10 Video Games That Punish You For Double Crossing Characters

Halo knew EXACTLY who you'd try to kill.

By Jess McDonell /

Bungie

A lot of times video games let you get away with being a bad dude. A little grand theft auto here, some light kleptomania there, but sometimes actions have consequences.

Advertisement

The following video games were happy to let you make mistakes, be a bad dude, and treat other NPCs with disrespect but they all drew the line at letting you get away with it. Whether your treachery came in the form of betraying a faction, a love interest, or a close companion, double crossing any of these characters was a one-way ticket to an outcome you’d probably rather avoid.

Sometimes these punishments locked you out of the best narrative outcome or some great loot, and sometimes they just left you with a yucky guilty feeling you’d rather have gone without.

Advertisement

10. Leave The Seagulls Alone - Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons Of Liberty

Konami

It’s always fairly entertaining when a game gives you the option of doing something scummy with the firm intention of punishing you for it if you actually do it.

This is absolutely the case in Metal Gear Solid 2 where you can shoot innocent seagulls but your girlfriend Rose will be extremely unhappy about it. She goes as far as to ring you and tell you to stop hurting innocent animals, calling you a monster. If you keep dropping birds out of the sky or doing other shady things like creeping around the girl’s toilets or hitting on Emma, she’ll get extremely angry with you and flat out refuse to save your game.

Advertisement

Which is probably something you’re really going to want to do so, you know, happy wife, happy life.

9. Romancing Everybody - Persona 5 Royal

Atlus

Plenty of video games are happy to let you flirt your way through your roster of companions or squadmates with little to no regard to whether that’s a relatively uncool thing to do.

Advertisement

At least the majority of these games will serve you with some sort of consequences for trying to get with everybody at the same time but arguably no game does it quite like Persona 5 Royal.

Persona 5 Royal gives Joker a huge variety of options for romance and while sadly neither Ryuji or Yusuke make the cut, there are nine women who are all set to fall for your mysterious outsider charms so if for some reason you aren’t immediately choosing Makoto you’ll likely take a shine to somebody. Or you can be a bad dude and romance literally all of them because apparently you have the time between being a high school student and a Phantom Thief. Doing so, however, will result in you being confronted by every character you’ve spent your 100+ hour game romancing.

Advertisement

This all comes to a head on Valentine’s Day and you need to sit there and be told how awful you are which, let’s face it, you absolutely deserve. And not just because you hurt Makoto’s feelings, which is unforgivable.

You’ll get the chance to apologise but if you fumble that one the girls will beat you up to tune of the game’s stressful battle music which is entertaining if relatively embarrassing for our boy. Sojiro does cover for you, though, and your bond grows with him as a result so that’s a cute little bonus.

Advertisement

8. Being A Crappy Commander - Mass Effect 2

Bioware

To really screw yourself over in Mass Effect 2 you’re basically going to need to be the worst Commander in the galaxy but this is a game about being a double-crossing scumbag so let’s assume you did that.

Advertisement

Choosing unkind and renegade options regularly, especially in your companion’s loyalty missions can result in them being disloyal to you when you need them later on, or it will lead to their death late in the game. For example, if you ignore Miranda’s Loyalty Mission, treat her unkindly or don’t keep her in the loop she will die in the Priority: Horizon mission.

Similarly, failing to help Thane find his son, or throwing Tali’s father under the bus during her Loyalty Mission will result in them being Disloyal to you for the rest of the game. Having any Disloyal squadmates during the game’s pivotal and easily fatal Suicide Mission can result in one or more of your companions dying so if you’ve been a shitty friend you can expect to say some hard goodbyes at the end of this one.

Advertisement

Or maybe not so hard goodbyes if you weren’t that into them anyway.

7. Choosing Triss AND Yennefer - The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

CD Projekt RED

Joker learned his hard lesson in his 100 game in Persona 5 Royal but if you want you can sink a tonne of time into stuffing up relationships in The Witcher 3 if that’s something you want to do. In your defence, Triss and Yennefer are both very cool and down very bad for Geralt so you’d be forgiven for wondering if you can romance both and get away with it.

Advertisement

Spoiler alert, you absolutely can not.

While there are plenty of other bangable characters in the game you actually can get away with spending an evening with, these two are not so up for sharing with one another. The quest It Takes Three To Tango kicks off with both women asking you to come share a bottle of wine with them. Geralt, thinking for a moment that he can in fact have it all, is advanced upon by the two women before they simply take the wine, leave him chained to the bed and tell him off about being super shady.

Advertisement

As if that wasn’t bad enough, neither of the two will want anything to do with you after the fact so there goes Geralt’s big romance.

6. The Gun Trap Consequences - Until Dawn

Supermassive

Supermassive horror smash hit Until Dawn lets you kill or save all your characters depending on your choices and skill. Those aren’t the only factors that will result in life or death situations, though. There is also a fluctuating relationship mechanic where characters can grow closer or apart depending on how you have them interact with one another.

Advertisement

As you’d imagine, you don’t really want to be on the outs with anybody when your life could quite literally end up in their hands and this is exactly the case with Chris and Ashley.

These two have friendship and a bit of a will-they, won’t-they thing going on but if you decide to have them constantly throw each other under the bus and treat each other poorly, you’re going to regret it. In Chapter 6 the two are captured by The Psycho, strapped to chairs, and Chris is forced to shoot either himself or Ashley.

Advertisement

If you aim your gun at Ashley and pull the trigger she is understandably not impressed. While the two survive that, Chris’ fate in Chapter 8 will depend on whether you’re in her good books. If not, she refuses to open the door for Chris when he arrives back at the lodge, leaving him out in the cold to be Wendigo chum.

You get what you give, I guess.

Advertisement

5. Fighting Without Honor - Bushido Blade

SCEE

While mowing down dudes in Grand Theft Auto or taking out 8 Sith at once with a well-timed Force Storm attack in Knights of the Old Republic, it can feel like video games don’t really care about being honourable when it comes to taking lives. Not so in the case of Bushido Blade though as the 1997 fighting game puts an emphasis on upholding the Code of Bushido, requiring you to fight with politeness, benevolence, and decency.

Advertisement

In the game’s story mode, doing things like striking an opponent when their back is turned, throwing sand in your foe’s eyes or attacking while they are bowing at the start of a fight will have a huge negative impact.

If you regularly fight dishonourably the game will actually end abruptly with a message telling you off for your actions. It’s hard to think of a punishment more brutal than a game that refuses to let you play it any more so let this be a lesson, some video games will even let you have it for being unfair to the bad guys.

Advertisement

4. Being A Bad Dog Owner - Haunting Ground

Capcom

It’s generally understood that every video game dog is a good boy, even the ones programmed to try and munch on our ankles, so it stands to reason that we should treat them all nicely, especially if they aren’t trying to obliterate our health bar.

Advertisement

In Capcom’s 2005 survival horror Haunting Ground you’re lucky enough to be accompanied by Hewie, a little sweetie pie who will follow your instructions, keep you company, and protect you.

The white German Shepherd isn’t just loyal and cute, though, he’s also clever. If trained correctly Hewie can be more effective at finding hidden items, do extra damage to enemies, and be a sneaky quiet boy when you need to hide.

Advertisement

If you’re a horrible person, though, you might decide to berate Hewie and abuse him in which case he’ll get really sad and the game will set you on a path to the worst ending where Hewie doesn’t save you in the final confrontation and instead attacks you and protagonist Fiona ends up in a glass box having been captured by the steward of the castle, Riccardo.

And given you have to be extremely awful to Hewie to get this outcome, it’s pretty hard to feel sorry for her.

Advertisement

3. Shooting Luis - Resident Evil 4

Capcom

As is the case in Haunting Ground, it’s nice to have a friend by your side when dealing with the ghoulish or undead beasties of a survival horror game which is why usually you wouldn’t want to treat them badly or shoot them.

Advertisement

At least not shoot them three times because everybody has to draw the line somewhere.

In Resident Evil 4 you’re accompanied by Luis Sera, a man who used to work for Osmund Saddler, the leader of Los Iluminados. He helps you out in protecting the President’s daughter Ashley for a short while when the two of you become trapped in a cabin that is beset by baddies. If you decide to turn your gun on Luis he’ll put it with it exactly twice before a cutscene rolls where he says “Adios, Leon”, aims his revolver at your head and shoots Leon dead.

Advertisement

Which, like so many entries on this list, is super fair enough.

2. Not So Peaceful Monks - Tomb Raider II

CORE

This one is an oldie but a goodie. Back in 1997 Tomb Raider 2 brought you action-adventure goodness, Lara’s puzzling polygonal form, and a brutal punishment for killing innocent peaceful monks.

Advertisement

You’ll find yourself in the idyllic Barkhang Monastery, home to a group of Tibetan monks and if you’re a psychopath you might think to yourself, “What if I start killing the inhabitants?”

That wondering would quickly backfire on you because while Taylor Swift says “karma is a cat”, clearly in Tomb Raider 2 karma is a battalion of warrior monks who are none too pleased you’ve decided to start attacking them. While you might be able to take on one or two, if you aggro one of these guys you’ll aggro all of them and there’s no way to get them to chill out once you’ve decided to break the peace with them.

Advertisement

Basically, expect to end up very dead here and start reassessing your life choices.

1. Bad Master Chief - Halo: Combat Evolved

Bungie

As quintessential video game heroes go, Master Chief is inarguably pretty high on the list.

Advertisement

That’s probably why if you decide to play him like a crazed murderer, Halo: Combat Evolved will come down on you before you even have a chance to pop the gun down and explain yourself.

In the very first mission The Pillar of Autumn, you can technically kill off one of your squadmates but if you do so the bridge will go into lockdown and invincible Marines will sink bullets into you until you’ve well and truly paid for your actions. As you might have guessed, there’s no way to win this encounter because you really shouldn’t have done it in the first place.

Advertisement

Developer Bungie even ensured that if you managed to escape the bridge after being a bad dude you’d be transported there and experience the inevitable death you definitely deserved.