With the release of Pokémon X and Y the ever-growing diversity of these unique and fantastical creatures climb to numbers we never thought possible over a decade and a half ago. Six generations in and we have 718 Pokémon to choose from. Back in the mid-to-late nineties when Generation I was at its peak popularity we thought surely the developers could not come up with any new ideas. At 151 perfect Pokémon, they must have already have exhausted all of their creative juices. That idea cannot be further from the truth. The franchise is still pushing strong and we still cannot turn away. However, that doesn't mean the designers behind Pikachu and more haven't had their momentary lapses in creativity. I am not claiming that Pokémon has ever lost its spark of imagination but with ice cream, key rings, and bodyparts as inspiration, from time-to-time fans can get nervous that the Pokémon crew are "running out of ideas". And with designs such as Luvdisc and Goomy paling in comparison to the likes of Milotic and Venosaur, it does seem that artists can get lazy from every so often. We all have our favorites but we all certainly have that list of Pokémon that force us to shake our head and think twice before wasting a precious Pokéball. And here is a rundown of 16 Pokémon that belong on that list. All generations are fair game. From Gen I to VI, each has had their fair share of Pokémon that had players wondering if it was a joke. I'll try to be as objective as possible. I won't look at a Pokémon's abilities and moves as a measure of quality but its overall conception and appearance instead. Whether opinions agree or not, the following Pokémon only support any cynic's claim that the franchise is bleeding dry of ideas. From the painfully simplistic to outrageously stupid, these Pokémon are proof that out of 718 tries some faults are bound to happen but some are unforgivable.
16. Woobat/Swoobat - Gen V
For some entries I include the evolved forms along with the base choice since the group overall are just as bad as the individuals, and this first entry is a perfect example. I am in no way a "GenWunner". I enjoy every single generation of Pokémon. In fact, I find it difficult to pick a generation of games to call my favorite. To be honest, despite the many entries you will see on this list from Black and White, Generation V is one of my favorites. For the first time since Pokémon Red and Blue/Green we are given a full Pokédex of 150 brand new Pokémon. It was refreshing while somewhat familiar as it paid homage to the original collection to draw inspiration and structure for the Unova Pokédex. However, there were some horrible Pokémon in this region that were a complete eyesore to look at. One of the worst offenders and the premiere entry on this list is Woobat and its just as goofy looking evolved form, Swoobat. Woobat and its evolution are to be this game's Zubat/Golbat equivalent. But where Zubat and friend are simple in appearance, mimicking its real life inspiration, Woobat looks like a Frankenstein monster of poorly drawn cartoons and various animal parts. Most Pokémon have a sort of concrete sense to its origins and existence but Woobat/Swoobat come off as a doodle drawn by a four-year-old. Nothing here yells "properly brainstormed" or "taken seriously". A puff of hair for a body, pig nose for a face, and a set of bat wings to complete it, this design only gets worse when it evolves. Certainly a Pokémon that should have went through a few more drafts.
15. Unown - Gen II
No PokémonI do not want to subconsciously go on a side quest to capture 28 different forms of the same Pokémon. You don't have to make it a mission with any reward because you know that I will not be able to resist the stinging temptation to hunt down hordes of useless Unown. This is why nobody likes Unown. I hate to admit it but when I was younger I was fascinated by Unown. It was mysterious and unique in the Pokémon world. Unfortunately these Pokémon are presented to be more rare, exciting, and useful than they actually are. Beyond taking up precious space in your storage boxes no matter what generation you find them in, Unown now come off as a joke from the developers. It might have seemed like a good idea at the time to use the alphabet as a source for Pokémon but when you realize they are nothing more than stick figures with dots for eyes you wish you never made the revelation. You sort of want to get upset that developers of Pokémon Silver and Gold thought it would be okay to toss something so dull and cheesy into the game. While they do contribute to some aspect of Pokémon lore as a work of a language, something I doubt few, including myself, care to know about, Unown seemed to be one of the first fears of Pokémon running out of ideas. The Unown are nothing more than boring and uninventive but they are still not the laziest designs from Pokémon, far from it.
14. Wingull - Gen III
Most Pokémon pull inspiration from real life objects, ideas, or animalsthe latter being the most prevalent. Even when a Pokémon is simply a morphed version of a rat or insect at least it has a special touch and twist that makes it a Pokémon and not just an animated form of the real life creature. But there are some Pokémon that seem to take the creation process no further than the initial brainstorm of ideas and little else. Wingull is one of them. Wingull is an innocent bystander. Unlike some Pokémon that people have distaste for, Wingull has done nothing to harm anyone. It just kind of waits in the corner without anyone realizing its presence until you fetch it to complete your Pokédex. And this might be why Wingull is on this list. It's obviously a seagull, nothing more. A lot of seagulls are already white, or a varied color thereof, and all that's done for Wingull is to add a few blue lines. That's it. Wingull may not be anyone's real poster-child of ill-conceived Pokémon. But when you truly consider the lack of imagination that went into Wingull all you can see is just a bird, a simple, uneventful bird that has virtually zero differences from its inspiration. It's pretty hard to get excited for Wingull. And on the note of Pokémon that make little effort to be unique...
13. Ducklett - Gen V
Even the name shows how little this Pokémon branched out from the insanely familiar creature, the duck. Shape, height, nor facial features were distorted or redesigned to claim this Pokémon as original or exceptional. They took a stereotypical cartoon duck and just colored in blue. It doesn't look mean, serious, or edgyit doesn't even look funny. It's just...there. Much like Wingull, Ducklett is completely forgetful. Nothing about this Pokémon begs catching. Ducklett is the sort of Pokémon that has me worried as a fan not because ice cream cones are becoming sources for Pokémon but instead that game creators are not even trying to think of new ideas. The duck is not even an exotic creature or significant in any regard and Gen V made no attempt to liven up the animal when they brought it to the Pokémon world. It's just a duck. A plain duck that was colored blue. What a drag.
12. Klink/Klang/Klinklang - Gen V
Once again, I state that I find Gen V to be an overall great collection of Pokémon but Klink and its evolutions are off-putting to those looking for reasons to start hating the franchise and call their precious Gen I the best ever. Klink, Klang, Klinklang (just like Woobat/Swoobat) are Gen V's answer to Magnemite and its evolutions. It is a fairly useable Pokémon. I did have one in my party for some time but at first glance you had to wonder "why gearsit's nothing but gears". It's not that players are uncomfortable with a random object being a Pokémon. I mean, Magnetmite was a magnet after all. Inspiration comes from everywhere. But it's the fact that Klink and company have no features that make it anything more than floating versions of something found on a garage floor. There's a slight effort to give it facial features and some life but it gets lost in its rotating movement, thus it looks like no time was put into giving this Pokémon an identity. As more Pokémon are added and those who grew up with each generation grow attached to the one before, fans can be increasingly cynical to new additions no matter what. Klink & company are the sort of Pokémon that give those cynics a sort of justification.
11. Ditto - Gen I
I have no doubt readers may get upset at this addition. Ditto is beloved by all those who seek the Pokémon that can transform to its opponent, not to mention the ultimate breeding Pokémon for those lucky enough to find one. But this is not a list for the most efficient or useful Pokémon, but for those that seem downright lazy. It's tough to argue. I understand a basic appearance to represent an absent form that can be molded to any other Pokémon imaginable, but in the end it's still just an enclosed scribble with two dots as eyes and another scribble for a mouth. Be it the intention or not, I feel it would have been improper not to include Ditto. As far as Generation I is concerned, Ditto is probably the most lackluster Pokémon in terms of appearance and feels like a total cop-out (with the exception of a pair to be seen soon). By no means is this an example of Pokémon already running out of ideas but it sure does show that even in the early days an animator for Pokémon had long nights. I know Ditto's purpose as the transforming Pokémon but it still doesn't mean that some detail or creativity could not have gone into this Pokémon's appearance.
10. Foongus/Amoongus - Gen V
The series got away one time before with a Pokémon that resembled a Pokéball but I don't think anyone can agree they can get away with it twice. The joke of running into a Voltorb that was mistaken for an item was a great gimmick in Generation I, but going for the same joke again some years later just isn't going to fly. I can't exactly say why Pokémon thought Foongus and Amoongus were necessary other than attempting to make Gen V rival Gen I. The idea that mushrooms just happen to grow to look exactly like Pokéballs feels a little bit like a stretch even in the Pokémon universe. This is indeed a case where attempting to copy a success twice seems like milking a dry cow.
9. Voltorb/Electrode - Gen I
Generation I is sacred ground to many people but like I mentioned with the entry of Ditto, it doesn't make it completely safe from this list. Yes, Voltorb and Electrode are awesome Pokémon. They are great in battle and despite my cynicism of their design, they were unique and fun in the first generation. But ultimately Voltorb is a very lazy creation. And only flipping the colors to create Electrode seems even worse. To be honest Electrode is probably a worst offender than its pre-evolved form given that there was no attempt to change the Pokémon other than turning it over. While not as offensive as say a Pokémon based on keys, when you do compare Voltorb and Electrode to the rest of the 151 Pokémon from Generation I it tends to come out the silliest. For all those who adore Gen I as unquestionably flawless, the plus side is that not many from that generation are on this listbut Voltorb and Electrode were going to make it at the very least.
8. Nosepass & Probopass - Gen III/IV
For many, Nosepass may be the first indication that the Pokémon franchise was losing its mind. A stubby legged rock with a huge nosethat's all it is. It looks so ridiculous that it's almost unbearable. But Nosepass does have a purpose, it is a compass. For some reason the Pokémon creators saw huge nostrils as a representation of which direction things point. All-in-all, Nosepass is definitely a miss as it displays a sense of immaturity that is lower than the usual 10 year-old target demographic for Pokémon. Yet, the franchise felt it was necessary to bring back this absurd design and crank it up a notch in the very next generation. Probopass was introduced as a bigger, bulkier version of Nosepass with the addition of a gigantic mustache making the Pokémon resemble Super Mario. At this point the Pokémon was just laughable. There was no serious redeeming value of a Pokémon as ludicrous as Probopass. Gaudy and too comical for its own good, Probopass was the dirty icing on the cake that just leaves a bad taste in your mouth.
7. Binacle/Barbaracle - Gen VI
Pokémon from Generation VI were not going to avoid this list for too long. With the introduction of only 70 new Pokémon (give or take), the lowest amount ever, you would think that designers would ensure that every single Pokémon would be well thought out and creative but that was not the case at all. Binacle and Barbaracle are a pair of Pokémon that forces players to scoff and exclaim "really...come on". Outrageously egregious, some are already calling Binacle the franchise's worst, but that is up to debate. However, I would not make too much of an argument against it. Based on barnacles, this Pokémon somehow took that inspiration and turned it into a pair of hands growing out of rock, resulting in a Pokémon that looks so unappealing that I'm surprised other Pokémon in the universe don't shun it as a mistake by whatever god it is that Pokémon worship. In a failed attempt to make amends by evolving this Pokémon into something "cool", Binancle turns into Barbaracle, a Pokémon so horrendous and over-the-top you wonder if the designers were even trying. Barbaracle believes that more of what made it ugly in the first place will somehow convince players that they will like it. It's doesn't. It's a pair of rocks with hands for legs and a head. Even the hands have eyes. It is just bad, pure bad. If there was ever a sin in Pokémon creation, Binancle and Barbaracle certainly is it.
6. Hawlucha - Gen VI
I'm not exactly sure if I should be more offended by some sense of political incorrectness or the fact that it's a bird with a luchador mask being passed as a legitimate excuse of a Pokémon. As I mentioned before, Gen VI has a mighty low number of new Pokémon, so there should be no issue of quantity over quality. Yet again, that doesn't seem to be the case. Hawlucha is so bizarre and nonsensical I don't think it was meant to be taken seriously at all. What were the Pokémon creators doing between Gen V and VI where all they could think of was a bird dressed as a luchador? Hawlucha does indeed look like he flew right out of a cartoon, but not Pokémon. Hawlucha seems more suited for something more campy and daffy than anything Pokémon could ever cook up. This is the sort of Pokémon that has you wondering if you even want the designers to attempt another generation. How much sillier and excessive can they become? Granted there have been Pokémon inspired by professions and various activities before but Hawlucha makes no attempt to make it unique to Pokémon. There is no blend or spin of the two worlds of animal and idea mixed together. It is just a bird with a mask on. It's a little too much that equals too little.
5. Luvdisc - Gen III
When you Google worst Pokémon ever you are guaranteed to find Luvdisc on any page you click on. Luvdisc has topped countless lists of Worst Pokémon Ever all over the internet. The wide distaste for Luvdisc seems to be the worst of both worlds, hated for its abilities and appearance. Considered to be completely useless in every aspect imaginable, Luvdisc's worthless contributions to the world of Pokémon is only topped by its hated design. As nothing more than a simplistic heart shape with little detail added for eyes and a mouth, fans should be happy that this one is tough to capture so they rarely have to look at it. This cheap Pokémon looks like it was created on a shoe-string budget. It would be instantly forgettable were it not for its infamous hatred around the internet and Pokémon community. Out of 718 Pokémon, no one is putting Luvdisc in their top 717 favorites.
4. Vanillite/Vanillish/Vanilluxe - Gen V
It was not until Generation V with Pokémon Black & White did we get this infamous trio. For a franchise that has been alive since the mid-nineties, Vanillite and its fellow evolutions inspired the first widely accepted consensus for many players that Pokémon just may have "jumped the shark". There had been some random inspirations in the past for Pokémon, but I don't think anything took players by surprise the way that this trio of ice cream cone Pokémon was able to do. The funny the thing is that Vanillite and company are not really that bad in a battle; and after awhile you sort of (ironically) warm up to the Pokémon. These three do really help with setting the bar low for future awful-looking Pokémon. I know many who saw Vanillite as a new Pokémon for Gen V had refused to play the games. It was their loss because the games and Pokémon were still great but a Pokémon that seems this drastic for an idea can poorly represent an entire generation of Pokémon. It is difficult to fault players for such thoughts because nothing shouts "we are running out of ideas" like looking at your afternoon snack as an idea. The biggest fear is how deep Pokémon is willing to scratch for future concepts...unfortunately Vanillite is not the worst.
3. Swirlix - Gen VI
Since ice cream was such a big hit as a Pokémon, why not continue the sugary trend? Surely it could not get any more insane. Well it sort of does, and a cotton candy Pokémon is the answer to that question. But this time, not only does the Pokémon draw inspiration from a ridiculous source, it also looks just as lazy as the thought process that went behind creating it. Simply, Swirlix is nothing more than a puff of lines with a tongue. It is very easy to draw and imagine, which is probably why Vanillite was such a difficult Pokémon to pass to players. There is no imagination in the design. We will always get crazy and random sources for Pokémon but if the designers make no effort to create something that looks like a creature that might actually be found in the Pokémon's version of the wild and instead just throw crudely drawn eyes onto any object, of course it is going to look bad. As you will notice, Slurpuff was not included. Well, that is because Slurpuff did exactly what I was talking about, it actually looks like something that put the 'monster' (creature or animal, etc.) in Pocket Monster. It looks acceptable as something more than just a cloud with a brainless expression on its face. Swirlix was not a great idea to introduce after some of the abrasive reactions to Vanillite, simply because it made the idea of candy as a Pokémon much worse.
2. Trubbish/Garbodor - Gen V
Yikes. Here is a Pokémon that sums up its entire existence with its very own appearancegarbage, pure garbage. There is no secret, whether it's good in battle or not, that players steer clear of Trubbish and Garbodor as if they were truly trash. There is no possible way that I can defend or justify the inspiration for these two sad and pathetic creations. Another Pokémon that if Googled you will find on many 'Worst Pokémon' list. If you did not feel such a strong sense of betrayal from thePokémon designers for such a blatantly poor excuse of a Pokémon, you just might feel sorry for these two...but you don't. Obviously this is Gen V's answer to Grimer and Muk. I have read of few defending this duo because Grimer and Muk were just radioactive slime and waste, no better than Trubbish and Garbodor, but I feel that the straight forward approach of a garbage bag with eyes and legs puts that debate to rest. Not only does the Gen V duo display a disregard for trying to be clever, it's not even funny. Trubbish and Garbodor will be the butt end of Pokémon jokes for years to come. Along the lines of ice cream and key rings, these Pokémon were clearly last ditch attempts after a long day for inspirationinspiration that came from no more than what just happen to be nearby at the time.
1. Klefki - Gen VI
And finally I get to that ring of keys that I have been hinting at for the entire article. One of Pokémon's newest additions, I am surprised that there hasn't been as much internet backlash from what feels like a downright insult to Pokémon fans of all ages. There have been bad and awful ideas for Pokémon, but never before has there been something so pathetically lazy and uncreative that you just want to forget the entire generation exists. At best anyone could describe Klefki as so deplorable and reprehensible that we fans probably deserve an apology for its creation. The idea that Pokémon thought it was okay for fans to dish out full price for a game that introduced the lowest amount of new Pokémon of any generation to date (by a long shot) then make Klefki one of those Pokémon feels disgraceful to the franchise. Absolutely zero work went into giving this random object found on the animator's desk personality, character, or any sense of identity as a Pokémon. What makes things even worse is that Klefki doesn't even evolve to make up for any of its existence. So it's just a solitary Pokémon that was only created to be filler in an already small collection of new Pokémon. Of all the entries on this list, Klefki is the biggest fear that the Pokémon franchise is losing momentum unlike ever before. If designers can only deliver Pokémon of such low caliber as Klefki, it makes fans worry for Gen VII and how little creativity will go into that set of gamesthat is Klefki's worst offense. Lazy in every sense of the word, Klefki is without a doubt the Pokémon franchise's biggest monument to ill conceived Pokémon. Agree? Disagree? What did I forget to include and who should not have been here? Let me know in the comments.