You wouldn't know it from the overwhelming popularity of some genres, but interactive entertainment is always trying to innovate, to find the next big hook. It's that drive that's given us such promising titles as No Man's Sky, Splatoon and Bloodborne to look forward to in the new generation. Unfortunately, that same ambition is all too often unruly and, ultimately, too much for a project. Games developers have a nasty habit of aspiring to become a jack of all trades, despite a mountain of evidence showing that mastering a single art is plenty to keep players engaged. Dishonored has its dynamic gameplay, LittleBigPlanet its adorable and creative platforming and Assassin's Creed has stabby-stabby down to a science. It doesn't have to make us breakfast to qualify as good, and going that extra mile may very well tire a game out to the point that it can't pick up the pace when it most needs to. Worse still, many games with too much on their plate have a truly novel idea at heart. Of course, trying too hard isn't the only way to wreck a good idea; outright bad design does just as little justice to a stellar pitch. That's where these 10 games come in. By way of needless fluff, poor design, or some deplorable combination of the two, these games took what could have been a game upon a hill and dragged it down. They aren't necessarily badthough many of them arebut they don't measure up to the shadow of what could have been.
10. Inversion
Shooters, in particular, are constantly struggling to break out of the mold. From various approaches to cover to health and weapon management to the creative freedom of increasingly fictitious sci-fi settings, putting bullets into things has been dyed at least half the colors of the visible spectrum. When 2012 rolled around, Namco Bandai's Inversion strolled up promising that it had the next big color: gravity manipulation. Aptly titled, Inversion flies in the face of Isaac Newton every chance it gets. In an almost Dead Space-like mannerthe first one, where you bounce around zero gravity zones like a moth in a jarthe game lets you turn ceilings into paths and buildings into stairs, which could easily have injected some much needed zeal into its cover-based shooting. Ironically, however, Inversion just couldn't get off the ground. It treats its much-touted gravity mechanic like something it got by sending in 25 marked cereal box tops. Needless to say, promises of perspective-swapping battles were not met, and gravitational warfare is in most cases supplanted by an obsession with cover so strong you'd need a crowbar to pry protagonist Davis Russell off his precious chest-high walls. Certainly not a Gravity Rush, if you will.
9. Resonance Of Fate
Presumably due to having exhausted much of their creativity on the fantastic Valkyria Chronicles two years prior, Sega rolled the typical JRPG die for Resonance of Fate. After just dodging "use the power of friendship to save the world," the plot landed on "post-apocalyptic-esque future in which a steampunk utopia comprising a microcosm of pre-devastation society is mankind's only solace." Well strap 14 barrels on a handgun, that's actually not a terrible idea! Indeed, the game's central locale, Basela towering achievement of human engineering and the last vestige of life on Earthis an interesting one. The reasons for it are damnably vague, but mankind retreating into what is effectively a giant air purifier to escape a cancerous poison which has overtaken the planet is at least a far cry above your run-of-the-mill nuclear apocalypse. At least, it could have been were it not for, in practice, an absurdly convoluted and disjunctive story that has more extraneous characters and hanging plot points than it does bullets (there are lot of those, by the way). Things only get worse when you add in a monochromatic main cast which somehow manages to hit every extreme of forced acting while remaining flat as pressed carbon throughout.
8. Dark Void
An incredibly young but promising branch of science has shown that jetpacks make everything better. It worked in Star Wars Bounty Hunter, Dead Space 2 and Ratchet & Clank, and who can honestly say Kratos wouldn't have been better off with one? If nothing else, Dark Void had the right idea when it began development: jetpack plus guns makes fun. Somewhere in Dark Void is the exact sort of diverse gameplay that shooters are crying out for. The ability to switch effortlessly between ground and air combat is, at its best, truly exhilarating and rife with creative approaches to otherwise linear confrontations. Unfortunately, it is a nigh-unplayable train-wreck at its worst. The game's physics engine takes an even more questionable approach to gravity than Inversion, alternating randomly between the surface of the sun and the far side of Pluto. The problem isn't helped by flight controls which can make gliding about feel like trying to staple water to a tree. At the very least, it can be fun to watch the game's wonky rag-doll physics take your airborne corpse for the ride of its not-life.
7. Eternal Sonata
If Resonance of Fate was a dash of cayenne pepper in the otherwise bland collective plots of Japanese role-playing games, Eternal Sonata was a bowlful of the stuff. It casts you as a fantastical incarnation of Polish piano prodigy Frédéric Chopin on a colorful romp through his own super ego as he lies on his death bed. It is an unorthodox and introspective depiction of the tuberculosis-stricken artist that is commendably true to its history. This is a game that makes use of authentic paintings and photographs as often as it does conventional cutscenes. A delightful score featuring some of Chopin's finest pieces played in rare form accompanies its action-heavy gameplay, which itself is punctuated by history lessons chronicling the pianist's short life. As you may suspect, though, what begins as an intriguingly metaphorical adventure predicated upon such undertones as maturity, self-sacrifice and Chopin's own romantic struggles quickly devolves into the crock of ass-pulls you would rightfully expect from a JRPG. There is no definition of avant garde capable of justifying its absurd ending, which is completely detached from every decision leading up to it and sends a theretofore brilliant story frame into a stiff nosedive.
6. Watch Dogs
If you had a dollar for every story-related criticism levied against Ubisoft's next-gen poster child, you may very well be able to match the game's staggering marketing budget. Of course, last it was seen, Aiden Pearce's morally questionable but unquestionably generic tale wasn't any less unworthy of the technological creativity the game is built on, so here we find ourselves. Who doesn't want a city at their fingertips? Watch Dogs' mantra is in many ways the epitome of sandbox design. Putting so many optionshacking, theft, environment manipulationquite literally in the player's pocket was a stroke of genius on Ubisoft's part. It boils the fun of open worlds down to easily digested bites, drops you in a playground and lets you run free. Things rapidly grow less fun, however, when you realize the jungle gym only has two tiers, one of the swings is broken and some annoying, gravelly voice is narrating your every move. For all its potential and hype, Watch Dogs is crippled by its uninspired if faithfully recreated city and equally tired plot. Fortunately, that potential will get a second shot in the inevitable Watch Dogs 2, which need only up the ante on gameplay variety and narrative to make good on the checks the original couldn't cash.
5. Remember Me
As was predicted by every gamer with a shred of humor or cynicism to their name, Remember Me met the grim fate of being forgotten. Curiously, though, the game had plenty going for it. A cyberpunk rendition of Paris is a new box on the list of environments, and Capcom's fighting expertise evidently trickled down into the game's developer, Dontnod Entertainment, enough for them to churn out a proper combo-building system. Then there's the game's namesake, a clever game of Musical Memories which allows players to effectively rewrite personalities. Much of Remember Me is, in fact, memorable, especially its story. However, both this and its combat are at their best as fond memories; in practice, the two are too busy fighting over screen time to do their jobs correctly. Both custom attacks and custom memories could have carried Remember Me to greatness, but keeping up with both of them proved to be too much for raw promise to carry.
4. The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct
Telltale Games proved that The Walking Dead can deliver a fantastic gaming experience by sticking to its guns and taking the narrative route. The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct, however, proved that even a wealth of backstory and promises to explore one of its more prominent characters cannot sell a smoldering pile so hideous that even the series' iconic Walkers appear more personable by comparison. Despite being canonically interwoven with amc's hit series and its source comics, Survival Instinct doesn't know what it is. It wanted to be a shooter, it wanted to be a mature story with karmic decisions, and it wanted to be a stealth game. It is none of these thing; just a repugnant reminder of the soullessness of most licensed games. Far from the grandeur of its brand, it is better described as The Little Engine That Didn't Even Freaking Try.
3. Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood
After a rocky start, the Assassin's Creed series finally found a foothold with its second installment. Brotherhood aimed to follow that momentum and continue the story of Ezio Auditoré, the Italian assassin who'd become the face of the franchise. In many ways, it did exactly that, but to its own peril, it did so in the manner to which Ubisoft is accustomedby grabbing the ending to a complete work and stretching it over another one.Largely thanks to its well-directed trailer, Brotherhood had a veil of regality and sublimity about it. The titular brotherhood was to be a band of assassins so skilled that only the boldest and most powerful of factions would dare oppose them. That conflict, that clash of titans, was what players were after. But that's not what they got. That veil came down upon release and Brotherhood proved to be the umpteenth tally on gaming's "more of the same" record. It's good stuff, to be sure, but not different enough to justify its place as a sequel, and certainly not all it could have been.
2. Sonic Generations
Sonic the Hedgehog may be the most unfortunate character in gaming history. Nevermind the scores of innocent bystanders in Grand Theft Auto; this is a questionably colored woodland creature whose entire existence is economic depression incarnate. Sonic games have been a string of self-contained ups and downsthe up being early footage and screenshots, and the crushing down being, you know, the actual gameever since he hopped on the 3D bandwagon. Sonic Generations was poised to change that by bringing back the games that made the IP great. Cobbling past successes together into a modern day release is straw-grasping if there ever was any, but who cares if it finally means a fun Sonic game, right? Make no mistake; Sonic Generations is quite fun. However, revisiting the Blue Blur's 2D glory days is a lot less fun when, rather than reimagined for modern hardware, those days have been arbitrarily chopped to bits and saddled with awkward 3D phases. Indeed, only a single level from each retro classic can be found in Generations, limiting its enjoyment to a slow drip.
1. BioShock 2
How do you follow Irrational Games' BioShock, an undersea thriller still considered one of gaming's most beloved shooters? This was the imposing question publisher 2K had to answer in the roaring wake of the original game's success. To the then-perked ears of many, they came up with the answer, "let's learn about the Big Daddies". Rapture itself has detail and care dripping out of every busted pipe, but its lumbering giants aren't quite as characterized. Naturally, the prospect of delving into their backstory and even playing as a Daddy ourselves raised some eyebrows when first revealed. And then the gameplay happened. The overly action-reliant gameplay which openly drops the survival and horror infusion which helped establish the legacy of the first game. Then the story happened. You know the one; the story that claims to take place several years after the events of the original, but still casts you as the "first" Big Daddy. The one that systematically replaces Rapture's haunting atmosphere with shallow villains, all while clinging absentmindedly to the moral disparities of its predecessor. It is to coherent what a cactus wrapped in wax paper is to a pillow. BioShock 2 not only fails to better the series' Big Daddies, but doesn't hold a candle to BioShock 1 in the contest of gameplay. Actually, it may hold a candle to it. But only while the candle is underwater. What great ideas have you seen wasted in games? Let us know in the comments below!