11 Fascinating Gaming Moments That Almost Happened
Elder Scrolls was almost something completely different.
Although the gaming industry today is arguably the biggest entertainment industry going, to say that everything about it is straightforward would just be wrong.
Video game development is fraught with plenty of issues, with studios going under what feels like every other day, and with cancellations rife. That’s without even mentioning just how much a given project can change over the course of development, with it sometimes even being the case that the finished product resembles nothing like the original concept.
Where are we going with this? Well the point is that it’s always fun to deal with hypotheticals - the "What if?" moments of a given medium - and gaming is no different. It’s big business, and a lot can rest on just a single decision.
It’s not just single titles either. Some choices have influenced entire franchises and have even altered the market landscape itself, whether that be something based on a given character’s look and aesthetic, or in how we consume video games themselves.
Spanning decades, franchises, companies and consoles, here are the "What if?" moments that should give every fan pause for thought.
11. Bioshock Almost Didn't Feature Rapture
11 years after it launched, developers are still trying to top the imagination of the original Bioshock. While its shooter gameplay wasn't anything to rival the likes of Call of Duty at the time, it more than made up for it with its world and lore, which were tied together brilliantly in Rapture's underwater dystopia.
But, during the earlier stages of production anyway, the decaying, Splicer-infested metropolis was nowhere to be seen. Originally the game was more of a direct sequel to Irrational Games' System Shock titles rather than a mere spiritual successor, and just like those earlier releases, was set to take place on space station without any of the retro aesthetics that defined Rapture.
Even once this idea was scrapped and the devs opted for a clean break, their next move was similarly a far cry away from the eventual game's underwater setting. For a time, the project was set on an island, in a series of labs and facilities abandoned since the German army built them in the Second World War.
Interestingly, the core of Bioshock's most memorable elements were birthed here, including proto Splicers, Little Sisters and Big Daddies, all of which were experiments gone wrong. The throwback aesthetic was also present in this version, which was retained when the devs decided to once again drop the setting in favour of the Rapture we know today.
Josh Brown
10. Infamous Was "Animal Crossing With Superheroes"
Back in the days where licensed superhero games fell somewhere between mediocre and total abominations that needed to be scrubbed from history, Sony's Infamous picked up the slack. The first two titles put players in the super-powered shoes of Cole MacGrath, a Conduit imbued with powers the player could either use responsibly, or to cause untold mayhem. There was little fluff; you jumped around a city and fought giant monsters, with Sony's aim being to let players fulfil their wildest superhero fantasies at every given moment.
The original idea, however, was more concerned with letting players fulfil their wildest city-planning fantasies. Yeah, that probably wouldn't have sounded quite as alluring slapped on the box art, would it? Reflecting on the original title back in 2010, Sucker Punch co-founder Chris Zimmerman explained that the team were trying to create "a superhero version of Animal Crossing". Going into detail, Zimmerman expanded:
"You roamed your city, tracked down criminals, helped out the citizens, and did some light zoning work along the way. The best superheroes have alter egos, right? So your alter ego was a property developer, deciding where to put the pet shops and tiki bars the citizens were demanding."
Advertisement
Looking after a city both from a financial planning perspective and a vigilante perspective could have been cool, but there's no denying the series probably ended up being better by focusing solely on the latter element.
JB
9. Call Of Duty Zombies Was Nearly Cancelled Because It Was A "Disgrace"
Though they started out on the back foot, only given just over a year to phone in Call of Duty 3, through sheer perseverance and talent, Treyarch managed to become the main driving force behind Activision's premier shooter franchise. Their earliest major contribution to the series was the coveted Nazi Zombies mode from World at War, a multiplayer game type that's since become a staple of almost every single release, and spawned an entire community who only play the games for this one reason. Weird, I know.
As you can probably have guessed though, Activision - a company notorious for playing it as safe as possible and not taking any creative risks out of fear of losing even a penny - initially weren't keen on the idea. Working on the prototype of the mode in their spare time, the developers were eventually told to stop wasting energy on the side project and get to work on shipping the actual game.
The higher ups didn't just dislike the concept though, they actively hated it. One apparently even referred to it as a "disgrace to the franchise." The devs got the last laugh, of course, as the game shipped with the mode included as a small easter egg, which then transformed into one of the series' core pillars.
JB
8. Gearbox Nearly Developed Halo 4
You’d struggle to find an Xbox exclusive as universally adored - or as influential - as Bungie’s Halo series.
The studio had originally intended for the franchise to be an RTS of sorts, and was even originally set to release for the Macintosh before evolving into a third-person shooter, and then into a first-person one over the course of development.
The rest was history. Halo: Combat Evolved released to universal acclaim, and spawned one of the most beloved mythologies in the gaming medium. However, there was always going to come a point in time when Bungie would have to leave the series behind, and someone else would step up to the plate.
That point came after the release of Halo: Reach, and though Bungie were always set to leave, the matter of who was going to replace them actually led Microsoft to an unlikely name, Gearbox, before they eventually settled on 343 Industries.
According to IGN, Microsoft actively pursued the idea of giving Halo to an external studio, and the one in pole position was Gearbox Software. The studio had originally presided over the PC port of the first Halo, but are most famous today for helming Borderlands.
Ewan Paterson
7. The Dark Knight Movie Tie-In Would Have Meant No Arkham Asylum
Although a world without Batman: Arkham is one all too many fans would hate to contemplate, it’s true, Rocksteady’s franchise nearly never made it to market.
The 2000s may be heralded as a ‘golden age’ of gaming, but it was also an age of half-baked movie tie-ins, most of which seemed to feature the Caped Crusader in a starring role. This first commenced with 2005’s Batman Begins, and with Christopher Nolan gearing up to release a follow up - The Dark Knight - in 2008, Warner Bros. were keen to cash in.
The task for making a Dark Knight movie video game fell to Pandemic, the studio who had previously helmed the once beloved Star Wars: Battlefront series for LucasArts. By all accounts, their vision for a Batman title actually seemed rather compelling too, with it having ditched the linear format of Begins and opting for an open world Gotham in the vein of Spider-Man 2.
However, the game was binned off several months into development, which led WB to reconsider their plans and give the franchise to Rocksteady, who set about making the best superhero video game of all time with Arkham Asylum. Snakes and ladders, really.
EP
6. Xbox One's All-Digital Future
Although it's a distant memory now (a testament to just how well Phil Spencer and his team have righted the ship in the last six years), the original Xbox One launch was a disaster. Not learning from the same mistakes Sony made a generation prior, Microsoft's new vision for consoles was destroyed by their own hubris, as they arrogantly told concerned customers that if they didn't like the direction they were going in, they could happily stick with their 360.
But customers did have the right to be concerned. At the time, the Xbox One was being pitched as an all-in-one entertainment system focused as much (or arguably, even more) on TV than actual video games. Not only that, but it was striving for an all-digital future, loaded with DRM that would require the machine to be online at least once a day, a Kinect 2.0 that needed to be plugged in for the console to work, and a new licensing model which locked players out from sharing their games.
Not every idea was sound, but the company's approach could have been salvaged with more consumer-friendly messaging. After intense backlash, Microsoft changed their tune, but it is remarkable how much the industry has veered towards their original vision recently - a future which could have been kickstarted far earlier had this marketing campaign been successful.
JB
5. Epic's Original Idea For Gears Of War 4
While original creators Epic ended up selling the Gears of War franchise to Microsoft back in 2013, that wasn't always the plan, and while another team was drafted in to craft spin-off Judgement, they actually put six months of work into pre-production on a potential Gears 4.
And, remarkably, some of their original concepts were actually used in what The Coalition would end up creating, at least in the broad strokes. Like the new devs, Epic was also looking to expand the game to a new generation of heroes, including Marcus' son, who was also called JD. The game would also focus on a new villain, the Swarm. However, while the name stuck, The Coalition apparently changed everything about the new monsters, from their design to their mythology.
When the new developers inherited the franchise, they received all of Epic's preliminary work, which gave them a head start on pre-production. Obviously, they didn't just pick up where Epic left off, but used some of the better ideas as a base, transforming them to fit their own vision of the sequel.
It's not entirely known how committed the company was to this sequel before they decided to hand the reigns over to Microsoft (a decision apparently down to the bloated development costs for each new game), but it's still interesting that we could be living in a world right now not only where Epic was still in charge of Gears, but where JD was actually a good character...
JB
4. Mario Originally Used A Gun
"Who needs courage when you can give Mario a gun?" was the question most likely asked by Nintendo when deciding on what their next protagonist should embody, because - for a time - everyone's favourite Italian plumber had more in common with The Godfather's Luca Brazzi than your local handyman.
In an interview with the Famitsu magazine (translated by 1Up), Nintendo legend Shigeru Miyamoto revealed that Mario was originally going to wield a gun, and that the original Mario Bros. title was going to be a side-scrolling shooter. Miyamoto also stated that shoot em' up stages were also considered, "where Mario jumps on a cloud and shoots at enemies," but that the feature was scrapped when the company decided that "jumping action" made for much more compelling gameplay.
Needless to say, the thought of Mario having potentially once become a forgettable side-scrolling shooter protagonist isn't one many Nintendo fans will want to entertain, but it doesn't make speculating on what could've been any less enjoyable.
EP
3. Team Bondi Was Nearly Rockstar's Next Big Studio
Back in 2010, Team Bondi were hot s**t. Their revolutionary facial-scanning tech made L.A. Noire a must-play title, and even though not everyone was onboard with their brand of detective gameplay, it was clear they were pushing the industry forward in some pretty remarkable ways.
Their ambitions overshadowed their actual resources though, and it was a partnership with Rockstar, who agreed to produce and help develop the game, which allowed the title to properly coalesce and become such a smash hit.
There were stories of mismanagement and a potentially strained working relationship with their new publisher, but they were initially chalked up to teething problems, and Team Bondi's talent was viewed as being worth the drama. In fact, it's been stated that Rockstar were looking to bring them into the fold properly, with the intent of making them the next big Rockstar development studio.
That didn't happen though, and Bondi and Rockstar split on pretty terrible terms. The main creative leads couldn't see eye to eye, and in the end, the drama proved too much for both companies. Bondi went out on their own to produce their next game, then titled "The Whore of the Orient", but shut down a little while later after running out of funds.
JB
2. Overwatch Was Nearly An MMO
Few could've predicted just how influential Blizzard's Overwatch would become when it released in May 2016, but it's a simple truth that the industry has been changed drastically by the title, which has managed to influence everything from first-person-shooters, to Battle Royale, to even micro-transactions themselves.
Loot boxes - randomised crates of loot that can be acquired either through bulk purchases or through levelling in the game - are an ever-present force in most major releases in 2019, and have courted controversy at every stage. It was Blizzard's hero shooter that popularised the trend, but it almost never came to be.
Speaking at BlizzCon 2017, Overwatch lead designer Jeff Kaplan remarked how that, in the wake of MMO Titan's cancellation, Blizzard was asked to pursue a brand new MMO IP. The resulting concept became Crossroads, a class-based MMO set on a planet that would've brought all the beings in the universe under one roof. A number of the classes designed went on to become Overwatch's now iconic heroes, as did several others from an also cancelled StarCraft spin-off, but it was only later that development switched into the hero shooter we know today.
It was only through Titans' cancellation that Blizzard were forced to reconsider their plans though, with developers forced to go back to the drawing board and look at how the medium initially inspired them. Unsurprisingly, those developers pointed towards the old arena shooters of the nineties, which came to inform Overwatch in a pretty significant way.
EP
1. Elder Scrolls Wasn't Going To Be An RPG
Although the Bethesda of today seem to embroiled in controversy with almost every release, there's no denying the influence they've had on the RPG genre. Both the Elder Scrolls series and Fallout have impacted heavily on the industry, but it is the former that kickstarted it all.
The first entry in the series was called Elder Scrolls: Arena, and was so-called because it was originally going to be a tournament based title. It was only later in development that Bethesda began to slowly incorporate RPG elements, but originally, the actual structure of the game seemed to have more in common with Pokémon than the open-ended exploration that the studio have become renowned for.
The actual title also harkens back to the original concept Bethesda had in mind. The player would travel with their companions and partake in various tournaments, while the game would end with the player becoming the champion of the Imperial City.
Had Bethesda stayed their original course, though, it stands to reason that the Elder Scrolls of today wouldn't be half as influential or as adored as it currently is.
EP