10 Worst Things Warner Bros. Games Have EVER Done
From mismanaging the Batman: Arkham games to fleecing LOTR fans, WB Games has a poor track record.
Films and video games have had a rocky relationship over the years, frequently trading between themselves but often failing to produce anything of note. And Warner Bros. reckoned they had the solution to this back in 2004 - Warner Interactive (now Warner Bros. Games): a division of the studio designed to make the seams between films and games less visible while creating that all-inclusive synergy big brands love so much.
And, you know what? It worked! From their first game, The Matrix Online, things went gangbusters, and within a decade, Warner Bros. were responsible for publishing and developing leading titles like Batman: Arkham, Mortal Kombat and most of the best LEGO games.
However, for the past decade and change, the wrong people have been making the decisions over at the ol’ Warner place, and things have gone more than a little pear-shaped. Major games have been cancelled, the studio's rich body of IP has been hollowed out, innovations have been ignored, and studio subsidiaries have been shut down. These awful decisions have led them to a very difficult place financially, conceptually and in the eyes of the general gaming public, and they’re still racing towards the cliff-edge with their foot on the accelerator.
Just in case you missed the action, we are going to take you through the company's history of stupid decisions - well, the 10 worst of them to be precise...
10. Batman's Death In Suicide Squad: Kill The Justice League
Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League has had a rough ride from inception through to release and, well, as far beyond as fans have been willing to go with it.
The game throws together modern favourite Squad members Harley Quinn, Deadshot, King Shark and Captain Boomerang, as they are sent out into the world (or, more accurately, worlds) to try and stop Braniac, who is manipulating the world's greatest heroes via brainwashing and mind control. Most critics slaughtered the game from the off, and fans weren't far behind, citing repetitive gameplay, poor mechanics and several story beats that made everyone a little uncomfortable - particularly as it was the first entry in the Batman: Arkham franchise for almost a decade.
The worst of all of these though was Warner giving the go-ahead to light up the big guy. That's right, true to the vague promise of the title, the Suicide Squad do in fact kill Batman, on a street bench, of all places! In this game, of all games!
Given the game was designed to be a spin-off of the Batman: Arkham series, this is about as disrespectful as it gets. The fact that it was the late, great Kevin Conroy's penultimate performance as the Dark Knight made it all the more unfortunate, with not even the post-story reveal that Batman had in fact survived (as had the other Leaguers, bar Wonder Woman) doing anything to redeem Kill the Justice League's sorry reputation.
9. Rejecting A John Constantine Game From Warner Bros. Games Montréal
A staunch fan favourite who has had precious little screen time considering his popularity, hellblazing anti-hero John Constantine is a character that Warner have tried for years to bring to life outside the comics - through one live-action movie (plus one middling-to-shoddy video game tie-in), several animated depictions and a short-lived live-action TV show.
But, despite this effort, and tacit acknowledgement of how much the Liverpudlian anti-hero means to DC Comics fans, they have never mustered the cojones to see a strong, coherent, well-funded and true-to-source adaptation through.
This all might have changed had the folks at Warner Bros. been receptive to WB Games Montréal's pitch for a Constantine title in the wake of Gotham Knights’ release (as reported by Bloomberg). Following initial excitement from Warner Games’ president David Haddad, his team became noncommittal around budget and timeline approvals, and after months of treading water, killed the idea, seeking a game starring a more widely recognisable character. (This ended up being The Flash, but that project was also nixed, with Montréal now reportedly working on a Game of Thrones video game instead.)
If done right, this game could have packed wise-cracking demon-hunting shenanigans into an expansive, plane-spanning mythos, harnessing the overall tone of something like the Arkham series while being even more violent, more sweary, and a good deal more humorous. And, if you ask us, that’s the perfect blend - “recognisable character”or not.
8. Forgetting Batman: Arkham Origins
The Batman: Arkham series is the crowning jewel in Warner's gaming roster, delivering quality experiences from inception in 2009 with Batman: Arkham Asylum through to 2015's closing chapter, Batman: Arkham Knight. Managing on each occasion to up the ante, build the universe and introduce exciting new gadgets and techniques, Warner and Rocksteady made one of the most successful game series of the last couple of decades, rooted in a strong IP, innovative combat system and impressive execution.
However, they almost derailed the whole thing in 2013 with Batman Arkham: Origins, a prequel set years before the first game, and the only game of the series not to be led by Rocksteady (who were busy on Arkham Knight).
While the story was exciting, featuring a gang war between Bane and the Joker, and it continued to expand the game’s world, Origins was marred by technical issues from day one - perhaps a consequence of a truncated development cycle and releasing on outmoded console hardware, with versions developed for the PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360, but not the newly released PlayStation 4 and Xbox One. Save files were corrupted, the game crashed and froze, and various other bugs made the game at times literally unplayable.
But while Warner initially went to work setting things right, just five months after launch they announced they would no longer be releasing additional patches or bug fixes, abandoning the player base and turning their attention solely to upcoming DLC. A bellwether for things to come, this feels attuned to the approach the company would take to their games - and players - in the years post-Arkham Knight, including overlooking Origins for a remaster altogether.
7. Shoehorning Lootboxes & Microtransactions Into Middle-earth: Shadow Of War
While DC is a major part of Warner Games’ output, it isn’t everything, as they also have (or have recently had) the rights to some other hot properties, including The Lord of the Rings. Now, unlike many other film-adjacent or -inspired game series, LOTR has done fairly well over the years, being graced with both movie tie-in and expanded universe titles that have been fun and playable, and that have jelled with the overall tone and feel of the franchise.
From 2010 to 2022, Warner helmed the gaming output for LOTR with seemingly a genuine interest in providing multiple formats and points of access, including the LEGO series and, of course, the Middle-earth games. The latter kicked off with Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor, an Assassin’s Creed-esque action-adventure game that introduced the Nemesis System, which allows AI characters to remember their interactions with you and react accordingly in subsequent encounters.
This made for truly killer single-player gaming, and expectations were high for the sequel, Middle-earth: Shadow of War.
While the game itself didn’t disappoint, offering up smarter enemies, more involved mechanics, large and varied territories to roam, and other neat surprises, there was one major wrong turn: aggressive, post-release monetisation. That’s right, Warner decided to introduce microtransactions and lootboxes, totally undermining the Nemesis System - the game’s USP. All in the name of an additional payday, which after fan backlash they ended up having to walk back anyway.
6. Turning MultiVersus From A Surprise Hit Into A Total Failure
Warner Bros. have never been a company to shy away from synergy between their various brands (just check out the last Space Jam movie), but nowhere is this more apparent than in free-to-play crossover game MultiVersus. A slightly less egregious IP cash-in than the likes of Funko Fusion, the game pits characters from DC, Looney Tunes, Game of Thrones, Adventure Time, Gremlins, The Matrix and others against each other in a fighting game built in the image of Super Smash Bros.
MultiVersus enjoyed a hugely successful beta launch, but took a massive break and, when players returned, progress and earned currency had been wiped. Bad enough, but that was the beginning of the problems.
Despite mixed reviews from the get, MultiVersus was at one point the most-played game on Steam, and yet the developers failed to listen to what the community genuinely wanted and needed. The audience was there, invested and receptive, but WB treated this as an easy win, relying on the combination of well-known IP and a live-service platform to rake in the cash. More fool them…
Their expectation of players to pour currency into the game’s many purchase points while failing to give them the characters, features and updates they requested backfired big time. The company failed to make anything like the money they wanted, and called time on the game just a year after its full release - with MultiVersus being delisted and taken offline in 2025.
5. Failing To Build On Batman: Arkham Knight's Legacy With Gotham Knights
While Batman: Arkham Knight might not be the best game of its series, it closed with a bang, introducing new characters, making best use of old ones, and delivering fun (if overused) systems like the Batmobile. Despite the Bat biting the dust at the game’s conclusion, it was always certain WB Games wouldn’t just leave it there. But did they have to do it like this?
Gotham Knights plunged us back into the city’s murk and mayhem in the shoes of the Bat Family: Nightwing, Red Hood, Batgirl and Robin, who are drafted in to investigate the Bat’s murder – but not the one we saw in the Arkham games. Running roughshod over the story and character implications of the previous game, Knights brings Batman back from the grave... only to kill him again.
Exacerbating all of this is that Gotham Knights had originally been conceived of by WB Montréal as an Arkham spin-off centring on Damian Wayne (per The Gamer). WB cancelled the game however, leading to Montréal developing Gotham Knights away from the Arkham franchise, despite the game's story feeling like it was springboarded from the events of Arkham Knight's ending, in which Batman fakes his death.
To top this, the game looks and feels like it belongs on a seventh-gen console. The characters feel surprisingly similar during play, and the scope and grace of Batman’s combat and stealth from the Arkham games is missing.
Why Warner put out an inferior game, or killed Batman three games in a row is anyone’s guess, but these choices ramped up some serious ill will that they may never recover from.
4. Hacking Away at Rocksteady
Founded in 2004, Rocksteady Studios have delivered some serious success for Warner Bros. Games), including - most notably - the Batman: Arkham franchise. But over the years, Warner have failed Rocksteady, failing to address a culture of toxic positivity where issues could not adequately be challenged, and leading to the departure of co-founders Jamie Walker and Sefton Hill at the end of 2022, who had reportedly envisioned Suicide Squad as a looter-shooter.
The subsequent commercial failure of the re-tooled Suicide Squad game in the wake of Walker and Hill's departure has reportedly already damaged the studio, as Warner have used this as an opportunity to cut as much as possible - rather than, you know, looking at what can be improved and making some much-needed changes.
Several rounds of layoffs (per GameRant), this year and last, have seen the studio lose staff from across programming, artistry and quality assurance (with QA down to fewer than half the original team members). Despite the fact that the studio is reportedly working on a new Batman game, this has left the team with a large workload and has, reportedly by senior management’s own admission, significant potential to affect future games’ quality.
3. Copyrighting (& Then Doing Nothing With) Middle-earth's Nemesis System
Middle Earth: Shadow of Mordor’s Nemesis System makes it a cut above the rest, offering exciting gaming experiences in which enemy orcs remember you, remember your decisions, and return with the scars and deformities of previous fights, as well as seeking to avenge their fallen comrades. This means no two games are the same, and that unique gameplay can be found even after completing the game in its entirety.
This system was used again in the sequel Shadow of War, upping the ante with additional generative abilities for the creation of enemy characters and more complex hierarchies of power. But since then (2017), Warner Bros. Games has shut down developer Monolith, and squatted on the system like a fat toad. As Warner holds the license and patents for Monolith’s engines and systems - until 2036! - the Nemesis system is likely to remain locked away for another 11 years with what is, if we’re being honest, an increasingly uninventive company (per CBR).
This means gamers may not see the system put to use at all, and even if we do, it could be in some cack-handed disaster that Warner has identified as its next big money-making venture...
2. Cancelling Monolith's Wonder Woman Game
You’ve seen her in Injustice, LEGO, Fortnite and MultiVersus, but you may never see her in her own title...
In terms of cancelled, killed or uncompleted games from Warner Bros. Games, few have left a sour taste in our mouths as, you guessed it: Wonder Woman. The hotly anticipated game, which was pitched and planned by Monolith, and announced back in 2021, was officially canned in February of this year.
The game promised to put the iconic superhero front and centre in a single-player, open-world epic that used the full talents of the character’s comic book writers and the people that developed the Middle Earth games (using the Nemesis system, no less). But, after three years (!) of development, Warner scrapped it along with Monolith itself.
Warner Bros. cited the difficult decision to close the studios and axe their games as a measure to boost profitability (reported by The Guardian). So, hey, gaming fans, at least you’ve got Warner’s profitability to keep you company when you’re looking for a fun evening in.
And this leads us into what is surely their worst decision of all...
1. Closing Monolith Productions
Yes, Wonder Woman may well have gone ahead if Warner hadn't made the decision to close Monolith Productions.
Founded back in the mid-‘90s, Monolith grew with the contemporary games market, initially developing titles for Windows before moving into consoles and attracting ever-bigger properties, such as Alien and Tron, before their acquisition by Warner Interactive in 2004. Since then, they have specialised in the development of horror games and those tied to big IPs, including both Middle-earth games. Recently, they have been working on Wonder Woman, and - if the game was as good as most of us expected - were in a good position to usurp Rocksteady as Warner’s go-to developer for DC single-player titles.
But the commercial failure of Rocksteady’s Suicide Squad, and reported $200 million loss from this and other snafus, put paid to this. In the wake of this failure, Warner decided not to close Rocksteady, but to instead do away with Player First Games, WB Games San Diego and Monolith. And this doesn’t just mean bailing on the upcoming game.
By binning Monolith, Warner have lost the cumulative expertise amassed across three decades, from their initial run of MS-DOS, through games like The Matrix Online, and into their modern innovations (including, as you well know by now, the one-of-a-kind Nemesis system).
But if you think this will be where the bad decisions end, boy do you have another thing coming...