16 Most Replayable Levels In Gaming History

Which are the ones that never get old?

By Scott Tailford /

Replayability is a funny thing to consider as games occasionally barrel towards a more cinematically-focussed agenda, as if you take one look at The Order: 1886's powerhouse aesthetic and complete lack of substance as a case in point, it's not enough to deliver something that just looks brilliant - there has to be something worthwhile to sink your teeth into. Not just collectibles either, although some games like Crackdown's orbs or Batman: Arkham's Riddler Trophies realise there's more to the want of seeking out such things than just to kill time. Instead the most successful titles that warrant repeated playthroughs are usually down to the trifecta of solid game mechanics, loveable/endearing characters and of course, the levels themselves. What good is your quip-happy hero if they can't be hurtled through any number of high-octane situations with you at the helm? The best games know when they're onto a winner and also when to up the ante without losing any of the sense that you're the one pulling the strings - something that Call of Duty frequently gets wrong. So, whether it's to revisit a certain level's art aesthetic, relive a set-piece, character moment, encounter - or a mix of all three and more - there are certain levels across gaming's past that really elevate their respective titles far above the rest.

16. Paris, Nice (The Train Level) - Splinter Cell: Pandora Tomorrow

The definition of a replayable game if there ever was one; Splinter Cell's trial n' error gameplay of old could've been the death of it - if not for absolutely fantastic, at-the-time jaw-droppers like this. Flashback 11 years and the industry was just starting to flex its cinematic muscles, and for Microsoft's first sequel to one of the games that was slowly but surely garnering the Xbox a large following, they pulled out all the stops to blow people away. From darting in and out of carriages as the whole thing hurtled along at what felt like lightspeed to crawling underneath and just scraping by the tracks themselves, this easily went on to define the franchise, putting you square in the shoes of Sam Fisher as he undertook what felt like one hell of a step up for the way we experience action in games.

15. Flatline - Hitman: Blood Money

You could probably pick any level from the fourth Hitman title (if not all the Hitman games) for this list, as it's with this series that IO Interactive really hit their stride - delivering games with core appeal built specifically around experimentation to succeed, and not seeing everything a given level had to offer on your first time through. However a highlight is Blood Money's Flatline, a fantastic setup that sees you infiltrating a health spa to silence three separate targets whilst escaping with another. The ways you can do this are just brilliant - and at this point in the series the gameplay itself made 47 did exactly what you wanted him to; no more skating around the floor when turning and he'd even hide weapons from guards behind his back at the right moment. With Blood Money's new system of disguising hits as accidents in full effect, it was then up to you to realise how to rig things like someone's gas fire to blow up in their face, or simply to drop a set of weights on another as they worked out. The Hitman games are all great executions on a genius concept, meaning everyone's got their favourite missions - let us know yours in the comments below.

14. Three Leaf Clover - Grand Theft Auto IV

The first look at where GTA V's much-maligned heist missions were going to come from, IV's Heat-style take on stealing bags of cash from a bank in the middle of the city easily became the highlight of the entire game - not to mention one of the most frustrating missions overall if you couldn't nail the escape. However, say you managed to get everything right first time through, it was a brilliant mesh-together of GTA IV's new combat, graphics that were pretty amazing at the time and one final tunnel-crawl that seemed to go on forever before you'd lose your wanted level. IV might be remembered as the title that feels the least like GTA across the board, but this was one of a handful of moments where Rockstar set up a great mission and just said "Have fun!"

13. Chop Shop - The Punisher

THQ's The Punisher remains a very shiny underrated gem that occasionally people seek out thanks to it frequently popping up on any 'Best of Marvel Games' lists. The core game saw you administering all manner of gory deaths to gangsters and criminals in ways ranging from bludgeoning them with baseball bats to dunking heads in piranha tanks. The whole game was as solid as they come - with plenty of Marvel cameos too - but it's the early level in a car-stripping chop shop that solidified just how much fun Volition really wanted you to have. Dropping cars on perps and shining others' skulls on an orbital sander was immediately fun, but it was the level layout that made the whole thing pop - when you've journeyed all the way up to the building's staff room only to ram a guy's head through the TV he was watching, the whole experience will stick with you.

12. To Catch A Train - Uncharted 2: Among Thieves

Few developers are as comfortable and well-versed in how to execute winning formulas as Naughty Dog, however as much as they were already on the top of the world thanks to Crash Bandicoot and Jak and Daxter's consecutive successes, it was with Uncharted 2 that you felt the studio take a shift into truly legendary, medium-defining status. This train level in particular has been discussed by the programmers quite frequently as it's a really impressive feat of game design. The physics on the train actually move along with the geography changing alongside you, so Drake's movements and momentum are offset when going round corners for example, and although you might not be mindful of it first time through the stretch of land you cover goes in real time from one place to the other too. It's a monumental step up from other sequences like this set aboard moving vehicles and platforms (like Pandora Tomorrow's from earlier) that usually feature one background repeated over and over, and a truly amazing level that gets better every time you play it.

11. The Intro - Brutal Legend

Double Fine's Brutal Legend is a game that should be known as a love letter to all things heavy metal - so perfect is its pairing of everything from a vintage devil horn-throwing soundtrack to corralling both Lemmy and Ozzy Osbourne as characters that it was a real shame when the whole thing fell apart almost immediately. Sticking with the good though, the whole opening scene plays out like some Pixar-does-metal collaboration, with Double Fine's fantastic humour bringing to life Jack Black's character Eddie Riggs as he's transported into a world where heavy metal artwork really has come to life. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JtTA_XKqJwU#t=135 Having Black Sabbath's Children of the Grave tick away in the background only to kick in when you grab an axe out the ground - and realising you can literally slay demons with the power of guitar riffs alone - is one of the high points of the entire generation. Everything from the opening cutscene through to the boss battle with 'Big Licky' as Riggs calls a certain tongue-waggling demon is the perfect execution on a formula that to this day hurts wasn't used more effectively throughout.

10. Ravenholm - Half-Life 2

Take any screenshot of Half-Life 2 and chances are you'll be able to pick out a handful of influential things that have gone on to spawn countless titles - Valve's physics-sandbox masterpiece hit the ground sprinting, and has just as much to offer anyone today as back in 2004. Many games have those levels where everything just 'clicks', and in HL2 as soon as you were given the Gravity Gun you were waiting for a sequence that would play to its strengths i.e. something to let you get crazy with the in-world objects and hurl them at anything in the way. Luckily Valve had you covered, and at the exact moment you realised you could use the gun to slice a string of Head-Crabs off the top of many a zombified host in quick succession, this was immediately Greatest Game of All Time material.

9. Your Favourite Song - Guitar Hero/Rock Band

Harmonix really hit onto something truly special across the last decade or so - Guitar Hero was like some crazy cultural phenomenon people just couldn't enough of. Following a couple of successful Hero games they then turned their heads to creating the entire band setup in plastic form, kickstarting Rock Band with MTV and leaving the GH franchise in the capable hands of Neversoft, who promptly recruited Slash and Tom Morello to star in part three. Everything was coming up fake axe-wielding Milhouse, so much so that even now there's rumblings of another Guitar Hero or Rock Band title making a return - but until then it's a 'thanks for the memories'-type deal, as everyone reading this who played either of these games will have that one specific song they just couldn't get enough of for hours (if not days) on end.

8. P.T.

Designed my Metal Gear-maniac Hideo Kojima and silver screen visual powerhouse Guillermo del Toro, this teaser for the upcoming Silent Hills reboot completely blindsided everyone with its quality and depth. It's a strange inclusion here sure, especially as the thing is literally labelled a 'Playable Teaser' and would fall more into the 'full game' category than just a level, but that's literally all it is; one area packed with clues and hints as to what's going on in the wider game - not to mention it went on to be many peoples' Game of the Year last year too. Not only were there recordings and certain in-world cues you'd only trigger if you did very specific things, but thanks to its linear nature and very existence as an enticing showcase of what's to come, it instantly created a very dedicated following of thousands who lapped up every last morsel in the process.

7. Charlie Don't Surf - Call Of Duty 4: Modern Warfare

Granted the fact that COD has more awesome set-pieces to than Nicki Minaj does left and right cheek surgeons, you could pick any one of them to stand up as the best from across the franchise. However, factor in a time when you weren't completely numb to all the explosions and "CHARLIE TANGO REPORT IN!'-style dialogue, go back to 2007 when you first got your hands on Activision's finest - the whole thing was revolutionary at every turn, but it's the Charlie Don't Surf level that really takes the cake. It's mainly down to the layout and the sheer amount of little touches Infinity Ward threw in to make you feel like you were slap bang in the middle of the greatest war movie on earth. There's blink n' you'll miss 'em jets flying overhead, a string of awesome locations to do battle across including an office packed with PCs that all crackle and burst with electricity, and one hell of a stinger for the main narrative when the guy you've been tracking and building up to take down is revealed to be nothing more than a recording.

6. Facility - Goldeneye

Isn't it awesome to know Rare just included the now-legendary multiplayer component of Goldeneye as a goof? They literally just threw it together in a few day's time, didn't tell their bosses (assuming it would just be some throwaway fun) and lo and behold; it redefined the very idea of local multiplayer. However, moving away from this pedestal-topping position within gaming's echelon of incredible titles, chances are you remember Goldeneye more as having 'the level where you shoot the guy on the toilet'. Coming back to you now? Goldeneye also introduced thousands of gamers to the delights of shooting a guard square in the crotch - something Metal Gear Solid 2 would do later on with even more impressively-rendered man-spud abuse. It's the simple pleasures in life.

5. The Suicide Mission - Mass Effect 2

Chances are you aren't going to journey through close to 100 hours of any Mass Effect just to replay a particular section, however with the fate of your entire crew hanging on every moment of the final stretch of part two, getting them all through in one piece momentarily transcended that. Remember that this was in a time where the mentioning of Mass Effect didn't conjure up imagery of spectrally-tinged little boys doing away with entire weeks of playtime at the last second, instead the series' reputation was at an all-time high. As critics and fans alike slowly burrowed into this final mission and emerged in many different states, the general outcry came back "Make sure you save beforehand!" This lead to thousands of us refusing to accept something like Mordin Solus biting the bullet at the last second - instead reloading, thumbing through a FAQ to see how best to keep his' skin on and having another go until everyone made it home safe.

4. Garibaldi - SSX Tricky

Of all the games that should make a comeback, Tricky is at the top, although thanks to a godawful more 'serious' reboot from 2012 that did away with everything people loved about the original trilogy - namely characters as large as their tricks, with tracks and music to boot - it doesn't look like it'll be happening any time soon. Just one of those 'exactly what we needed at the time' games, EA BIG's second attempt it took a formula that was already fun, added absolutely bucketloads of character and charm, and sped everything up until your eyelids couldn't stretch any wider. The course selection was top-notch even though many tracks were riffs on their originals, but it didn't matter when the opening slope of them all ended up being the one you'd hop back onto every time. A perfect blend of speed, huge air and even a couple of shortcuts made this the perfect track to chase after gold snowflakes yourself or with friends, and to this day remains one of the high points of the entire franchise.

3. The Challenge Rooms - Batman: Arkham

It's very hard to narrow down one particular combat encounter that stands out more than the rest across the entirety of the Arkham trilogy, but that's no knock against the game, instead quite the opposite. What Rocksteady created with their 'Freeflow' combat system was a truly revolutionary take on third-person brawling that mixed Fable and Assassin's Creed's core feel with some brilliant gadgets and a hell of a lot of impact. When you land a right hand as Batman you really feel it, and no matter which Arkham title you pick up, you'll get access to a range of 'Challenge Rooms' purpose-built to showcase how well you can beat the paste out of everything in sight.

2. The Silent Cartographer - Halo: Combat Evolved

The level that made the world take notice, and not only that - the one that proved first-person shooters could work perfectly well on consoles. Halo's mix of quick-switch double weapons, regenerating health, vehicular combat and team-based gameplay has now been picked apart ad nauseam, but if you fire it up today there's just nothing like the original Cartographer level. Taking place mostly on a beach with occasional forays through intersecting underground cavelike structures, it was also one of the first times you'd bare witness to cutscenes playing out through your gameplay perspective - giving way to a Normandy beach-like charge at the opening that saw you get stuck in bashing grunts with melee attacks and lobbing sticky grenades into the path of oncoming Elites. In short, it's still just as heart-pounding and phenomenal now as it was then.

1. The Tanker - Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons Of Liberty

Although MGS: Ground Zeroes tried to make lightning strike twice when it was released as a tiny portion of an upcoming game (for around £30), back when Zone of the Enders came out it was bundled with MGS 2's Tanker section for free. Considering back in 2001 Metal Gear was yet to go off the deep end (and up it's own Snake-hole) with a myriad of crazy plot elements and bait n' switches regards to who you'd play as, the world couldn't get enough of this level. It helped that the whole thing encouraged experimentation like nothing else, letting you play with the enemy A.I., discover places to hide, routes to take, saucy photos to find - not to mention the cutscenes and narrative itself was just as enticing. Come the release of the full game this was one incredible way to kick things off, and regardless of whether you think Raiden 'ruined' MGS 2 alongside the vampires and arm-possessed villains, every part of the Tanker's section is damn-near immaculate. What are the levels you couldn't wait to replay across all of gaming history? Let us know in the comments, and don't forget to sign up to our new Gaming page on Facebook!