10 Video Games That Had No Right Being Fun

For those times when we all question just where the last six hours went.

By Glen James Lewis /

When you really think about it, the fact that the most famous video game star is a fat plumber who eats mushrooms and kicks turtles in the face is a bit weird. It sounds unique, yes, but it doesn't exactly sound like €œfun.€ Unless you're into that sort of thing. It just goes to show that some of the best ideas developers have ever come up with are the ones you would never have considered. Some of the best games sound exactly as fun as they are, like Metal Gear and its €œtactical espionage€ pitch or Skyrim and its €œswords and magic€ shtick, but others just sound like nonsense. Nonsense, that is, until you actually play it and realise that fun can be found in even the most unlikely places. Thanks to the huge range of creative licence and freedom in the gaming market, there have been some absolutely terrible sounding products in our time that miraculously turned out to be awesome experiences. And so, this is a series of titles which don't seem to have any place being called €œfun,€ yet still manage to blow your socks off, even though it feels dirty and completely wrong. Just like kicking turtles.

10. The Oregon Trail

Oh good, Mary broke her arm. All we need now is for Davey to contract measles and it'll be a party. Dying of dysentery is universally accepted as being kind of rubbish, so it's strange to think that Oregon Trail was such a popular video game. It's designed as an educational experience (another warning sign for most discerning players) to teach kids about life as a pioneer travelling across the titular trail. What this basically means is that your characters will be dying from various awful illnesses quite a lot and being hungry, which is exactly as pleasant as it sounds. Thanks to the unpredictable simulation game play, it manages to make a tiring, dangerous and very real journey oddly engaging.

9. Animal Crossing

Ask most Animal Crossing fans what they actually do in the game, and they'll say something like €œWell, you collect fruit to pay off crippling debts and swap furniture with squirrels.€ For a series that people spend hundreds of hours in, it doesn't seem like you actually DO much. This is one of those games where you can sink hours and hours and come out unsure about what you actually spent all that time doing. You develop deep, emotional relationships with fluffy animals even though all they do is send you letters that make no sense. You sell shells to make enough money to buy that six-hundredth bedside table shaped like a lemon. And you do it because you learned something about yourself playing Animal Crossing: You like fruit-themed furniture. It's akin to waking up after a particularly crazy night out with no recollection of events, all that's left is a traffic cone in your living room as proof that someone - somewhere - had a bloody good time.

8. Doritos Crash Course

This game controls terribly and is obviously a quick cash-in to advertise the titular crisps brand to their target audience: poor innocent gamers. Despite this, the game ended up being incredibly fun, especially if you play it with friends. And as a bonus, it's free! Crash Course is designed to be challenging, and plays like a side-scrolling video game version of Wipeout with various obstacles blocking your path to the finish line. You have to do it as quickly as possible, but that's easier said than done with super floaty controls that aim to be like Super Meat Boy but end up feeling like throwing a slice of ham into a keyhole - nigh impossible, yet strange appetising. Even so, it ends up being fun to try to unite with your friends and defeat not only the obstacles in your path, but the actual game itself. You end up having a genuinely good time even though it feels wrong in every way.

7. Curiosity - What's Inside The Cube?

You could argue that this game wasn't actually any fun. People ended up in a kind of abusive relationship with this strange creation that told you outright what would ultimately be your downfall: curiosity. People played because they genuinely wanted to know what Fable-creator Peter Molyneux had put at the centre of this gigantic cube made up of tiny blocks - all you had to do was work together and tap away. Most predicted the prize to be dumb, but some people were cautiously optimistic that it would be a suitably Molyneux-ian dream like getting taken off to live out their lives in a paradise among the stars. The 'life-changing' prize turned out to be some kind of God-status in 22Cans' next game Godus, as well as a portion of revenue from the game. Yay? While the result was a little underwhelming, it's undeniable that for a while there, we were all having a genuinely good time tapping on our phone screen for hours on end, hoping and wondering about that mysterious centre.

6. Mario Bros.

Though not talking about Super Mario Bros, the side-scrolling masterpiece, nor about Donkey Kong, the game about climbing pylons to thwart an evil gorilla. This is actually talking about the arcade game Mario Bros, where you...kick turtles, crabs and sometimes bees while trawling through the sewers. Yeah, that one. In the infancy of video games, it was perfectly acceptable to pitch an idea such as €œyou are a big dot eating smaller dots and sometimes ghosts€ and people would stand up and slowly clap in awe. But when €œyou're a plumber killing turtles and angry lobsters€ was pitched, surely something like Asteroid sounded a bit more exciting by comparison. Either way though, the game became a smash hit, as it turned out running around a dirty sewer with inexplicably angry amphibians roaming the pipes was a blast.

5. Papers, Please

No game in the history of games has ever sounded so ludicrously unappealing as Papers, Please does, yet it bagged itself quite a number of accolades last year after turning out to be a lot better in practice than on, well, paper. You take the role of a border control officer for a fictional country called Arstotzka, and must take on the thrilling task of... inspecting the documentation of immigrants wishing to make a new home in your glorious homeland. In the game, you are strictly punished for missing small details that mark documents as fake, creating a meticulous and draining experience that, against all odds, utterly gripped everyone around the globe. With a family at home that needed feeding and occasional dramatic events requiring tough prioritising decisions, this border control simulator asked just how far you would go in making sure your family survived, winning the hearts of gamers despite it looking like the most soul-crushingly dull minute-to-minute gameplay experience out there.

4. Flappy Bird

This is one of those few games where the title literally tells the entire story of the actual experience itself. You're a bird that flaps. While console games continue to explore deeper and richer experiences, mobile games seem to have done the exact opposite, presenting gamers with quick experiences that last seconds at a time. This is great for portable gaming on the bus or while going down a slide at the park, but something about the sheer bare bones simplicity of Flappy Bird defies all logic when it comes to €œhaving fun.€ There's only one environment, one button to press, one character to 'control' and one experience to have over and over again. And yet, for a few months earlier in the year people were utterly addicted. It was almost a Pokemon-level craze, despite being so incredibly basic.

3. Final Fantasy XIV: A Realm Reborn

When Final Fantasy XIV first launched in 2010, it sailed into shore to a crowd of notably peeved Final Fantasy fans who were less than happy with this awful MMO addition to their beloved series. It had bugs, errors and numerous seemingly unfinished elements, as well as unsatisfying gameplay to boot. Normally, you would expect a catastrophic failure such as this to crawl into a shack far away in the mountains and never emerge again, save for the occasional hunting expedition to sustain its sad life of solitude, but this story turned out very differently €“ Square Enix rereleased the game as Final Fantasy XIV: A Realm Reborn, and this time...it was incredibly good. This second coming in 2013 took the same basic game and cleared up pretty much every issue people had with the original, resulting in a miraculously well-made and fun experience. To see a game go from some a universally panned mess to a critically acclaimed success was utterly unbelievable.

2. Manhunt

Violence in video games is a common thread, but when it came to Rockstar North's ultraviolent horror game Manhunt - in which players would experience psychologically draining and visually gruesome acts in order to progress - things got very, very real. This was a stealth game which asked players to avoid having horrible things done to them by doing far more horrible things to any surrounding gang members that were hunting them down, and it's a bit of a nightmare. Where some horror games have moments of relief after big scares where you might laugh at your reaction, Manhunt is just a dark trip that revels in violence in a way that borders on total discomfort. Despite being banned in many places and having an overbearingly grim atmosphere, the game was fun when you can get along with the whole 'horrifyingly brutal murder' thing. If ever there was an argument that video games are getting too violent, this would be Exhibit A, and Exhibit B would be how much fun people have actually had tumbling down this creepy rabbit hole.

1. Viscera Cleanup Detail

There are a lot of simulators in the world of video games which let you take on exciting jobs that you would never be able to experience otherwise. Things like flying a plane, or running your own farm, or being a goat. Or being a janitor. That last one sticks out a little because it does not, in fact, sound very exciting. And yet, that is your role in this year's incredibly popular indie release, Viscera Cleanup Detail, in which you must clean up the mess left behind by various battles that other games might have had you taking part in. Meticulously cleaning up gruesome blood stains, it turns out, is a lot of fun when you let your imagination decide exactly what went down. And that is a scary thought indeed. The stereotype is that gamers don't like to clean. Well, look at us now! What games do you think had no right being as fun as they turned out to be? Let us know in the comments!