10 Video Games That Tried To Exploit Nostalgia (And Failed)

Play with nostalgia and you have to get it JUST right.

By Dylan Webb /

Nostalgia is a powerful motivator when trying to sell products. People often gravitate towards the familiar; the comforting, and the games industry is no exception.

Advertisement

Publishers seek to capitalise on this, utilising existing franchises or creating spiritual successors. Sometimes they turn out brilliantly - like the recent Spyro and Crash Bandicoot remakes - but this doesn’t always succeed, with the rebooted Star Wars Battlefront games both coming under strong criticism.

Mobile gaming is another key offender, and many existing franchises have seen new entries where gameplay deviates significantly from the main games, often favouring free-to-play or freemium mechanics.

Crowdfunding has also contributed to this amongst indie developers, allowing a nostalgic public to pledge money towards the development of spiritual successors but these campaigns have gained a reputation for overpromising and underachieving.

It’s clear when publishers are looking to make lazy cash-ins but sometimes well-meaning titles end up guilty of this too. We’ve seen a number of examples of this in the last decade and here are some attempts that simply fell flat.

10. Star Wars: Battlefront (2015)

If you ask a Star Wars fan what their favourite video game adaptation is, chances are that 2005's Battlefront II will be mentioned. Bringing in a narrative-based campaign, the ability to use Jedi and Sith characters and new game modes, it was well received and fans had been crying out for a third game since.

Advertisement

So when EA announced plans to reboot the franchise in 2013 with Battlefield developers DICE, initial anticipation was strong. It soon became apparent though that this would be primarily a multiplayer experience, featuring only a few single player missions and no dedicated campaign.

Releasing in 2015, EA’s reboot lacked depth, was sparse on launch content and critics took aim at the planned DLC being stuck behind a Season Pass. It was also seen to be aiming at casual audiences, a fact EA later admitted to.

It’s been completely overtaken now by EA’s Battlefront II, which released in 2017 and provided a single player campaign. So unless you have a Playstation VR headset and want to dive into the Rogue One mission, there’s little point in going back.

9. Mighty No.9

Mighty No.9 wasn't the first game to fail in delivering it’s Kickstarter promises but it's certainly the most public. Developed by Mega Man creator Keiji Inafune under his studio Comcept, it was announced back in 2013 as a spiritual successor to Mega Man, which hadn’t seen a new game for several years and multiple cancelled projects.

Advertisement

Using a 2.5D visual style and asking for donations via Kickstarter, it was an appealing concept at the time, boosted by Capcom’s alleged neglect of the Blue Bomber and reached $4 million in funding. Big multimedia plans were made and numerous stretch goals were funded for additional platforms.

But as development went on, it became apparent that Comcept were not equipped for the task at hand, seeing various delays and accusations of mismanagement. This wasn’t helped by Comcept attempting to launch a second Kickstarter project whilst Mighty No.9 was still in development.

It slowly unravelled into a PR disaster and eventually released in June 2016 to highly negative reviews, failing to deliver on a large number of campaign promises such as 3DS and Vita versions.

Just as well then that Capcom released Mega Man 11 two years later. Also utilising a 2.5D art style, it released to much better critical reception and has made Mighty No.9 completely redundant in the process.

8. Yooka-Laylee

Banjo-Kazooie might be one of the N64’s most fondly remembered adventures but it’s a series left in the cold in recent years. Despite a recent re-appearance in Super Smash Bros, it’s not seen a new game from developers Rare since 2008 via Xbox 360’s Nuts and Bolts but even that proved divisive amongst fans.

Advertisement

Deciding to make a spiritual successor, Playtonic Games was formed by ex-Rare employees in 2014 and come May 2015, a Kickstarter was launched for Yooka-Laylee. Promising a return to traditional 3D platformer “collectathons” of the 1990s, it reached over £2 million in funding and released in 2017.

It launched to mixed reviews and a lot of criticism was specifically targeted at the game’s camera system, later addressed in a patch. It captured the spirit of classic 3D platformers but some critics believed this made gameplay feel outdated.

Ultimately, the game was successful enough for Playtonic Games to develop a spin-off, Yooka-Laylee and the Impossible Lair. Released last October, it swapped 3D platforming for a 2D side-scroller and released to better critical reception.

Given the success of the new entry, we may see a further 3D adventure yet.

7. Final Fantasy: All The Bravest

No introduction is needed for Final Fantasy. Now spanning 15 main entries, the iconic series is packed with memorable characters, themes and gameplay mechanics that helped define RPGs.

Advertisement

Square-Enix are no strangers to the idea of crossovers between the different entries and games like World of Final Fantasy, Dissidia and Theatrhythm are good examples of this.

All The Bravest is another crossover title that launched for mobile platforms but with little rhyme or reason and became one of the worst games in the entire franchise.

Featuring no story mode, minimal gameplay depth and extortionate microtransactions for unlocking beloved characters like Tifa Lockhart, Terra and even franchise mascots like the Chocobo and Moogles.

It represents the worst aspects of modern gaming, was misguided at best and a slap in the face for fans at worst.

6. Dungeon Keeper (2014)

Developed by Bullfrog Productions and published by EA, Dungeon Keeper proved to be an instant hit back in 1997, widely noted for it’s dark humour.

Advertisement

Playing as a Keeper, you worked to protect your treasure, employing a squad of minions to maintain operations whilst fending off invasions from “heroes” set on stealing your wares and attacking rival dungeon keepers.

It saw a sequel in 1999 but efforts to make a third game floundered and Bullfrog eventually closed down in 2001. Despite the closure of Bullfrog Productions, EA wanted to retain the gameplay approach within a new title and launched a reboot in 2014.

Changing it to a tower defense game, it came under heavy criticism for its monetization practises, failing to capture the spirit of the previous titles.

It’s adverts were also judged as misleading and this led to the British Advertising Standards Authority ruling that EA must add further information within game about its in-app purchases. It’s an irredeemable mess and one that only served to line up EA’s pockets.

5. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5

Tony Hawk may have long retired from professional skateboarding but his legacy holds strong. Working with Activision across a wide range of licenced titles, the Pro Skater series is fondly remembered across the PS1 and PS2 for their gameplay, precise controls and enjoyable soundtracks.

Advertisement

Following a series of less-successful ventures such as Proving Ground and RIDE, Activision’s licence was set to expire in 2015. Looking to squeeze out one more title before this happened, they proceeded to develop Pro Skater 5, returning to the core gameplay not seen since Proving Ground.

Development only lasted several months, whereas most games usually take several years, and released unfinished, seeing the rest of the game released via patches.

Filled with bugs, glitches and a complete lack of structure, it’s a title that should never have begun development and holds the dubious distinction of Activision’s most shameless release yet.

4. Warcraft III: Reforged

Blizzard Entertainment is no stranger to controversy in recent times. Once revered amongst its fanbase, they’ve come under major criticism from fans in the last few years after their Diablo Immortal reveal, Hearthstone’s Blitzchung incident and most recently, Warcraft III: Reforged.

Advertisement

Launched back in 2002 as Warcraft III: Reigns of Chaos, it was the last traditional Warcraft game before Blizzard moved to World of Warcraft and is often considered amongst the best RTS games ever made.

So when Blizzard confirmed at Blizzcon 2018 that a remastered edition was on it’s way, expectations were understandably high. But upon its release this January, fans were vocally upset.

Promising modern HD visuals, remastered maps and remodelled characters, it soon became clear that this wasn’t delivered and updates were minimal.

This was made worse by its £25 price point, the fact Blizzard merged the PC clients with the original version and initial refusal to provide refunds.

It’s another highly public failure from a company that could once do no wrong, leaving fans worried about what'll happen next.

3. Shaq-Fu: A Legend Reborn

Its one thing to see publishers try and reboot classic franchises but Shaq-Fu was certainly no classic. Released in 1994 across SNES and Mega Drive, it starred Shaquille “Shaq” O’Neal within a 2D fighting game.

Advertisement

It released to negative reviews and retrospective opinions have been even less kind, so its baffling anyone thought a sequel was a good idea. The developers at Big Deez Productions seemed to think otherwise, believing in the brand power of Shaq and launched a crowdfunding campaign via Indiegogo in 2014.

After little word on it’s development for several years, it eventually released in 2018 across all major platforms. Changing from a 2D fighting game to a beat ‘em up, it was just as badly received as its predecessor and was even given away for free on Switch to early adopters of NBA Playgrounds on Switch.

We all love Shaq but we certainly did not love this.

2. Alone In The Dark: Illumination

Before Resident Evil became king of survival horror gamed. Alone in the Dark set the groundwork. Released in 1992 across MS-DOS, it was gaming’s first 3D survival horror and launched to critical acclaim.

Advertisement

It spawned several sequels to varying reception but 2016 saw Atari take a different approach to revive the franchise with Alone in the Dark: Illumination. Featuring a co-operative focus and only being playable online, it saw you working with other players to solve mysteries within the horror setting.

Releasing only on PC, it felt more like a mix of Left 4 Dead and Resident Evil but failed to capture the good qualities of either and critics tore it apart. It was a poorly executed concept that failed to achieve it’s basic goals and buried the franchise once again.

Since its release though, series rights have been snapped up by THQ and leaves the door open for future sequels.

1. Contra: Rogue Corps

Konami are a shadow of what they used to be. Once a powerful force within the industry, their recent efforts seemed more focused on arcade machines and retroo compilations than serious console games.

Advertisement

We saw it with the lacklustre Metal Gear Survive, the first (and so far only) entry since Hideo Kojima left the company and last year it was Contra’s turn. First appearing back in 1987, the classic run and gun side-scroller series was a staple of the 8 and 16-bit eras and Contra III: The Alien Wars was arguably the franchise peak on SNES.

It was disappointing then to see Konami revive the franchise last year as Contra: Rogue Corps. Ditching the 2D scrolling for a top-down isometric view, it’s came under fire for its departure from series conventions, bad visual design, clunky gameplay and unpolished presentation.

If you’re desperate for a new Contra fix, you’d be better off sticking to the anniversary collection.

Advertisement