10 Video Games Where The Bad Guy Won

Fairytale endings don't always happen.

By Sean Martin Moscardini /

Every hero goes on a journey, battles a villain and saves the day. It's the happy ending we've all come to expect and though the actions going through these stages may differ, the majority of video games tend to follow this reliable routine.

Advertisement

This is the natural law of video game stories most players have gotten used to, as you guide a character through a large mission in order to restore balance to a corrupted world.

Your goal at the beginning of the game is usually firmly established and it almost always involves taking out some unlikeable person with an agenda that doesn't benefit anyone but themselves.

However, there are those games that have bucked the trend of having a nice, cushy climax to their narratives, and instead, inject a big heaping dose of reality into the proceedings by having the bad guy get what he wanted.

These ten games all decided to go down the dark alternative route of the evildoer claiming victory, be it for a bigger emotional gut-punch, turning what you knew on its head, or it just made sense for them to claim the victory.

It goes without saying, but spoiler warning ahead.

10. Singularity

Singularity is a standard shooter with a major boost in appeal due to its fun use of time manipulation powers. It is also unique in that you have three choices to make during the ending, and every single one ends up with the villain winning and taking control of the world.

Advertisement

After a lot of time-travel antics, at the climax, there's the scientist Demichev who made the time manipulation device (TMD), a military man named Baritov who wants the device for himself, and you with a gun pointed at them.

If you shoot Demichev, you go back in time and make it so you never saved him earlier in the game. Baritov ends up finding the TMD anyway and rules the world with an iron fist.

However, if you choose to fire a bullet into Baritov, you end up ruling the world alongside Demichev until you both grow paranoid of one another and a new cold war breaks out over who will gain power over the other.

If you're selfish and shoot them both down, the protagonist Renkov watches as the world falls into chaos, then seizes power with his use of the TMD, basically becoming a new Hitler.

It's a lose-lose-lose situation that means you never get a chance to be a hero, and no matter what way you pull the trigger, a bad guy wins.

9. Mortal Kombat (2011)

The original timeline of the Mortal Kombat series ended in a massive battle royal between every combatant, all trying to obtain ultimate power and rule of the realms.

Advertisement

After this showdown between the entire roster, it came down to the final two warriors, Shao Kahn and Raiden, standing atop the pyramid of Argus and duking it out.

Raiden, realizing he is beaten, sends a message back in time to himself in order to prevent this fate from befalling everyone right before Shao Kahn cracks his skull open like a ripe watermelon with his war hammer.

This then leads to the new alternate timeline the series follows to this day where Raiden prevented this bleak future from occurring.

However, the beloved original timeline everyone grew up with and followed was now over, and a point many players miss is that it ended with the villain Shao Kahn killing Raiden and winning Armageddon.

Shao Kahn's ending in Mortal Kombat: Armageddon explained that after gaining ultimate power he went insane after he had nothing left to conquer.

A fitting end to the evil emperor, but a depressing one for the fans of our heroes who had failed to stop him.

8. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

While Modern Warfare 2's underrated narrative ends well on a personal level, in the grand scope of things it ends exactly as the villain wanted.

Advertisement

After some devastating twists that leave many members of Task Force 141 dead, it comes down to Captain Price and Soap chasing down and killing the corrupt, double-crossing Commander Shepherd in a hard-fought fight that leaves them both bloody and beaten.

Everything seems peachy as the duo is extracted out of the scene via helicopter and heroic music starts blaring for a job well done. Captain Price gives us one final one-liner to see us off into the credits, however, there's really little reason to celebrate at all.

Shepherd has triggered a war between Russia and America, and the actual mastermind, Makarov, managed to escape without any repercussions. Sure Shepherd is lying in the dust with a knife in his face which is satisfying, but it doesn't change the fact that he achieved his goal and architected World War 3.

Our heroes are then forced into hiding for months as they end up in enemy territory with the villain's henchmen hunting them down.

While the plot of Modern Warfare 3 continues the story and follows Captain Price finally finishing the fight, this entry in the series ends on a decidedly grim note.

7. Shadow Of The Colossus

Shadow of the Colossus is an experience no gamer should miss, and it's a minimalist story that contains a shocking twist that turns the idea of a happy ending on its head.

Advertisement

Our hero Wander is guided to kill the sixteen gigantic stone beings of the game known as the Colossus by an entity known as Dormin, and in return, a maiden named Mono will have her soul return to her body and resurrected.

It's a little sketchy, but Wander journey's forth and kills the only forms of life you encounter in the vast landscape, for the most part, with a special sword its revealed he's stolen.

What Wander doesn't know is that each Colossus contains a piece of Dormin's soul and as he destroys them a part of Dormin latches onto his soul and is stored inside him. Once the last Colossus falls, Dormin fully possesses Wander and a new team of heroes arrive then attempts to seal both Dormin and his corrupted host away forever again in a pool of water.

The now awakened Mono goes to the pool and discovers an infant with horns. It's heavily implied children like this are cursed in this universe and Dormin has been reborn.

So, you spent the entire game murdering innocent creatures and at the end of it, true evil is reborn through you. Well done, you played yourself.

6. Halo: Reach

Halo: Reach's story was known long before the game's release, but it didn't make finally seeing the fall of an entire planet any easier to swallow.

Advertisement

The game was never about winning the fight, but about the bravery of those involved and showing how losing a battle doesn't mean losing an entire war.

Players fight alongside Noble team as new recruit Noble Six. As they investigate a communications blackout and end up facing an alien invasion no one was prepared for.

Throughout the game, players slowly watch the Covenant swallow up the entire planet and rain down hellfire from space. One by one your squad of Spartans are killed, battling on despite the clear suicide mission they're undertaking.

It all ends with a small victory, as the heroes make a final push to save the Pillar of Autumn which does manage to escape the planet. We get to play as Noble six's last stand and no matter what you do, eventually, you die and the events of Halo: Combat Evolved begin.

In the end, it is all or naught and the Covenant reign victorious and glass the planet into a cold, dead wasteland.

5. Heavy Rain

While Heavy Rain is a game where you can get an insane amount of endings for each playable character, there is a genuine combination of them that is so dire it threatens to ruin the entire experience for you.

Advertisement

The magic combo is managing to get the endings named 'Helpless', 'Dead Heroine', 'Smoking Mirror', and 'Unpunished'.

If you're unlucky enough to gain these endings, Norman dies after overdosing on the fictional Drug Triptocaine he is addicted to and Madison is killed. Ethan is framed for the Origami killer's crimes and ends up hanging himself in prison, having been unable to save his 8-year-old son Shaun after he gets kidnapped.

The other character Scott who is revealed to be the killer all along ends up walking away free and not answering for any of his crimes.

For perspective, your main goal is to save Shaun and the killer ends up succeeding in killing the 8-year-old child, along with countless others. It's also implied he will continue his murderous ways until he finds a dad who is able to save their child.

Anyone else for therapy?

4. The Walking Dead

Telltale's The Walking Dead rivals the hit TV show in terms of the emotional damage it does to anyone who plays through it.

Advertisement

Your character, Lee, is tasked with protecting the infinitely likable and charming young Clementine from not only a variety of human villains but the hordes of the undead that now rule the land.

Over five episodes, we see Lee push himself to the limit and make a variety of tough choices. It will test just how much tension your heart can take until you reach the end of his journey. Then after all your efforts, Lee is still bitten and there is nothing the player can do to stop his slow demise except watch.

You can even chop off his arm in a vain hope it will save him, but in the end, Lee will end up either turning into one of the reanimated corpses or being put down by poor Clementine with a bullet to the brain.

And that's how the first game ends, Lee is killed and Clem' is left alone in the violent apocalypse to fend for herself.

This is truly a world where the Zombies rule.

3. Star Wars: The Force Unleashed

2008's divisive Star Wars game put you in the shoes of Darth Vader's secret apprentice, Starkiller, and had you become a one-man wrecking ball across the galaxy.

Advertisement

After too many plot twists and turns to mention, you find yourself being used as a means to an end by your master in order to expose the empire's enemies. Gamers tough it through a climax that has you battling the dark lord of the sith himself, emperor Palpatine, and after this final fight, they eventually win.

However, the Emperor releases a final attack that kills Starkiller and the two main villains look over his corpse and contemplate whether he will be a martyr or not. We later find out in the sequel he didn't.

It's revealed in the next game this is canon and a clone of Starkiller gets made that stirs up more trouble effectively making his death here near pointless.

In the end, a lot of rebellion leaders, Jedi, and innocent people are killed off and our main hero snuffs it after causing it all.

Pretty bleak for the 'light side' choice that's supposedly the good ending of the game.

2. Outlast

Outlast finds players in the role of journalist Miles Upshur investigating a psychiatric hospital and becoming embroiled in a horrifying story of cultists and experiments.

Advertisement

After surviving encounters with some of the most grotesque and intimidating inmates video games have to offer, Miles finds himself against the big bad of the game, the Walrider, in an underground science facility.

It manifests as a cloud of nanobots killing everyone in its path and is revealed to be controlled by a poor victim of the scientist's experiments.

Miles then proceeds to kill this host of the Walrider after a struggle, then stumbles to the exit, opens the door, and is instantly slaughtered by a SWAT team who shower him in a hail of bullets.

As Miles lies dying, it is revealed he is the new host of the Walrider and we hear the agonised screams of your murderers being slaughtered as the game fades out.

So the main hero gets possessed and the source of the madness that corrupted all the asylum inhabitants is released into the world to no doubt cause more terror and despair.

For a horror game it works, but it does mean you spent five hours trying to stop evil only to fail at the final hurdle.

1. Prince of Persia (2008)

You play through the 2008 Prince of Persia reboot hoping to restore the fertile grounds that will imprison the big bad of the game, Ahriman, and rebuild the seal that keeps him from destroying the earth.

Advertisement

Your partner, Elika discovers she's been given powers by the god opposite Ahriman and is the key to restoring the seal. As you begin to talk with her more, it is strongly suggested that she died before the game started, and was resurrected by the villain at her father's request which caused him to become corrupted.

In fact, during the final fight, she sacrifices herself to seal away Ahriman, since her life gave him a link to the world and thereby strengthened him.

By this point, your character The Prince has realized that he was in love with Elika and could not bear to let her die. He proceeds to cut down the trees that strengthened the seal and releases Ahriman back into the world just to revive her.

You walk away at the end with her in your arms, asking you why you did it, as the world is crumbling to blackness behind you and the villain's darkness begins to corrupt everything once more.

Even the Epilogue DLC didn't have you vanquish Ahriman, only revealing that our main characters got away alive, and he is still on the prowl hunting them down.

Advertisement