10 Video Games That Only Work ONCE

A surprise is only surprising the first time around.

By Greg Hicks /

Video games have the power to amaze and surprise us, much like any high-budget movie or captivating book. Seeing Captain Walker realise his madness is akin to Darth Vader revealing his paternal side, with as much impact that people will still talk about it ten and forty two years later, respectively.

Advertisement

That being said, reveals like that only have the power to shock once.

Playing through a game again knowing the twist will most definitely not have the same effect, unless you've got short term memory loss and had forgotten it. But it's not just an unexpected twist that only works once.

A sightseeing experience, be it solo or with an AI pet-monster thing, can and will be beautiful the first time a player witnesses it. Going over the same beats immediately loses the gravitas when you start again.

But it's not just the divisive "walking simulators" that fall victim to one-and-done, there are other genres too. Horror games, naturally, lose the impact when the scare is already known. As do inventive puzzle games that rely on visual spectacle and object manipulation. Once the trick is revealed, it's not a surprise anymore.

Unless the lure of trophies/achievements and full completion spurs you on, how many of these games get relegated to the pile of memory? Quite a few, we'd wager.

So, with that in mind, here are ten games that only work once, and be warned: there will be some endgame spoilers in here.

10. The Last Guardian

The rule of diminishing returns is normally applicable to big budget films and games, in which series fatigue and repetition set in. Unfortunately, it can happen to auteur studios and their cult darlings too.

Advertisement

Following Shadow of the Colossus, The Last Guardian's prolonged development and release had gamers hoping it would strike with that whimsical, Team ICO brand of magic we'd come to love.

And, to an extent, it did.

Whilst retaining its clunky, on-brand controls, leading the nameless lad and his pet dog-bird-gryphon-thing is fun to play. Scaling towers, fleeing an unknown sense of evil, whilst reaching the literal heights of escape is great.

However, once it's done, there's no real incentive to go back to it. Knowing how to solve the puzzles and/or Trico-leading sections removes the... magic, if you will. There's no other story paths to take, nor are there any divergent sightseeing paths to show off how well Team ICO do pretty landscapes.

There are speedrun and collectible-based trophies, but that's about it. No recycled whimsy, just the frustration of trying to fast-track your pet's behavioral skills.

9. Superliminal

Games like Portal truly revolutionised first-person puzzlers. The only way from there was up, and what could come next? A game that uses forced perspective and trompe-l'œil to cause some right noodle-scratchers.

Advertisement

The first time players have to lift an item above them, only to drop it down to enlarge it (work that one out), or grab an item from the background to bring it to foreground in the exact same space is mind-blowing.

It's cliche to call something "a trip", but that's exactly what Superliminal is: a visual journey that confuses as much as it excites when it comes to its next puzzle.

But, that magic only applies to that sweet, initial run.

Going through again is, well, like playing Portal through a second time. Players already know the puzzles, the tricks in place and how to solve them. Aside from maybe a divergent room or two for, again, the collectible hunter, there's little different in what to do.

Even watching someone else play for the first time loses its magic, as the solutions are still the same regardless of who plays.

8. Martha Is Dead

Martha Is Dead, the most recent game on this list, caused a bit of a stir prior to its release. Taking the horror genre further, MID stepped it up by making some of its gorier moments interactive. It isn't worth printing them here, but suffice to say they were pretty grim.

Advertisement

But then, most of the story is, not that that's a negative. It covers a lot of sensitive topics, which may be taboo but it offers some representation, for better or worse. It's worth it alone just to play through a psychological story with some grounded horror in it.

That being said, once the Requiem for a Dream-level ending has been seen through, and the bummer feeling subsides, there's really no reason to go back to Martha's vineyard.

There are a few different missions that change some in-game threads, but it doesn't really change the overall ending. Like the aforementioned film above, it doesn't make for repeated viewing/playing.

By all means, experience it the once. But unless players really want to shut off the body horror on screen for the sake of trophies, there's little to lighten the mood a second time.

7. Fahrenheit/Indigo Prophecy

Whilst it could be said that any of David Cage's "interactive movies" would fit here, he at least got better with Heavy Rain and Detroit: Become Human. Whilst the endings are mostly the same, there are branching narratives, to a degree, that warrant some replayability.

Advertisement

The same can't be said for Fahrenheit (or Indigo Prophecy to the non-UK gamers).

For one, the gameplay is achingly slow, making even the most basic of task a drawn-out experience. It was tense the first time Lucas murdered that poor chap in the diner toilet, but the second time? It's quicker to let yourself get caught.

Whilst it may have a few different endings, they only really come into effect near the end (surprisingly). The main game remains largely unchanged throughout, making another playthrough largely the same beats.

Sure, players can speed up some events, or conversely drag a few out. But there's not much incentive to do so. When the story's grand reveal about Mayans, old-lady-secretly-the-Internet and other nutter-butters drops are out there, forcing Lucas et all to play the entire thing out again just doesn't seem worth it.

6. Second Sight

Back in 2004, psychic games were at the centre of a hot debate: Second Sight or Psi-Ops: The Mindgate Conspiracy. The former a brilliant tale with an unexpected ending, the latter a more "military-cover shooter" with psychic powers.

Advertisement

Second Sight puts you in the amnesiac shoes of John Vattic, a man once part of a research team that ends up granted psychic powers. Something's not right, things have gone wrong, and we don't know why.

For the most part, players will be trying to unravel what's happened to Vattic, why the mission was a failure, and why people keep dying around him. The big twist, however, is that it isn't what has happened, it's what will happen.

The "present" we play is actually a premonition, a potential future of what could be. So instead of playing the past, it's the present. With us here?

However, once you know that... it loses all impact playing again. It just becomes another thinking man's shooter, with some nifty psychic powers unlocked at key points. At this point, might as well give Psi-Ops a go.

5. L.A. Noire

Let it not be said that L.A. Noire fails to tell a cracking story across its lengthy playtime. The rise and fall of a fallible man, the seedy side of Los Angeles, all against the backdrop of post-war drug trading and the limited support for veterans.

Advertisement

It is, without hyperbole, a great game. It may look dated today, with its motion capture not quite capturing the same awe that it did eleven years ago. In fact, the remaster does a poor job, making the body/head movements look disjointed.

But that's not the point here.

The caveat to it being a vast, drawn out story is that it on first run's through, that doesn't seem to matter. Players will be gripped by Cole's rise, fall and drama in-between. That, and solving the murder/interrogations without knowing the outcome.

On subsequent runs, when you know that some of the outcomes are fated to play out the same regardless of what you choose, isn't as fun. That Black Dahlia thread, for instance.

Nor is the amount of time that can be wasted driving everywhere. Even with fast travel, trekking across L.A is one heck of a slog.

4. Sayonara Wild Hearts

There are some games that are formulaic, and there are some that are art. And then there are some that are just such beautiful assaults on the eyeballs, that they need to be seen to be believed. Over the years we've had Rez, Hotline Miami, Furi and Journey.

Advertisement

Now, there's Sayonara Wild Hearts to add that to that niche, too.

It's a simple enough game to play, akin to Panzer Dragoon or another rail shooter. There are points to be scored, some Tarot decks to complete, and a colourful, vibrant story about heartbreak to go through.

All set to the backdrop of some catchy pop tunes and battling the J-Pop versions of the T-Birds from Grease. If players aren't tapping their feet in time to their button prompts, something is amiss.

The thing is, unless you really want to listen to the soundtrack on repeat, there's not much incentive to play it through again. The fights are all the same prompts, the quick-reflex moments are the same obstacles to avoid.

It's definitely worth playing, but don't expect the glory to sustain on each level repeat.

3. Resident Evil 3 (2020)

The Resident Evil games are no stranger to repetition, and not just in the plots. Most of, if not all of them, encourage multiple playthroughs to unlock in-game items and the like. And for the most part, it is worth it.

Advertisement

Pitchforks were already out for the Resident Evil 2 remake which, whilst an amazing take, cut out and changed some things. So Capcom, in their infinite wisdom, doubled down on the Resident Evil 3 remake, making for a more "streamlined" experience.

Which, on first playthrough, is great. The new Nemesis is a nimble brute, not to mention the zombies he makes into his tentacled protegees. It follows the more action-focused gameplay of the original, that's for sure.

But when it's done, there's no real incentive outside of trophies/achievements to go through it again.

The Nemesis jump scares are way too scripted to have a lasting effect, the quick time events just as formulaic. And for those hoping for a visit to the seemingly-cut Clock Tower section on a subsequent run through?

Forget it, that's gone.

Play it once, because it's great, but it does not warrant a few runs through.

2. SOMA

Frictional Games do make some very intense, first person horror games. First with Penumbra, then striking gold with the Amnesia series, before the sci-fi focused SOMA released in 2015.

Advertisement

A trip into the future (of sorts), the nature of the soul, existentialism and the power of memories, SOMA added a strange twist on the narrative that Frictional can produce in gaming form.

Whilst it would be remiss to spoil the story, instead it's best left unmentioned to lure new players to it. The game has spooky moments, indestructible monsters and a really claustrophobic, underwater setting that makes it genuinely terrifying.

But once players have seen Simon's surreal story through, the whole gimmick doesn't work on a subsequent playthrough.

Discovering that all is not what it seems (although anyone who's played a Frictional Games game will see that coming) loses its impact on a second run.

Unlike other games on this list, SOMA is the most linear game of all. No alternate endings to explore, no changing the narrative. Play it once, savour the ending, and that's all the Frictional you need.

1. Death Stranding

And here it is: the divisive game that just keeps on giving discourse. Death Stranding, 2019's offering from Kojima's new studio, still remains a hot topic about narrative, graphics, "boring gameplay" and whatever petty argument the fans/critics will defend or throw at it, respectively.

Advertisement

Whichever camp you fall into, one thing can be agreed on: Death Stranding is quite boring on a second playthrough.

When players first explore the lands of ravaged pseudo-America, the visuals alone are breathtaking (even more so in the PS5) version. Coupled with a beautifully haunting score, it's an absolute trip to well, take this trip.

As is the story, which is "peak Kojima". It's bizarre, it doesn't make sense without a wiki, and will probably have players asking more questions than they have answers to. But, it is engaging.

The same can't be said when starting again, as the sentiment and motivation of each character holds no real weight any more. We know Higgs is the weird pizza customer, we know Hardman is responsible for Sam's existence (sort of, it's complicated).

Trudging through knee-deep snow doesn't feel worth it when we already know the ending is a lacklustre payoff.

(and that "Princess Beach" bit doesn't need to be seen again)

Advertisement