14 Most BROKEN Video Games Of The Decade

There are plenty to choose from.

By Scott Tailford /

Ubisoft

As the decade winds to a close with one year of the generation left, it's fair game to start commenting on how this console cycle has gone overall.

Advertisement

Because whilst gaming has exploded to lucrative highs that outmatch even Hollywood in pound-for-pound revenue, chances are you've got a handful of personal stories surrounding high-profile disappointments, titles that felt unfinished, missed opportunities or even outright cancellations.

Yes, the gaming industry is bigger than ever; yes the likes of the Game Awards are being seen by more people around the world, but this increased breakneck pace has resulted in many major studios crunching project turnarounds to cash in as fast as possible.

Advertisement

That means more genuinely broken games put out for full price than ever before - a situation that mimics the industry crash of 1983, where afterwards, public perception of gaming was thought of as a waste of time.

After all, if all you're getting for your money is disappointment and half-baked time wasters, why bother?

Advertisement

Going forward it's clear that attitudes need to change in regards to turnaround, hype cycles, when games are first shown to the public and how much studios fall back on post-launch patches.

Right now though, we have a decade filled with games that did a harsh disservice to their most creative staff, and those that lay down the cash to play on day one.

Advertisement

14. Assassin's Creed: Unity

Ubisoft

The face seen around the world.

Advertisement

All it took to tank an already fairly un-hyped Assassin's Creed was this abomination of a face glitch, but sadly, the torment for Ubisoft and its fans didn't stop there.

No, clearly AC Unity was rushed to market to meet a late 2014 release window, as Ubi - touting a new slogan of "The next generation starts here" - wanted to unveil what the "next cycle" of Assassin's Creed would look like.

Advertisement

While environments remain some of the franchise's finest and the chemistry of romantic leads Arno and Elise is exemplary, actually playing this sequel was expectedly horrific.

If Arno wasn't getting snagged on outcrops of buildings he was falling right through them, and that's before the state of the game on Xbox One was so bad, it required a full replacement of the game file through a gargantuan patch.

Advertisement

13. Fallout: New Vegas

Obsidian

It comes to something when a game is staring you in the face with its glitches and lack of polish, even in the opening scenes.

Advertisement

And yet, after being unceremoniously executed by Matthew Perry's Benny, thousands of players awoke to find Doc Mitchell's head swivelling on the spot.

Naturally this only went on to show that otherwise legendary developers Obsidian had struggled considerably with Bethesda's godawful Gamebryo engine, and New Vegas barely held itself together from then on in.

Advertisement

It would later come out that Bethesda were extremely unhelpful across development, and only gave the studio 18 months to turn around this spin-off from Fallout 3 - both things that contributed to a stilted title whose positives struggled to shine through.

Thankfully, New Vegas was eventually patched and reworked enough to remain one of the best Fallouts of them all, but that opening period? Oof.

Advertisement

12. Star Wars Battlefront 2

EA

A game not broken through lack of polish, but a disastrous business mandate crowbarred into development, that was then ripped out on day of launch.

Advertisement

This of course refers to the state of microtransactions in Battlefront 2, which before release were barely talked about, yet still referred to a card system of power-ups, damage modifiers and stat boosts.

Want to buff your character? Pay some money and unlock more cards, or grind for a good 40+ hours to get enough credits for one skin at a time. It was that "simple".

Advertisement

All this came after years of people putting up with MTX systems became the most hated thing in the modern industry, EA "being EA" and applying the worst practices to Star Wars was just too much.

The backlash was overwhelmingly strong, leading to the storefront being gutted from the game... which in turn meant your ONLY recourse was grinding.

Advertisement

DICE and EA would put out numerous responses to this tire fire of a problem, eventually overhauling progression and unlockables to make BF2 an incredibly fun Star Wars product.

The fact it took such a mounted offensive to get them to do right by the fans though, remains a notable example of EA being the dog worst this generation.

Advertisement

11. SimCity (2013)

EA

No, it wasn't microtransactions this time, but EA had the bright idea of tying SimCity's core gameplay to an always-online connection. Why? Because according to the game's creative director, Ocean Quigley, EA wanted a "platform for content" they could plug DLC and additional purchases into.

Advertisement

Infuriatingly, this even applied when you were offline, and as the game's servers couldn't handle the load of incoming players, it resulted in a literal countdown clock on-screen, denoting when you could access the game you just bought.

Wait times were upwards for 20 minutes on a good day, and even when you got into the game, SimCity's A.I. was a shell of it advertised self, and scores of signature features had been streamlined for the worst, or removed altogether.

Advertisement

EA's response? To sell "hot air balloon DLC", with Quigley comparing the project to a "sinking ship", and saying the game's "back-end [was] collapsing in flaming server rooms".

Ouch.

Advertisement

10. No Man's Sky

Hello Games/GamesBeat

Straight up, No Man's Sky is a heartily recommendable sci-fi gaming gem, but man did it start out as the total opposite.

Advertisement

The product of a tiny 13 person team being given the platform of a lifetime i.e. the E3 spotlight and various placements amongst PS4 highlight reels, coupled with creative lead Sean Murray lying his ass off when it came to potential features, the result was nothing of the sort.

Yes, NMS was a walking sim-meets-intergalactic survival title, but its creature designs clearly needed a lot of work. Space dogfights had you being blasted from off-screen, and planet generation fell back on the same structures over and over.

Advertisement

No Man's Sky was definitely a product of hype and exaggeration gone wrong, but it had many coding issues that were only rectified and overhauled going forward.

9. Aliens: Colonial Marines

Gearbox

The game that felt as though it had killed the Alien IP in gaming forever (until Alien Isolation miraculously resurrected it a year later), Colonial Marines was a straight-up laughing stock at launch.

Advertisement

Not only were launch day graphics completely different to what was advertised and even demoed at trade shows beforehand, and not only was actor Michael Biehn phoning it in when reprising his role as Hicks, but glitches and animation bugs were everywhere.

The reason?

Advertisement

Well, as it turned out in July 2018, the coders had overlooked literally one digit in the game's files, that caused the Xenomorph A.I. to freak out.

PC modders tweaked this and had a substantially better time, but Colonial Marines remains a crunching disappointment, a sign of things to come when it came to Gearbox's performance across the last 10 years, and a franchise black mark we're better off moving on from.

Advertisement

8. Diablo III

Blizzard

If there was one thing that got in the way of so many titles from moment one, it's server overload.

Advertisement

I'm not even done covering the amount of games that crumbled under their own weight, but it never helps when the title in question is a sequel, or something the developers and publishers should KNOW will be a big deal.

Enter Diablo 3, sequel to a RPG gaming royalty, and something people had been looking forward to with wide-eyed glee since it was first announced.

Advertisement

Like every other example of overload at launch though, Diablo 3 could only throw up an error message, as players couldn't get past the title screen.

Thankfully Diablo 3 turned it around in a major way through sheer hard work and management of ongoing traffic, but the meme-isation of "Error 37" makes this stumble legendary for all the wrong reasons.

Advertisement

7. Sonic Boom: Rise Of Lyric

Sega

I pity anyone still looking forward to a Sonic game in the new age (at least, unless it's not developed by Sega and is called Sonic Mania anyway).

Advertisement

To that end, Sonic Boom was godawful from the second we lay eyes on it.

Redesigning Sonic to be an olympian-adjacent athlete and making Knuckles a bumbling fool did nothing to endear this "soft reboot" to fans, but then we played the game.

Advertisement

Product of Sonic Boom going through hell across development, with many ideas being conceptualised and then thrown out at various stages of completion, the final product barely held together.

Sonic's signature speed was nowhere to be found, the environment lacked detail, and best/worst of all a glitch let you repeatedly jump out of the world altogether - all the way to the final boss.

Advertisement

Sonic Boom was so bad, Sega actively apologised... then gave us Sonic Forces.

6. Battlefield 4

EA

You can't go too long without EA popping back up again, as whilst Ubisoft learned from their mistakes and started to turn the second half of the generation around, EA were more like Emperor Palpatine - revelling in being as mad cackling'ly even as possible.

Advertisement

With Battlefield 4, it was yet another product of EA rushing as many things to market as possible, with the otherwise brilliant DICE simply not having enough time to iron out the kinks.

Eventually... it was abandoned, as the fiscal turnaround meant upcoming titles needed to be worked on instead. That initial period was filled with elongated character models, crashes when parts of multiplayer maps attempted synchronised destruction, and more matchmaking issues that you can shake a microtransaction at.

Advertisement

Like Sega with Sonic Boom, EA issued an apology for the state of Battlefield, but that did very little to quell the rage of those who dropped 60 notes on what was supposed to be a premium product.

5. Halo: Master Chief Collection

Microsoft

The last of the server-based issues, but holy cow was 2014 a mess of generation-defining issues.

Advertisement

It got so bad that even the mighty Halo - a flagship for an entire console and gaming identity for Microsoft - was mishandled, to the point where its iconic multiplayer was impossible to play.

Dogged by failed connections and matchmaking queues that could descend into more than 10 minutes per match, the Master Chief Collection would also be abandoned, as 343 Industries had to shift gears onto Halo 5 instead.

Advertisement

They've since gone back, added Halo: ODST and Halo: Reach as peace offerings to fans - alongside fixing matchmaking and stability across the board - but the Master Chief Collection was an insulting release that needed literal years of additional work.

4. Fallout 76

Bethesda

One of many formerly beloved developers whose reputations died this generation, Bethesda turned in the immaculate Skyrim (which itself, was still notably glitchy), only to get worse and worse.

Advertisement

This culminated with the horrific Fallout 76, an attempt to take the already-unreliable Creation Engine, and apply it to an online MMO.

Obviously the results were terrible. Bethesda can barely get their offline titles to work without a hitch, never mind juggling 30 different players and their respective world events at the same time.

Advertisement

76 immediately fell apart, its character models T-posing, its world barely loading in. There was even a bug where if you stared directly at the ground - minimising the amount of things the game had to load for you to see - everything would run faster, letting you speed-walk from A to B.

Somewhere along the way, Bethesda went from an ambitious studio we championed despite their mistakes, to company far out of their depth, abusing past fan devotion to rake in more cash.

Advertisement

3. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5

Advertisement

A game pumped out to - you guessed it - squeeze some more money out of an existing fandom, THPS5 was finally the next numbered instalment in the Pro Skater franchise since 2002, but it also only existed because Activision were about to lose the Tony Hawk's license.

Set to expire in 2015, that meant developers Robomodo had to throw extra coal on the fires and forge a game from next to nothing, ultimately reusing a ton of assets and the game engine from Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD, which itself was gut-punchingly disappointing.

Advertisement

THPS 5 was a wreck. Characters would fall through the floor, tricks wouldn't trigger, grinds could bounce off walls, but most hilariously, often your skater would just launch right off the ground, a good few feet into the sky... for no reason.

Indicative of just how many IPs and fandoms were abused in the name of profit these past 10 years, THPS left gaming as a joke.

Advertisement

2. Mass Effect Andromeda

Bioware

A rare case of a broken EA published game not entirely being their fault, as it turned out after a revealing Kotaku exposé, that Andromeda's issues came almost entirely from a lack of planning, and warring internal studios at Bioware.

Advertisement

Still, we're talking about the version of the game you got to play, and Mass Effect's grand return - after the already despised Mass Effect 3 - ended up burying the IP for good.

Seriously, EA declared the franchise "on ice" after ME:A's terrible reception, and it was for good reason.

Advertisement

Besides some fairly enjoyable combat, not a single necessary part of the Mass Effect formula held together. Facial animations were laughably unfinished, animation in general was robotic and distracting, and every emotional or story-based cutscene fell flat on its face into the uncanny valley.

Bioware would continue to patch Andromeda across its following launch months, but the end result was cancelling the game's season pass content and abandoning everything for... well, Anthem.

Advertisement

Good going, guys.

1. WWE 2K20

2K Sports

Oh god, top tier publishers, just give developers more time.

Advertisement

Clearly, as you'll see from literally any screenshot or piece of footage taken from WWE 2K20, the game was not ready for public eyes.

In beta at best, 2K19 saw longtime developers Yukes booted off the project, and NBA 2K20 devs Visual Concepts brought in to pick up the pieces. They were then asked to assemble said pieces into WWE 2K20, but the results were genuinely horrifying.

Advertisement

If character models' faces weren't disappearing, the game camera was actively leaving the arena. If the referee wasn't melding with a wrestler's leg, the ropes were glitching out and vibrating the entire ring.

It might have made for a funny montage video, but when this is the one official WWE game - and there are millions of fans awaiting the next instalment - still pushing this out the door was shameful.

Advertisement