10 Video Games Probably Made Out Of Spite

When games exist because the developer has a bone to pick.

By Jack Pooley /

While there's absolutely no denying that most video games are developed primarily to make money, there's more often than not some sort of underlying artistic spark coming from a genuine place of creativity.

Advertisement

Developers generally want you to enjoy their games or be emotionally moved by them, but sometimes games come to market for altogether more cynical reasons - out of good old-fashioned spite, even.

These 10 video games were all produced not purely through artistic inspiration but a rage-driven desire to prove their many detractors and enemies wrong.

From battling the press and vocal players to even previous employers, the developers behind these games had gigantic chips on their shoulders, as they attempted to enact the best revenge by releasing a game that stuck two fingers up at all their detractors.

In some cases this fury led to a genuinely innovative or entertaining piece of work, but in many examples the end result was overly clouded by the bile-induced nature of its creation.

And so, spite alone rarely makes a good game, but if it's backed by a great idea it can prove to be sufficiently compelling motivation...

10. Duke Nukem Forever

When Duke Nukem Forever was announced back in 1997 - just a year after the release of the acclaimed, iconic Duke Nukem 3D - nobody would've ever dubbed it a project greenlit out of spite.

Advertisement

But as the years wore on and the game's development became increasingly strained, with various unrelated spin-off Duke titles coming and going, Duke Nukem Forever became the laughing stock of the gaming industry.

With the games press dubbing it "Duke Nukem Taking Forever" following numerous delays, developers 3D Realms responded by declaring in 2001 that it would be released "when it's done."

For most of the next decade, players and journalists alike assumed the game would never come out, while also questioning whether Duke Nukem as a character could hold up in an increasingly progressive, sexism-averse society.

The intense doubt surrounding the game's release was exacerbated by the downsizing of the original dev team in 2009, and in the very same year publisher Take-Two Interactive filed a lawsuit against 3D Realms for failing to deliver a complete build of the game.

But in 2010 it was confirmed that the game was indeed in development as a co-production between Triptych Games, Gearbox Software, and Piranha Games.

Duke Nukem Forever was finally released in the summer of 2011 to unsurprisingly negative reviews - citing both its dated gameplay and now-unappealing protagonist - while sales were just half of Take-Two's expectations.

Needless to say, the game was laboured over for 15 years, and it's easy to appreciate that the pervasive mockery surrounding the project only further encouraged 3D Realms to keep pushing the outdated, flagrantly bigoted boulder up the hill.

9. Metal Gear Survive

You won't find many games that rustled more feathers through their sheer existence than Metal Gear Survive.

Advertisement

The survival game spin-off to Hideo Kojima's iconic action-stealth franchise was immediately derided by fans when it was announced in the summer of 2016, almost exactly a year after Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain hit shelves.

Survive was the first Metal Gear game developed without Kojima due to his acrimonious split from Konami following completion of The Phantom Pain, and given its marked departure from the gameplay, style, and tone of the Metal Gear games, many felt it was effectively flipping the bird at Kojima.

With its emphasis on felling zombie-like enemies, microtransaction-driven multiplayer, and requirement that players are permanently connected to the Internet, it was understandably interpreted as a soulless, bitter attempt to milk the Metal Gear brand after Kojima's exit.

The fact that Konami licensed a series of Metal Gear-branded pachinko machines shortly before Survive's announcement only further fuelled the belief that the publisher was basically turning the IP into a merchandising carousel once Kojima was out of the picture.

Survive went on to receive mixed-to-negative reviews from most critics and also underwhelm at retail.

Though rumours persist that a new remake of the original Metal Gear Solid is in the works, we've heard barely a concrete peep about the series since Survive cratered commercially.

8. Returnal

The recently-released PS5 roguelike shooter Returnal delivers one of the most impressive developer glow-ups in recent gaming history, as Finnish outfit Housemarque went from developing more modest shooters like Resogun and Nex Machina to an insanely ambitious, critically acclaimed third-person shooter which Sony considers a "mega-hit."

Advertisement

As great as Returnal is, though, it's clear that Housemarque's decision to move away from niche retro-styled shooters towards something closer in style to Dark Souls wasn't something they did by choice.

Back in 2017, Housemarque co-founder and CEO Ilari Kuittinen spoke bluntly about the commercial underperformance of their most acclaimed titles, namely the raved-about Nex Machina, before confirming the company would be no longer developing arcade-y shooters:

"We know from those numbers that quite a lot of people have played those games, but I think it's more that they don't want to pay for them. They expect to get them for free... Actually, Super Stardust HD sold more for PlayStation 3 [ten years ago], when it had a fraction of the owners that PlayStation 4 has now with Nex. So maybe those people have just moved on. They are not active in the market any more.
The core thing is that there's no paying audience for games like this. Or we can't reach them, and I don't know how those people can be reached if they haven't heard about our games [already]... We would love to have continued developing Nex Machina for years to come, to support the audience that has been loyal to us. But unfortunately there is not enough of those guys."

Kuittinen took his frustration with the industry and developed a larger-scale, more mainstream-skewing product which resonated with a large swath of players.

As a cherry on top, Returnal's success led to Housemarque being acquired by Sony just two months after its release. Talk about a happy ending.

7. Call Of Duty

Nobody could've ever predicted the unprecedented success of the Call of Duty franchise, which before becoming an unstoppable commercial juggernaut with 2007's Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare, staked its claim as a more modest competitor to the popular Medal of Honour series.

Advertisement

The original 2003 game was created by new studio Infinity Ward, after co-founder Vince Zampella had worked at 2015, Inc. as co-designer of the universally-acclaimed Medal of Honor: Allied Assault.

With EA trying to absorb 2015, Inc. into EA so that the next game could be developed in-house, Zampella and co-designer Jason West both decided to leave the studio and form their own outfit, Infinity Ward.

Ultimately all 22 original members of Infinity Ward were brought over from the Allied Assault team at 2015 and helped create Call of Duty, which in addition to being a bit of a "f**k you" to EA, in Zampella's own words, was also internally called "the MOH Killer."

As we all know, Call of Duty's surging popularity caused Medal of Honor's decline in the years that followed, and though West and Zampella enjoyed enormous success publishing their new franchise under Activision, that relationship also had its limitations...

6. Titanfall

After Infinity Ward's Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare proved to be a groundbreaking critical and commercial success in 2007, West and Zampella used their newfound clout to renegotiate their contracts with publisher Activision in 2008.

Advertisement

Activision agreed to larger bonuses and more creative control for the pair in exchange for Modern Warfare 2 being released in 2009, albeit with the asterisk that Activision would regain creative control if West and Zampella were ever fired.

And here's where things get ugly. Activision ended up firing the pair for "breach of contract and insubordination," even having security march them out of the office under the belief they were trying to set up a new independent studio while taking many Infinity Ward employees with them.

Various settlements were eventually reached out of court, during which time West and Zampella set up their new studio, Respawn Entertainment, with 38 employees resigning from Infinity Ward to come join them.

The kicker? Respawn ended up publishing their work through EA, who would allow them to retain all intellectual rights to their original titles.

This led to the creation of Respawn's revolutionary shooter Titanfall, which was naturally dubbed a "Call of Duty killer" in the games press.

While ultimately failing to unseat Call of Duty as the FPS king, it nevertheless delivered a huge breath of fresh air in the genre space - as did its superior sequel.

5. Radical Heights

Hero shooter LawBreakers was released in 2017, with developer Cliff "CliffyB" Bleszinski hoping that his irreverent take on the genre would be worth a retail purchase, rather than being a free-to-play release as originally planned.

Advertisement

Despite solid acclaim, LawBreakers failed to find an active community, in part due to it never being released on Xbox One, resulting in the game's servers being deactivated barely a year after launch.

But several months before LawBreakers was officially shuttered, Bleszinski evidently realised the writing was on the wall, and attempted to cash-in on another hot trend at the time - the Battle Royale genre.

In April 2018, while LawBreakers was still letting out its prolonged death rattle, CliffyB announced Radical Heights, a PUBG-esque Battle Royale game, which was released in Early Access shortly thereafter.

The announcement and the game itself were both met with considerable derision by players and the press, noting its blatantly thrown-together state, and the perception that CliffyB was hastily chasing a flashy trend rather than actually making a game out of artistic inspiration.

A month after the game entered Early Access, Boss Key Productions was shut down due to the commercial failures of both LawBreakers and Radical Heights. Yikes.

4. Manhunt 2

Rockstar's 2003 stealth-horror game Manhunt was released to enormous controversy due to its high level of graphic violence, which a year later led to a a moral panic being incited by the British press, suggesting that the killer of 14-year-old Stefan Pakeerah may have been "trained" by the game.

Advertisement

This naturally only led to Manhunt becoming a more sought-after item worldwide, and despite Rockstar's understandable frustration at their grisly game being linked to real-life killing, they pretty much seemed to double down for the sequel. Controversy creates cash, after all.

Within two days of Manhunt 2 being announced, before any gameplay footage had been released, campaigners began calling for the game to be banned, and the situation only became more heated as its release neared.

Many ratings boards around the world refused to classify Manhunt 2 due to its extreme violence, deemed to be far in excess of the original Manhunt, such that it was only released in some territories with brutal executions blurred out and the point-scoring system removed.

Though reviews were ultimately wildly mixed, it's clear that Rockstar saw the hysterical reaction to the original game and decided to one-up things for the sequel, no matter the enormous hassle it caused them.

3. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5

Sometimes publishers decide to greenlight games not because they've got a particularly worthwhile idea, but simply because they want to make the most of their licensing rights before they expire.

Advertisement

That's precisely what happened with the Tony Hawk's Pro Skater franchise. Though the series had been flagging for many years, Activision opted to rush a fifth mainline game through production before their deal with Tony Hawk expired in 2015.

Like most of the Tony Hawk's Pro Skater games made by Robomodo, THPS5 was near-universally panned by critics for its janky, bug-filled gameplay and how obviously it wasn't anywhere close to being complete.

It was painfully clear that Activision wanted to squeeze a little extra cash out of the series without any care for the actual quality of the release, further tarnishing the once-good name of Tony Hawk's video games in the process.

But Activision made good with Hawk last year with the release of the Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 1 + 2 remaster collection, which received strongly positive reviews and became the fastest-selling game in the franchise.

2. Hatred

In 2014, Destructive Creations announced their new isometric shooter Hatred, which cast players as a misanthropic mass shooter tasked with slaughtering as many helpless civilians as possible.

Advertisement

Hatred was immediately controversial, prompting director Jarosław Zieliński to retort that the game was intended to be a reaction to the perceived surge of political correctness in games, challenging conventional notions of both morality and art.

Hatred was given the ultra-rare "Adults Only (AO)" rating by the ESRB and even temporarily removed from Steam Greenlight before the company returned it with an apology from Valve co-founder and president himself, Gabe Newell.

Ultimately Hatred was largely panned by critics but went on to become a best-seller on Steam, with a "Mostly Positive" consensus from over 9,000 purchases.

As the saying goes, there's no such thing as bad publicity. Hatred may not be a very good game, but as a rebuke against good taste, it clearly struck a chord with a lot of people.

1. Muck!

But perhaps no video game in history has been more literally created out of spite than the recently-released free-to-play multiplayer survival game Muck!

Advertisement

Popular YouTuber Dani received a reply to one of his posts where a user mockingly challenged him to make his own multiplayer survival game, and despite the months of work it would entail, Dani did just that.

The Minecraft-esque Muck! was created in Unity by Dani, who used various online tutorials to create the most basic gameplay systems and then implement more complex elements such as procedural generation.

Despite being a game basically made "for the lulz," Muck! released to enthusiastic reviews from the Steam community, where it holds a "Very Positive" average rating from roughly 70,000 players.

For a game that could so easily have been a charmless, slung-together "anti-game" in the name of humour, that it actually functions at all is insanely impressive. Bravo.

Advertisement