20 Biggest Video Game Bombs Of 2025

The gaming world of 2025 had quite a few duds that were dead on arrival.

By James Egan /

With 2025 almost wrapped, it's natural to reflect upon what the last 12 months have brought the gaming industry. The Nintendo Switch 2 finally launched, breaking numerous sales records. Sandfall Interactive's debut, Clair Obscur: Expedition 33, surpassed all expectations and picked up the Game of The Year Award. And after a decade-long hiatus, Donkey Kong returned, bigger than ever.

Advertisement

Of course, not everything panned out the way studios intended or players hoped. Several RPGs or sandbox titles were promoted as the next big thing, but ended up being nothing special. Certain games were received positively, but are still ending up seeing an enormous player drop-off. New gaming gadgets or peripherals were expected to change the landscape of gaming forever, but proved to be nothing more than gimmicks.

Even though some of these entries are considered "fine," that's not good enough if the property in question spent an eternity in development and was advertised as a revolutionary game-changer.

Over all, it has been a superb year for gaming, which is why it's painful to see these 20 entries bomb so spectacularly.

20. South Of Midnight

Due to the middling reception of We Happy Few, not much was expected from Compulsion Games' next project.

Advertisement

And yet, South of Midnight proved to be surprisingly solid. The action-adventure carves its own identity by leaning heavily into the Gothic folklore of the Deep South. With so many games highlighting Greek, Norse, or Egyptian legends, it's a nice to see myths based on Georgian or Cajun cryptidgs for a change, like the Rougarou or Two-Toed Tom. With its stop-motion-inspired art and enrapturing story, South of Midnight is one of the year's most beautiful games.

Too bad quality doesn't always translate into profit. Despite impressive reviews, South of Midnight had one of the weakest Game Pass releases in gaming history, with its concurrent player count peaking at 1,438. Its numbers have since nosedived to a few dozen, with no sign of them picking up anytime soon.

Although reception remains positive, it's possible South of Midnight was way too niche to hit a larger demographic. Ironically, Compulsion Games' originality may be the very reason this underrated gem failed to find its audience.

19. Mecha Break

Before explaining what went wrong with Mecha Break, it’s worth noting what the project had going for it.

Advertisement

Developed by Amazing Seasun Games, the futuristic shooter attracted attention early, since it contained a huge variety of mechs. It's deeply satisfying to perform aerial manoeuvres and dodge missiles while piloting a giant robot, due to the dynamic combat and accessible controls. To top it off, it's free.

When its beta opened in February, Mecha Break reached over 300,000 players on Steam, which was higher than Marvel Rivals. On paper, it was shaping up to be a monumental success.

But in hindsight, Mecha Break was too good to be true. What had been free or easily accessible in the beta was suddenly locked behind grind-heavy missions and paywalls. Despite being promoted as a free shooter, players needed to spend up to $50 on packages that contained basic skins, mechs, and cosmetics. Coupled with an abundance of performance issues, Mecha Break ended up losing 60% of its player base within its first week. 

The beta indicated Mecha Break could've grown into something truly epic, which is why it was a pity to see the property fade into the ether.

18. Nintendo Switch 2 Welcome Tour

As the title suggests, the Nintendo Switch 2 Welcome Tour was a launch game that served as an introduction to the new console. Boasting 20 mini-games, 14 tech demos, and numerous quizzes, the digital-only title was meant to showcase the Switch 2's capabilities.

Advertisement

But Welcome Tour wasn't just uninteresting, but pointless. Although the Switch 2 is noticeably more powerful than its predecessor, its functionality is virtually identical, making this tech demo redundant. (Sure, the new Joy-Cons can function as a clickable mouse, but you don't need to buy an entire game to tell you that.)

Though players spend countless hours on Wii Play due to its addictive gameplay, the mini-games here are unappealing. As such, expect anybody purchased Welcome Tour to play the mini-games once then turn this launch title off forever. 

These issues could've been forgiven if Welcome Tour was bundled with the system, much like Wii Play and Nintendo Land for the Wii and Wii U respectively. Instead, the powers-that-be decided Welcome Tour should be purchased separately.

Welcome Tour isn't just awful in its own right, but downright insulting, since the company believed consumers would pay for an instruction manual disguised as a game.

Rather than showcasing the new console's capabilities, Welcome Tour ended up being the worst-rated Nintendo game in a decade.

17. Avowed

Avowed is a real mixed bag, since almost every positive attribute can be cancelled out by a negative. 

Advertisement

Although the Pillars of Eternity spin-off has engaging weapons, the battles are compromised by arbitrary RPG systems. The gaming world is noticeably larger than Obsidian's last project, The Outer Worlds, but feels empty. Despite the fact the artwork is lush, the deluge of technical issues ruin the immersion.

But the good outweighs the bad, since Avowed was recommended by 84% of critics on OpenCritic. It was rated between 77-80% on MetaCritic, which isn't astounding but also not to be sniffed at. On top of that, Avowed was nominated for Best Role Playing Game of the Year. (Not bad for a development team that only consisted of 80 people.)

However, the paying customers were far from impressed. Avowed managed less than 20,000 concurrent users, which is modest at best for a high-profile release. If that wasn't humiliating enough, the game saw an unprecedented 98% drop over the next month, reducing its numbers down to under 400 players.

The critical rating may be decent, but Avowed's popularity (or lack of) will decide whether it'll last much longer.

16. Bubsy In: The Purrfect Collection

Thanks to Super Mario and Sonic the Hedgehog, platformers exploded in popularity during the 1990s. Wanting a piece of the action, Accolade got to work on their own 2D side-scroller, Bubsy in Claws Encounters of the Furred Kind.

Advertisement

Even though the pun-filled IP has never been particularly popular, Limited Games released a compilation this year called Bubsy The Purrfect Collection. It includes every port of the first four titles, including the Jaguar-exclusive, Bubsy in Fractured Furry Tales.

As can be expected from an Atari-published compilation, The Purrfect Collection includes interviews with the developers, tons of artwork, a music player, behind-the-scenes material, commercials, and even details involving the cancelled Bubsy cartoon.

It's difficult to fault the presentation, but that doesn't change the fact these games aren't exactly top-tier. I mean, why is Bubsy 3D included, when it's regarded as one of the worst platformers of all time?

Even though Bubsy has its defenders, The Purrfect Collection is a lost cause, since it has an all-time peak CPC on Steam of 77. Based on those numbers, it's possible this kitty will be put to sleep for good.

15. Nintendo Switch 2 Camera

Even though the Switch 2 has been hugely successful, its launch had a few hiccups (and not just because of the cartridge price-hike). One of the first things revealed at the first Nintendo Direct for the new console was the Switch 2 Camera, suggesting it would be a prominent feature.

Advertisement

However, the gadget is a basic webcam with no advanced features, like background blur or low-light performance, making image quality washed out or pixelated. Given the camera's modest specs and narrow usage, the $54.99 launch price is unjustifiable, considering there are webcams that deliver better performance for lower cost.

Furthermore, the poor design undermines the gizmo's utility. Rather than having a built-in front‑facing camera, Nintendo decided to make it a docked peripheral, which is terribly awkward. And apart from a handful of niche titles, most Switch 2 games ignore the camera entirely.

Though Nintendo probably expected big things from the Switch 2 camera, it's easy to forget it ever existed, based on the sales numbers. It turned out so badly, it's a wonder why Nintendo had such faith in the superfluous add-on in the first place.

14. Game Of Thrones: Kingsroad

Even the biggest fans of the Song of Ice and Fire saga struggle to defend the ending of the TV adaptation. For that reason, skepticism surrounding any Game of Thrones project isn't just understandable but warranted.

Advertisement

Having said that, Game of Thrones: Kingsroad showed a lot of promise. Netmarble's open-world RPG captured the spirit of George R.R. Martin's work, with its visceral combat, deep world-building, and character-driven conflicts. If Kingsroad succeeded as well as everybody hoped, it could give closure to fans who felt betrayed by the HBO series' last season.

Sadly, Kingsroad was another major letdown. The co-op functionality is limited, the objectives are plain, and the basic mechanics naturally being suited to a mobile game.

However, the worst aspect of Kingsroad by far has to be the aggressive monetisation. The most fundamental elements of the game are locked behind a paywall, including fast-travel, inventory slots, and decent horses, making every task a tiresome chore unless you're a Master of Coin.

Though Kingsroad attracted a lot of players at first, it saw a 94% decline from peak by November. Rather than redeeming Game of Thrones, Kingsroad accomplished a historic feat and managed to sour its reputation further.

13. The Precinct

The Precinct has a simple but intriguing premise. The police sim lets players patrol a gritty city as a rookie cop, combining procedurally-generated crimes, vehicle chases, and arrests.

Advertisement

Although it's a cool concept, the delivery is bungled. It's fun for a while, but the core loop becomes tiresome, since more time is spent waiting for crimes to occur than stopping them. Worse still, many of the activities aren't engaging, like checking licenses or telling off locals for minor infractions. Yes, it's more realistic than other crime-oriented titles, but it doesn't stop the objectives from being profoundly mundane.

Even when missions get mildly exciting, they're undermined by the first-draft dialogue, minimal characterisation, and cliche-riddled plot.

Mechanically, the combat and driving aren't up to scratch either. Shooting is imprecise and the gameplay is locked at 30fps, making the most thrilling tasks feel sluggish.

Ultimately, The Precinct ends up caught between two identities. It's too dull to satisfy fans of action-heavy cop thrillers, but too mind-numbing to deliver a meaningful simulation. Taking into account the player numbers went from nearly 10,000 to the low hundreds, there's no doubt The Precinct is deep in the red.

12. Tales Of The Shire: A Lord Of The Rings Game

Rather than focusing on sprawling battles against Orcs and trolls like most Middle-Earth properties, Tales of the Shire takes a more tranquil approach. Developed by Weta Workshop, The Lord of the Rings sim takes a page out of Stardew Valley, dealing with the day-to-day activities of a Hobbit commune.

Advertisement

Even though Tales of the Shire promises to be a feel-good cozy experience, it drops the ball big-time. While cooking and fishing are reasonably enjoyable, many of the broader activities, like gardening, chores, and social interactions quickly run out of juice. Chats between the halflings lack depth and emotional investment, which is disappointing for any purist of J.R.R. Tolkien's work.

The lack of voice acting and ambient sound creates a lifeless atmosphere, which is a far cry from the beloved source material. Frame-drops, bugs, and crashes are regular, which is pretty preposterous, since there's no viable reason why such dated graphics would put a strain on any modern system.

Although Tales of the Shire was intended to have DLC, the negative reception may have led to all planned updates being paused indefinitely. 

11. Metroid Prime 4: Beyond

Metroid Prime 4: Beyond has been delayed so many times, it genuinely felt like the cursed project would never come out. But 17 years after the last instalment, the long-awaited sequel is finally here.

Advertisement

And boy, it's hard to put into words how disheartening the game is. Exploration has been a fundamental component in the franchise since its inception, which is why it's uncharacteristic to see Beyond's layout lack depth and structure. Instead of getting a tight interconnected world, many environments, especially the central hub, are barren, diluting the desire to look around.

Not only that, the gripping isolation that Metroid is renowned for is tainted by annoying side-characters. These NPCs frequently provide commentary or direction, disrupting the atmosphere. Although it's reassuring to see a sequel mix it up, the additional psychic abilities and vehicle-based segments feel jarring, especially since they're not implemented well.

Even though Beyond hasn't bombed as monumentally as other entries on this list, seeing a decline of quality this extreme is baffling. After years of hype and Prime's near-mythic reputation, it didn't seem feasible for the next entry to match expectations. However, nobody anticipated Beyond to be the worst Prime entry and arguably the weakest mainline game in the Metroid series.

10. Captain Blood

Captain Blood had such a nightmarish development, everybody was praying it would be good. Based on the 1922 novel of the same name, the first iteration of the swashbuckling adventure was teased back in 2004 and set to be released on the original Xbox. Due to legal problems, a lack of funding, and the publisher's bankruptcy, Captain Blood was in development hell for a decade before being canned.

Advertisement

Several years ago, former Captain Blood developers acquired the rights, allowing them to outsource the project to another studio, General Arcade. 

Now, the idea of a supposedly doomed game seeing the light of day is uplifting. But the reality is anything but. Resurrecting a project with a two-decade old codebase was a Herculean task, since the engine was built with tools that are now deemed obsolete. Even though General Arcade moved heaven and Earth to get Captain Blood up and running, it wasn't worth it, since the finished product suffers from poorly mixed audio, bugs galore, repetitive gameplay, and a lack of polish overall.

The fact Captain Blood failed to hit a hundred simultaneous players worldwide just goes to show the creators should've focused their passion elsewhere.

9. Dreams Of Another

The first thing that stands out about Dreams of Another is how absolutely gorgeous it looks. Pixeljunk's ambitious shooter has players take control of a man in pyjamas who's traversing across a dream landscape. Each object and environment is composed of cloud-like particles, giving everything an otherworldly vibe.

Advertisement

As luscious as it appears, it isn't long before the gameplay grows stale. After an initial sense of wonder, the act of shooting to build, rebuild, or materialise pixelated objects becomes boring.

Even though a reality that exists within the subconscious should be disjointed, Dreams of Another seems more interested in abstract symbolism than coherence. Because of this, any moment that's meant to be poignant comes across as meaningless noise. 

The project was handled by Baiyon, who orchestrated the music for Big Little Planet 2, so it's no surprise the score is on point. However, the tracks lose their impact when paired with the flat voice-acting.

Next to nobody is playing Dream of Another, so anybody who has the slightest interest in the concept may want to give the maligned indie a whirl before it's gone for good.

8. Hunter X Hunter: Nen X Impact

Hunter x Hunter: Nen x Impact emulates the Marvel vs Capcom series, with 3 vs 3 tag-team fights that showcase wild combos and flashy specials. 

Advertisement

Unfortunately, the game itself is devoid of substance. The story mode resembles a glorified slideshow, since the cutscenes are composed of static images and bare-bones dialogue. There are only 16 playable characters, which is shockingly low for a 3-on-3 fighting title. The limited roster reduces team-building options, especially with how unevenly balanced the fighters are.

Even though Nen X Impact was delayed to implement rollback netcode, it's impossible to tell, due to the endless lag, flickering characters, and frequent disconnects. On top of that, there's no crossplay, splitting the already minuscule player base further.

But the most unforgivable aspect is the pricing. Nen X Impact cost $60 at launch, which is the kind of price expected from an established fighting brand like Street Fighter or Tekken, rather than... this. (And if you include the Season Pass, it brings the grand total to $80.) Obviously, asking consumers to pay hard-earned cash for a thin single-player, sketchy online modes, bland visuals, and a tiny roster is beyond unreasonable.

Even though Nen X Impact did a 30% discount shortly after release, it was too little too late, as can be seen by its single-digit player numbers.

7. Painkiller

The original Painkiller follows a man trapped in Purgatory, who must battle demons to earn a place in Heaven. Inspired by Quake and Serious Sam, the cosmic shooter was praised for its straightforward gameplay and expansive multilayer modes.

Advertisement

Though fans were hoping the 2012 remake would help Painkiller transition from cult-classic to global phenomenon, Painkiller: Hell & Damnation didn't live up to its predecessor. So, when it was announced a reboot was in the works, it was another chance for Painkiller to reclaim its glory days.

But after experiencing 2025's Painkiller, players may draw the conclusion they were too harsh on the 2012 version. The latest iteration strays so far from the original, it might as well be a different game. You're basically forced to play co-op, since solo missions have you accompanied with laughably bad AI.

Beyond that, the game suffers from uninspired design. Levels are bland, enemy variety is limited, and gunplay lacks anything that resembles creativity. Although the first Painkiller was known for its gothic tone, this version is filled with quippy humour, which is extra cringey thanks to the dire voice-acting.

By trading innovation for generic shooter tropes, it's not hard to understand why nobody is playing this soulless reimagining.

6. Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines 2

Although Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines is regarded as a cult classic in the RPG genre, its debut was chaotic to say the least. Coupled with a troubled development and technical issues at launch, the grisly bloodfest came out the same day as Half-Life 2, which hogged the spotlight. Despite the fact Bloodlines is viewed as a flawed masterpiece, these factors contributed to poor sales, which didn't even reach 80,000.

Advertisement

But decades later, the love for Vampire: The Masquerade hasn't subsided, which is why it was reassuring when a sequel was green-lit.

But like its predecessor, Bloodlines 2 had an apocalyptic development, involving rewrites, delays, and a complete change in studio. Though veterans wanted Bloodlines 2 to knock it out of the park, the final product was a mess, due to the rampant glitches, primitive RPG mechanics, and glacial pacing.

However, its critical reception was nowhere near as bad as its financial situation. Bloodlines 2's publisher, Paradox Interactive, announced a write‑down of $37 million in development costs, acknowledging the sales didn't come close to matching projections.

It was upsetting to see the first instalment bomb, but this one hurt even more.

5. Ambulance Life: A Pandemic Simulator

It's been a rough year for new sims, as can be seen with The Precinct, Tales of the Shire, and now Ambulance Life. 

Advertisement

In this self-proclaimed pandemic simulator, players need to rush to emergency scenes to diagnose patients, perform first aid using realistic medical tools, and transport the injured to the hospital. Missions are varied, since they deal with minor accidents, major catastrophes, and everything in-between. 

Not only is this a great spin on the already cramped sim genre, this sort of game should be informative and practical, since it gives players a basic understanding of the medical process and training regime.

Of course, none of that matters if the game itself isn't up to standard. Driving is awkward, patient handling is unintuitive, and NPCs behave erratically. There are many tasks to perform, but little incentive to take part, due to the buggy gameplay. What should've been an atmospheric experience is sullied by the frequent frame-rate drops, clipping, and stuttering. This makes the high-stakes missions intense and frustrating, but not for the reasons the developers were hoping for.

And with Ambulance Life's player numbers going from bad to worse to double digits, there doesn't seem to be any way of saving it.

4. Neptunia Riders Vs Dogoos

The most recent instalment in the Hyperdimension Neptunia brand launched in Japan in 2024 but didn't see a worldwide release until this year. Based on the naff reception, it's a mystery why Neptunia Riders vs Dogoos didn't remain a Japan-exclusive.

Advertisement

While riding a motorcycle, players must collect a certain amount of slime monsters called Dogoos to move onto the next stage.

And that... is the entire game. Although the concept would be amusing for a mini-game, having it serve as the entire premise for a full-priced title is outrageous.

What's worse is the botched mechanics make the simplest tasks intolerable. Drifting needs to be mastered to maximise how many Dogoos can be collected. Sadly, the manoeuvre is floaty and exasperated by the clunky controls. Combined with awkward camera angles and poor draw distance, it's a slog to perform basic moves on your vehicle.

Each level is incredibly brief and the whole campaign can be beaten in under three hours, with little variety or incentive to replay. Although the presentation is charming and the voice-acting is solid, it's not enough to save this travesty.

With that said, this Neptune instalment's critical score is nowhere as woeful as the player rating. Peaking at 14 concurrent players on Steam and boasting a current player count of zero (give or take), Riders vs Dogoos is an unmitigated disaster across the board.

3. Tamagotchi Plaza

Even though Tamagotchis reigned supreme during the 1990s, the digital pets never translated well in video games, demonstrated further by the recent Tamagotchi Plaza.

Advertisement

Here's the thing. The original Tamagotchi thrived on simplicity, since players only had a handful of options to take care of their virtual pet. 

Tamagotchi Plaza clashes with this idea since you're bombarded with features, shops, and mini-games. Although the game is trying to offer as many fun tasks as possible, packing the screen with menus, bright visuals, and rapid-fire tasks results in sensory overload. Its attempt to create a bustling world comes across as cluttered, leaving players jumping between activities without any meaningful connection or noticeable progression.

Also, the mini-games lack tutorials, making these already annoying games hard to follow. (And if an adult can't understand the rules, children don't stand a chance.)

Additionally, the social elements feel shallow. While the idea of interacting with pets is entertaining, the execution tends to prioritise gimmicks over genuine engagement. Because of this, there's zero emotional ties towards these cutesy critters. If Tamagotchi Plaza lacks the emotional attachment that defined the original, there's literally nothing here for the fanbase.

Though Tamagotchi Plaza fared well in Japan, it sold atrociously everywhere else, especially in the UK, where the game entered the sales chart at 29th place upon its release.

2. Call Of Duty: Black Ops 6

Black Op 6 had the largest launch weekend in Call of Duty history and was most lucrative video game in the United States in 2024. As a result, the future couldn't have looked brighter for the iconic war shooter.

Advertisement

But, oh, how the mighty have fallen. Black Ops 7 was torn apart for its unfinished campaign, which had uninspired missions, a disconnected story, and inconsistent checkpoints. It required a constant online connection (even on solo play) which proved to be extremely unreliable.

The multiplayer was equally underwhelming, thanks to the frame-rate drops, lagging performances, and inconsistent matchmaking. Also, the devs really thought players wouldn't notice that a large chunk of the content was recycled from earlier entries. When it became common knowledge that several art assets were created with generative AI, players responded with review-bombing and boycotts. The hatred towards Black Ops 7 is so intense, it makes the reaction towards Infinite Warfare generous by comparison.

According to reports, the latest COD entries could've lost the studio a whopping $300 million, which is hard to fathom.

1. MindsEye

Even though many video games tank for not being ambitious enough, MindsEye sounded fascinating, making its failure more tragic. Using a game-creation system called Everywhere, players can add user-generated content into their playthrough. Producer, Leslie Benzies, believed this mechanic had untapped potential and expected MindsEye to evolve into a franchise that explored different timelines, regions, and go beyond the realms of space.

Advertisement

Of course, these grandiose plans went down the tubes since MindsEye turned out very, very badly. NPCs freeze, textures disappear, and progress erases with such regularity, it's impossible to understand why the devs thought this clunker was acceptable to release. If the gameplay isn't stuttering or crashing, gameplay caps at 30fps, even on a high-end system.

If MindsEye was remotely playable, it wouldn't matter since the gameplay and design is uninspired and derivative. Despite being promoted as next‑gen, the missions resemble poorly constructed rail-shooters. 

And that's not even looking at the internal side of this catastrophe. The development was rife with mismanagement, poor work conditions, rushed deadlines, and unbearable overtime, making success borderline impossible. Co-CEO, Mark Gerhard, went into full conspiracy mode, claiming MindsEye's negative reception was part of a malicious act conducted by a third-party.

Despite Gerhard's wild accusations, it seems more likely that MindsEye is just terrible.

Advertisement