Prior to a console's release there's always a lot of talk surrounding the hardware of the device. Does it have x amount of RAM? What resolution can it output to? Can it run x game? However, no matter how powerful the console, or how fantastic the exclusive releases are, it's all null and void if the controller is complete crap. We've all been in the position of going to a friends house and being handed the weird, third-party controller to play with. Between the unresponsive buttons and hand-cramping design, it can be frustrating to watch someone else gaining a clear advantage with a well-made, purpose-built controller. There's no bigger dampener on your gaming fun than not feeling in full control. Beyond scheap knock-offs of popular devices, mainstream controller design has vastly improved in recent years, partly due to the smaller pool of consoles on the market. However, this list takes a look at the absolute worst offenders of bad controller design through history, be it through poor build quality, shameful design oversights, or just outright weird concepts. These are the controllers that are so questionable in design, that they have the potential to put a newcomer off of gaming for life.
10. Nintendo 64 Controller (1996)
The Offender: Nintendo The Console: Nintendo 64 Worst Component: The fragile thumb sticks would rarely last a year of twiddling. Redeeming Feature:Those same fragile thumb sticks were the first of their kind, and helped to popularise 3D gaming environments. The Nintendo 64's controller is a classic example of a company trying to have their cake and eat it. One of the most daunting mainstream controllers ever released for a console, this three-pronged monstrosity is the result of Nintendo wanting to create an innovative new control method, while simultaneously sticking with the old. Requiring the player to hold it in a different way depending on the required control scheme, the Nintendo 64 controller was bulky and the thumb stick was easily broken. However, when used correctly, it wasn't actually too bad or uncomfortable when playing most games. The key issue was that many players were unaware that the 64's games were designed with the controller in mind, and therefore didn't require the use of every single button. Later controller designs eventually proved that 3D and 2D game control was possible within a less confusing, ergonomic package, allowing the Nintendo 64 controller go down in the history books as an ugly, but wholly necessary stepping stone towards modern video gaming.
9. Gravis PC GamePad (1992)
The Offender: Gravis The Console: IBM PC Worst Component: The controller body is a less comfortable, asymmetric rip-off of the SNES controller. Redeeming Feature:It was possible to slot a little joystick into the middle of the D-pad for added control in fighting games. To Gravis' credit there wasn't much choice back in the day, when it came to game controllers on PC. The choice was pretty much just between mouse and keyboard, or a joystick, until the Gravis PC Gamepad came along. It's a shame then, that one of the first PC gamepads was a plasticky, uncomfortable knock-off of the classic SNES controller. The buttons would get easily stuck, the asymmetric body was weird and uncomfortable, and the D-Pad was inaccurate. Worst of all, the drivers were finnicky at best, and it could be a royal pain in the ass to get the thing working in the first place. So to all the people unhappy about how long it took for Microsoft to bring out the Xbox One controller's PC drivers: count yourself lucky, at least they didn't outsource the controller design to Gravis.
8. The Playstation Mouse (1994)
The Offender: Sony The Console: PlayStation Worst Component: There was nothing particularly wrong with the mouse itself, it was just useless in 99% of games. Redeeming Feature: If you received it as part of a badly thought out Christmas present, at least you can finally own a playable version of your PS1 copy of Sim City. Most people are probably entirely unaware that the Playstation even had a mouse, let alone the fact that it was available from day one of the console's launch. The mouse wasn't particular awful for the time or anything, it was just almost entirely useless. Sure, it was great for controlling RTS titles on the console, but then you'd have been far better off getting things like Command & Conquer and Sim City for the PC, and have access to the full, non-watered down versions of the games. You couldn't even use the mouse for the PC, because the lead could only plug into a Playstation controller port. The Playstation was a console that grew popular due to its shooters, racers, and RPGs, ensuring that the PS Mouse fell quickly into obscurity.
7. Fairchild Channel F Controller (1976)
The Offender: Fairchild Semiconductor The Console: Fairchild Channel F Worst Component: The baseless joystick that must be pushed down as a button. RSI ahoy! Redeeming Feature:Perhaps it gave Nintendo ideas on what not to do for the Wii's nunchuk attachment? In terms of sheer discomfort, the Fairchild Channel F controller is near the top of the scale. Some genius decided it would be a neat idea to put a joystick on top of a handheld device, which is then controlled by the player's thumb. Note that it's a joystick, not a thumbstick. The joystick was stiff, oversized, and imprecise. Add to that the fact that players were also required to push in the joystick as a button, also using their thumb, and you're with a controller that really should've come with a health hazard warning against repetitive strain injury. It's a shame, because the Fairchild Channel F was a promising console at the time, and the first to make use of a microprocessor. Unfortunately, it was quickly overtaken in the market by its competitors, presumably in large part to its sadistic controller design.
6. Original Xbox Controller (2001)
The Offender: Microsoft The Console: Xbox Worst Component: The gigantic, colossal, huge, pie-like size of the thing. Redeeming Feature:The best thumb sticks available at the time. Microsoft's first venture into the console market, the Xbox had a lot of hype, and a lot of pressure to succeed behind it. Dominated at the time by Nintendo, Sony and Sega, the original Xbox entered the console market as an underdog, despite Microsoft's status in the computing industry. Therefore, the last thing the Xbox needed was a controller that everyone was openly laughing at. In retrospect, the original Xbox controller wasn't all that bad, it's just that it eeked of clunkiness, a fact not helped by the similarly large size of the console itself. Nicknamed the Fatty, it was on the receiving end of several "industry worst" awards in 2001. Thankfully, Microsoft were able to take on board the harsh criticism, releasing the much more comfortable (and smaller) 'Controller S' as the standard Xbox controller by 2001.
5. Power Glove (1989)
The Offenders: Mattel, PAX (in Japan), and Nintendo The Console: Nintendo Entertainment System (NES) Worst Component: The fact that it's a glove made this the most awesomely impractical way of controlling a game possible. Redeeming Feature: The fact that it's a glove made this the most awesomely impractical way of controlling a game possible. A ridiculous device that embodies Nineties culture, the Power Glove was actually released for the NES in 1989. Nintendo also aren't the ones solely to blame. The Power Glove was a Mattel creation, although Nintendo were the ones that officially licensed it. How the Power Glove worked, or rather, didn't work, was by emitting ultrasonic sound at microphones surrounding the television, by performing different hand gestures. If that sounds like an absolutely mental way of controlling a video game, that's because it is. The confusing keyboard positioned on the arm also did no favours for the usability of the Glove. The Power Glove has come to be a pop culture icon, and we wouldn't fault anyone for secretly feeling awesome while wearing it. Just don't bother trying to play any games with the thing.
4. Atari 5200 Controller (1982)
The Offender: Atari The Console: Atari 5200 Worst Component: The joystick near the top of the controller wouldn't centre itself properly, making it fiddly and highly frustrating to use. Redeeming Feature: It was the first controller to have a single-purpose pause button. The Atari 5200 wasn't a bad console, featuring a bunch of premium features for the time, such as an automatic TV switchbox and four controller ports. Unfortunately, it's also one of the only consoles that can attribute its commercial failure directly to the awful controller. The 5200 controller was originally one of the console's major selling points, touting a level of control that far outclassed that of the Atari 2600. For some unknown reason though, Atari decided to make use of a flimsy rubber boot to centre the joystick, instead of the usual springs. The rest of the controller wasn't much better either, with an outdated keypad and a cheap outer case. The unalligning joystick and tiny buttons resulted in a controller that made game control more difficult and fiddly than ever.
3. The U-Force Motion Controller (1989)
The Offender: Brøderbund The Console: Nintendo Entertainment System (NES) Worst Component: The "infra-red technology" just didn't work; the vast majority of games controlled by the U-Force ranged from unreliable to totally unplayable. Redeeming Feature: No lawsuits were made against Brøderbund, so presumably not many people bought one. The U Force motion controller promised a lot. "Feel the power," announced the television adverts. "The first and only video game controller that, without touching anything, electronically senses your every move, and reacts." It all turned out to be rubbish though. The U-Force was only designed to work with a small number of games from the NES' catalogue, and it was almost totally unusable even with those chosen few. The U-Force had children and adults alike wildly flailing in front of the strange device in an attempt to get it working, and it was never more than a barely functional peripheral. Even worse than the Power Glove in its attempts at motion control, the U Force verged on scam territory with its total lack of delivery on Brøderbund promises.
2. CD-i 220 Controller (1991)
The Offender: Philips The Console: CD-i 220 Worst Component: Ensured that games for the CD-i 220 could never reach the potential of those released on consoles with real controllers. Redeeming Feature: No lawsuits were made against Brøderbund, so presumably not many people bought one. Philips should have been on to a winner with the CD-i line of consoles. One of the earliest consoles to use of CDs, online play, and support for a wide range of peripherals, the CD-i's had the potential to be a great success for the booming hardware manufacturer. Instead, the CD-i consoles are now regarded as amongst the worst of all time, largely thanks to the controllers that came with the devices. They were all terrible in their own way, but the worst has to be the one that shipped with the CD-i 220. The controller didn't just look like a television remote control, it was about equally suited for gaming with. The horribly positioned buttons that surrounded the stick made even the least taxing games difficult to play, and ensured that no good action titles ever made their way onto Philips' console.
1. Jaguar Controller (1993)
The Offender: Atari The Console: Jaguar Worst Component: Everything. Redeeming Feature: All the people that never played another game after handling this monstrosity might have gone on to have productive, distraction-free lives. Everything about the Atari Jaguar's controller is depressing. About as ergonomic as a brick, this controller could only have been designed by someone that had never played a game before, or desperately wanted the industry to crash and burn. Nothing is well positioned, from the tilted D-pad, to the puzzling keypad that dominates the controller's body. Just looking at it is enough to give you hand cramp, and we can smell the cheap plastic all the way from over here. An exercise in making a product as consumer unfriendly as possible, even the cable was badly thought out, and would come unplugged at the slightest of tugs. It was also released during a time when fighting games were becoming all the rage, but the three face buttons severely limited the Jaguar on this front. Like the Microsoft and the Fatty, Atari eventually saw the error of their ways and released the Jaguar Pro controller. By then it was too late though, and the Jaguar was discontinued only months later, followed by Atari shortly after. As the only controller that can be credited with bringing down what was once the largest video game company in the world, it can be safely said that the Atari Jaguar had well and truly the worst controller design of all time.