12 Most Underrated Video Games Of This Console Generation (So Far)
Someone, give these poor games some love!
It's been a funny old generation. With remastered games being the order of the day, exclusivity being increasingly replaced with 'timed' exclusivity, and Microsoft's melding of its Xbox and Windows platforms, this gen of consoles hasn't quite felt like 'Where it's at' as it has in previous generations (Full Disclosure: PC Gamer here, with a dejected PS4 sitting in the corner of my room).
But dig beneath the surface, beyond the esteemed halls of hit AAA games, and there's a treasure trove of already-forgotten gems to discover. They may have been lacking the Metacritic averages, marketing budgets, or love from the gaming community, but these underrated games are more than deserving of a second look (plus many of them are dirt-cheap now, so that helps, right?).
Read on for our list of the most underrated games of this generation, ranging from ingenious indie games, to innovative shooters, to an awesome RPG not called Witcher or Fallout. Will you give them a home?
12. Divinity: Original Sin - Enhanced Edition
A rich, wonderfully deep RPG that can be played through in its entirety with a friend in the same room (or online). Surely that sentence alone is enough to prick up any gamer's ears?
But while Divinity is a critical darling, its Enhanced Edition came to consoles with little fanfare. Maybe it's to do with the old-school top-down perspective or the complex (yet rewarding) combat system, or that the 'console RPG' is the exclusive domain of The Witcher and Bethesda games, and gamers will not tolerate any pretenders.
Whatever the case, this is the definitive version of an epic open-world RPG spanning a fascinating lore-loaded world, with a deep levelling system, solid story, and cleverly-designed local co-op that shifts between split-screen and same-screen as and when required.
11. Alien: Isolation
When it was revealed that the new entry in the waning Alien franchise was to be a survival horror inspired by the original movie, it was hard to believe whether we should trust SEGA, or laugh them off ("What? In the same way as Colonial Marines was inspired by Aliens? Ha. Haha. HAHAHAHAHA").
But no one was laughing when Alien: Isolation arrived, because it was tense, terrifying, and unpredictable, as you'd spend countless minutes hiding under beds or in lockers, waiting for the stalking, procedurally-spawning alien to go by, before making a run—sorry, crouch-walk, for it.
Strangely however, sales weren't much better than Colonial Marines (though still decent), and critical opinion was decidedly split, perhaps because cowering and hiding don't fit traditional models of video game 'fun'.
It's the kind of game that horror fans will love and horror-phobes will loathe. It was a brave move to take a mainstream genre in such a niche direction, but it worked incredibly well, and if you want to encourage more creativity in the AAA industry, then it's your moral duty to buy it.
10. This War Of Mine
Hey, want to play a game about war? No, you don't get to gun down swathes of faceless soldiers. No, helicopters don't crash into buildings, sending shardy showers of glass onto your head. And no, you won't feel like a hero while playing it.
This War of Mine is a tough sell in a games industry with a very blunt status quo of what 'war' is. It's a survival game in which you control a group of people trying to survive a siege in a fictional Balkan town inspired by the Siege of Sarajevo.
It's bleak, beautiful, and confronts you with heart-rending questions like: should you steal food from the elderly couple to look after your own? How many innocent people are you prepared to rob or kill? Is co-operating with strangers worth the risk in such dangerous times?
It's powerful, profound stuff, and one of the best examples of games as commentary on 'Sh*t that Actually Matters'.
9. Mad Max
Coming out so soon after the blockbuster movie of the same name, you'd have thought that the game would be a guaranteed hit so long as it was a bit better than average.
While sales were decent, critics were lukewarm towards this post-apocalyptic, open-world romp through the (Australian, I think) outback. Yes, the setting is a bit on the stark side (desert and, oh look, more desert), but the base-capturing gameplay, teeth-clenched driving, and Arkham-like combat mechanics all add up to a brilliant game that could easily have earned the same critical acclaim as Shadow of Mordor had it come out a year earlier.
Maybe due to not being tied in to the brilliant and wonderfully-imagined world of the movie, or the possibility that critics don't know what the hell they're talking about, Mad Max was, errr, buried in the sand quite quickly.
On the bright side, that means you can now grab it on the cheap!
8. Hand Of Fate
So, this one's got 'geeky niche' written all over it by combining action-RPG gameplay with a card game. And within that niche, Hand of Fate has been warmly greeted, though outside of that it's virtually unheard of.
You progress through the game by sitting opposite a Game Master, who dishes out cards that give you health, send you on adventures, and improve your character. The encounters themselves are played out in a combat system that's based on timing, counter-attacks, and combos not unlike the Arkham series. Admittedly a bit inferior.
There's something warm and meditative about Hand of Fate's meta-gameplay where you hang out with a GM between encounters, and the endless mode is great for jumping into sessions without too much commitment.
But all of that will probably fall on deaf ears for many people as soon as they hear the words 'Card Game', so let's move on, shall we?
7. Battleborn
The fact that I instinctively started writing 'Bloodborne' when writing this entry kind of sums up this game's predicament. Its name sounds too much like another, superior game, and the fact that it's a hero-based colourful online shooter means it's doomed to always be compared with the superior Overwatch, which was released around the same time.
But pretend for a moment that Overwatch and Bloodborne don't exist, and you'll see that Blood—sorry, Battleborn is a perfectly good game in its own right. It has an entertaining story, a huge array of characters, and that trademark Borderlands-like Gearbox humour. The game really shines in the competitive multiplayer, which is well balanced (maybe even more so than Overwatch?!?), and encourages you to experiment with countless hero combinations.
It's maybe so overloaded with ideas and visuals that it sometimes doesn't fit together, but this is still one of the better shooters of this generation. And with its player numbers waning, it might soon be free. Yay!
6. Titanfall
It was meant to be the big, hulking game to break up the Battlefield-CoD dominance of the online war shooter. And on a technical level, it kind of was, as two teams of six pilots (and a whole load of expendable bots) took each other on using a mixture of parkour and giant bipedal robots.
Titanfall tried to be different and almost succeeded, though the fact that I'm talking about it in the past tense despite it being only a couple of years old is pretty telling about where it's at now. EA failed to market and support the game properly post-launch, its early days were buggy, and players weren't willing to stick around to wait for it to improve. As such, Titanfall was destined for the scrapyard.
Just months after launch, the servers were empty in this mechanically unique and riveting online shooter. At least EA has seen enough potential in it to warrant a sequel—with added grappling hooks! Stayed tuned for that one...
5. Dark Souls 2: Scholar Of The First Sin
Dark Souls 2 was well received by the media at the time of its release, raked in its fair share of sales, and kept up the momentum of the Souls series to hype people up for Bloodborne and Dark Souls 3. But sandwiched by brilliance, this solid middle-man hasn't been treated kindly by hindsight.
Once the initial excitement of its launch faded, it was open season for slamming into Dark Souls 2. People bemoaned the fact that the series' visionary creator Hidetaka Miyazaki hadn't worked on it, resulting in a much more linear world design, a less coherent story, and apparently too many 'big dudes in armour' boss fights (11 out of 32, by my count).
Some of these criticisms are legitimate, but what about the improved combat mechanics, awesome PvP gameplay, and the fact that, well, it's more Dark Souls? The Scholar of the First Sin came with all the DLC and a tweaked story too, making the whole thing much more coherent. Though by this point it seemed that people had already condemned the game as the ugly duckling of the series.
4. Broforce
Not that many people have heard about Broforce, though you may know it as 'yet another pixel-art platformer chucked in as a PS Plus freebie'. That would be doing it an injustice however, as Broforce is one of the best things you can possibly do that involves four people and four gamepads.
The 2D pixel-art look combined with glorious excesses of blood and explosions is a joy to behold, but really it's the satirical All-American spirit of the game that makes it really shine. You control 'Bro' versions of iconic Hollywood action heroes (Broheart, Brommando, Rambro etc.), each of whom has their unique abilities to decimate battalions of squealing little baddies. Later on, you even get to duke it out in the fires of hell, and take on the xenomorphs from the Alien series.
The randomisation of who you play as (there are over 30 Bros to choose from) prevents the game from ever feeling over-familiar, and the wealth of co-op and competitive multiplayer modes make it endlessly replayable.
3. The Evil Within
With Resident Evil having long since gone off the survival horror rails, the brains behind the brilliant fourth entry, Shinji Mikami, sought to recapture some of that old magic with The Evil Within.
Granted, he didn't quite succeed, because the game is more Grindhouse, big-dudes-with-chainsaws, and rooms-inexplicably-filled-with-lethal-sawblades than any Resident Evil game or survival horror I've ever seen. But get over that hump, and you'll find that for all its lack of subtlety, it's a veritable gory-hole of a game.
The creature designs are brilliant, the shooting mechanics crunchy and satisfying, and there are even a couple of cheap yet effective jump scares thrown in for good measure. It's about as subtle as chucking a human into a wood-chipper, but nonetheless one of most enjoyable horror romps around.
2. Wolfenstein: The New Order
Teetering on the border between this generation and the last, Wolfenstein: The New Order wasn't exactly shrouded in hype, perhaps because of the forgettable nature of its predecessor and expectations that it'd be kind of generic.
But in the trusty hands of Bethesda, the venerable shooter series went through a beautiful revival, featuring innovative shooter mechanics and an excellent story set in an alternative-history '60s world where the Nazis won World War II.
For the first time, BJ Blazkowicz has actually been endowed with some personality too, showing a tender (and raunchy) side alongside his ability to cut throats and take Nazi names. The Dieselpunk aesthetic looks fantastic, and travelling around a formidable, metallic Nazi-occupied Europe is just as thrilling as it would be in real life...
... because that would be fun, right?
1. Dying Light
With the excess in recent years of survival games, and zombie games, and survival games featuring zombies, it's easy to bunch them altogether into one big, brutal pile. Maybe that's why the excellent Dying Light never garnered a huge amount of critical love or attention—it was hard to get over the fact that it was yet-another open-world horror exploration game.
But you should get over that fact, immediately, because Dying Light is one of the most satisfying, mechanically sound games of its ilk. The free-running gameplay, which sees you bounding up walls and across rooftops fits with the fact that very often you will have to run. Ammo's in short supply, as are health packs, and the thrill of the chase is as great as the thrill of the fight.
Dying Light has really come into its own with The Following expansion pack, which adds in a new area to explore, some fancy new firepower, as well as a dune buggy to bomb around in. And as we all know, a dune buggy in a game is always, unequivocally, a good thing.