10 Video Games That Released At The WORST Possible Time

Going up against Rockstar? Bad move.

By Jordan Rylins /

Release dates, often planned over a year in advance, can be a huge deciding factor on whether your game makes it or breaks it.

Advertisement

At the core, you've got a project that has been worked on for years, with creative minds and dedication behind it. Then, whether made in isolation or in an attempt to compete with another franchise, sometimes it can all be taken away by something as simple as a poorly managed released schedule.

So, why not just not release your game alone in the year, away from the traditional big dates, such as the third quarter? A few reasons.

Firstly, delays. Poor management and unexpected circumstances can cause delays, which require you to push your titles back. Secondly, sometimes it’s just not as easy as "releasing in [X] month". Is the early year a good lull, or will people be preoccupied catching up on what went before? Is this summer dead or will The Last of Us be coming out?

You’d need a crystal ball to answer such questions, and unfortunately, the games on our list did not have anything close.

Perhaps these poor releases made them hidden gems, perhaps they still managed to turn a profit. What’s for certain, is that had these games released at a different time, we’d be talking about them very differently.

10. Borderlands: The Pre-Sequel

Since the second instalment, Borderlands has led a rough path. From The Pre-Sequel to Borderlands 3 aligning with the Epic Store, all the way through to Randy Pitchford being a general a**hat in the public eye.

Advertisement

However, The Pre-Sequel’s issue wasn’t due to being a bad game, platform exclusivity or any other issues. Instead, it was due to an outright weird set of decisions surrounding the release window.

The Xbox One and PlayStation 4 released in the fall of 2013. This is important to note because The Pre-Sequel released one year after this. No problem, though, throwing a spin-off to one of your biggest franchises is sure to make some quick next-gen money, right?

Apparently not, considering 2K Games decided to release it on the Xbox 360 and PS3, a year after the new consoles released.

No one cared about the old tech, we wanted new games on our shiny next-gen hardware. It was a weird choice that made sure the Pre-Sequel stayed out of everyone’s minds for a good six months before the Handsome Collection released.

At that point, not even a year old, the Pre-Sequel was relegated to the B-side of a double-bill port that people bought just to get another fix of Borderlands 2.

9. Metro 2033

Released in March 2013, you would imagine that THQ thought they had a safe window to release their post-apocalyptic Russia-based game.

Advertisement

Regardless of what they thought, they were undoubtedly wrong, with a sequel coming out for numerous major titles that very month.

Assassin’s Creed 2, Battlefield Bad Company 2 and Just Cause 2 are awesome games in their own right, but when you put them in a trio and face them against the small-time Metro, you’re in for a problem.

In fairness, only one of the three competitors are first-person shooters, of which, Metro has a more unique narrative edge. However, you still have to account for genuine selling power of a brand and those three had plenty to offer.

In the end, though, it’s not like this release window killed Metro, as the slight murmur it got on release was enough to warrant further success. Two sequels, two next-gen remasters, continued chatter throughout the decade and a perception that its tone and atmosphere were enough to place it well above average.

8. Alan Wake

Taking a look further back to 2010, and Alan Wake was in a weird place, even on Steam.

Advertisement

It wasn’t great, it wasn’t awful, it had atmosphere and heart but not enough to make it a heavy hitter. Although, could anything really have the potential to hit heavy when released on the exact same day as Red Dead Redemption?

Alongside Prince of Persia: The Forgotten Sands, that’s a pair to beat, and we haven’t even mentioned that it was originally an Xbox 360 exclusive.

Both before and after release you had Skate 3 and Super Mario Galaxy 2.

Really, no matter how you spin it, Alan Wake was going to struggle in every market it tried to break into.

Wake now sits in that weird area of not quite a cult classic, not quite a hidden gem but more, hey, remember that game that was kind of okay but you don’t fully recall because of Red Dead? Interesting to note, Alan Wake actually got a good bit of buzz in 2017 when it was indefinitely removed from Steam due to music licensing issues.

It got a huge discount, which finally got a lot of people interested.

7. Beyond Good & Evil

Taking a look at the fall of 2003, you’d think I was joking when I listed the amount of absolute classics released within October to November.

Advertisement

To start with, Call of Duty and Grand Theft Auto III on Xbox, as well as Tony Hawk's Underground and Smackdown: Here Comes The Pain. In early November we have Fire Emblem and True Crime: Streets of LA, leading up to Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time and Mario Party 5.

Alright, alright, games are made and games are released, we get it. The point is, that is an absolutely stacked line up, irrelevant of what market you’re trying to hit for the holiday season.

In regard to tone, Beyond Good & Evil lodges itself in the cartoonish, comfy area between the likes of Ratchet & Clank or Banjo & Kazooie. There’s nothing wrong with it but overall, you don’t need to be a release coordinator to realise why going against the above lot is a bad idea. Like, really, Mario Kart: Double Dash and Max Payne 2?!

Though, there's clearly some love for the game, as in 2017 a cinematic trailer was released at E3 to hype up the release of a sequel which will eventually come out, we think.

6. State Of Decay

It’s clear that in 2013 there were some serious decisions to be made in regards to how best to tackle the upcoming console releases.

Advertisement

State of Decay and our next entry, as well as The Pre-Sequel, seemed to have been perplexed by their options of launch. Releasing near or around the next generation of consoles can be a weird process, as you’re not sure if you want to keep your original plan or delay and make the most of the new hardware.

Consumers would say delay, to make it easier for us to choose but if you get a game out in two generations, you’ve got a lot more chances to sell.

This is exactly what State of Decay did. However, it released its next-gen port two years after the Xbox One launched, to mixed reviews nonetheless. How did the original fair, then? It went against the likes of Hotline Miami and Remember Me, in the downloadable market.

On a bigger scale it was fighting the likes of Animal Crossing: New Leaf, Deadpool and oh yeah, The Last Of Us.

All I’m saying is, if you need a zombie killing fix, are you buying State of Decay or The Last Of Us?

5. Beyond: Two Souls

Beyond: Two Souls might still have sold three million copies, but it was released in the grey area between the PlayStation 3 and PlayStation 4.

Advertisement

Arriving in October 2013, it would have been hard for gamers to justify buying more games for their PlayStation 3 with the PlayStation 4 coming out in less than a month.

This wouldn’t have been the same situation in the Summer, with exclusives such as The Last Of Us or the 360’s State Of Decay. Instead, Beyond released at the very end of the console generation.

This is where it gets confusing. You would once again assume that, if your game was releasing close to the very beginning of a console’s launch, you’d have two versions ready, one for the PS3 and one for the PS4.

Yet, that wasn’t the case with Beyond: Two Souls. Borderlands managed ports in six months and Grand Theft Auto V a year later. Quantic Dream seemingly failed to capitalise on this opportunity, taking over two years to release ports of both Beyond: Two Souls and Heavy Rain.

4. Mad Max

Dependent on what kind of product you’re shipping, there are other ways to poorly handle your release window. Failing to tie in Mad Max’s video game with its film, for example.

Advertisement

That’s if it was a movie tie in to begin with, of course. It gets a bit confusing when you release a game so close to the film, using the same brand name but then expect people to know it’s actually an original, unrelated work.

Already you can see why the release of Mad Max is such a weird topic to discuss.

Okay, so it’s not a movie tie in but it does share the same name. Our next question is, why did they release it so close to the film, then? And if they did, why wouldn’t it be cross promoted to high heavens in an attempt to get as many eyes on it?

On top of that, no one really wants video game based off a movie. Sure, The Incredibles’ game was as its name insists but that’s the exception to the rule.

Confusion aside, Mad Max, if not received as somewhat mediocre, Mad Max did fairly well in regard to sales.

Lastly, I’m sure it could have done even better if Avalanche didn’t drop on the same day as Metal Gear Solid 5: The Phantom Pain.

3. Titanfall 2

In regards to a game’s wind being taken from its sales due to a window surrounded by similar products, Titanfall 2 has the worst of it.

Advertisement

Now, I’m not trying to say Battlefield 1 and Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare are amazing games, but the latter is very similar to Titanfall 2 from a certain standpoint. What’s worse is that Battlefield 1 and Titanfall 2 were both published by EA.

How unaware can you possibly get to think that two of your shooters don’t clash?

On October 21st you had Battlefield 1, a week later Titanfall 2, a week after that, Infinite Warfare. It could be argued that Titanfall fills a niche that Battlefield 1 doesn’t. Yet, when you compare it to the likes of Infinite Warfare, with wall-running and zooming about all over the place, you’ll see that on the surface they’re not too far apart. From a casual fan’s point of view, at the very least.

It’s an even bigger shame considering many adored both Titanfall’s campaigns, offering a very enjoyable and above par narrative for the likes of a first-person mech shooter.

2. Resistance: Fall Of Man

Another shooter, the first entry into the Resistance franchise had a difficult release, but not because of any kind of FPS sandwich. In fact, even though Resistance was a PlayStation 3 exclusive, its biggest competitor comes out of nowhere in being that of the Nintendo Wii.

Advertisement

Both releasing in November of 2006, the Wii took the world by storm and as you probably remember, everyone had to have one. This is also the reason why Wii Sports, the most basic of concepts, is the highest selling single platform game of all time.

Past the Nintendo hype you might think Resistance could enjoy its comfy place among the PlayStation 3’s exclusives. That’s correct, to some degree. The simple, bland shooter held its own as an exclusive.

However, it also had to compete with the likes of Call of Duty 3 and across the industry on the Xbox 360, the original Gears of War. Although they’re not direct competitors, we can clearly see which exclusive won that little showdown.

1. Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodlines

Last on our list is what I will refer to as Vampire, for the sake of brevity.

Advertisement

Ultimately, it had three major factors of competition, but they weren’t all in direct alignment.

Firstly, we have the Xbox exclusive Halo 2 releasing a week prior. This gobbled up a huge chunk of the casual market and as with the rest of the competition, will have done so leading into the Christmas time. Vampire’s biggest competitor, however, doesn’t come from a shared genre, but instead, a shared release date:

The highly anticipated and extremely delayed Half-Life 2.

The argument here isn’t, "well, they’re hardly comparable", it’s more, "which game would you be choosing come November 18th 2004?"

I can assure you, MANY chose Half-Life 2. Then, day later we have Metal Gear Solid 3 and a week later is the North American release of World of Warcraft.

These are legitimate juggernauts to fight, and it goes to show that regardless of how unique of a game you offer, a level of difference or edge over your competitor means nothing compared to the huge names of Metal Gear Solid, Halo and Half-Life.

Advertisement