10 Video Games That Killed Off The Wrong Character
The Arkham games had nowhere to go after Joker died.
Death is everywhere these days. Whether it's a movie, TV show, or video game, it seems that every piece of media released in the past decade has been designed to kill off as many characters as it can.
So why do so many get it wrong?
Killing a character can be a good thing, if it's done right. If not then it leaves the audience dejected, mad, and more importantly feeling just that little bit robbed. Worse than that sometimes the death is so egregious that it can single-handedly ruin an entire franchise in one fell swoop.
After all there's nothing worse than getting attached to a character, growing with them through multiple instalments of a series, and watching them develop as the story goes on - only for for them to be ripped away for no good reason at all. Especially when there are so many other, worse characters that could have taken that bullet.
Whether they were killed for reasons good or bad, the following characters bit the dust one way or another, and their respective series have simply never been the same.
10. Lilith & Maya - Borderlands 3
Borderlands 3 arrived late last year and... has pretty much been forgotten about by everybody. While the premium looter shooter will never make its way onto any 'Top Ten Narratives in Video Games' list, it still tries. Apparently that involves killing off at least one fan favourite character per game, like all storytelling should aim to do.
Due to the narrative genius of Gearbox, it isn't just one, but two Vault hunters that die this time around.
The problem isn't that Maya and Lilith get the axe - it's that there are SO many worse characters the game could have chosen instead.
Ava is annoying, she's always in the way, and she complains at every step of her journey. Not only that, but then the game tries to claim she's one of its most important characters, and just gives her Maya's powers. Wonderful work Gearbox, hilarious joke.
It's as if one of the writers said 'we need to kill someone, fans love that', then made the voice actors play a game of Russian roulette. The twist being every cylinder was loaded and only the fun characters were allowed to play.
9. Revan - Star Wars: The Old Republic
With the revelation that Star Wars may be working on some sort of new Knights of the Old Republic game/show/movie fans are understandably divided. Especially after the recent direction Star Wars has been going in.
In The Old Republic, Revan is back, except he really isn't. One of the most popular Star Wars characters of all time re-enters the franchise just to be beaten in a single flashpoint (The Old Republic's version of a raid or dungeon).
Then Shadow of Revan came out and most assumed it would be another chance for Revan to really shine. Turned out, the expansion was just one long slog through ever increasingly insulting missions, just to put the old legend out of his misery.
Again.
The simple solution would have been not to kill him in the first place.
Instead, the player base was left with the likes of Theron Shan and Koth Vortena, two of the worst characters currently still alive in The Old Republic's ever diminishing lifespan. Don't just throw some random guys on screen and try to act like the player's level seventy characters should care after countless hours of grinding without them.
To any Star Wars writers reading this:
Stop ruining Star Wars.
8. Johnny Gat - Saints Row 3
There used to be a time when Saints Row meant something, back when there were no flying cars, no aliens, and thank God no Professor Genki.
Then Saints Row 3 happened. After too much criticism that Saints Row 2 was just a poorer man's GTA, it was time for Volition to radically mix things up. That involved killing the best damned character in the whole franchise, and worse it involved killing him off screen.
When Johnny Gat dies in the opening of Saints Row 3, there is nothing the player can do other than scream. "Please take Pierce instead! Even Shaundi will do!"
Unfortunately that doesn't happen, and Gat is gone.
In his place the player is left with two characters that serve their purpose well enough, yet they could never really compare to the raw charisma of Mr. Johnny Gat.
The death is such an egregious example of killing off the wrong character that Saints Row 4 retconned the whole thing and threw away a slew of 3's mediocre supporting cast.
Turns out Gat was simply kidnapped by aliens because he was a threat to their plans. At least you made it right in the end, Volition.
7. Frank West - Dead Rising 4
What is the single biggest character assassination in all of video games? No it isn't Sylvanas or Thrall, or really anybody left alive in Warcraft. Although they do come damn close.
Frank West used to be a verifiable video game mascot for the Xbox. He wasn't some macho badass that swung fists and sweated protein shakes. Frank was just a regular guy, kinda flabby, a bit behind on the whole 'zombie' thing, and honestly just trying to make a quick buck.
When he came back in his own "what if?" scenario for Dead Rising 2: Off the Record fans were thrilled. He was chubbier, balder, and while a little too competent he still had that winning Frank West charm.
So clearly the only smart move was to change him entirely and then kill him off in Dead Rising 4. Instead of say Nick Ramos or Chuck Greene - the two infinitely worse - and far more stereotypical macho protagonists of the Dead Rising franchise. Who out there would have really missed those two?
At least Frank can finally rest in peace, safe in the knowledge that it's all over.
Wait, there's a DLC where he's a zombie now? Jesus Christ, Capcom.
6. The House Leaders - Fire Emblem: Three Houses
To anybody even remotely familiar with the Fire Emblem franchise, one thing is immediately clear upon starting the game. One of the beautiful students is going to die, and it's going to be your fault.
Halfway through the game all three houses are thrown head first into a war situation. Dependent on which of the three routes the player takes (four, if you want to admit you're a monster), they will be thrown against the people they regularly took to tea parties and ate lunch with in the early stages, now watching as they fall by Byleth's sword.
The worst part is that one of all three of the game's most interesting and well rounded characters - the three house leaders - will end up dead by the end of the game. It's simply unavoidable and heartbreaking, considering there's no way to save them.
Meanwhile characters like Hanneman are free to sit around Garreg Mach being completely useless for the rest of the game. The choice between listening to Hanneman talk about crests or helping Dimitri overcome his trauma is no choice at all.
There's no amount of butler and maid outfit DLC that can fix this decision.
5. The Joker - Batman Arkham City
The Clown Prince of crime is Batman's most famous villain, and for good reason. While Bats may have a much better rogues' gallery than most superheros - looking at you Whiplash - it's hard for even the likes of Bane or The Riddler to live up to the Joker himself.
So that makes it all the more devastating when he seems to bite the dust for good at the end of Rocksteady's Arkham City. The problem with this death isn't that it was a bad decision; it's simply that the question became "where do we go now?" Arkham Knight follows this up by trying to use Scarecrow and the titular villain himself to drive the story, yet neither of them ever filled those huge clown shoes.
A great choice would have been to kill off one of Batman's every growing roster of support characters instead. Someone like Dick Grayson or Barbara Gordon would have opened up a whole other realm of possibilities. Not to mention just how well it would have tied into the whole Arkham Knight plot line, adding yet another layer into the concept of Batman's guilt.
Instead Joker dies, then just kinda comes back anyway. Classic comic book move.
4. Pretty Much Everyone - Danganronpa
Danganronpa is a game that doesn't get enough credit in the wider gaming world. The premise revolves around a 'killing school game' that involves a twisted moral situation for each of its participants.
Will the students kill someone else to escape their captivity? If they do can they get away with it? Obviously this leads to a lot of deaths, and a lot of player tears as their waifu is unceremoniously murdered.
Eventually this gets to the point where all that's left are some of the most boring and one dimensional characters in the game. So of course, Miss Fanservice and the useless Psychic Stoner Bro are two of the final participants. Unfortunately, the two add nothing to the plot or gameplay; beyond both of them shouting out absurd theories during the class trials that is.
But think of how much better it could have been had pretty much anybody else survived instead. Someone like the manipulative goth gambler, or maybe even the stoic martial arts master. Not the fanfic writer. He can stay dead.
The second game does seems to fair a bit better. This time around only some of your favourites will end up dead.
3. Vol'jin - World Of Warcraft.
What is the problem with the MMO genre and their inability to make smart decisions? Worse yet what is wrong with the Horde and its inability to hold down a good Warchief?
Way back at the end of Mists of Pandaria, Vol'jin was named Warchief of the Horde and all was well for a time. He was a worthy successor to the fan favourite Thrall and held enough of his own personality to lead the Horde in a different, yet smarter direction.
So obviously Vol'jin died and named Sylvanas Warchief.
This was so out of character that he could have turned to the camera - winked - and told every player that Blizzard don't know how to write games anymore. Believe it or not that still would have made more sense to the lore than this.
If Vol'jin's death was replaced by literally any other Horde leader everything would have been better. Maybe with someone like Sylvanas killed off instead, Battle For Azeroth wouldn't have turned out like it did. If only somebody could go back in time and show Blizzard the error of their ways before it was too late, like some sort of Azeroth themed A Christmas Carol.
2. Kenny - The Walking Dead Season 3
Telltale's The Walking Dead is one of those games where nobody is safe and everybody dies. So when Kenny comes back to life in season 2 it's a bit of a shock to the system. He may be one of the biggest jerks this side of the apocalypse, but he's still a kind face in a rather unkind world.
Then he gets thrown out of a car window.
Kenny's death in season 3 is completely out of left field. The whole ordeal happens in a flashback that takes about 5 minutes and then he's gone for good. Get ready for the slog after that as not a single new character in the 3rd season even comes close to his presence.
Although there's nothing particularly wrong with Javier Garcia (The 3rd season protagonist and Kenny replacement for Clementine), there's nothing really right about him either. So for him to live while someone like Kenny dies is a tough pill to swallow. Especially when Telltale didn't even bring him back for the final season.
Maybe it's harsh to suggest Garcia should have died. Maybe he could have just never been written at all? Better yet let's just forget all about season 3.
1. Shinjiro Aragaki - Persona 3
When it comes to JRPGs there are very few that stand as unique as the Persona series. So with the franchise finally getting the mainstream recognition that it deserves in recent years, it's always important to look back at the aging members of its roster.
While there are a good few deaths in Persona 3 that stand out in their respective cut scenes, it's in the game play that Shinjiro Aragaki's stands out. When the player first gains access to Shinjiro as a party member he is an absolute tank, able to take hits and dish them out with equal ease and ability.
Then when he's unceremoniously shot in the heart and killed on a random night (unknowable without a guide). It means a lot of lost progress and a lot of extra grinding to be done.
Compared to other party members that are allowed to live - like Ken or Koramaru - it comes as a heavy blow when Shinjiro is killed. This article in no way condones the killing of video game children or dogs, but let's just say that Ken's whining attitude and mediocre skill set would not have been missed in comparison.