10 Video Game Remasters NOBODY Asked For

The most ridiculous remasters of all time.

By Jack Pooley /

The subject of video game remasters has never been more contentious than it is right now, with some viewing the uptick in remasters of recent games being a waste of precious developer resources, while others cite them as important for accessibility and the preservation of the art form.

Advertisement

Wherever you fall down on the debate generally, there are certainly those remasters whose necessity is dubious-at-best, whether because the original release was fairly recent, has aged incredibly well, or simply isn't being treated with the respect it deserves by its publisher.

These 10 remasters, then, all arrived despite few asking for them to happen - or at least not like this. 

And so, while folks patiently wait for Sony to finally pull their finger out and get a Bloodborne remaster out the door - and that's without even mentioning the conspicuously absent PC release - consider that these remasters have all inexplicably happened.

The lesson here? When all else fails, publishers can just fall back on regurgitating their prior successes for another go-around, and we as players are generally all-too-happy to obligingly shove our hand in our pocket a few years after the fact...

10. Grand Theft Auto V: Expanded & Enhanced

There are only a few certainties in life - death, taxes, and Grand Theft Auto V continuing to sell copies by the shedload until the heat death of the universe. 

Advertisement

And so, it perhaps wasn't a huge surprise that, some eight-and-a-half years after its PS3 launch, GTA V was released on PS5.  Possibly in an attempt to skirt the negativity surrounding the "remaster" label, Rockstar dubbed it an "Expanded & Enhanced" edition of the game. 

However, this didn't stop the reveal trailer from receiving hundreds of thousands of dislikes on YouTube, with fans expressing frustration that Rockstar continued to refine a near-decade-old game already released on two generations of hardware rather than focus their efforts on Grand Theft Auto VI.

The prospect of triple-dipping simply wasn't there for most, especially with the clear appetite for Rockstar to deliver the long-overdue next instalment in their epic open-world crime actioner saga.

9. Life Is Strange Remastered Collection

Released in February 2022, the Life Is Strange Remastered Collection was a compendium consisting of Life Is Strange and prequel Before the Storm, as were released in 2015 and 2017 respectively.

Advertisement

While a seven-year gap between original and remaster might not seem egregious compared to other examples on this list, Life Is Strange just isn't a game that really merited the remaster treatment. Back in 2015 it was by far the best-looking mainstream episodic adventure game, and even today, it still holds up well. 

The remasters' marginal-at-best aesthetic improvements didn't make the characters significantly more expressive, and certainly not enough to justify a double-dip for most players.

That the remaster ultimately introduced new glitches not present in the original games, also didn't help persuade anyone of its necessity.

It was incredibly easy to see the remaster project as a calculated move on the part of developer Deck Nine and publisher Square Enix to get Life Is Strange back in the public mindshare before they announced the impending sequel Life Is Strange: Double Exposure.

8. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Campaign Remastered

Now to be clear, after the release of Call of Duty: Modern Warfare Remastered, fans were naturally excited to see Modern Warfare 2 get the very same treatment, only for Activision to make the most weirdly anti-money move possible.

Advertisement

The publisher ultimately decided to release a campaign-only remaster of Modern Warfare 2, ensuring that players excited to revisit legendary multiplayer maps like Terminal, Highrise, Estate, and Rust in glorious 4K were all out of luck.

Given that Modern Warfare 2's multiplayer suite remains one of the most beloved in the entire series, this was an epic own goal by Activision, with many fans ultimately surmising that they ditched the multiplayer remaster to stop it competing with their more current Call of Duty titles.

All the same, Activision left a ton of money on the table here by not giving the people what they wanted. Modern Warfare 2's campaign is great and all, but given that the remaster also lacks the beloved Spec Ops mode, it only covered a fraction of the original 2009 release.

7. Braid, Anniversary Edition

Braid is undeniably one of the most iconic and successful games from the indie game boom of the late 2000s and early 2010s - an ingeniously conceived and executed puzzle-platformer that's fondly regarded to this very day.

Advertisement

And yet, was anyone angling for a remaster? Apparently not.

Braid, Anniversary Edition - a remaster touting repainted visuals, smoother animations, reworked audio, and even dozens of new levels - came and went without making a dent this past May, enough that even designer Jonathan Blow later admitted that it "sold like dog s**t." Yikes.

As brilliant as Braid is, it's simply not a game that left its many fans itching to open their wallets for a shinier new version. The original iteration still looks excellent, which combined with its short three-hour play-time ensured this remaster was predictably dead on arrival.

Plus, for as innovative as Braid was in 2008, clever indie puzzle-platformers are a dime a dozen in 2024, so why shell out again for something you probably already own?

6. Marvel's Spider-Man Remastered

Surely the award for most shamelessly expedited double-dip remaster must go to Insomniac's Spider-Man, as the original iteration of the web-slinging adventure game launched for PS4 in September 2018, only for a PS5 remaster to release barely two years later in November 2020, coinciding with the PS5's launch.

Advertisement

Though this remaster did include The City That Never Sleeps DLC, three extra suits, and other minor additions such as extra trophies, many understandably felt the PS5 upgrade should've been free given the proximity of the remaster's release.

Instead, upon launch players either had to splash out for the pricey Ultimate Edition of Spider-Man: Miles Morales or pay an uplift fee, a decision which was met with considerable backlash by the fanbase.

Ultimately it was an easy remaster to skip, though, given how recently most would've played the PS4 release. 

The utter lack of "necessity" was staggering, and that's without even getting into the wildly polarising change of Peter Parker's facial model, switching out John Bubniak for the decidedly more Tom Holland-looking Ben Jordan.

5. Batman: Return to Arkham

Released in October 2016, Batman: Return to Arkham was a remastered collection of both Arkham Asylum and Arkham City, which were released in 2009 and 2011 respectively.

Advertisement

And while there were admittedly some clamouring to see the games brought forward to the PS4/Xbox One generation - especially with the PS3 lacking backwards compatibility - it's also fair to say that the original iterations of both game have aged very well.

Upon release, many even complained that Return to Arkham's makeover stripped away much of the grit of the original games' aesthetic, giving it a cleaner, more "plastic" look. And beyond that, the duology was disappointingly locked to a mere 30fps. 

Couple all this with the conspicuous lack of prequel Arkham Origins in the collection - likely because it was developed by WB Games MontrĂ©al rather than Rocksteady Studios - and the value proposition just wasn't there for most folks who'd already played these games on PS3.

4. The Last of Us Part II Remastered

This past January, barely three-and-a-half years after it originally released on PS4, The Last of Us Part II's remaster launched for PS5. Even accepting the overwhelming popularity of Naughty Dog's apocalyptic action sequel, many had to ask "really"?

Advertisement

The PS4 release was given a free 60fps patch for PS5 owners back in 2021, which was surely enough of an upgrade for the overwhelming majority of players. 

But it's tough not to scoff at the notion of remastering a game that looked positively cutting-edge on PS4 back in 2020, and still looks absolutely incredible on that hardware today. 

That Sony charged a $10 uplift rather than offering the upgrade for free didn't help much, either.

Though The Last of Us Part II Remastered was well-received by critics and did add new content such as a speed-run mode and audio commentary, there was also a common sentiment that, unless you're among the few who haven't yet played the game at all, the remaster was in no way "vital."

Naughty Dog could've probably avoided some very foreseeable blowback by just dubbing the remaster a "Game of the Year Edition" instead.

3. Super Mario 3D All-Stars

On paper, Super Mario 3D All-Stars seemed like a totally unscrewupable remaster collection of Super Mario 64, Super Mario Sunshine, and Super Mario Galaxy, but Nintendo being Nintendo, of course they had to make some totally baffling business decisions.

Advertisement

Even accepting that just about every card-carrying Mario fan has played these three masterpieces to death, there certainly would've been a sizable audience for a remaster compendium which lovingly brought the trio of games up to modern muster with a bevy of new quality-of-life features.

But even if you could forgive how flagrantly barebones the remaster was, and that it puzzlingly didn't include Super Mario Galaxy 2, it was raked over the coals by many once it was revealed that Nintendo utilised emulation technology.

Naturally many players weren't thrilled about paying top dollar for an emulation collection, especially given Nintendo's own aggressive attacks on the emulation scene.

And as the cherry on top, Nintendo ultimately made the remaster trilogy a limited-time release, only being available on sale for six months, with second hand copies now selling for princely sums on sites like eBay. 

Artificial scarcity sucks, and though Super Mario 3D All-Stars did admittedly sell shedloads of copies regardless, did any Mario fan want a remaster that showed such little respect for them as a consumer?

2. Horizon Zero Dawn Remastered

Sony recently confirmed the long-percolating rumours that a remaster of Horizon Zero Dawn was in the works, the announcement of which left the great many scratching their heads.

Advertisement

Even as video game publishers might try to convince us that seven-and-a-half-years is a damn long time - and certainly enough time to trot out a remaster - the original PS4 version of Horizon Zero Dawn still looks fantastic, and PS5 owners can already play it in butter-smooth 4K 60fps courtesy of a performance patch.

Sony and developer Guerrilla Games have attempted to sell the remaster as bringing the original game up to the glossier aesthetic standard of sequel Horizon Forbidden West, including shooting 10 hours of new motion capture data to make dialogue scenes more realistic, but fans generally don't seem dissuaded.

Even with Sony offering a cheap upgrade path for those who own the original version of the game, it's a tough pitch. The PS4 version still looks fantastic, and for all but the most die-hard Horizon fans, that's more than good enough. 

This is the epitome of Sony remastering a game simply to fill a content gap in their pipeline. Well, almost the epitome...

1. Days Gone Remastered

And finally, while the Days Gone remaster hasn't officially been announced yet, it's been reported on by enough credible sources - namely reputed insiders Jeff Grubb and Jordan Middler - that it's very clearly happening.

Advertisement

A remaster project that makes Horizon Zero Dawn's seem positively patient by comparison, Days Gone launched on PS4 back in April 2019 - just five-and-a-half years ago.

Unsurprisingly, the open-world action-adventure game still looks pretty damn spectacular, and so the scuttlebutt about an imminent remaster invoked its fair share of eyerolls from the gaming masses.

Again, it's painfully clear that Sony is putting out unasked-for remasters in an attempt to populate their light release calendar, though more than any other remaster on this list, it's tough to see this one being worth the investment that's been put into producing it.

Considering that the PS4 version of Days Gone already runs at 60fps in dynamic 4K on PS5 courtesy of a free patch, who exactly is this for?

Advertisement