10 Video Games That Were Too Damn Long - Commenter Edition

When video games just didn't know to pack it up and go home.

By Jack Pooley /

Video game length is one of the most hotly debated aspects of the medium these days, with players considering the value of short, cinematic campaigns compared to AAA open-world experiences crammed with time-wasting collect-a-thon "content."

Advertisement

While some might argue that no bad game is short enough and no great game is too long, there are definitely excellent video games that outstay their welcome by at least a few hours.

With developers worried about reviews complaining their game isn't long enough, there's a tendency for them to over-egg the pudding rather than risk delivering a product that's just not worth a full retail price.

And so, we end up with so many modern games in particular that are just bloated out with extra content in the misguided quest for "value."

These 10 video games, most of them genuinely great titles, all ended up running far too long with their over-indulgent storytelling, relentless repetitive dungeons, and generally infuriating disregard for the player's time.

Obviously everyone who spends £70 on a new PS5 game wants to know they're not going to beat it in six hours, but a game that leaves you tired and drained can be just as frustrating as one that wraps up abruptly...

10. Uncharted 4: A Thief's End

Uncharted 4 was, at the time, the peak of Naughty Dog's powers as innovators of slickly cinematic gameplay.

Advertisement

There's a fair argument to be made that the three prior entries into the franchise also all outstayed their welcome by an hour or two, but the finale to Nathan Drake's story takes this to frankly exhausting extremes.

As gorgeous and brilliantly crafted as the game is, fatigue begins to set in roughly two-thirds of the way through the near-15-hour campaign, when it's clear that Naughty Dog has more-or-less run out of fresh ideas to keep the gameplay exciting.

The formula of exploring an area, platforming around, and engaging in an inevitably prolonged firefight becomes wearisome long before the end, and by cutting down some of the more snoozy platforming segments, the game could've clocked in at a more palatable 10-12 hours.

Naughty Dog clearly heard the complaints loud and clear, though, as The Lost Legacy spin-off project was a spry, lean six hours and all the better for it.

9. Resident Evil 6

Though the earlier Resident Evil games were all incredibly short, Resident Evil 4 began the series' trend of longer and more ambitious campaigns, culminating in the excessive slog that was Resident Evil 6.

Advertisement

With four interwoven mini-campaigns lasting 4-5 hours each, getting to the end credits could easily take up to 20 hours, by which point most players were surely happy to see the back of it.

The extended play-time of course wouldn't be so bothersome if people actually loved what Capcom was going for here, but RE6 is by far the most divisive major entry into the series with its unbalanced focus on action over survival horror.

Across 20 hours, the high-octane set-pieces become incredibly numbing, with little in the way of sufficient innovation to keep it interesting.

At half this length RE6 still would've been a mediocre entry into the franchise, but at least a lot less ennui-inducing.

8. The Last Guardian

The Last Guardian is a wonderful - if deeply flawed - game which spends most of its play-time bonding the player with their bird-mammal companion creature Trico.

Advertisement

And while that bond benefits from the game's length to an extent, it's also fair to say that the surprisingly long 12-14 hours it takes to beat the game forces it to outstay its welcome.

A big part of the problem is Trico's frustrating A.I., which while at least somewhat intentional in order to imitate the behaviours of a real animal, becomes positively maddening over so many hours.

Given that Team Ico's previous game, Shadow of the Colossus, crammed sixteen bosses into a mere eight-hour game without feeling rushed, there wasn't much reason for The Last Guardian to get dangerously close to double that length.

Considering the divisive nature of the gameplay, brevity would've absolutely been the soul of wit here.

7. Octopath Traveler

Octopath Traveler is a gorgeous RPG albeit one you couldn't really be blamed for never even starting, considering that the main story unfolds over a beefy 50-60 hours.

Advertisement

Despite its gorgeous visuals and inspired combat system, there are two key issues which accentuate the game's brutal play-time. For starters, many of the eight focal stories are actually pretty uninteresting and pore over similar ideas, ensuring the game feels woefully padded.

In addition to the story bloat, battles - especially boss fights - have a tendency to drag on interminably, resulting in a game that feels egregiously long-winded and self-indulgent.

Look, nobody goes into an JRPG expecting a short game, but Square Enix took the genre's expansive canvas to self-parodying extremes here. And yet, it's somehow not the longest game on this list - not by a long shot.

6. Death Stranding

Hideo Kojima's Death Stranding is one of the most singular video game experiences of the last decade - a mesmerising reinvention of the modern action game, focused less on combat than on traversing an ultra-treacherous post-apocalyptic landscape.

Advertisement

Kojima has never been a concise storyteller, so it's not terribly surprising that his latest project is a long game, but even so, did anyone expect the critical path to run a full 30 hours?

Beyond even the fact that the game's final cutscene is literally longer than most movies, it is a game that encourages players to stop and smell the roses across its 70 story missions, and per its sometimes-frustrating traversal mechanics, doesn't allow players to get anywhere fast.

As relaxing an experience as it can be, Kojima could've definitely said everything he had to say in 10 hours less, and made a large chunk of the mandatory story missions optional side-quests for the most dedicated of players to tackle.

5. Doom Eternal

As much as 2016's Doom reboot was a hugely pleasant surprise, many players nevertheless felt that its 12-hour campaign was a couple of hours too long, with repetition well and truly setting in by the end.

Advertisement

Rather than listen to that criticism, though, id Software largely doubled down for last year's sequel Doom Eternal, with an expanded single-player mode that clocked in at a few hours longer.

By the time it's over, and you've slogged through all those elongated arena battles and slain every annoying last Marauder, it feels more like a tiresome endurance trial than a face-melting power fantasy, as awesome as the central combat might be.

You can't fault the ambition on offer with its more diverse array of environments, but between the clunky platforming, that irritating underwater section, and the overall sense of sameness which creeps into many of the battles, it's ultimately a game that would've benefited from some trimming.

For many fans more Doom can never be a bad thing, but if you're a casual player who would be happy with an 8-10 hour blast-a-thon campaign, this definitely feels tiresome and overbaked by the end.

4. Final Fantasy VII Remake

After years and years of waiting, Final Fantasy VII Remake was finally released last year to considerable acclaim, largely delivering the goods in expanding the opening portion of Square Enix's legendary RPG.

Advertisement

But Final Fantasy VII Remake is also one of the most shamelessly bloated AAA games in recent memory - an excellent 20-hour game encased within a woefully padded 30-hour critical path.

For all of the brilliant ways Square Enix fleshed out the original game, the remake is also padded out with tedious dungeons - most egregiously, Hobo's Lab late in the game - boring switch-throwing exercises, prolonged gap-squeeze animations (which, in fairness, disguise load times), and that horrendous crane puzzle.

Despite 20 hours being more than long enough for the main story - especially with the wealth of side content on offer - Square needlessly filled out roughly one-third of the critical path play-time with boring repetition.

When you consider that this remake project is going to be at least three games, the entire compendium is looking to be around 100 hours long, and that's for players who don't stop to smell the roses.

3. Immortals Fenyx Rising

Immortals Fenyx Rising was one of 2020's most pleasantly surprising games - a Ubisoft bloat-fest collect-a-thon game that also boasted fun combat and neat puzzles.

Advertisement

It's just a shame it went on and on and on for a soul-draining 25 hours, long after your average player was ready to move on.

This is par the course for Ubisoft these days, in throwing so many Things To Do at the player that it's impossible to get through their games in a pacy manner.

Beyond flooding the map with icons, though, Immortals' repetitive boss-felling loop makes the padding feel especially blatant, as enjoyable as the core gameplay might be.

By the time you've made it to the end, you couldn't be blamed for wishing it was a svelte 12 hours instead, because Immortals simply doesn't have enough gameplay variety on offer to sustain dozens of hours.

2. Persona 5

If you're thinking of starting Persona 5, it's worth knowing from the outset that Atlus' all-timer RPG is the slog to end all slogs as the genre goes.

Advertisement

Even on the lower end you're going to need to commit 80 hours to the cause, and players not rushing are more likely to end up with 100 hours on the clock.

Persona 5, for everything it does so well, is a game that has little regard or respect for the player's time: you're locked in, and you're going to enjoy it.

Sections like Okumara's Palace are torturously overlong, distending the game out to such ends that players not sufficiently invested in the story or characters are highly likely to bounce off eventually.

Literally a few-dozen hours of the game could be straight-up lost without compromising the entertainment value on offer.

There are obviously many hardcore Persona fans who lick their lips at the prospect of a 100-hour game, but for the average player with limited free time and a desire to, you know, play other games, it is a colossal, unreasonable ask.

1. The Last Of Us Part II

The Last of Us Part II is one of the greatest games of the decade, and to the surprise of just about everyone ended up clocking in at well over 20 hours. That's basically double the original.

Advertisement

And while Naughty Dog are to be commended for their first-rate combat and the game's bold narrative detours, even its ambitious, character-hopping story doesn't justify such a lengthy experience.

Some might argue that the game's excess length makes players feel like they're truly on the gruelling journey with its characters, but ultimately it's easy to feel like the game could've wrapped up at least two or three hours earlier and said everything it had to say.

Given the extremely downbeat nature of TLOU2, spending almost an entire earthly day reaching the end makes for a genuinely draining experience, even if you spread play out over a week or so.

Needless to say, if Naughty Dog does press on with a third game, they'd be foolish to double the play-time once again. Sometimes restraint is a good thing.

Advertisement