10 Worst-Kept Spoilers In Video Game History

Even if you didn't want to know them, you probably already do.

By Kate Decker /

When is it okay to spoil something? A week after release? Two? A month? Twenty years?

Advertisement

Seemingly it's whenever the internet deems fit. With spoiler culture being mangled with mainstream pop culture wherever you look (thanks to juggernauts like Marvel and Game of Thrones), the level of plot concealment across the gaming industry is a pretty admirable achievement.

Perhaps it's down to games being slightly less accessible than an episode of TV that 20 million people streamed at the exact same time, but video games and their players tend to have a much higher level of decency when it comes to protecting spoilers for the enjoyment of each individual player.

However, there are some game spoilers so huge and well cemented in gaming history that they've effectively worked their way into the pop culture pool of common knowledge. Oftentimes it happens outside of pop culture, if certain references can be thrown around enough.

Whether you're into games or not, chances are you've heard of at least some of these enormous immersion-breaking spoilers.

10. Bioshock - “Would You Kindly?”

You may not know the full story behind this iconic phrase from the beloved game franchise, but just by nature of it being so iconic, you’ll be sure to know that not everything is as it seems on the other end of that radio every time you hear these words.

Advertisement

“Would you kindly” is actually a trigger for protagonist Jack to follow orders, as he has been programmed to obey every time he is kindly asked by someone to do something that follows that phrase.

Atlas – your guide on the other end of the radio – is actually Frank Fontaine, one of the game’s antagonists. Fontaine took the persona of Atlas after faking his own death, essentially using Jack as a pawn to take control of Rapture.

Perhaps one of the most famous lines in video game history, it’s hard to talk about Bioshock without someone throwing a “would you kindly” into the mix.

9. Final Fantasy VII – Aerith’s Death

Just by nature of being a game over twenty years old, it’s impossible to keep such old spoilers at bay. However, what makes this shocking video game moment such a badly kept secret is that it’s just so famous.

Advertisement

In FF VII, Aerith acts as your companion and potential love interest for the first half of the game, only to be impaled by a sword, wielded by Sephiroth, the game’s lead villain.

Having just been on a romantic date with her (if you so please), this death comes out of nowhere, remaining one of the most famous and saddest in video game history.

Watching Aerith die in the FFVII remake is going to break hearts all over again.

8. The Last Of Us – Sarah’s Death

Considering the plot of The Last Of Us is famous for its relationship between gruff protagonist Joel and young deuteragonist Ellie, the game opening with the former being a happy family man is perhaps the biggest clue towards daughter Sarah's demise.

Advertisement

Base knowledge of Joel’s character almost commands that you’re aware of his tragic past as the outbreak begins, and considering this game’s immense popularity and fame, it’s difficult to avoid this spoiler.

Even if you haven’t ever booted up the game before, the cutscene itself is so heart breaking that there’s a chance you’ve watched it out of sheer curiosity anyway.

7. Silent Hill 2 - James Killed His Wife

With every Silent Hill that followed Silent Hill 2 relying on a pretty big crazy twist to drive the climax of its story (what with Heather being pregnant with God’s baby and all in Silent Hill 3), it’s hard to avoid the wild twist that started it all for the franchise.

Advertisement

With the original Silent Hill being a pretty straightforward search for your missing daughter, Silent Hill 2 takes the set structure of having James search for his missing wife Mary with amnesia, opening the door for the perfect it-was-you-all-along twist.

Due to the sheer crazy nature of finding out your protagonist was the murderer all along, this twist got pretty famous pretty quickly. The parallels between Mary and Maria can’t be discussed without mentioning James’ subconscious torment of killing his wife as he watches Maria die over and over again.

Plus, this game came out in 2001, so it’s pretty old news at this point.

6. Dragon Age: Inquisition - Solas Is A Traitor

While Solas’ full backstory and motivations for his betrayal can be confusing, even to those who have played the game, this reveal fully comes to fruition in the game’s Trespasser DLC.

Advertisement

Even then, it's hard to avoid considering the entire crux of Dragon Age 4 now relies on Solas as the main villain, his iconic “I suspect you have questions...” being the biggest takeaway from its teaser trailer in 2018.

While someone who hasn’t delved into the series’ lore could probably play Inquisition and not know the full extent of Solas’ reasoning, the heavy focus on his villainy going forward makes it pretty easy for any player to be dubious of his story and allegiance during a playthrough.

5. Metroid - Samus Is Female

It’s hard to believe that this was an enormous plot twist at some point considering Samus’ general video game presence as a series leading protagonist, but her gender wasn’t actually revealed unless you completed the original Metroid in under five hours.

Advertisement

With it being common knowledge at this point and with an unmasked version of her featuring in the latest Smash Bros. instalment, back in 1986 there weren’t too many female protagonists in video games, so finding out a young woman was under that helmet all along was a pretty big twist.

While not a spoiler by any standards today, back in the 80s this would have been a huge reveal to anyone, as the general impression was that she was male, whether they’d completed the game or not.

4. Red Dead Redemption - John Marston's Death

As a consequence of being one of the most famous games in history, Red Dead Redemption’s final scene of John Marston getting torn to shreds has pretty much been seen by every set of eyes even remotely interested in video games.

Advertisement

What makes this spoiler so famous is just how beloved John had become, and how much of a gut-wrenching moment watching him get tracked down after achieving what appeared to be his happy ending is.

John Marston getting gunned down on his farm in front of his family is so visually brutal, clips and screenshots of the sequence are plastered across all corners of the internet.

It would be hard for anyone to pick up this game and play it blind today, but even though this is one of the most famous spoilers in video game history, it doesn’t take away from experiencing John Marston’s iconic journey.

3. Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic – You’re The Bad Guy

Much like Silent Hill 2's it-was-you-all-along twist, this is so mind-blowing that it has to be talked about across the internet.

Advertisement

Despite the game letting you choose which side of the force you want to veer towards, the outcome is always the same: you’re a brainwashed Sith. The path you choose determines whether you return to your dark ways or turn to the light in the climactic decision of the game, but this twist has become so well known, that influencing which path you want your protagonist to take is pretty easy.

Twists like these always garner too much attention to keep them a surprise for long, as such a revelation can make you reassess the entire game. While a lot of character deaths serve as simple plot events or a casualty of a tumultuous battle, finding out the character you play as isn’t who you think they are is huge.

2. Portal – GLaDOS Is Evil And The Cake Is A Lie

While “the cake is a lie” might not be a clear spoiler in itself just by hearing it, its cemented legacy as such a famous and quoted video game line makes questions surrounding its origin answerable with a simple “GLaDOS is evil and tricks you into making you think you can escape her.”

Advertisement

While a lot of people use “the cake is a lie” as an idiom separate from its specific Portal-related meaning, knowing that GLaDOS wants to keep you trapped in the Enrichment centre is itself a pretty unavoidable spoiler.

With the puzzle element of Portal being the main draw, the fact that its remaining strand of plot lies in a huge twist at the end makes it pretty much the only way you can explain the gist of the story.

1. Bioshock: Infinite – Booker And Elizabeth’s Origins

With the final section of Bioshock: Infinite being a stunning series of reveals that not only is Elizabeth Booker’s beloved daughter Anna whom he sold as an infant to Zachary Comstock, but that Booker is Zachary Comstock in an alternate universe.

Advertisement

The sequence of events gets a little tricky to explain, but the general gist of the enormous plot spoilers can be summed up with “they’re related and he’s actually the bad guy.”

The gorgeous slow-motion shot of the pinky finger being severed by the tear as the player realises Elizabeth’s true identity is unforgettable, and the image of the alternate Elizabeths surrounding Booker is so iconic, at least the basics of this spoiler are hard to avoid.

Advertisement