You might be thinking that Until Dawn's replayability comes from the differing outcomes of the various scenarios that you can have, but in fact, what truly makes the game worth replaying is its status as an absurdly entertaining party game. That's right. The game has 8 main characters, so find 8 buddies, pick names out of a hat and each player controls one of the characters throughout the adventure. This adds an extra layer of tension to gameplay as players will literally kill their friends off in order to save themselves, though as anyone who has played the game will know, this can often go sideways for the player in question. The actual core game doesn't have as much storyline variety as you might expect and picking up collectibles isn't especially interesting or fun, but the game goes down great at parties, and you can easily get at least three or four playthroughs from it by just showing it off to your buddies.