's Quest, players will encounter an old gnome who says that he has something useful for them. Instead of just handing it over, though, he demands that players guess their name within three attempts.

Advertisement

Given that this riddle is a reference to the story of Rumpelstiltskin, players would rightly assume that this would be the answer. However, they'd be incorrect.

A note in a witch's house earlier in the game reading "Sometimes it's wise to think backwards" sheds some light on the answer. But instead of typing the name in reverse like the hint suggests, the developers expected players to figure out that they were supposed to invert the entire alphabet to use as a cipher in which "A" is "Z" and so on. Using this illogical method, the gnome's name becomes "Ifnkovhgroghprm".

Making this puzzle somehow even more frustrating was that the developers accidentally misspelt the fairy tale character's name in the game by swapping the "e" and "l" around, meaning that players would still get the wrong answer even if they somehow cracked the code.

The puzzle was so logically broken that the answer was changed in the remaster to be "Nikstlitslepmur", Rumpelstiltskin backwards.

5. The Mountain Door - Tunic (2022)

Despite featuring an adorable anthropomorphic fox as its hero, Tunic is far from being a cutesy adventure game. Much like the Dark Souls series, this title leaves it up to players to figure out how everything works, with the most baffling challenge being to open the door at the top of the mountain by discovering what the game calls the Golden Path.

Advertisement

The solution to this puzzle can be found within the pages of a virtual game manual that's written in its own unique language. Specifically, on a page containing numbers on a golden grid.

These numbers refer to pages from the manual which have yellow lines carefully hidden on them. Find all the lines (one of which involves quitting and reloading the game to find a secret save file containing the lines laid out in a maze) and match them to where they belong on the grid to unveil the Golden Path.

Players must then note down each direction the line takes and convert them into button presses on the D-Pad. Once completed, they can now stand in front of the door and input the gigantic 100-button combination to unlock it.

The bigger question is how anyone figured this out on their own.

4. Stealing The Gold Belt Buckle - Discworld (1995)

Whether it's the infamous rubber duck puzzle in The Longest Journey or attempting to get the Babble Fish from the Hitchhiker's Guide To The Galaxy game, puzzle games have a terrible habit of operating on their own bonkers logic.

Advertisement

No puzzle, however, is as insane as stealing a gold belt buckle in Discworld.

At this point in the game, the player is required to steal gold items throughout the map to give to a dragon. One of these items is a fishmonger's golden belt buckle. However, the merchant is understandably unwilling to just hand over their possession. Therefore, players must find a crafty way to rob them of their treasure.

Rather than tricking the fishmonger into handing over the buckle, the steps to obtain it are ludicrously nonsensical.

Before players can swipe the belt, they first need to steal an octopus and some aphrodisiac custard. Next, tie the octopus in string and place it in a toilet before covering it in the custard.

Finally place some prunes in the fishmonger's caviar, which will cause him to run to the toilet where he'll be assaulted by the lustful octopus, allowing his belt to be taken.

Only video games can have this level of absurd logic.

3. Stopping The Waterfall - Monkey Island 2: LeChuck's Revenge (1991)

Containing insult sword fighting, rubber chickens and dozens of quippy one-liners, the beloved Monkey Island games are known for their signature sense of silly humour. Unfortunately for fans of the cult series, though, the whacky comedy could make some of the puzzles far harder than they should've been, with the most frustrating of all being the waterfall puzzle from the second game.

Advertisement

During his quest to defeat the villainous pirate LeChuck for a second time, smart-mouthed pirate Guybrush Threepwood needed to turn off a waterfall via a pump to reach the house of Rum Rogers.

But with no tool for the job available for purchase at any of the game's shops, players need to get inventive when finding the solution. However, nobody was expecting the writers of the Monkey Island series to go this overboard with their video game logic.

What players needed to do to stop the waterfall was place a banana on a metronome in front of a piano-playing monkey. This would then hypnotise the primate, which Guybrush could then use as a literal monkey wrench on the pump.

While this puzzle demonstrated the series' fantastic comedic writing, the steps to reach such a pun punchline weren't obvious at ALL.

2. The Mantras Puzzle - La-Mulana (2006)

Originally released in Japan in 2006 before the remake introduced the game to the west in 2012, La-Mulana is a challenging adventure outing inspired by classic Metroidvanias. In it, players take on the role of archaeologist Lemeza Kosugi as he explores the titular ruins in search of ancient treasures.

Advertisement

Alongside facing perilous traps and dangerous enemies, players will likewise need to solve various puzzles to progress deeper into the game.

While there are plenty of difficult challenges in this game, the most perplexing is the mantras puzzle which players will need to complete to reach the final boss. This riddle involves finding eight mantras and chanting them in order at specific spots. However, finding these exact locations isn't made clear.

The best method for finding where to perform these chants comes from the game's manual, which suggests each level should be plotted as a map of four-by-five squares for both its front and back sides. Starting from the compass room, players need to trace the directions to get to the boss room on the front side and then retrace this same path on the back to pinpoint the correct location.

As far as obtuse game puzzles go, this is one of the worst.

1. Getting A Fake Moustache - Gabriel Knight 3: Blood Of The Sacred, Blood Of The Damned (1999)

Another maligned puzzle with its own Wikipedia page, what's become known as "the cat hair moustache puzzle" from point-and-click title Gabriel Knight 3 is another example of illogical video game design that the developers expected players to understand.

Advertisement

Early in the game, players are tasked with disguising the titular supernatural investigator as one Detective Mosley.

Despite the real Mosley not having any facial hair, part of this puzzle requires Knight to source a fake moustache to complete their makeshift costume.

Procuring this accessory, however, requires players to complete a series of convoluted steps, beginning with sticking some tape to the bottom of a shed door. Next, a nearby cat needs to be sprayed with water, which causes it run under the door and catch some of its fur on the tape. After retrieving the homemade moustache, maple syrup is used to glue it onto Knight's face.

Lastly, to make the costume as authentic as possible, a fake moustache needs to be drawn on the real Mosely's stolen passport.

Added into the game after another puzzle was axed for budgetary reasons, this setup was just as despised by the developers, and was only kept in because there wasn't enough time to replace it.

Advertisement