10 Video Games That Didn't Go FAR ENOUGH

Half an idea is only half an excuse.

By William Carter /

The gaming medium is packed full of eclectic experiences, new ideas, and brave innovations.

Advertisement

Approaching a video game with a fresh perspective can grant new opportunities, and when a title promises something different, it's always hard to live up to the hype. Standing out from the ever-growing crowd is a feat reserved for the very best minds in the business, meaning only half an idea simply won't do.

That said, half-steps are nothing new, as there are plenty of games that claim to offer a unique gameplay formula, quirky narrative wrinkle, or revolutionary presentation. Such claims are ripe for fan anticipation, so when the game releases and it doesn't utilise the feature as much as expected, it stands out for all the wrong reasons.

It doesn't mean that the product is bad, and can't be improved in the future, but it's a sign that the developer bit off more than it could chew, and promoted an addition that wasn't fully fleshed out.

There are plenty of games that go too far with an idea, but perhaps even more that simply don't go far enough.

10. Life Is Strange

For all its shortcomings, Life is Strange is a superb example of character development done right, and overcomes its issues to be one of the best games of 2015.

Advertisement

Max Caulfield is a great protagonist, and players are granted the opportunity to see the fictional town of Arcadia Bay, Oregon through her eyes. The story that unfolds is one of friendship, deception, and mystery, but one of the most well-known inclusions was Max's sudden ability to rewind time which gets her into, and out of plenty of sticky situations throughout.

An unexpected ability is the one through-line for all Life is Strange main characters, and though Max uses hers regularly, it never feels like anything other than a lazy plot device.

Alex Chen being an empath in Life is Strange: True Colors is baked into the fabric of the story, as her ability to experience others' emotions allows us to better understand the world around her. It's essential to the journey, but Max being able to rewind time is just a means to unravel what has already occurred.

Max constantly keeps it hidden, and the solution would surely be to reveal it to more side characters, as it would then feel more of a substantial narrative thread.

9. Shadow Of The Tomb Raider

Shadow of the Tomb Raider is the conclusion to the superb Survivor Trilogy that explores Lara Croft in her early years. The events of all three games shape her for future adventures, and as the series goes on, she becomes a more proficient explorer.

Advertisement

2013's Tomb Raider shows the character is a survivor and its sequel, Rise of the Tomb Raider, demonstrates that she's becoming resourceful in the harsh wilderness. Shadow of the Tomb Raider promised a new side of Lara Croft, one that is an effective and unapologetic killer.

In reality, the final chapter of the trilogy felt half-hearted.

The most popular criticism of Shadow of the Tomb Raider is that is didn't offer anything new. It felt like just another game in the series, and with a mediocre story balanced by gorgeous environments, it didn't bring the darker tone that was promised.

There's a glimpse f hope in the game's latter stages, as Lara is faced with overcoming a barrage of Trinity's forces and does so in brutal fashion. However, when the scene ends, she reverts back to the somewhat boring character she has been throughout the game.

There is so much potential for the character that Crystal Dynamics created, but Shadow of the Tomb Raider didn't take advantage of it.

8. Detroit: Become Human

Detroit: Become Human is the latest game from the mind of David Cage, the director of both Heavy Rain and Beyond: Two Souls. Telling the story of three separate androids in a futuristic Detroit, Michigan, the tale is one that is steeped in cultural and social commentary.

Advertisement

The developer's previous works meant that players knew what to expect with its game design. Quantic Dream were never going to release an online shooter or intricate driving simulator, and Detroit: Become Human is thoroughly in line with what came before for the Paris-based company.

Where it differs from past projects was its near-future setting and approach to technology as a narrative driving force. Promotional material showcased a tense relationship between humans and androids, and the impact that a reliance on artificial intelligence has had on the midwestern city as a whole.

The reality is that, while Detroit: Become Human is a great game, it spends more time exploring the humanity of androids themselves instead of the way their inclusion has changed society.

Connor, Markus and especially Kara are more compassionate than most of the humans in the game, and while this compelling, the game didn't delve far enough into uneasy the rift between androids and humans.

7. Deus Ex: Human Revolution

Deus Ex is a franchise that has a rich history, and though the 2000 original is one of the most influential games of the century, the series was revived in an attempt to recapture the magic.

Advertisement

Developed by Eidos Montreal (creators of the recent Guardians of the Galaxy title), Deus Ex: Human Revolution served as both a prequel, and a reboot. Players take on the role of Adam Jensen, a security officer for Sarif Industries, the leading company of body-altering 'augmentations'.

The story is one that is gripping from the get-go, with Jensen attempting to make sense of events that occur in the game's opening hours while navigating a gorgeous cyberpunk-inspired setting.

Naturally, the topic of cybernetic enhancement and transhumanism comes with the territory. It's an intriguing wrinkle to the game's presentation and storytelling, but goes sorely underutilised throughout.

The contrast between those augmented, and those who are not isn't explored in any significant way. Such a glaring divide in society should make for a compelling narrative thread, and is ripe for further analysis, but the tale that unfolds around Adam Jensen simply gets in the way.

More needed to be done to make Deus Ex: Human Revolution in keeping with the success of the original.

6. Wii Play

When it released in the winter of 2006, the Nintendo Wii promised an entirely new way to play. Motion controls were the flavour of the generation, and while some games like the beloved Wii Sports and unjustifiably criticised The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword were utilising them entirely, others didn't really bother.

Advertisement

Nintendo themselves are guilty of this, as Wii Play released as a launch game for the system in most territories. It was only really designed to be a demonstration of the technology, and certainly won't be mistaken for an ambitious RPG any time soon. However, while it sold in astronomical numbers, it failed to live up to the intended purpose of the console it was promoting.

Whereas Wii Sports took full advantage of the technology, Wii Play didn't. Most of the mini games required the controller's pointing capabilities, so it failed to feel like anything more than an uninspired collection of menial activities that could just as easily be played on a PC.

Copies also included an extra controller, which was the only real reason to pick Wii Play up. It missed the mark, and didn't do enough as an in-house, Wii-branded game.

5. No Man's Sky

No Man's Sky is one of gaming's biggest redemption arcs.

Advertisement

Revealed to the world in December 2013 and quickly becoming one of the most disappointing titles of the generation, No Man's Sky has since become a game that is almost the one that was promised.

The basis of No Man's Sky was that it presented a randomly generated galaxy of over 18 quintillion planets for players to discover, understand and survive on. The lofty expectations were provoked further by the game's marketing, so when it released and was incredibly frugal with its aesthetic variety, the backlash was inevitable.

The game didn't promote exploration anything close to what fans expected. The number of planets available was truly incredible, but the volume of locations doesn't mean that there's always something different to do on each one. It was a real shame, as players' minds were racing at the possibility of finding new, uninhabited lands with pockets of intrigue in every corner.

When the ambition of the game's developer is the very reason it was so underwhelming, its limitations become far more newsworthy, and it's clear to see that it wasn't what so many fans thought it was.

All that space, and No Man's Sky still didn't go far enough with its premise.

4. Animal Crossing: New Horizons

Animal Crossing is a franchise that is near and dear to so many. From its beginnings on the GameCube to a thoroughly underappreciated mobile offering in the form of Pocket Camp, it is known for cute characters, pick-up-put-down gameplay and menial tasks that are far more fun than they have any right to be.

Advertisement

The latest, Animal Crossing: New Horizons, is perhaps the series' best game, with plenty of elements from past entries being refined for its debut on the Nintendo Switch. However, so many annoyances that plagued previous games remained, and though there are hours upon hours of fun to be had, the perfect island getaway always feels restrictive.

Most of what is done in Animal Crossing: New Horizons is for aesthetic purposes. Arranging flower displays, meticulously reorganizing garden decorations or filling out Blathers' museum all serve to make running around the island a more pleasing experience to look at.

Only a few items in the game provoke new gameplay mechanics, and while social elements are included, it never feels like there's anything for multiple players to do. It's a beloved franchise for so many reasons, but so much of it feels surface level, and it should have offered more substance this time around.

3. F1 Race Stars

F1 Race Stars is a game that many have forgotten, and even more never heard of to begin with.

Advertisement

Released in November 2012, the game was a typical, by-the-numbers kart racer. However, instead of Mario and Luigi, it included the grid of that year's F1 season with the likes of Lewis Hamilton, Sebastian Vettel, and Kimi Räikkönen making up its roster. The references didn't stop there, though, as tracks were inspired by real-world circuits on the calendar.

This sounds great, but upon completing just a handful of races, it became clear that the game lacked identity, as it failed to lean into the sport that spawned it. With the likes of Monza, Silverstone and Montreal featured in the game, they didn't feel anything like what F1 fans would have expected, as the iconic corners and gorgeous scenery is replaced by Mario Kart-ish mayhem.

As such, it didn't do anything to stand out. It released on a litany of platforms, yet never reached the heights that Nintendo has achieved, and while there is fun to be had, it didn't go far enough with the F1 license.

F1 Race Stars forgets the magic of the circuits that it includes, and thinks that more craziness is better when in reality, it was its downfall.

2. Dead Space 3

The lofty expectations that were set by its predecessors meant that Dead Space 3 was always doomed to fail. The original is one of the most beloved horror games of all time, presenting an engaging story, plenty of violence, and claustrophobic, unsettling level design. While the sequel was less revered, it was still met with high praise.

Advertisement

Dead Space 3 released in the early stages of 2013, a year that would be packed with genre-defining titles like Grand Theft Auto V, The Last of Us, and Dota 2. It built upon the first two in a number of ways, with tighter gameplay and new upgrade system leading the charge. However, in the pursuit of innovation, it forgot what made the franchise so great to begin with: horror.

Dead Space 3 isn't scary, as the narrow corridors and tense combat encounters are few and far between. Action was the flavour of Dead Space 3, and like the Resident Evil series before it, the emphasis on Hollywood-esque set pieces only served to damage the game's horror-driven identity.

Dead Space 3 went too far with its action, and as such, it didn't have time to go far enough with its approach to tension, intrigue, and fear.

1. Mortal Kombat (SNES Version)

Mortal Kombat is a series that is as hated as it is loved. It's one that offers intricate fighting mechanics and tough competition while also being a visual marvel with its liberal, and controversial use of blood, guts, and gore.

Advertisement

Fatalities have been the topic of much chatter over the years, with many believing them to be too brutal for the gaming medium. For fans, Mortal Kombat would not be the same without it, and its unapologetic violence has quickly become part of its charm.

When the arcade original arrived on home consoles, there was a clear divide with the way in which Sega and Nintendo handles its release. The former opted for a straight port of the arcade classic, whereas the Super Nintendo version censored the mature content and as such, the game lost one of the very things that made it unique.

With Street Fighter 2 releasing a whole year before, there was no reason to play the SNES port of Mortal Kombat, as its clunky controls and lack of gore made sure it was nothing compared to Capcom's crowning achievement. It didn't do enough to separate itself from the crowd, so most players opted to play it on the Sega Genesis instead.

Advertisement