10 Video Game Villains We WANTED To Win

From lovable rogues to misunderstood not-so-bad guys.

By Jack Pooley /

Konami

The world of video games is jam packed with incredible villains whose animated personalities and terrifying powers have helped create so many unforgettable gaming moments over the decades.

Advertisement

At the best of times, a villain can be more interesting than the hero, and as such their presence can significantly elevate a game's staying power with fans. But some games dare to take this even further by having players flat-out sympathise with the "baddie."

These 10 games all dared to present antagonists with more relatable, if not entirely morally ambiguous, motivations, such that we could at least see where they were coming from, and perhaps even wish that the game would straight-up let us team up with them.

Advertisement

In a few of these games players were thankfully afforded the opportunity to spare the villains or at least grant them a dignified death, but for the most part we enjoyed their personalities and identified with their actions enough to actually want them to triumph over even the "hero" themselves...

10. Marlene - The Last Of Us

Naughty Dog

One of the greatest things about The Last of Us is its prevailing sense of moral ambiguity, cemented by the game's ending, where players are left to ponder whether or not protagonist Joel did the right thing.

Advertisement

The game concludes with Joel shooting his way through a hospital in order to "save" Ellie from having her immune brain experimented upon, which would've resulted in her death but could've also led to a cure for the infection plaguing humanity.

The final person standing in Joel's way is Marlene, the leader of the Fireflies, whose logic is absolutely sound and who Joel murders in cold blood in the final moments of the game.

Advertisement

Though there was admittedly no guarantee that Marlene's experiment would've netted a cure, it's easy to appreciate the utilitarian thinking in sacrificing one immune person for the potential salvation of humanity.

Joel, meanwhile, was blinded by the loss of his own daughter at the start of the game, and selfishly put Marlene down like a dog so he could maintain his own surrogate-father-daughter relationship with Ellie.

Advertisement

Even if you agree with what Joel did, how can you not at least somewhat sympathise with Marlene's desire to find a cure?

9. Darth Traya - Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic II - The Sith Lords

BioWare

Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic II sees the player mentored by the shadowy Jedi known as Kreia, but later in the game it's revealed that she's actually the ultimate antagonist, a secret Sith Lord known as Darth Traya.

Advertisement

And honestly, it's tough to argue that much with Traya's ideology. She explains to the player that she desires to annihilate the Force to end the relentless death and suffering which stems from the war between the Jedi and Sith, and also to restore pure free will to the galaxy.

The sheer extent of the Jedi/Sith conflict throughout the Star Wars franchise bolsters her claim pretty decisively, and so had Traya managed to succeed in her plan, she would've unquestionably saved a ton of lives.

Advertisement

She's not perfect, of course: she kills a lot of people throughout the game and battles the player at the end, but even in death it's clear that her motivations were for the betterment of the galaxy rather than sheer self-interest.

8. Solidus Snake - Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons Of Liberty

Konami

Much like Traya, Metal Gear Solid 2's Solidus Snake strove to free humanity from a form of control, but ultimately went about it in a questionable - and yes, violent - way.

Advertisement

Solidus' aim was to eliminate the shadowy world-controlling force known as The Patriots, all in the hope of giving personal freedoms back to citizens.

Granted, he murdered protagonist Raiden's parents and freely made use of child soldiers, but given the hand he was dealt in life - being created by the Patriots as the third clone of Big Boss and all - it's easy to appreciate why he's a little screwed up.

Advertisement

Still, his vision for a world no longer ruled by the iron fist of a mysterious organisation was an appealing one, all things considered, and pretty much everything he feared would come to pass eventually did, so you can't even call him paranoid.

7. Handsome Jack - Borderlands 2

Gearbox

Now, there's no denying that Hyperion Corporation president Handsome Jack is a pure tyrant, ruling over the planet of Pandora with a certain megalomania and effectively enslaving his own daughter Angel. But shucks, personality goes a long way, alright?

Advertisement

Jack is one of the most charming and likeable video game antagonists of the last decade, frequently showing up to vomit cheeky banter in the player's face, and in turn proving far more entertaining than the protagonists themselves.

Though there's absolutely no denying that Jack is a murderous maniac, he nevertheless deserves credit for creating two relatively stable areas on Pandora, Lynchwood and Opportunity, while the rest of the planet is a lawless cesspool.

Advertisement

But at the end of the day, we really wanted Jack to win because he's such a charismatic and exciting presence to be around, and in a world as cartoonishly OTT as Borderlands, he turned out to be its enduring emblem.

6. Ganondorf - The Legend Of Zelda: The Wind Waker

Nintendo

The Legend of Zelda's evergreen antagonist Ganondorf is still a card-carrying baddie at the best of times, but in Wind Waker, he was far more nuanced and even sympathetic than he's ever been.

Advertisement

Throughout the Zelda games, Ganon has characteristically been a one-dimensional, mustache-twirling antagonist hell-bent on conquering Hyrule just because.

But The Wind Waker sought to lend some much-needed shade to the character through his periodic interactions with Link, where he explains that his plan wasn't motivated by sheer maniacal self-interest, but to restore fertility to his desolate land.

Advertisement

Hell, he even flatly explains that he doesn't want to kill Link or Zelda, and his poetic, sorrowful monologues in the game ultimately transform him into a more compellingly weary, tormented character.

That's not to say that Ganon in The Wind Waker is good, because he isn't, but given the well-trod formula of the Zelda games, it actually would've been pretty interesting to see him finally score a decisive win over Link, especially with motives this relatable.

Advertisement

5. Saren - Mass Effect

Bioware

The road to hell is paved with good intentions, and that pretty much defines antagonist Saren's arc throughout the first Mass Effect game.

Advertisement

Saren is a member of the Spectres, an elite group which attempts to ensure stability throughout the galaxy no matter the cost, while answering only to the Citadel Council.

Saren eventually comes across the Reaper flagship Sovereign and surmises that the galaxy's organics are better off being indoctrinated by the Reapers and serving them rather than simply warring themselves into oblivion.

Advertisement

Though Saren ultimately becomes wholly indoctrinated, he's far from a one-note drone, and at the end of the game it's entirely possible for the player to tease out his prevailing sense of self, leading him to commit suicide in order to stop himself from opening the Citadel relay.

But whatever your choice, it's made clear that Saren's reasoning was totally sound: the Reapers' return was as inevitable as the sun rising, and if the only palpable "freedom" was extinction, then synthesis with the Reapers was a thoroughly understandable alternative.

Advertisement

4. The Colossi - Shadow Of The Colossus

Bluepoint Games

We're admittedly using the term "villain" rather scarcely here, but at the outset of Shadow of the Colossus it's nevertheless easy to appreciate that the game's sixteen gigantic ancient creatures do strike fearful and imposing figures.

Advertisement

As the game carries on and players fell Colossus after Colossus, a creeping doubt emerges, that maybe these creatures are just minding their own damn business, and by slaughtering our way through them in order to save our unconscious love Mono, we're the real a**hole.

This feeling is confirmed at the end of the game, when it's revealed that killing the Colossi simply united the scattered remnants of the tyrant Dormin, the real villain of the game, while the Colossi largely only acted out of self-defense when pestered by protagonist Wander.

Advertisement

Replaying the game, there's that nagging feeling at the back of your brain that just wishes the Colossi could win and live happily forever after, because though they're undeniable roadblocks that players must push through, they really deserved to just crush Wander into a fine paste.

3. Letho - The Witcher 2: Assassins Of Kings

CD Projekt RED

Letho of Gulet is The Witcher 2's primary antagonist, and though he may look like nothing more than a musclebound brute, he's actually one of the smartest and most impressively Machiavellian characters in the entire Witcher universe.

Advertisement

It's ultimately revealed that Letho is in league with the Nilfgaardian Empire, who have offered to revive the dying Viper School of witchers if he helps wipe out the rulers of the Northern Kingdoms.

Throughout the game, it's made clear that Letho is a fiercely intelligent villain who, regardless of whether you decide to kill or spare him at the end of the game, manages to effortlessly execute the bulk of his plan with a fair degree of ease.

Advertisement

He's also got a shared past with protagonist Geralt, and so when it came to that final decision, most players simply couldn't bring themselves to kill him.

As much as we can all argue that murder is flatly wrong no matter the cause, it's easy to see why Letho was seduced by the Empire so easily.

Advertisement

2. Pagan Min - Far Cry 4

Ubisoft

Though Far Cry 3's Vaas Montenegro is undeniably the most iconic antagonist in the franchise, Far Cry 4's Pagan Min beats him on the relatability and sympathy fronts.

Advertisement

To be clear, the country of Kyrat is a fascinating stew of moral ambiguity at the best of times, and so when you consider that the charismatic despot Min has known nothing but a life of violence since the cradle, is it at all shocking that he turned out the way he did?

Kyrat is already in ruins before Min usurps control, and given that both of the game's two alternatives to Min, the Golden Path's Amita and Sabal, ultimately have highly questionable methods, it truly feels like maintaining the status quo is the least-damaging approach.

Advertisement

Hilariously, players are actually able to let Pagan Min win in the game's secret ending, which is unlocked by simply sitting tight for 15 minutes at the start of the game until he comes back and helps you spread your mother's ashes. What a guy.

1. Shadowlord - Nier

Cavia

The big plot twist at the end of the first Nier is that the villainous Shadowlord is actually the Gestalt version of Nier who is briefly playable at the very beginning of the game, and the Nier players have actually been controlling for the majority is simply a Replicant.

Advertisement

The brilliant irony of this is that both versions of Nier effectively have the same goals, to save their daughter and also humanity as a whole, but are coming at it from entirely different perspectives.

Given that the Replicant Nier slaughters his way through Shades even with the eventual knowledge that they are actually sentient people simply trying to fend off his attacks, he's not exactly the most sympathetic hero all things considered.

Advertisement

And so, the game could so easily have flipped its protagonist and antagonist around, given how difficult it is to passionately root against Shadowlord.