10 Video Games That Totally Wasted Their Biggest Selling Point

The "definition of insanity"? Building a marketing campaign around a character you don’t use.

By Scott Tailford /

Whether your production budget is reaching for the skies or buried under a mountain of paperwork, you need a hook for your video game to really take off. Newer genres like first-person 'walking simulators' and roguelikes fall back on exemplary stories or loot-grinding gameplay mechanics to hold you in their midst, but there are many age-old staples of marketing that work wonders if the right amount of care and attention is thrown their way.

Advertisement

Every long-standing, easily-recognisable character or gameplay aspect had to start somewhere, and although such a quality can receive quite the boost of popularity depending on various factors at time of release (Sonic the Hedgehog releasing amidst the "Radical, bro" 90s, for example), it remains that if you're then going to frame your entire PR campaign around such a thing, you'd better deliver on it.

Now, take that ideology and apply it to the ludicrously budgeted likes of the modern era, and wasted potential can be just as crippling as an outright broken game. Anticipation and hype are forever through the roof if you're a gamer, and when those emotional investments you're making don't pay off, well, you get these...

Advertisement

10. Master Chief Vs. Spartan Locke - Halo 5: Guardians

Whether you agree with the fan consensus on Halo 4 as the 'one that ruined Halo' or not, it nevertheless put the franchise to the back of many gamers' minds, especially seeing as Bungie had left after Halo: Reach to pursue what would eventually become Destiny. 343 Industries were never going to achieve the sort of global media-enslaving might we saw when Times Square itself shut down to reveal Halo 3, but they certainly gave it their all, doubling-down on marketing geared towards a major conflict between series-regular Master Chief and relative newcomer Spartan Locke.

Advertisement

Multiple teasers were shot in live-action, showing alternating setups where Locke would have gotten the better of Chief, and vice versa. The whole thing was set up to allude to a major untold story point, something "personal" that Chief had supposedly done to Locke, with the idea being that Chief was on the run for an act he didn't commit or do.

In reality, this just wasn't the case. It turned out the much-touted Locke versus Chief 'bout of the century' came from the former wanting to find the wayward Cortana, thereby disobeying a 'return back to HQ' order, as Locke was customarily sent to retrieve him. When the two finally do catch up, they have a brief 'perp tries to escape the law'-style kerfuffle, before reconciling their differences in pursuit of Cortana herself.

Advertisement

And... that's it. A good few year's worth of PR materials, viral marketing and buildup completely failing to pay off, with Guardians ending on a Halo 2-style cliffhanger that required you still look to the future for the really good stuff.

Advertisement

9. The Coolest Video Game World Ever - Brütal Legend

Double Fine

Okay, I'm biased a tad; being a fan of all-things chock-full of distorted guitars and wailing screams, Brütal Legend appealed to me (and millions of fellow metalheads) like nothing else.

Advertisement

Not only was Jack Black going to be voicing lead character Eddie Riggs, but everyone from Lemmy to Rob Halford and Ozzy Osbourne would appearing in support as exaggerated versions of either themselves or side characters, the whole thing was being written by self-confessed rock-fanatic Tim Schafer - y'know, the guy who tends to write some of the most funny and well-scripted adventures of all time?

Trailers had shown gameplay being a hack n' slash extravaganza of music references and humorous abilities (you could even shred on guitar to scorch your foes), but in reality it turned into a weird, real-time strategy. Rather than be 'God of War with headbanging', you were quickly running between things you'd otherwise control from an overhead menu, the biggest disappointing factor being that this was not at all what anyone expected or wanted.

Advertisement

It felt as weird to play and understand as it is to describe or read. What was set up to be a love letter to heavy metal and action-adventures ended up being Command & Conquer's more anarchic little stepbrother. It was just, so, weird.

8. Thinking You Were Solid Snake - Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons Of Liberty

Konami

Yes yes, the entire point of MGS 2 was established ideologies being challenged and broken, thereby in a total meta sense, knocking your expectations for a loop and giving you Raiden instead was closer to some sort of genius - but it didn't help the reception at the time.

Advertisement

Also, although it's a game we'll never see, can you honestly say a version of MGS 2 featuring Snake throughout - with more levels themed like the Tanker and cutscenes fleshing out a focussed campaign about his and Otacon's mech-thrashing efforts - wouldn't have gone down in gaming history all the same?

Sons of Liberty's story was breaking new ground (especially when it came to how much a director's vision is allowed to run wild), but the main thing we were all collectively blown away by were the game mechanics, which thankfully helped MGS 2 regain its footing in the end.

Advertisement

Snake would later be added in the re-released 'Substance' version, but in terms of whether you think Raiden 'worked' as intended or not, is a debate that divides rooms to this day.

7. The Return Of A Beloved Franchise - Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5

For better or worse (most definitely worse in retrospect) 2015 saw the return of not one, not two, but three beloved franchises from the 2000s attempting to continue where they left off. However, whilst Guitar Hero and Rock Band were solid enough affairs that skirted by executing on established formulas, Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5 was a genuinely unfinished mass-market product, built and released to listlessly cash in on nostalgia.

Advertisement

Graphics debuted as lacklustre and later had an cel-shaded filter applied to try and 'convince' the public they'd improved, your special moves were no longer pulled off with skill, as a full meter now triggered a 'win mode' that played the game for you, and gone were the likes of Spider-Man and Darth Maul appearing as bonus characters; instead the new big 'get' was - wait for it - Lil' Wayne.

Score one for business executives appealing to 'the kids', eh?

Advertisement

It was quickly apparent that Robomodo just didn't have the time or talent to pull this together into the franchise love letter fans wanted or needed, and by charging full price for something that messed up the core foundations of gameplay from the get-go, it wasn't even fun in small bursts, killing the franchise stone dead from day one.

6. A 'Vertical' Cover-Shooter - Dark Void

Airtight Games

Remember across the 2000s, every developer under the sun was trying to cash in on the Gears of War's runaway success? Every other game was suddenly a cover-shooter; from Harry Potter's film tie-ins to new franchise-starters and anything in between, and aside from the completely bland Dark Void, it's a formula that's remained fairly unchanged - just look at the upcoming Quantum Break.

Advertisement

However, this 2010 release from Airtight Games actually tried something completely different; vertical cover. Hey, it could've worked!

Voiced by Nolan North (as everything was back then, before the ongoing golden age of Troy Baker), hero William Grey had the ability to boost between various cover points both on a horizontal and vertical plane, tackling enemies from all directions thanks to some pretty nifty jetpack controls. Like the criminally-underrated Singularity that also released in 2010 or 2008's slow-mo melee-fest Dark Sector, it was these mid-tier developers who had the ambition and funds to try something truly unique, yet somehow stumbled when it came to getting the eyes of the world to look their way.

Advertisement

Granted, in the end it didn't come together for Dark Void thanks to being way too repetitive for its own good, alongside combat just not having the requisite x-factor that titles like Gears have in spades. It was almost a victim of the timeless 'wrong place, wrong time' label that strikes down so many initially ambitious projects, but vertical cover remains a cool gameplay mechanic that another developer may eventually fully execute on.

5. Lara's Debut On Next-Gen - Tomb Raider: The Angel Of Darkness

Crystal Dynamics

A game so bad, even the most diehard Lara Croft fans barely remember its existence. Angel of Darkness was supposed to be Lara's next-gen debut; one filled with jaw-dropping graphics, refined platforming and a story that would make the most of its 'darker' presentation. In the end, we got stealth - stealth - levels that had you using the most rudimentary mechanics to avoid detection and take down enemies through canned animations, puzzles that were far too easy to complete and a move away from actual tomb raiding into a multiple city-spanning tale that felt completely aimless.

Advertisement

In addition, better and more detailed graphics highlighted something we never thought possible at the time; that Lara's ludicrously-proportioned frame could actually look ridiculous, the more realistic the world around her became. Less an ass-kicking, dual pistol-wielding badass at home battling a T-Rex or backflipping away from tigers and more a Smackdown create-a-superstar gone rogue, this weird feeling of 'getting with the times' extended across AoD's entirety.

What was supposed to be the highlight of the PS2's exclusive library fell down in every respect. Angel of Darkness remains one of the most disappointing games of all time, and one so completely off-kilter with fan expectation it forced Crystal Dynamics to reboot the character almost entirely three years later.

Advertisement

4. Those Unprecedented Graphics - The Order: 1886

Ready At Dawn

The last two years in the gaming industry have been fraught with errors and major lapses of judgement. From Microsoft's now-legendary balls up of the Xbox One's reveal to every single triple-A game launching with various crippling issues on day one, until the tail end of 2015 and into 2016, it was looking as though the negative perception people had of the new machines was to remain true.

Advertisement

And could you blame them? If it weren't for the likes of The Witcher 3, Metal Gear Solid V or Fallout 4 righting the ship, we'd be left with toss like Watch_Dogs and The Order: 1886, the latter a game that should've been the best-looking and best-playing thing on your shiny new PS4, yet turned into one overlong cutscene instead.

Quotes from the developers downplayed the importance of game length and actual gameplay in favour of supposed quality, setting up the expectation for The Order to be something short, but incredible in a way that would change the very core of the industry itself. What we got were terribly repetitious 'boss battles' (literally the same fight, copy n' pasted twice), cover-shooter mechanics that paled in comparison to the original Gears of War, and a story that barely did anything with its killer 'Knights of the Round Table tackle werewolves at midnight' setup.

Advertisement

The Order came to embody everything people hated about the new hardware push; all talk and all show, with zero substance.

3. The Titans - Titanfall

EA

It was a weird idea, building a new game's identity around what would otherwise be a power-up in a more standard shooter. But still, this was Respawn Entertainment, the studio forged from the fires of Call of Duty's finest former-developers - surely they of all people, would be able to do for the new gen what Modern Warfare did for the last?

Advertisement

Well... not really. Although the idea of calling in a whopping great custom mech when you were suitably powered up was pretty awesome, the core thing that saw Titanfall shoot itself in the foot was that basic on-foot combat was just way more fleshed out and fun. Inside a mech you were a sitting duck for ordnance of all sizes and all directions, most of the time seeing players get toasted within seconds as calling one in had the entire map converge on your position.

Outside this, the game had a weird, bolted-on 'story' mode that manifested as a series of audible conversations inside the multiplayer, and with on-foot movement borrowing the nifty dynamic wall-running from Mirror's Edge (a tact COD: Black Ops III would then mimic in tow) it only made you long for a shooter that could double-down on these more athletic sensibilities, rather than force you to abandon them for mandatory bullet-shields.

Advertisement

2. The Arkham Knight's Reveal Isn't A New Character - Batman: Arkham Knight

Rocksteady

One of the biggest PR blunders in gaming history, and one made all the million times worse by Rocksteady and Warner Bros. reinforcing the idea that the titular Arkham Knight was "a brand new character".

Advertisement

Fan theories flooded the internet despite them being adamant he was created just for the game, and it wasn't long before we'd zeroed in on the AK being either being Jason Todd, Azrael or perhaps Damon Wayne at a push. Still, Rocksteady had a marketing campaign to (understandably) uphold, and so we kept getting the same rhetoric about his reveal being a landmark event; a tact that manifested in-game as Batman literally grabbing his mask and growling "WHO.ARE.YOU?!"

Thing is, from the very first thing the Knight says ("Time to die, old man") we knew it was Todd all along. From then on out the Arkham Knight's character was Jason Todd 101, complete with snivelling "You wouldn't understand, it's personal!" remarks in regards to his motivations, and a late-game allegiance-switch you could see coming a mile off.

Advertisement

It's not that Rocksteady shouldn't of hid their biggest selling point - if anything, they just wanted to reinforce the surprise of it being Todd all along - but for the script they knew everything was going to fall back on, it should've done a far better job of dissuading fans from going with their immediate gut feeling.

1. Vaas Dies WAY Too Early - Far Cry 3

Ubisoft

Remember Vaas? Remember the whole "Did I tell you the definition of insanity?" shtick? It was pretty great. Thanks to Ubisoft absolutely nailing the initial rollout of both Far Cry 3's new gameplay mechanics and a character who would go on to become one of the best villains in gaming history, people hardly ever mention the fact that his full inclusion was actually pretty terrible.

Advertisement

After a brilliant opening where Vaas berates you from the other side of a cage you've been locked in, post-escape you reconcile to building up your strength and bringing the fight to him somewhere down the line. Cue a major tonal change as supernatural elements are brought in and you dart off to rescue the other GAP models that are masquerading as your friends from across the island. Following a handful of other missions where you're shown the ways of the mysterious Citra, an ancient (or something) warrior woman hellbent on overtaking the island itself, you journey back and... kill... Vaas... immediately?!

Yup, that's it. You stab him as part of a barely interactive segment after triggering the takedown and he never comes back. In the run-up to release there was a ton, absolutely metric TON of materials alluding to Vaas being the main villain, or that he could perhaps be your character of Jason, as following Vaas' death, his eyes look back at you one last time.

Advertisement

Did any of that matter though? Nope, you had to make a thoroughly forced decision whether to side with Citra at the close of the game and remain on the island, or escape with the various sentient piles of clothes you'd rescued on a fancy yacht.

The "definition of insanity"? It's building an entire marketing campaign around a character you barely use.

Advertisement

--

What games sold you on one awesome feature, only for it to be totally wasted potential? Let us know in the comments!

Advertisement