15 Batman Arkham Series Elements That Would Make Future Films Great
Should future films take inspiration from one of the greatest game series of the modern era?
Before 2009, it could be argued that Batman, or any other comic character for that matter, had never seen justice done by a game adaptation. That all changed with the release of Arkham Asylum, which captivated with its gripping narrative and innovative free-flow combat system - since widely imitated. Despite little experience, developers Rocksteady truly allowed players to 'be' Batman, hunting down foes within the claustrophobic confines of Arkham Asylum.
Since then, the series has gone from strength to strength (an ill-advised prequel notwithstanding) and though the ending of Arkham Knight brought an apparent conclusion, it's hard to imagine that more titles won't follow, especially given that the likes of the Suicide Squad and the Justice League have featured or been hinted at throughout the series.
The success of the Arkham series is something that Warner Bros will be keen to replicate in the upcoming screen outings they have planned for Ben Affleck's new take on Batman over the new few years, particularly given the air of cynicism that has resulted from their decision to reboot the series just four years after the conclusion of Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy.
To attempt this, they could do much worse than by using Rocksteady's work as an inspiration, given the myriad of compelling storylines and concepts, either original or adapted from comics, that they have brought to life. There is a very distinct map of success from the games, which, replicated on screen, could resonate with film audiences as much as they have with gamers.
15. Blackgate Uprising
Blackgate Prison is as notorious as Arkham Asylum in the Batman mythos for how frequently it plays hosts to riots and escapes. Indeed, Arkham Origins begins with a jailbreak led by Black Mask, while the Joker's plot in Arkham Asylum is made possible by a fire at the facility that results in the temporary relocation of his thugs.
The prison made for an interesting setting in Arkham Origins: Blackgate, a 3DS/Vita spin-off game that sees the Joker, the Penguin and Black Mask each carve territories for themselves within its walls following an explosion. Batman naturally has to subdue all three to rescue supposed hostages, as Catwoman infiltrates the facility in an attempt to break out Bane. Though the Dark Knight thwarts her plot, more interesting is the revelation of the identity of her employer - Amanda Waller, who previously appeared in Origins' post-credits scene attempting to recruit Deathstroke to the Suicide Squad.
Waller and the Suicide Squad also appear in Batman: Assault On Arkham, an animated film within the Arkham continuity where the team break into Arkham Asylum to retrieve a thumbdrive from the Riddler, though they fail through a combination of infighting, multiple deaths, Batman's infiltration of their ranks and the Joker's entry into proceedings.
An uprising within the narrow walls of Blackgate would suit a film well, whilst the involvement of Amanda Waller behind the scenes could be the catalyst to interlink Batman and the Suicide Squad, who will begin life in the DC Cinematic Universe as the subjects of different films, together further.
14. A Focus On Barbara Gordon
In the world of comics, Barbara Gordon, the daughter of Batman's long-time ally Commissioner Jim Gordon, has been kicking around since the 1960s, when she was introduced as Batgirl on both the page and the infamously camp Batman television adaptation at the same time. In 1988's The Killing Joke, one of the most widely renowned and sought after graphic novels of all time, she was paralysed by The Joker in an attempt to morally compromise her father.
Subsequently adopting the persona of Oracle, she refused to let disability get in the way of her crime-fighting ways, using her computer expertise to become an information broker in Batman's ongoing crusade for justice.
The Arkham series opened with Barbara as a paraplegic in the Oracle role, providing remote support to Batman throughout the events of both Arkham Asylum and Arkham City. She then appears in person in Arkham Knight, where her kidnap and apparent murder at the hands of Scarecrow is a heart-wrenching moment that drives the actions of both Batman and her father through to the game's conclusion.
Including Barbara and depicting her subsequent paralysis would be a powerful moment on film that would both erase painful memories of Alicia Silverstone's performance as her in the much-maligned Batman and Robin and extend her status as a powerful disabled and female role model to a wider audience. The latter would be particularly refreshing in a genre where women are all too frequently featured solely as 'damsels in distress' that serve no purpose other than needing to be saved by the hero.
13. The Penguin As A British Arms Dealer
There have been two notable depictions of Oswald Cobblepot, otherwise known as The Penguin, on screen. The first was Burgess Meredith's light-hearted portrayal in the 1960s television series, whilst the second was Danny DeVito's grotesque version of the character in 1992's Batman Returns, which shedded his image from the comics as a 'gentleman of crime' by making him deformed with actual Penguin-like characteristics. Since then, the character has been regularly depicted in both this guise and his traditional persona as an upper class member of society with extensive underworld connections.
Though he didn't feature in Arkham Asylum (as a perfectly sane individual he is typically sent to an ordinary prison upon capture instead), Penguin appears as one of the primary antagonists of Arkham City, where the titular prison development absorbs his Iceberg Lounge nightclub. Reimagined as a ruthless gang leader, this iteration of Cobblepot has a smashed beer bottle for an eye instead of a monocle and a Cockney accent that makes him sound much more menacing than he would with a more refined twang.
Arkham Knight sees him return as a weapons dealer that supplies the criminals that remain in the evacuated Gotham with black market arms, though Batman and Nightwing soon put a stop to this in a series of cooperative missions.
Utilising the Penguin as a weapons dealer on film would allow him to be featured in a supporting (and possibly recurring) capacity, adding depth and functioning as a shout-out to fans without having to dedicate an entire story to him as a primary or secondary antagonist. He could eventually, however, become such if audiences were receptive to the interpretation, which could certainly be given gravitas by somebody of the Ray Winstone mould.
12. Batman vs. Assassins
Arkham Origins is undoubtedly the weakest entry in the Arkham series. Though still a highly enjoyable game, the prequel doesn't hold a candle to those that preceded or followed it and is often ignored (and the series referred to as a trilogy) as a result.
At its heart, however, was a highly interesting premise, as a relatively rookie Batman finds that the tables have turned on him when crime lord Roman Sionis (otherwise known as Black Mask, who is a highly underrated villain) puts out a bounty on his head. This results in eight assassins pursuing the Caped Crusader in search of the reward money, along with corrupt members of the Gotham City Police Department.
Though some of the 'assassins' are not traditionally known as such (Bane, Killer Croc and Firefly in particular) and others were c-list fodder at best (The Electrocutioner and Copperhead), others would be an intriguing addition in a film that sees the hunter become the hunted.
Deadshot is particularly prevalent at present, given that Will Smith will be stepping into his shoes for the Suicide Squad adaption, and he could easily become an opponent of the Dark Knight if his cold-hearted tendencies are not downplayed to turn him into the film's hero. Lady Shiva, though not hugely well-known, could stand out given her status as a female villain, something that Batman's rogues gallery is lacking somewhat when you take Poison Ivy and Harley Quinn out of the equation.
Of course, one assassin does stand out above the rest...
11. Batman vs. Deathstroke
Deathstroke makes a surprise return to the Arkham series towards the end of Arkham Knight, where he assumes control of the Knight's militia following his disappearance. His time on screen is short-lived and sadly, in contrast to the excellent fight sequence that he and Batman share in Origins, his downfall is something of an anticlimax.
Regardless of this, his interactions with his adversary are excellent, particularly his revelation that he took the job as Scarecrow's backup should the Knight fail upon hearing that Batman considered him one of the toughest adversaries he has ever faced.
Deathstroke has been seen on screen recently as an adversary to Oliver Queen on the television series Arrow, but first appeared in comics as an opponent for the Teen Titans as Deathstroke the Terminator, before the latter part of his name was dropped (blame James Cameron) and he gradually became renowned as one of the DC universe's deadliest mercenaries.
Otherwise known as Slade Wilson (not to be confused with Marvel's Wade Wilson, otherwise known as Deadpool, who was seen as suspiciously similar to his DC counterpart before being re-imagined as the smart-talking fourth wall breaking antihero that we now know), Deathstroke is truly a fascinating character.
As a result, it's surprising that he has never been considered for inclusion in a film before now. The dynamic between him and the Dark Knight, which sees them mutually respect each other's abilities but nevertheless strive to take the other down, would come out well on camera, particularly if Deathstroke's campaign becomes more and more personal despite his proclamations that he is only a professional that doesn't care who Batman is under the mask.
10. Minor Villain One-Shot Sequences
One of the advantages of featuring Batman in a game as opposed to a film is the opportunity to feature an extensive number of members of his rogues gallery in supporting roles. A film is constrained by a two hour run time and can only feature a maximum of two adversaries if it wants to allow for any form of character development. As a result of this, the Dark Knight has faced only a handful of adversaries on film, some on multiple occasions.
The James Bond series of films has always featured a pre-credits sequence between five and twenty minutes long that re-introduces the character in spectacular fashion, either setting up the plot to follow or simply demonstrating his abilities through a captivating action sequence. A Batman film could take inspiration from this formula by dedicating the first ten minutes of film to witnessing the Caped Crusader square off against some of his secondary adversaries in action sequences akin to some of the ones seen in the Arkham trilogy.
Such sequences could pit Batman against Firefly on the scene of a deadly arson or Deacon Blackfire against the backdrop of a cult sacrifice. They could also feature the likes of Hush, the surgeon who transforms his own face into a replica of Bruce Wayne's to pursue revenge against his childhood friend, or Calendar Man, the holiday-obsessed killer who has been portrayed as a deranged psychopath in the Arkham series, in contrast to his usual semi-joke character status.
9. Anarky In Gotham
Each of the Batman: Arkham games, with the exception of the original Asylum, has featured a host of 'Most Wanted' side missions, which task the Dark Knight with tracking down and neutralising the threat of various adversaries. Some of the villains featured in these have appeared in multiple games, such as the Mad Hatter or Bane, whilst others have appeared in just one instance, such as Professor Pyg, a surprising inclusion in Arkham Knight.
Origins and Origins alone played host to Anarky, also known as Lonnie Machin, a radicalised teenager that plants bombs across Gotham in his pursuit of his anti-authoritarian philosophy, which calls for social equality and a reduction in government and military control.
In the world that we currently live in, complete with faceless organisations like Anonymous, a general reduction in privacy as a result of technology and social media and a number of high profile large scale uprisings and protests, Anarky's persona is more relevant than ever.
A film could capitalise on this, expanding upon his bomb-focused side mission by depicting him as the leader of an Anonymous-esque organisation hell-bent on taking down 'the system', which corrupt or not, Batman must preserve to prevent Gotham from descending into full-blown chaos.
8. Media Personalities
If Batman was a real entity in our celebrity-obsessed world, he would inevitably be the subject of innumerable YouTube videos, as well as television panels and internet commentaries by the likes of Perez Hilton that speculate on his motives and identity.
In minor capacities, the Arkham series has brought to two Batman media personalities to life. The first, Jack Ryder, has been depicted as the sort of integrity-less journalist willing to twist truths in order to garner ratings and readership, making himself the hero of his rescue from Deadshot at Batman's hands in Arkham City. Though in the comics, he leads a double life as the garishly-coloured Creeper, this was left out of the game series, lest it veer too much into ridiculousness (which is saying something given the inclusion of characters such as Killer Croc and Man-Bat).
The second is Vicki Vale, known predominantly as one of the primary love interests of Batman's civilian identity Bruce Wayne and portrayed as such in Tim Burton's 1989 Batman film, where she was played by Kim Basinger.
Television series The Wire built upon its original premise by extending its focus on law enforcement and criminals to encompass politics, the education system and journalism, becoming much deeper and multi-faceted in the process. Future Batman film writers could follow this formula to greatly enhance the substance of their creations.
7. The Arkham Knight
When Rocksteady announced that one of the principal characters in Arkham Knight was to be a new character of the same name, there was much speculation as to his identity, as it was widely presumed that it would be an existing character under the helmet rather than a wholly original creation.
Ultimately, the grand reveal was a little disappointing to anybody with the faintest knowledge of comic lore. It became painfully obvious when the hallucinatory Joker made several references to Jason's predicament when he hadn't been featured in the series before, though the presence of Tim Drake as Robin indicated that he must've existed at some point.
However, Todd's 'personal revenge against Batman' scheme, born out of the hatred instilled in him by a year of torture, was an interesting one, even if it did require several billion dollars worth of militia personnel and equipment to concoct. A film adaptation of this would have to have a slow build-up, as Todd would have to exist as Robin for some time for his capture, torture and presumed murder to have any effect, but the pay off would be excellent in showcasing how devastating Batman's actions can affect those close to him.
Interestingly, the Suicide Squad film trailer seems to hint at a Robin already being dead at the start of proceedings. If Dick Grayson isn't featured in this new continuity and the supposedly dead Robin is Todd, then his future inclusion either as the Knight or the Red Hood could already be planned.
6. Batmobile Tank Battles
Much of the marketing material for Arkham Knight focused on the titular character of the same name and the identity of the individual behind the mask, but considerable emphasis was also placed on Batman's vehicle, the Batmobile, which players would be able to control for the first time after spending the entirety of the previous three games on foot.
Reactions were mixed. Though it was undeniably delectable to cruise the empty streets of Gotham, far too much focus was placed on a) forcing players to use the machine to solve puzzles and progress with the story, b) pitting it against waves and waves of drone tanks in a seemingly never-ending sequence of battles (how did the Knight afford these things!?).
Regardless of repetitive it eventually became, tank combat was enjoyable enough at first. Firing a machine gun, cannon and missiles against enemies seems like a gross violation of Batman's no killing policy, even if all of the vehicles he goes up against are conveniently unmanned (as the Knight knows Batman would never kill anybody, why didn't he opt for vehicles with drivers?).
A vehicle-on-vehicle battle would make for a terrific action sequence in a film. Though the Batmobile has previously been featured quite extensively, it has been primarily in chase scenes - seeing it square off against and conquer a tank would be an awe-inspiring moment.
5. Riddler's Revenge
Batman's villains each bring something unique to the table and require different tactics to conquer. The likes of Bane and Killer Croc can more than match him in the physical stakes, the likes of the Scarecrow and the Mad Hatter attempt to use fear against him and the Joker operates on pure chaos. The Riddler, meanwhile, prides himself on being Batman's intellectual equal, forcing him to undertake mind-boggling endeavours in order to bring him to justice.
In each of the Arkham games, the Riddler has been used as an excuse to put collectibles in the game. Many curse the 'Riddler trophies', mostly because of the sheer number of them that have to be collected (thankfully scaled down somewhat in Arkham Knight after 440 were featured in Arkham City), but many are a considerable challenge to figure out for those who don't instantly resort to the Internet the moment they become stuck.
Catching Riddler actually feels like an accomplishment when each has been collected, as his quest truly tests players and isn't over in five minutes and a few button mashes like so many others.
They could easily serve as the inspiration to a film plot, as Riddler could challenge Batman to an increasingly complex series of tasks in a manner not too dissimilar to Jeremy Irons in Die Hard With A Vengeance, where Bruce Willis and Samuel L. Jackson had to work together to piece together clues and solve riddles to prevent tragedy.
4. The Arkham City Concept
Batman: Arkham City has two primary storylines that can be seen as independent to one another despite the fact that they intertwine on a number of occasions. One of these revolves around the overall concept of the Arkham City facility, a walled-off open air prison on the streets of Gotham City where criminals, minor and major, are confined following the events of Arkham Asylum by Mayor Quincy Sharp, the asylum's former warden.
Sharp is revealed to be a puppet of Hugo Strange, who oversees the prison facility. Strange is one of Batman's oldest villains, yet has never appeared in a film. His controlled demeanour and exercise of control that results from his deduced knowledge of the Dark Knight's secret identity would be interesting to explore on film, as would his relationship with Ra's al Ghul, who is eventually revealed as the brainchild of the prison's ultimate goal - the systematic extermination of Gotham's criminal element.
Ra's relationship with Batman, who he sees as a worthy successor to his mission to violently rid the world of injustice, has been featured before in Batman Begins, but in Arkham City he was arguably at his finest, particularly given that the romantic feelings mutually shared by his daughter Talia and Bruce Wayne (touched upon somewhat haphazardly in The Dark Knight Rises) were brought into the mix and made much more emotional by her murder.
Transferred to the screen, the Arkham City narrative could translate well to a film of the hardboiled variety, where Batman has to function primarily as a detective against a desolate backdrop, identifying and attempting to eliminate conspiracy. The story has more than enough moments capable of shocking and awing audiences, chiefly Strange and Talia's deaths.
Though the latter would have to be changed to avoid bloating surroundings given that it came at the hands of the Joker, the fact that it made Batman pursue personal vengeance over saving people from Ra's murderous programme would allow a film to demonstrate his flawed (but human) side.
3. Scarecrow As The Primary Villain
Ask somebody what the greatest moments in Arkham Asylum are and you'll inevitably hear the 'Scarecrow sequences' in response. Through the use of his fear toxin, the villain formerly known as Jonathan Crane is able induce hallucinations that Batman must endure, forcing him to live his nightmares in a series of trippy and often terrifying sequences.
Scarecrow has always been an impactful villain for his use of fear of a weapon. He mirrors Batman in this regard, though their ultimate objectives differ.
Crane has been seen on screen in all three of Nolan's Batman films, though his appearances in the latter two were cameos and he played second fiddle to Ra's al Ghul in Batman Begins. Though he succeeds on unleashing his fear toxin upon areas of Gotham in this appearance, his actions in Arkham Knight, where he functions as the main villain, are much more horrifying. Deformed by an encounter with Killer Croc in Arkham Asylum, he seeks to both coat the entire city in his fear toxin and break Batman, first by appearing to murder Barbara Gordon and later by forcing the Dark Knight to reveal his identity to the world.
He is successful at accomplishing both objectives to an extent, though Batman is able to team with Poison Ivy to neutralise the toxin threat (albeit at the cost of Ivy's life) and subdue Crane after his identity as Bruce Wayne has been revealed. Nevertheless, Scarecrow's achievements could be used on screen to great effect, particularly his forcible unmasking of his opponent, which could subsequently lead to an adaptation of the 'battle for the cowl' comic storyline that sees numerous individuals attempt to assume the Batman identity.
2. Joker Takes Over The Asylum
Arkham Asylum succeeded because of a wide variety of reasons - its free-flow combat system was innovative and slick, its stealth options were tense and strategic, whilst its story was nothing short of sublime.
The key focus of said story was Batman's most iconic villain, the Joker, who allows himself to be captured and taken to Arkham Asylum only to spring a trap, taking over the facility. Trapped within its confines amongst a number of dangerous individuals that he helped to put there, the Dark Knight is first tasked with ensuring both his own safety and the safety of surviving staff from the likes of deranged serial killer Victor Zsasz, before investigating the Joker's motives and trying to put a stop to them.
These investigations lead to the discovery that the Joker is seeking a formula named Titan, pioneered by one of the asylum's medical staff and based on the Venom substance consumed by Bane, who is one of the many opponents that Batman must square off against before he can go one-on-one with Joker and put a stop to his scheme.
Batman and the Joker always play off against each other so well, regardless of the medium. The asylum is the perfect setting for a battle, both physical and psychological, between the pair, given how keen Joker is to stress that it is where both of them belong.
Quite a lot would have to be altered to keep a film adaptation realistic, but Arkham Asylum (in tandem with the A Serious House On Serious Earth comic that served as a inspiration) is one of the greatest Batman stories of the modern era and deserves to be showcased to an even wider audience at some point.
1. The Cure
Arkham Asylum's storyline was hard to top, but from an emotional standpoint, Arkham City succeeded with the second of its main narratives, as the Joker, locked up within the open air prison, is revealed to be dying of an illness as a result of his exposure to the Titan formula that he so desperately sought.
Early on in the game, Joker performs a blood transfusion on Batman, infecting him with the same condition and forcing him to seek out a cure for the pair of them. Mr. Freeze plays a sizable part in proceedings as the individual tasked with devising this. Though portrayed as a tragic figure rather than a true villain as a result of his backstory (which involved him attempting to find a remedy for his terminally ill wife Nora), he nevertheless squares off against Batman in a fight sequence that serves as one of the best boss battles in gaming history, as Freeze constantly alters his strategy and surroundings to ensure that he can't be bested by the same tactic more than once.
The eventual revelation that the dying Joker has been having the shapeshifter Clayface masquerade as a second, healthy version of him came as a true shock at first, whilst the doubly shocking final moments shared between Batman and his archenemy made for one of the most poignant game endings of all time, particularly the final interaction that revealed that despite all of the Joker's past actions, Batman still would've saved him had the cure not been destroyed by the villain's actions.
The possibilities for a film adaptation of this storyline are endless - the inclusion of Mr. Freeze's tragic origin story would make for a highly emotional moment that would shred the dreadful pun-based memories of Arnold Schwarzenegger in the role, though any fight against him wouldn't be as tense as the game equivalent. Whilst placing Batman in peril by infecting him with a deadly disease would keep audiences on edge and add an element of desperation to his actions as control slips away from him.
The almost-perfectly written death of the Joker, meanwhile, could be one of the most powerful scenes in movie history if replicated and done right, particularly the final moments that see Batman wordlessly carrying his body through a crowd of shocked onlookers.