12 Video Games That Drastically Changed Between Reveal And Release
If we don't say anything, they'll just keep doing it.
The reaction and reception to No Man's Sky proved one thing about the game industry - consumers sure do love to hype things up, and those in marketing really love showing off games in a way that doesn't remotely indicate what they'll look like in the end.
It's called a 'vertical slice'; a chunk of a game siphoned off from the full project. These 'demos' don't take into account the ongoing development of the game itself i.e. features that may get added, changes in the size of the game overall etc. - basically, they're about as indicative of the big picture as one piece of pepperoni is to a pizza.
But still, the way press and hype cycles work - consumers need to be satiated and the exposure that comes with saying something like "Here's the first look at our game!" can't be turned away. It's why we get CG trailers instead of gameplay, and why I can't point to a single modern game that released in the exact same condition as when it was first shown.
Is being lied to just a harsh reality of being a gamer? Well, sadly, it just might be...
--
12. Killzone 2
Remember this? Sony really were drinking the Cool Aid back in the first couple years of the PS3's launch. Not only did they expect people to pay $600 for a 60GB model at launch, but when it came time to show off the new Killzone, they literally faked gameplay footage with a pre-rendered cutscene.
I mean, that's... that feels almost criminal at some point, doesn't it?
Sony's Jack Tretton went on to state the footage was “real gameplay everybody’s seeing out there”, before a member of Guerilla Games labelled it "a target render of what we thought would be possible on the PS3. Something we would be aiming for".
Both parties seemed determined not to admit fault (or start a lawsuit), leading to 2007 when a now in-game version of Killzone 2 looked... completely different.
Perhaps it's testament to how much social media just wasn't a thing back then, that they managed to get away with such a ridiculous stunt.
11. The Division
Sometimes you just want to champion that sense of ambition that comes with "first looks" and debuts, but then looking back it's clear that what The Division was shown off as and turned into, were two completely different beasts.
For a start, it wasn't a loot-shooter. I'd hazard a guess those elements were added once Ubi got wind of just how successful microtransactions were becoming, alongside Destiny's model of "Just let people re-run the same areas over and over, they'll love it!"
Graphics too, received a considerable downgrade from that initial footage, and the ability for multiple players to join in regardless of whether they were on consoles, phones or tablets was ditched entirely.
As a result, hype netted Ubisoft some insanely strong day-one sales... only for the player base to drop off 93% in the following two months.
Ouch.
10. Aliens: Colonial Marines
Imagine working on a game: You're hard at work pulling morning-to-night shifts, occasionally sleeping over at the office just to ensure certain deadlines are met. You're being pestered by marketing teams and it feels like the goalposts are shifting on a day-to-day basis.
At some point - and we're only human - there's a chance said game will release with less than the right amount of polish.
Like thinking "Ah f**k it, it'll do" when handing in a work assignment, Aliens: Colonial Marines was a shell of its proposed self. However, such a drastic change in what the game was advertised as versus its release state, led to lawsuit being filed against the company that cited false advertising.
Once the dust had cleared, the case was eventually thrown out as Gearbox CEO Randy Pitchfork described it as a "huge waste of time". Still... it all could have been avoided if the game we received bore any resemblance to what was first advertised and demoed.
9. Halo 5: Guardians
Graphical downgrades are one thing, but advertising your game so strongly in a particular direction, only for final version to be nothing of the sort? That's a rather big problem.
Halo 5 sat alongside Metal Gear Solid V and Batman: Arkham Knight as a trilogy of titles that all purported to be about a specific plot point - only to drop the ball entirely. Guardians felt particularly egregious though, as an entire viral marketing campaign was set up around the supposed idea that the Master Chief was on the run, with two contrasting adverts showing both the Chief and relative newcomer, Spartan Locke, attempting to take each other out.
What was at the heart of their conflict? Why was Locke convinced the Chief had done something truly awful? How could that make him want to kill the guy?
Well, erm, it didn't matter, because the 'conflict' was MC nonchalantly disobeying an order, being asked to come in, and reconciling with Locke immediately after.
If you were promised a turbine and delivered a mouse fart, that was Halo 5.
8. Bioshock: Infinite
Bioshock Infinite's development was one fraught with problems and artistic redirects. As a result, the version of the game first shown back in 2010 was a far cry from what players received in 2013.
You can read the full breakdown of what was removed from the game as developers Irrational Games were slowly closing over here, but mainly, gone were Elizabeth's more visually stunning abilities that would bend dimensions at will, gone were tears in the fabric of time that would let you manipulate levels more freely, and gone were a ton of levels, enemy designs and the general integration of the Sky-Lines.
2013's edition retained some of these features, but at their most watered-down state. Bioshock Infinite was still a solid game, but scratch just a little at the surface, and something completely different was beneath.
7. Destiny
The most expensive video game ever made at a whopping $500,000, Destiny's original vision was hacked and butchered by Bungie's higher-ups only one year before release, forcing the remaining team members to stitch something together for an impending launch.
You can read the full breakdown of just how absolutely broken the whole procedure became on Kotaku, but sufficed to say, the reason that Destiny felt so threadbare at launch and had to have content resigned to DLC, was because the devs were cramming a multi-year long dev cycle into just one, before attempting to patch over any cracks once the train was out the station.
As a result, the game engine was exquisite (as it's often one of the first things to get nailed down) but content-wise... that was another story.
Rumours are that there's still a ton of content left on the cutting room floor, and although Rise of Iron is coming later in 2016, you can expect Bungie to hit the reset button and try again with 'Destiny 2' instead.
6. Splinter Cell: Conviction
How about something that changed for the better, for a change?
When Splinter Cell was first revealed in 2007 it was met with unanimous disapproval. The sight of Fisher no longer being a leather-clad, knife-wielding badass and more... angry homeless man? left fans reeling as to the direction of the franchise.
Melee attacks appeared to form the majority of gameplay as enemies were sent pinwheeling across rooms and tables were flipped in an attempt to (assumedly) rein in a wider audience. Naturally, this couldn't have been farther away from where the majestic Chaos Theory and mediocre Double Agent left off, and by the time Sam's latest did show up, these 'action segments' were completely removed in favour of a more stripped down, story-heavy affair.
5. No Man's Sky
You almost feel like you have to apologise to No Man's Sky developers, Hello Games, because 13 people crafting a galaxy from the ground up is genuinely remarkablein every respect.
But that said... there are a number of key features that were shown since 2013 (in particular how the game appeared on Colbert, seen above) that either aren't in the game whatsoever, or are buried to an extraordinary degree.
Reddit has an ongoing list cataloguing such features, but some rather large omissions include fleet-on-fleet factional warfare, crashed freighters, density of flora and fauna combined (as shown above) and most damningly, some sort of 'multiplayer' that should at least boil down to being able to meet up with other players.
Since then we've had many players realise that, 1. The game doesn't actually seem to have a file for a usable character model, and 2. There's actually no netcode present that could put two players in the exact same spot on the exact same planet.
No Man's Sky has only been out for just over a week and there's every possibility Hello Games were going to patch more content in, but for now... there are a number of things in the buildup to launch that just aren't present.
4. Watch Dogs
Next to Aliens: Colonial Marines, Watch Dogs is the epitome of a game riling up the entire populace after years of misleading marketing materials.
Case in point: The graphics. Whilst gameplay mostly had delusions of grandeur when it came to a version of Chicago you could hack in multiple ways (or so we thought), graphics were shown off as having dynamic lighting and far better texture work, with what looked to be playable set-piece moments happening dynamically.
Come launch and it was what's become the 'same old story'. Ubisoft stated they hadn't downgraded the game - only for PC owners to mine the disc and find a way to restore how it looked from the previous years - and as for those set-pieces you wanted to do? They amounted to holding a button every half hour or so and maybe triggering something memorable.
The next generation had truly started...
3. The Xbox Kinect (Both Versions)
No, it's not a game, but in terms of misdirection and outright lying to a general populace during a press event, Microsoft's Xbox One reveal was one of the most egregious.
Remember the terribly cringeworthy footage where Xbox man Yusuf Mehdi was shown moving his hands and getting the console to respond exactly? Yeah, it was fake - another product of the "Well, we wanted to show off what it COULD do" train of thought.
In reality, both the original Kinect and revamped Xbox One release didn't work, like, whatsoever. Microsoft eventually realised they couldn't ice-skate uphill and ditched the Kinect for all subsequent revisions of the Xbox One.
And it was never spoken of again.
2. Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons Of Liberty
It's a testament to how much the proliferation of social media breeds contempt and easy access to uproar, that when MGS 2 released as one massive troll on the gaming populace, people heralded creator Hideo Kojima as more a genius than an outright liar.
So it went, that as MGS 2's story was about the want to embody something greater than ourselves (in this case, main-man Solid Snake), that Kojima slipped the rug out from under us, supplanted Raiden in his place, and then spent a good 45 minutes philosophising about why it was the best thing ever.
Needless to say, the fact that one of the most hyped games of all time was a bait n' switch didn't go down too well, and it's a testament to just how impeccably well MGS 2 played, that nothing more came of it.
1. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
Woah there, I love The Witcher 3 - but the graphical clout it showed off in 2013 was nowhere near representative of the final product.
Instead, although what CD Projekt RED released was still an outstanding achievement in every respect, they still caught hell for the difference between the two. However, CO Marcin Iwinski's comments on the matter were very important, as he very frankly outlined precisely what happens between trade show and release:
"We do a certain build for a tradeshow and you pack it, it works, it looks amazing. And you are extremely far away from completing the game. Then you put it in the open-world, regardless of the platform, and it's like 'oh poop, it doesn't really work'. We've already showed it, now we have to make it work. And then we try to make it work on a huge scale. This is the nature of games development."
"Maybe we shouldn't have shown that [trailer], I don't know, but we didn't know that it wasn't going to work, so it's not a lie or a bad will - that's why we didn't comment actively. We don't agree there is a downgrade but it's our opinion, and gamers' feeling can be different.
You can't get more honest than that: The 'nature' of video game development is to unrealistically wow you up front, with the team then doing their damnedest to hit goals and benchmarks that were born from the state of a game in a completely different context.
Iwinski has a point, in that when a game is optimised for performance, is it still a 'downgrade' overall?
--
Such things continue to be huge talking points amongst gamers and marketers I'm sure, so let me know your thoughts on how the industry as evolved over the years, in the comments below!