10 Video Games You Regretted Pre-Ordering

RIP, your wallet.

By Isobel Frost /

Whether or not to pre-order an upcoming release is always one of the most contentious subjects in the gaming community, and with good reason.

Advertisement

These days, it's a toss up not only as to whether the game will live up to your expectations, but if it will actually be playable — even when the title is made by a well-regarded, AAA studio, or part of an existing series.

With the hype train for a new video game often starting upwards of five years in advance of its actual launch, developers have more time than ever to both finish their games and make false promises. Unfortunately, many seem to only focus on the latter.

If there's one thing gamers hate even more than losing a game, it's losing their money. Add lying about the product and poor consumer practices to the pot, and you've got yourself a perfect game launch storm.

Here's hoping you didn't pre-order too many of the games on this list, for your wallet's sake.

10. Days Gone

From the director who famously complained, “If you love a game, buy it at full f***ing price!” Sony’s 2019 zombie IP Days Gone came out the gate swinging — and by that, I mean it hit players who pre-ordered square in the face.

Advertisement

Buggy at launch and to date, Days Gone is a misled post-apocalyptic epic that cares more about making you eavesdrop on enemies and chat to your dead spouse than actually fight any zombies.

This genre can be used as a successful vehicle for character introspection and insight into the human condition, as proven by The Walking Dead and The Last Of Us franchises, but buyers were disappointed to discover they had invested in what is merely the sad, rotting cousin of these particular juggernauts.

While the game was still successful commercially, the story of Deacon St. John failing to fulfil his promise to ride his wife as much as his motorbike (yes, that’s a real line) didn’t engage players enough to secure the sequel the developers wanted, leading them to blame the fans, rather than accept their game simply wasn’t up to scratch.

Here’s hoping most of you really did get it “on sale” or “through PS Plus” as John Garvin ridiculed, because with respect to those of you who genuinely enjoyed Days Gone, you probably wasted your money otherwise.

9. We Happy Few

Sometimes, there’s not really much wrong with a game, per se. It just doesn’t live up to fan expectations. Unfortunately, We Happy Few is one of these games.

Advertisement

Prior to release, many had been drawn in by this Bioshock-esque tale of a dystopian 1960s town trapped under the influence of ‘Joy’ drugs, making the residents perpetually happy and manipulable.

We Happy Few certainly delivered on these themes and story, with a striking aesthetic to boot. However, the game received significant criticism for gameplay mechanics, repetition of gameplay and environments, and technical issues at launch.

Some of the commercial disappointment can be attributed to overhype — if you are expecting a AAA polish on a game initially funded by a kickstarter campaign, you just aren’t going to get it.

But with the game’s price having been increased by double its original to £60 at release, it’s a pre-order that definitely wasn’t worth it, purely because you were asked to pay for a more expansive and better quality game than you actually ended up getting.

8. Marvel's Avengers

With Spiderman being one of the PS4’s best titles, fans had been waiting years for Marvel to capitalise on the opportunity for an Avengers game. After all, when one of the most profitable media franchises in the world is based on superheroes beating up baddies, what could make for a better game?

Advertisement

Sadly, Marvel’s Avengers hit its first stumbling block when the game footage was first revealed, as many MCU fans were startled and put off by different actors and visual designs for such familiar characters.

The ‘what I ordered vs. what I got’ memes were rife, and strangely prophetic of the eventual launch, as Avengers was buggy as all hell upon release. There’s no better way to traumatise a young Captain America fan than have them watch his eyes pop out of his head mid-scene as they trudge through a bloated and unsatisfying campaign.

If that wasn’t enough to get fans crying, making your way into the multiplayer mode where a microtransaction-filled live service model immediately tacks itself onto the pre-existing £60 price tag would certainly tip the scales. For anyone who did buy into the multiplayer, player numbers quickly tanked, making the experience a frustrating one irregardless.

While the game has committed to its model, putting out a variety of expansions since launch, it’s no doubt that Marvel’s Avengers missed the mark — one which spiritual sequel Guardians Of The Galaxy thankfully did hit, allowing most of us to forget about its predecessor the same way we forgot about getting our money back.

7. Evolve

A game which exemplifies the potential woes of all asymmetric multiplayers, Evolve was critically and commercially well received at first, even winning several awards for its innovative gameplay structure and space-age horror.

Advertisement

The concept a a deliberately unbalanced multiplayer composition was relatively new at the time of development, and demos showcased at conventions showed the very best parts of the game, building hype amongst fans.

Then things went downhill. One of the few games on this list to not be particularly plagued with bugs, Evolve was instead missing the foray of content that had been expected. Many found that not only the team composition, but also the fun of the game was lopsided, and with the vast majority of people only wanting to play the alien monster and not the four humans battling it, player numbers dwindled.

Further controversy followed surrounding the game’s DLC, as while the developers had promoted their support of future DLC as a selling point for the game, it turned out much of the DLC was not included in the separately-purchasable Season Pass.

While all map additions were free, many players felt that paid content was being deliberately withheld to increase revenue instead of being included in the Pass or base game.

While Evolve did still see success and maintained a dedicated player base for some time, it failed to live up to expectations over all, and the game’s servers have since been shut down in 2018, rendering the game no longer playable.

6. Grand Theft Auto: The Trilogy - Definitive Edition

There’s only one thing more infuriating than getting a worse game than you thought you paid for, and that’s getting a worse version of a game you already own.

Advertisement

Disguised as the remaster to end all remasters, in 2021 Rockstar released a compilation of the ‘3D Era’ Grand Theft Auto games that turned out to be three piles of hot garbage dressed up in a hat and a trench coat.

Unfortunately, this ploy actually managed to fool a significant portion of fans, having sold in excess of 10 million copies by February 2022 and enticed many with a $10 off pre-order bonus for the Rockstar Games store.

Alas, the launch was positively bursting with commercial and technical errors — including the game releasing more than 24 hours early in some territories and subsequently being removed from the Playstation store, and the Rockstar Games Launcher being down for 28+ hours, which rendered the game un-buyable on Windows and unplayable for even longer.

Players were enraged to encounter the poor quality of the remaster once they finally got into the game, with updated character models arguably looking far worse, and many features of the originals completely missing alongside the performance issues.

As a result, the game was subject to review bombing and poor press reception despite the assurance that the game would be improved through updates. To make matters even worse, the original versions of the three games were pulled from digital storefronts prior to release, so anyone who didn’t already own the preferable experience no longer could!

Rockstar may as well have stolen gamers' £60 outright and spat in their hot coffee. Not impressed.

5. Battlefield 2042

The 12th main instalment in the Battlefield series was expected to bring new life to the property after its predecessor, 2018’s Battlefield V, underperformed commercially and was criticised for lack of content and innovation. Regrettably, Battlefield 2042’s development team overshot by a country mile and released a game that was heavily criticised for being both uninspiring and making significant unwanted changes to the typical gameplay.

Advertisement

Having ditched the single player campaign entirely, Battlefield 2042 mistakenly boasts an exclusively multiplayer experience, and features a hero based character roster of Specialists for players to choose from — something that deviates critically from the one-soldier-among-many tone of the previous games, and which many fans disliked.

If that wasn’t enough to stir the gaming community’s collective pot, removal of features such as the previously ever-present scoreboard, a host of bugs and technical issues, and lack of story content meant that players abandoned the game in droves.

What little story content there was didn’t help matters, as the premise of a near-future world war with Russia and certain morally dodgy cosmetic names against the backdrop of ongoing Russo-Ukranian tensions was considered by many to be in poor taste.

Less than a month after release, 70% of Battlefield 2042’s initial players on Steam had been lost, likely along with their money. Though EA blamed stalled development and work from home conditions during the Covid-19 pandemic for the state of the game, realistically they probably just need to give this series a rest.

4. Anthem

Anthem, when announced, glowed with all the promise of a new classic, returning developer Bioware to its typical standard after Mass Effect: Andromeda didn’t exactly make gamers jump for joy. And then Anthem actually launched.

Advertisement

For a game with combat focused so significantly on the use of high-flying exosuits, few recent releases have been quite so shallow in all aspects. Yet another exclusively multiplayer game that would have benefitted from a real solo campaign, players who bought into Anthem’s action-RPG-shooter tagline quickly realised there wasn’t all that much else to it, and the inevitable grind this resulted in left a bad taste of buyers’ remorse in everyone’s mouths.

Anthem was severely missing the level of technical and narrative polish expected from Bioware, likely due to a significant overhaul of the game made less than two years before its eventual launch. Without a defined identity and sense of direction, the version of the game that shipped to players amounted to little more than a lackluster flying simulation.

Initial announcements did commit to improving Anthem in the long term. However, a content plan outlining ‘acts’ adding new narrative and gameplay quickly turned into proposed seasonal updates, which then became plans to reboot the game, which in turn were eventually scrapped.

Live servers do still remain operational as of July 2022, but in 2021, Bioware stated that all future work on Anthem had been discontinued, killing the game — and players hopes — before it ever really got off the ground.

3. No Man's Sky

For many of us, No Man’s Sky is immortalised as the first modern example of the ‘overhype plus false promises equals disastrous launch’ pipeline. Coming from a small studio with big ideas and a Sony-backed budget, it quickly became clear that developer Hello Games had bitten off way more than they could chew.

Advertisement

During promotions the team fell prey to promising many features that they hoped to include in the game, but had as yet not actually implemented. This precarious stack of cards fell apart shortly before release, when a fan managed to acquire a review copy on Ebay, only to discover the game’s world, which had been described as entirely procedurally generated and populated with planets to explore, was actually a barren wasteland.

Many further inaccuracies in promotion were unearthed upon release, along with frequent bugs and crashes. The response from fans and critics seemed fatal, and many felt that the false advertising might actually warrant a lawsuit. No Man’s Sky was dead. Or was it?

Like many developers since, Hello Games immediately committed themselves to fixing and improving the game. Founder Sean Murray even routed all complaints to himself to allow the team to focus exclusively on the updates and, eventually, they began to roll out. Technical fixes first, but soon came content expansions, DLCs, and the promised multiplayer. As of July 2022, No Man’s Sky has received 20 free post-launch updates, and its review aggregate on Steam has flipped from Overwhelmingly Negative to Mostly Positive.

No Man’s Sky is famously a game that almost everyone who pre-ordered it regretted at launch.

However, it deserves commendation as rare proof that when a studio makes a mistake and truly commits to fixing it, regret can turn into a reward — as long as you didn’t already get your money back.

2. Fallout 76

Unlike the previous entry, Fallout 76 falls on the other side of that particular false promises coin — as in, Bethesda were happy to rake in fans' hard-earned money in the first instance irregardless of the state of the game, and continue to do so with paid DLC and in-game purchases. Yikes.

Advertisement

Much anticipated as the next installment in Bethesda’s award-winning Fallout series, Fallout 76 quickly went nuclear, and not just because of its setting in a radioactive post-apocalypse. An exclusively multiplayer experience already had fans divided, but those who did decide to splurge the £60 to purchase the game quickly found themselves more than disappointed.

“16 times the detail,” Todd Howard promised at E3. “4x the [map] size of Fallout 4!” What did we get? Bugs in droves the industry had never before seen, rendering the game practically unplayable. It was mayhem — and it was only going to get worse.

Inevitably, in came the requests for refunds, and their initial refund policy proved so inconsistent that Bethesda decided to disallow them almost entirely. Bad luck, gamers! Fans who had pre-ordered special editions of the game were particularly furious, as a replica canvas bag included with one such edition turned out to be, er, not canvas. And no, Bethesda wasn't planning on fixing it — besides giving you £5 worth of in-game currency as compensation.

At this point, the lawsuits started rolling in. Unfortunately, the game hasn’t improved too much in the years since, and with dropping player numbers and outrageous microtransaction costs, it’s safe to say almost no one who pre-ordered Fallout 76 is happy about it.

1. Cyberpunk 2077

You all saw this one coming. While No Man’s Sky and Fallout 76 are up there for most widely regretted game purchases of the century so far, Cyberpunk 2077 truly takes the cake, the biscuits, and the entire confectionery drawer.

Advertisement

No one wanted Cyberpunk to fail, but the first signs of unease behind the scenes came with several stacked release delays, which irritated those with pre-orders no end, and put the studio’s employees under unprecedented crunch.

When it finally did drop in December 2020, the world was horrified with the state of the game. While some bugs were simply funny, like the heavily-memed instance where the player character’s customisable nether regions clip through their trousers, many found the game would barely even run on their system.

It quickly became clear that the game only performed as expected on top-end PCs, and was so unplayable on consoles that Playstation eventually pulled the game from their store entirely, only returning for purchase in June 2021.

CD Projekt Red ended up facing several class-action lawsuits over the perceived deception on technical performance, which were eventually settled at a cost of US$1.85 million. The developer has committed to not only fixing the game’s performance, which they largely addressed with a year-long plan of updates, but adding content in the future.

Despite this, the game remains not worth playing on 8th-generation consoles, and with new projects in The Witcher series announced for development, there is a feeling that just how bad Cyberpunk was is trying to be swept under the carpet.

Pour one out for Keanu Reeves. It was not, in fact, breathtaking, in anything except its downfall.

Advertisement