10 Worst Things That Nintendo Have Done

Despite the cutesy characters, Nintendo harbours a dark side...

By James Egan /

Nintendo has cultivated an image as the fun-loving, family-friendly company since it entered the medium of video games. After devising adored franchises like Super Mario, Donkey Kong, and The Legend of Zelda, it’s no wonder Nintendo is viewed so highly. And with the towering success of the Switch and the insurmountable hype for its successor, it's hard to think of a time when Nintendo was more popular.

Advertisement

But beneath the whimsical platformers, addictive kart-racing, and moustachioed mascots, there lies a dark reality. At the end of the day, Nintendo is a business. With gaming being an ever-changing and turbulent industry, the Japanese conglomerate has to do what it can to stay at the top.

Looking back, some of Nintendo's most questionable moments boiled down to bad business decisions rather than malicious actions. Other times, the company has committed acts that are so concerning, it's hard to believe these are the same guys who brought Animal Crossing and Pokemon into the world.

Nobody is going to deny Nintendo have made some of the best titles ever and have continuously innovated the industry. With that said, Nintendo aren't as innocent as they seem.

10. Manufacturing Scarcity

With remasters and remakes surging in popularity, the Nintendo fanbase had been hoping for a revised version of the classic 3D Mario games.

Advertisement

But when Super Mario 3D All-Stars was finally revealed for the Switch, it turned out to be a barebones re-release of Super Mario 64, Super Mario Sunshine, and Super Mario Galaxy. 

Though it was nice to play these gems on a modern system, the flaws were clear as day. Despite the fact Super Mario Galaxy 2 is considered one of the best Wii games, it was notably absent from this collection. (Imagine if Super Mario All-Stars excluded Super Mario Bros. 3.)

But that's just the tip of the iceberg. Despite the fact the Mario trilogy was well over a decade old, Nintendo expected consumers to pay full price. 

Anyone who intended to wait for a price drop was in for a rude awakening since Super Mario 3D All-Stars was only available temporarily, meaning customers had a limited time to purchase it. Though 3D All-Stars was available digitally, this option was removed soon after, purely to manufacture scarcity.

Even though this was a bad business move, Nintendo hasn't learned from it. They pulled the same trick with Super Mario Bros. 35 - an online subscription title that was only available briefly. 

It mightn't be the worst decision Nintendo has made but it wreaks of unnecessary greed.

9. Never Fixed the Joy-Cons

One of the finest features the Switch has to offer is the Joy-Cons. The controllers are detachable, wireless, and allow for motion-based gameplay. They can attach to the system, be played as a pair, or each Joy-Con can work as an individual controller.

Advertisement

Of course, we should've known it was too good to be true. Shortly after the Switch's release, Nintendo realised certain Joy-Cons suffered a error called "drift" where the analogue stick registers movements without being touched. 

Depending on the game, this made gameplay range from annoying to impossible. If the title in question requires pinpoint precision, what do you if your character or the cursor moves around on its own? The drift could get so bad, selecting options on the home menu screen became a task in itself.

And this isn't an uncommon problem. Up to 60% of Switch owners stated they've experienced drift. Worse still, this problem could occur in as little as 12 months. 

Joy-Cons break so regularly, you'd think Nintendo would lower the price. But even now, these flawed controllers can cost over $70, despite the fact there's a good chance they'll start to glitch within a year.

With that said, Nintendo could be forgiven if they remedied the issue. But after eight years, the drift hasn't gone away, which has led to legal disputes.

Nintendo are renowned for triple-checking and fine-tuning their hardware before release, so it's bewildering how this major bug escaped their attention nor were they able to fix it.

8. Pay For Games You Don't Own Over and Over

The Wii and Wii U utilised an emulation service called the Virtual Console that allowed customers to download retro games. By hopping onto the Wii Shop Channel or Nintendo eShop, consumers could trade points or real currency to buy Nintendo titles. It may have been pure nostalgia bait, but it was gratifying to replay classics from various consoles.

Advertisement

The Virtual Console was such a hit, it was assumed Nintendo would utilise a similar system for the Switch. But 2016's Nintendo Switch Online worked differently since it allowed members access to a myriad of old-school titles for a reasonable fee. 

But when Mega Drive and N64 games were added to the service in 2021, the price skyrocketed. Not only was this announcement universally panned, another detail started to dawn on the gaming community. Being a subscription service, subscribers didn't technically own the games. Rather than playing a flat fee for each title, Switch owners must keep paying to maintain access to Nintendo's library. After a couple of years, subscribers will have forked over hundreds of dollars.

The Virtual Console was so straightforward and positively received, it's clear the only reason Nintendo replaced it with this over-priced system is to line their pockets.

7. Game Inaccessibility Leads To Piracy

Despite the child-friendly image, Nintendo are ruthless when it comes to piracy. Frank Cifaldi, who founded the Video Game Foundation, stated that Nintendo have ordered the shutdown of ROMs that aren't even based on their property. Not only that, there have been occasions where they've demanded up to $150,000 for every infringement of their work.

Advertisement

Interestingly, one of the easiest ways Nintendo can combat this issue is to make their games more accessible. Even though Nintendo Switch Online allows subscribers to play a wealth of games, some noticeable titles are missing.

Despite the fact Super Smash Bros., ActRaiser, Shinobi, Alien Soldier, Donkey Kong 64, and many others were available on the Virtual Console, they're nowhere to be seen on the modern service. This is odd, considering there's nothing stopping Nintendo from re-releasing any of these titles on the modern service.

Considering Nintendo is sitting on the aforementioned games, they won't lose any money by bringing them to the Switch Online. In fact, doing so should deter people from pirating them. After all, Nintendo should remember that they don't do themselves any favours when going after small-time hackers.

Speaking of which...

6. Sued A Man Called Bowser FOREVER

Although Nintendo are in their legal right to protect their properties, the way they crackdown on ROM websites isn't just tough but cruel.

Advertisement

Probably the best example of Nintendo's uncompromisable policy towards pirates centres around a Canadian hacker called Gary Bowser. (Yes, that's his real name.) When Nintendo learned Bowser was pirating 3DS and Switch titles, they had the fittingly named hacker's operation shut down. Since he undermined Nintendo's intellectual property, Bowser was sentenced to 40 months in prison and a $4.5 million fine. It may sound harsh, but it's pretty on-brand for the Japanese company.

But it didn't stop there. Nintendo tacked on a civil lawsuit, so Bowser owed an extra $10 million. Being an unfeasible amount to pay, Nintendo compromised (in their minds), allowing them to snag at least 25% of Bowser's monthly income until the debt is paid. 

If Gary Bowser earned $5000 per month, it would take almost a thousand years for him to be debt-free. Also, it's worth mentioning that Bowser only managed to pay Nintendo $175 within the first three years.

Though this Draconian punishment is meant to ward off would-be pirates, suing a man into oblivion until his dying day doesn't put Nintendo in the best light.

5. Releasing Unplayable Switch Ports

Even though the Switch has a hefty selection, there are many coveted titles that can't run on the hybrid console, due to its limitations in hardware, storage, and RAM.

Advertisement

With that said, the Switch has successfully ported some graphic-heavy properties like Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice and Doom Eternal.

However, some ports range from janky to unfinished. Many Resident Evil titles can only be played through the cloud, often with spotty results. The Batman: Arkham Trilogy felt like false advertising, since the third instalment, Batman: Arkham Knight was virtually unplayable. The Switch version of Mortal Kombat 1 was so laughably broken, it's regarded as one of the worst ports in recent times.

To be fair, having state-of-the-art games functioning perfectly on a less powerful system is a miracle. 

But sometimes, there's no excuse. Although several Kingdom Hearts entries were ported to the Switch in 2022, they're only available on the cloud. The earliest available title, Kingdom Hearts HD 1.5 Remix, was released on the PS3 in 2013. As such, there's no rationale why the Square classic couldn't be purchased digitally or physically. 

This decision could be acceptable if the Kingdom Hearts franchise played well on the cloud. On the contrary, playing the Disney-themed entries is borderline impossible, due to the abominable connectivity problems.

Porting these games was executed so poorly, the developers shouldn't have bothered in the first place.

4. Stabbing Their Former Partner In The Back

Sony and Nintendo have been rivals ever since the PlayStation debuted. This is deeply ironic, since Nintendo played a major hand in the console's creation.

Advertisement

During the early '90s, Nintendo seemed unstoppable after the SNES outperformed every other system on the market. Willing to push its tech further, Nintendo partnered with Sony to develop a CD add-on for the console.

Nintendo grew uneasy about the terms of the contract, especially surrounding Sony’s control over licensing and profits from CD-based games. Unable to see eye-to-eye, Nintendo thought it best for the two to part ways. It's a shame things didn't work, but there shouldn't have been any ill will between the pair, since it's all a part of business.

However, Nintendo's next move was pretty low. Oblivious they had rubbed Nintendo the wrong way, Sony confidently declared they were teaming up with them at the 1991 Consumer Electronics Show. The very next day, Nintendo announced at the same venue they had replaced Sony with Philips.

Of course, Sony had the last laugh. Rather than letting the project go, they continued with their PlayStation system, which went on to sell a hundred million units. If Nintendo didn't humiliate Sony in such a petty way, maybe they wouldn't have been encouraged to one-up their former business partner.

3. Mistreating Rare Time and Time Again

Rareware, which was co-founded by Chris and Tim Stamper, is responsible for creating some of the greatest games ever, including the Donkey Kong Country trilogy, GoldenEye 007, Banjo-Kazooie, and Perfect Dark.

Advertisement

Serving as a second-party developer for Nintendo, you'd think the company would greatly appreciate Rare. However, there are many examples of Nintendo taking the British developers for granted. 

Despite the fact GoldenEye 007 was revolutionary, it barely saw the light of day since Nintendo stopped funding for three months and tried to can the project.

When Rare worked on a new IP called Dinosaur Planet, Nintendo repurposed it into a Starfox spin-off so it would be more marketable. Making this decision in the eleventh hour resulted in the game feeling like two different titles squished into one, which was jarring.

Nintendo may have mismanaged Rare a little, but there was no doubt they were a winning formula when they worked together. As a result, the Stampers were certain Nintendo would eventually purchase Rare. 

But when their contract expired, Nintendo cut all ties, allowing Microsoft to swoop in and buy Rare. Sadly, Rare failed to recapture the former glory while working for Microsoft, causing the company to slowly dissolve.

If Nintendo bought Rare when they had the chance, the beloved developers could still be going strong and we could be playing Banjo-Kazooie 7 right now.

2. Going After Content Creators' Revenue

Being the devil's advocate, Nintendo's brand control is purely to preserve their characters, games, and assets, which are viewed as highly valuable commodities.

Advertisement

Having said that, Nintendo can be just as tough when it comes to innocent content creators. Since 2013, there've been cases of Let's Play videos surrounding Nintendo being deleted and accounts being suspended unless the creators have permission from the company. 

After agreeing to these terms, the creators were still limited with what games they could discuss or what criticisms they could make. Even if a YouTuber or Twitch streamer's platform centres around Pokémon or Metroid, their hands are tied what they can and cannot talk about.

Just to add salt to the wounds, users can follow these unreasonable guidelines and not earn a penny, since Nintendo can seize the advertising revenue on any video involving their property. The content creator is at a disadvantage if they challenge this claim, since sites are sure to favour the billion-dollar conglomerate, leaving the user at risk of receiving a strike or a suspension.

The money earned may be chump-change to Nintendo but it's a living wage for content creators.

1. Jacking Up The Price of the Switch 2 Games (And Hiding It)

Although the Switch 2 was hyped to an immeasurable level, the Nintendo Direct for the upcoming console seemed to exceed all expeditions (at least, at first). With a ton of exclusive games in the pipeline, 4K output, strong third-party support, and improved hardware, the gaming community looked like they were in for a treat.

Advertisement

Those who watched the Direct got so excited, one crucial detail might've eluded them - the pricing. Since it wasn't mentioned, players naturally assumed the games would cost the same as usual.

That's why it was shocking when it came to light that Switch 2 titles cost up to $89.99. And we're not talking about Nintendo's heavy-hitters like Metroid or Donkey Kong. Switch re-releases like Super Mario Party Jamboree are priced at $79.99.

If that isn't a slap in the face, ports cost around the same. The Switch 2 port of Breath of the Wild is over $69.99 despite being nearly a decade old and looking almost identical to the original.

Nintendo have emphasised the price hike is justified, due to the amount of content each title offers. But considering the billion-dollar corporation is drowning in money, it's not like they need to scramble for pennies.

Even though the Switch 2 is being pre-ordered like crazy, Nintendo's greed could massively backfire. In recent weeks, many of Nintendo's video announcements and livestreams have been flooded with messages, reading "Drop the Price". Ironically, Nintendo would probably sell more Switch 2s if they lowered the games' prices, which would net them a bigger profit.

The controversy surrounding this topic is so profound, Nintendo may cave under the pressure and reduce the prices. But considering how long it takes for Nintendo to learn from their mistakes, nobody should be holding their breath. 

Advertisement