10 Video Game Puzzles You Couldn't Solve (Even With A Guide)
When the solution isn't the answer.
It's crazy to believe there was a time where gamers couldn't summon an online walkthrough anytime they got stuck in a game. If you didn't know how to solve a puzzle back then, you had to get your hands on a physical guide, or accept the fact you would never complete the game.
Thanks to the internet, this issue seems to be a thing of the past. If you keep dying on the same boss, get lost, or can't answer a riddle, there's no need to tear your hair out just yet. After a watching a few walkthrough videos and scouring GameFaqs, there's no conundrum you shouldn't be able to crack.
At least, in theory. Every once in a while, you will stumble upon a section in a video game that's so complex or incomprehensible, not even the most detailed strategy guides can assist you.
Whether you draw out the level, memorise patterns, research maps, and watch step-by-step instructions on loop, the solution to these brainteasers eludes you.
If you find yourself dumbfounded by these devilish headscratchers, you should pray for a miracle because a guide isn't going to help you.
10. The Oculory - Skyrim
While playing the Skyrim DLC, Dragonborn, things probably grinded to a halt during the Revealing the Unseen quest. Near the end of this mission, you'll be led towards an observatory tower, which contains an Oculory sphere.
To obtain the Staff of Magnus, you need to to press three buttons to rotate the overhead mirrors at specific points. Because the focusing crystal is powered by heat, you need to keep blasting it with Flames and Frostbites spells until the light reflects off each mirror.
If that sounds complicated, it is! Unsurprisingly, many gamers will find this section so confounding, they won't attempt to solve it and instead, look up a walkthrough straight away.
Sadly, this will not aid you. If you follow an instruction video to the letter, you'll notice the light doesn't reflect the same way that's shown in the walkthrough.
So, why is this? Well, if you're watching a video guide of someone hitting the crystal with spells at Lv. 70, you can't do the same thing if your spells are at Lv 20.
Unless you can find a tutorial video where the player's spells are exactly the same level as you, you'll have to solve the puzzle yourself.
9. Anchors Away - Grim Fandango
In Grim Fandango's boat section our hero, Manny, discovers criminals have hijacked his vessel, forcing him to hide in the engine room.
To escape, Manny must hoist and drop the anchors at specific points, and then use the lever to turn the ship at a certain angle. If you do this correctly, the anchors will get caught in each other. If you try to reverse at this point, the ship will break in two, allowing you to flee.
If you find this whole ordeal too confusing, you'll probably consult a walkthrough. (There's no shame in it. Grim Fandango's puzzles are so illogical, the average gamer has a guide ready at all times while playing it.)
However, guides aren't going to cut it. Every time you pull a lever, it cuts to an animation of the ship moving. However, this footage doesn't really help the player understand if they're making any progress. Because watching a video of this section has the same problem, looking at online tutorials won't help.
Now, there is no question Grim Fandango has tougher puzzles. (Still don't understand how the developers expected us to figure out that Peanuts Rocket Fuel caper by ourselves.) Even though there are trickier sections, they shouldn't give you much trouble after looking at a walkthrough.
However, outside help won't help you with the anchor scenario. More often than not, players will solve this riddle, without understanding why.
8. Handaconda - Paper Mario: Origami King
Rather than relying on a conventional turn-based battle system, each enemy encounter in Paper Mario: Origami King takes place in a ring-based puzzle brawl. By rotating the rings horizontally and vertically, the overall-wearing plumber can line up attacks, perform killer combos, and smash multiple baddies at once.
Despite the innovative mechanics, these bouts can become incredibly convoluted, especially when it comes to the bosses. Rather than wailing on them with your strongest attacks, you need to follow a rigid set of rules to vanquish the bosses.
Also, since the battle ring's layout is randomly generated, you can't imitate the strategy you see on an online video. If that was your plan, you're out of luck.
Although every boss is a nightmare to fight, Handaconda is the worst (despite having the cleverest name). Not only does this calamitous cutout hit you with the standard attacks, he'll also routinely challenge you to Rock-Paper-Scissors (which the game hilariously calls "Stoney-Sheety-Cutty"). Since there's no indication which of the three selections Handaconda is going to choose, most of your fight is left to chance rather than skill.
7. The Final Boss's Only Weakness - Wizardy IV
Wizardry IV: The Return of Werdna concludes with our hero duelling with a seemingly invincible foe called Lord Hawkwind. No matter what you hit this guy with, he just shrugs it off.
However, there's an elusive clue on how to defeat him. If you draw out each level from a top-view perspective (which no rational person would ever think of), you'll notice the walls of four rooms are shaped in the letters "D I N K". This "hint" is telling you to bring a Dink with you to the final confrontation, and hurl it at Hawkwind to defeat him.
First off, how could anyone figure this out? Did you ever get lost playing Mario and think, "Maybe if I draw out the level in top-view perspective, I'll know where to go." Because nobody in the history of mankind figured this puzzle out, everyone who got stuck on this section either gave up or looked at a walkthrough.
Unfortunately, knowing the solution won't help as much as you'd think because the Dink only has a 20% of working! If that happens, you'll be forced to watch the game's bad ending, through no fault of your own.
6. Test Chamber 18 - Portal
If you don't know how to solve a puzzle in Portal, you can be stuck for an hour. But if you know what to do, you can normally whizz through a section in a matter of seconds.
However, Test Chamber 18 is a little different. Because this level is filled with turrets, insta-kill slime, a cube, slow-moving platforms, easy-to-miss sections, and shifting panels, you know you'll have your work cut out for you.
Although a tutorial video will show you how to get out, actually pulling it off is a different matter altogether. In the final stages of the puzzle, you need to press a button to raise a panel on the other side of the room. After that, you need to teleport yourself beside the panel and crawl through it while holding the cube.
The problem is that the cube is so bulky, it can easily catch on the panel, preventing you from passing through. Even if you know precisely how to complete the task, it's the one moment that's sure to take the most experienced players five or six attempts to complete. Because of this, it's no surprise Test Chamber 18 is detested by speedrunners, since the slightest error will jeopardise their run.
5. Shinespark In Burenia - Metroid Dread
Certain upgrades in Metroid Dread are hidden behind seemingly impenetrable walls called Speed Booster blocks. To break through these, you need to press down while running at top-speed to go into Shinespark mode. If you press jump and a directional button afterward, you'll charge into that corresponding direction, breaking any Speed blocks in your way.
Because you can't go into Shinespark mode unless you build up enough momentum, all puzzles involving these blocks is tricky. However, the hardest section is reaching the Missile+ upgrade in Burenia. Because the Speed blocks here are beside a slope, it's impossible to run at maximum speed. To get around this, you need to go into Shinespark mode in the corridor above, fall down, run up the slope, and then charge into the blocks.
But there's another snag. The Shinespark fades after three seconds. Navigating through this area takes 15 seconds. So, the only way to get this upgrade is to keep pressing down to reset the Shinespark while running through the corridors. If you lose your footing or bump into a wall, your Shinespark disappears, forcing you to start again.
If you watch a breakdown video of this section, it won't really help since you'll still need fly-like reflexes to pull this feat off.
4. The Goat - Broken Sword: The Shadow Of The Templars
The Goat section in this classic point-and-click adventure is so infamous, it has its own Wikipedia page.
Despite its terrifying legacy, the premise for this puzzle is very simple. Playing as George, you need to get past a goat, which is blocking the doorway of a castle. If you get too close to it, the farm animal will butt into you.
So, how has this little conundrum caused so much frustration and smashed keyboards over the years? Well, the only way to get past this devilish creature is to allow it to ram into you. As it returns to its original position, you need to adjust the machinery on the left. When the goat charges at you again, its rope will get entangled in the machinery, allowing you to get by.
So, once you know this solution, this puzzle should be a piece of cake, right? However, the amount of precision one needs cannot be stressed enough. If you click on the machine one micro-second too soon or too late, it won't work. So, even after you figure out what to do, expect to be butted by that infernal goat many times before moving on.
Unsurprisingly, the puzzle was simplified when the game was remastered.
3. Baseball - Zork II
Long before Zelda, Donkey Kong, or Super Mario, gamers had to settle with text-based titles like Zork II. Since this game came out in 1981, access to walkthroughs was virtually non-existent, which is why few people have ever completed it.
More specifically, those who actually played Zork II probably never got further than the Oddly Angled Room. Although this section is a maze, you'd assume you can get to the exit through trial and error. Sadly, this doesn't work, since the game keeps teleporting you to random places.
But if you noticed the bat-shaped club near the diamond-shaped window, you may have deduced the solution is connected with baseball. If you run the bases in the maze like you're playing a baseball game, you should find the exit.
Few people figured this out because, well, why would you?? Even if you know baseball inside out, NOBODY would've made this leap in logic.
Unfortunately, making this baseball connection doesn't help since there's no hint which direction you are meant to head in from the home base!
This puzzle is so universally hated, the designer, David Lebling, apologised for it... as he should.
2. The Rotating Maze - The Legend Of Zelda: Breath Of The Wild
Unless you're looking to complete every Shrine in The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild, it would be wise to avoid Myahm Agana.
In this dungeon, you will see there's a ball inside a hovering labyrinth. By operating the Gyros nearby, you can rotating the floating platform to direct the ball through the maze. Once the sphere reaches the end, it will fall into a slot, allowing you to complete the Shrine.
If that sounds easy, it isn't! Every time it looks like the ball is about to fall off the edge, you can't help but jerking the platform in the opposite direction out of reflex. By doing this, the ball is guaranteed to sail into the abyss below.
After you fail for the 50th time, you may look online to see if there's an easier technique to get through this maze. Luckily, there is. By rotating the platform 180 degrees, you can skip the maze section entirely. By angling the platform at a specific angle, you can launch the ball into the slot as soon as it drops down.
Unfortunately, this "easier" method... isn't easy! The amount of precision required is so unfair, this method is actually harder than the regular one. Sadly, your best bet to complete this Shrine is to keep ploughing through the conventional way.
1. The Challenge - The Witness
Every puzzle in Witness follows one simple mechanic: You need to draw a path to the exit of a grid-like maze. Of the 650+ tasks that Witness boasts, the most challenging one is... The Challenge. (It's not a creative name but it's very justifiable.) If you choose to partake in this endeavour, you must complete a dozen headscratchers in seven minutes.
Now, you might be thinking, "What's stopping you from looking at a walkthrough?"
And the answer is simple - These 12 enigmas are generated randomly by an algorithm. It's impossible to look up the answers because they didn't exist until the algorithm created them.
Now, this is not suggesting The Challenge is the hardest brainteaser in the history of gaming. But because its random nature makes it guideproof, it's easy to see how Witness' toughest level has maintained its infamy over the years.
As frustrating as The Challenge is, it's deeply gratifying when you complete it since you can't use outside help. If you are one of the very few who actually conquered The Challenge, you know it's because you relied entirely on your own skills.