10 Worst Video Game Heroes Of All Time

Seriously, why are we playing as these clowns?!

By Steve Clark /

Quick. Think of an iconic video game hero. What makes them so memorable?

Advertisement

A whole combination of factors, like a kickass personality, super-sweet skills and enjoyable gameplay that saw you complete that game a billion times over, right?

Creating a great gaming hero is vital to a game’s success – after all, you’re going to be spending a fair few hours playing as them, and the last thing you want is one that makes you thrust your Doc Martens through the TV screen.

Yet, somehow, despite decades of game development, some studios still manage to mess it up, serving up playable characters designed to carve out your sanity and chip away at your good-natured tolerance.

Throughout that time, we’ve witnessed annoying catchphrases, frustrating movements, stupid animations, or bland personality, or worse, all of the above. And yet somewhere in their sick psyche, game developers thought that these were exactly the sort of people we wanted to support and spend time with.

They were wrong. Oh-so-very wrong. And if you disagree, you’re probably wrong too.

Who’s your favourite video game hero? None of these, I hope…

10. Lester The Unlikely (Lester The Unlikely)

Worst Offence: He’s a clumsy yellow-belly.

Advertisement

Video game heroes aren’t all badasses who can kill at the drop of a well-crafted hat. Some heroes are barely even heroes at all, like Lester the Unlikely – he’s an unlikely hero, don’t you know, which is an epitaph that’s only 50% accurate.

Lester is what a committee of aliens thinks a nerd must be, based on pop culture alone. The slick side-parting, the glasses, the dorky name – apologies to every other Lester out there. The plot even has him falling asleep reading a comic book (what a loser, amirite?!), and the dozy lad winds up alone onto a hostile island.

All that’s missing is his nightly fantasies over the head cheerleader and typing, like, really, really quickly because that’s what computer hacking looks like.

Letting gamers play as someone different is always cool, but male, female, black, white, big, tall, they all have one thing in common: They’re not wailing cry-babies like Lester, who bolts in terror whenever he sees enemies, stubbornly refuses to do what you ask and has one of the weakest attacks in gaming history.

What a hero!

9. Aiden Pearce (Watch Dogs)

Worst Offence: Not even Aiden Pearce remembers who Aiden Pearce is.

Advertisement

Ever wondered what it’s like to play as a balloon with a face drawn on it? Actually, that’s not fair; balloons have way more character than Aiden Pearce, ‘hero’ of Watch Dogs.

A moody hacker who thinks 'going incognito' involves a baseball cap and a trenchcoat with a popped collar. Mind you, maybe he’s onto something – because Pearce is so god-forsakenly dull, he could slap you in the face with a desktop computer and you still wouldn’t notice him.

Hackers are cool. Or should be, the urban Robin Hoods of our time. Yet, for all his technical wizardry, Pearce seems more interested spying on the denizens of Chicago, stealing money from innocent folks, while developing a psychotic desire to kill policemen. That makes him just as bad as the so-called villains he’s fighting. Even attaching a lame revenge story to him doesn’t make his character any less insufferable.

I'm all for well-written anti-heroes, but Pearce isn’t even that. He’s just a bit of a wally dressed all in black. And for some reason, Ubisoft thought he was exactly the type of dude gamers would want to spend hours with in Watch Dogs.

8. Bubsy The Bobcat (Bubsy Bobcat)

Worst Offence: Like swearing, he’s not big and he’s not clever.

Advertisement

Bubsy is what you get if you performed a charisma bypass on Sonic the Hedgehog, and fused him with all the hatred developer Accolade clearly hold for humanity. Either that, or they mistook irritating for charming.

This bobcat is one lousy mascot, from shockingly rough controls to going down later a single hit to mocking the players with his over-the-top lisp. It was as if this guy actively despised you for even touching his game (and, frankly, we can’t say we blame him). The worst part is, he returned for three more, wholly unnecessary sequels, each titled with their own achingly unfunny puns.

Also, maybe it’s just us, but his exclamation mark T-shirt is such a nakedly cynical attempt at creating an iconic gaming symbol that it makes us want to maim things – bobcats in particular; Bubsy specifically.

7. Chris Redfield (Resident Evil 5)

Worst Offence: He’s become the thing he professes to despise – A monster.

Advertisement

Chris Redfield was always a cool guy. A bit laconic and all-American hero, but he was never completely annoying – until Resident Evil 5 arrived. That marked the moment when everyday elite cop transformed into steroidal soldier.

Tragically, those steroids had a detrimental effect on Redfield’s personality – by which we mean, it erased it altogether, and replaced it with a series of clichés and a side order of cheese. Sure, this guy can punch the living hell out of boulders now (a fine party trick), but he also stopped being anything like the character fans had grown to love over the years.

Not that he had much character even back in the day, but at least he looked and acted vaguely human. And he could go more than a minute without saying the sort of lines you’d expect to hear in an 80s action movie. And if you thought Redfield was bad…

6. Jake Muller (Resident Evil 6)

Worst Offence: Who the hell is Jake Muller anyway?

Advertisement

Jake Muller is destined to be remembered as the Resident Evil character no-one ever remembers. Be honest, had you ever given him a second thought until now?

There’s a very good reason for that: He has no character whatsoever. Seriously, it’s difficult to even keep him on the list because there’s so little to Muller – what can we say about him? He has a gun. And a face.

Unfortunately, you can’t use said gun on said face, however much you’d like to. Actually, Muller has a fairly interesting backstory, since he’s the son of arch-antagonist and professional sunglasses collector Albert Wesker. But those daddy issues are never really developed, and he swiftly settles into the role of ‘person’.

Of course, we're talking Resident Evil 6, which like the T-virus (G-virus? C-virus? Who-even-cares virus?) was created by Capcom to destroy the zombie-slaying series through boredom. Still, though, pray for anyone who plays as this guy.

5. Gex The Gecko (Gex)

Worst Offence: Do you like Gex? Because Gex sure likes Gex.

Advertisement

Gex, the lazily-named gecko is living proof that, contrary to popular belief, you can have too much of a good thing. Gaming mascots were a big deal back in the 90s, and after the success of Mario and Sonic, the industry decided that just about every game needed a goofy cartoon hero. Some of them worked (Banjo-Kazooie, Crash Bandicoot, Conker) but some of them, like Gex, clearly did not.

The trouble with Gex is that he is uniquely unlikeable. Crystal Dynamics looked at all the things successful video game heroes are, then didn’t do that. Because Crystal Dynamics are just so avant-garde like that.

The result is a smug gecko who’s not nearly as clever as his wise-cracks imply. Worse, still, his parodies are laboured, his spoofs are contrived, and even Leslie Phillips’ cut-glass tones could make this gecko any more magnetic. Remember when everyone in the playground used to yell his catchphrase, ‘it’s tail time!’? Nope, neither do we.

4. Dante (DmC)

Worst Offence: He’s a juvenile wannabe caught in the throes of a tantrum.

Advertisement

What is it with Capcom taking a beloved hero and then ruining everything fans love about them? That’s exactly what they did in the Devil May Cry reboot, turning the generally awesome Dante into a whiney spoilt brat who tosses out moody one-liners as if his shallow life depends on it. Because that’s what ‘cool’ is to middle-aged executives.

If you stare very intently, you can make out the ghost of a Final Fantasy ‘too-hip-to-live’ vibe. A man designed to appeal to younger gamers (seriously, that’s why Capcom has him redesigned). Only here, it completely fails since that’s not who Dante is – or was. Dante was already a recognisable character, if only for his shock of white hair.

The reboot even does away with that. What once was a tough, skilled swordsman in the anime mould, becomes the simpering, inexperienced try-hard teenager DmC presents.

It’s telling that we’ve not seen this alternate-universe Dante since DmC was released in 2013. We can only hope that record remains unbroken.

3. Ryo Hazuki (Shenmue)

Worst Offence: Unless you’ve got information he wants, he’s not into you.

Advertisement

Shenmue is a sweeping epic. An engaging revenge story set amongst the suburbs of Japan, which sees the impulsive Ryo Hazuki hunt down the killer of his father. Awesome game, awesome cast of mostly memorable characters, but still, there’s no getting around the fact that Ryo is a total dick to those around him. Because leather jackets equal bad boys. Probably.

We get it. Grief does weird things to people. But Ryo’s manner is so stilted and brusque, and not just because of his voice-acting. It’s as if he’s never quite sure if he’s talking to a robot or a real-life human being with feelings. When his friend Tom leaves, he can barely muster up an ounce of sympathy. And all his endless questions to storekeepers, like they don’t have a business to run…

It leaves us wondering what supposed love interest Nozomi even saw in this guy. Sure, Ryo might’ve saved her life, but the rest of the time he treats her with absolute disdain.

Like, who is this dame asking to go out on dates when I’m buying up Sega toys?

Honestly, she’s better off without that jackass.

2. John Yesterday (Yesterday)

Worst Offence: Does. Not. Compute.

Advertisement

Did you ever play Yesterday and its sequel Yesterday Origins? Probably not, since it’s a low-rent Broken Sword-a-like that’s completely over-priced. Heading up the two games is the impossibly named John Yesterday, an immortal who, upon each resurrection, must re-remember who he was before. It’s basically Memento meets the Spanish Inquisition.

‘All right,’ you’re thinking, ‘That sounds pretty cool.’ You’re right – it does. But it’s also unutterably ruined by our so-called hero, John. Chiefly, it’s his voice: A slow, monotone drawl that, we guess, is supposed to come off as laid-back, but actually sounds more like he’s comatose and being forced to read from a script he’s never seen before, in a language he’s unfamiliar with.

And that lasts throughout the game, John never once dips and rolls into anything approximating emotion.

Despite a promising concept, thanks to the vocally challenged John, the Yesterday games are largely unplayable for anyone with ears that work. Hell, the voice-acting in Resident Evil was Oscar-worthy compared to this shtick.

1. Luigi (Luigi’s Mansion)

Worst Offence: Scared of his own shadow. And everyone else’s shadow.

Advertisement

We like Luigi. We like his extravagant moustache and his commitment to green issues (specifically, his clothing). What we don’t like, though, is his sheer cowardice. Don't get us wrong, if we were in a haunted mansion, we'd be terrified too, but hey, that's why we play games - because video game heroes are supposed to be braver than we are in real life.

Luigi’s Mansion is insanely enjoyable. Luigi in Luigi’s Mansion, on the other hand, is all over-the-top squeals and Hanna-Barbera-ish animation that renders him totally annoying.

He slows to a crawl, teeth chattering, in the face of danger, because gamers love being told they’re moving way too fast. Apparently. If that’s not bad enough, his irritating yelps remind us of those yappy dogs old ladies insist on taking on the bus.

Spend too long with Luigi and he’ll have you wishing you were playing as Baby Mario, it really is that bad.

--

Who are the absolute worst heroes in gaming history? Let us know in the comments!

Advertisement