20 Dumb Choices That Will DESTROY Your Game Save

Don't ruin your game with these choices!

By Michael Fincher /

In the age of tutorials, hints, and all manner of guides in video games, it's easy to let a game hold your hand through the entire experience and never question a thing.

Advertisement

However, even the most restrictive or "explainy" games still have moments when you have to make a choice. And if you haven't been paying attention, it can be a really dumb choice that will completely ruin your experience!

Not every title is considerate enough to give you room to make mistakes and learn from them. Some of them will punish you for making incorrect choices,  especially if they are so dumb that no rational being would ever even consider picking them.

You might make the choice by accident, or because you thought it would be funny, but even then, the punishment is coming anyway.

The game might give you a permanent debuff, take away something valuable you will never get back, or even delete your save file!

If you don't want to have a bad time, make sure to be extra mindful when making the following choices. Stupidity can cost you dearly.

20. Eat Tsuchinoko - Metal Gear Solid Delta

Metal Gear Solid Delta, just like the original, rewards the player for collecting all 48 plants and creatures in the game with the EZ gun that comes with infinite ammo.

Advertisement

However, there is also an incredibly rare creature that grants an additional reward for its capture—Tsuchinoko.

Tsuchinoko is a Japanese yokai resembling a rotund snake. The creature is small and incredibly rare, making it near impossible to find, let alone capture. For this reason, when Snake catches one in his mousetrap, his crew will inform him to keep it in his inventory and deliver it to the base.

Doing exactly that and carrying Tsuchinoko in your inventory until the end of the game will reward you with the Infinity Face Paint.

However, if curiosity gets the better of you, instead of safekeeping this legendary creature, you may choose to eat it instead.

This unbridled case of gluttony will immediately cause your team to gasp with shock, as they are unable to comprehend you making a light snack out of a supernatural being.

More importantly, though, since there is only one Tsuchinoko per campaign, you permanently lose your chance to unlock the unique face paint on your save file.

Think with your brain, not your stomach!

19. Suicide Mission - Mass Effect 2

Mass Effect 2’s ending features one of the most intense final missions in the entire series. You and your crew have to go on a suicide mission deep inside the Collectors’ territory to finally put their threat to an end.

Advertisement

The game makes a point about preparing yourself for this daring task, and you’d do well to listen to this advice, unless you want the mission to be a suicide in more than just its name.

While planning the operation, you are in charge of making critical decisions, such as assigning your crew to specific tasks and organizing the resources that will let individual parts of the plan proceed smoothly.

If you weren’t paying attention and blazed through the game without much thought, this is when you will come to deeply regret your actions (or lack thereof).

Depending on how poorly you prepared for the mission, it is possible to kill off everybody involved, even including Commander Shepard themselves, and prompt the game’s worst ending.

So if you don’t want to doom an otherwise promising campaign you have, make sure to complete all of your companions’ quests, gather the right equipment, and put the right people in charge of the right task.

18. Secret Death Ending - Shenmue

Shenmue is an open-world adventure telling the story of a young man on a quest for revenge.

Advertisement

Or at least that’s what the game would like to be. In reality, most players would rather laze around its virtual town, spending all their money on arcades and gacha machines.

Because Shenmue’s open world features so many mini games and side activities, it’s easy to set aside its somewhat boring main storyline in favor of exploration. The only problem is that if you spend too much time ignoring the obvious threat posed by the game’s main antagonist, your neglect will eventually come back to bite you.

The in-game clock isn’t there just for the opening hours of the arcade joint, but it is also secretly ticking away. The game makes it quite apparent that the man responsible for the protagonist’s father’s death is still a threat to you, and if you ignore him for too long, you will run out of time.

The game will suddenly trigger a game over cutscene and show the main character, Ryo, getting killed by the man he was supposed to track down.

In retrospect, maybe wasting your time and allowance on video games isn’t the best idea while fighting an international crime syndicate.

17. Picking YaoGuai - Amazing Cultivation Simulator

Amazing Cultivation Simulator is often described as an ancient China version of RimWorld. You control a settlement of acolytes as they try to achieve enlightenment through the practice of martial arts, meditation, and alchemy.

Advertisement

The simulation is full of convoluted mechanics that may feel overwhelming to beginner players, but with this said, make sure to at least understand one of them right away, or else you can lose your save file in a really embarrassing way.

When you begin the game, you get to design your own starting acolyte. Aside from their appearance and characteristics, you have to decide whether they are a human or a YaoGuai, a race of half-humans and half-animals.

Now, although the latter option may look interesting and offer various perks, the YaoGuai are secretly a ticking time bomb.

This is because, lore-wise, YaoGuai are actually just animals transformed into half-humans, and when you start the game, they only have a limited amount of time before they revert back to their basic form and become unplayable.

If you start a game as a YaoGuai and transform back before you recruit anyone or find a way to prolong your magical existence, you can lose all of your progress before you even realize what’s happening.

16. Killing Toriel - Undertale

Undertale is a unique RPG that gives you the option to spare your enemies instead of just killing them. At this point, the plot twist related to this mechanic, that killing creatures turns you into a genocidal maniac, is known to pretty much everyone.

Advertisement

However, the same cannot be said about how the game teaches you that every monster is able to be spared and this is why some players can make an early mistake that will haunt them for the rest of their playthrough.

The first boss of the game is Toriel, the fan-favorite goat mom, who challenges you to a fight to the death to prevent you from leaving her home.

Up until this encounter, sparing creatures works instantly, but when you try to click the spare button with Toriel, it doesn’t seem to do anything, so less patient players will eventually cave and end her life, even though Toriel is spareable—it just takes a lot of tries to convince her to stop fighting.

If you can’t figure this out, Toriel’s death will weigh on your consciousness for the rest of the campaign.

You will be given a chance to correct this mistake for a pacifist ending eventually, but the other characters will comment on it, and you will be branded a murderer.

15. Crossing The Bridge - King's Quest 2: Romancing The Throne

King’s Quest 2: Romancing the Throne is one of Sierra Entertainment’s point-and-click adventures. The game follows the adventures of King Graham as he tries to rescue his future wife from an evil witch, and as you would expect from its prequel, it is full of deadly and treacherous moments that punish you for making the wrong decision.

Advertisement

In fact, one moment in the game is so harsh about punishing reckless behavior that it can force you to repeat the whole game for it.

While traversing the map, the player has to pass a rope bridge suspended over a giant chasm. The construction isn’t the most stable, and every time you cross it, you will see a part of it fall off.

Indeed, the bridge will fully collapse after you cross it six times, which is actually the exact number of times you have to do it to complete all of the game’s missions.

This means that if you forget to do something while backtracking, you might end up having to cross the bridge one too many times, effectively softlocking yourself and rendering hours of playtime completely worthless.

14. Trusting MIllibelle - Hollow Knight

Although the world of Hollow Knight is ravaged by a horrible plague, the game still features a handful of friendly NPCs. This said, not all of them are trustworthy, and putting your faith in Millibelle in particular can have some really negative consequences on your game.

Advertisement

Millibelle is a merchant in Fog Canyon who offers one-of-a-kind banking services. For a small fee, she lets you deposit your excess Geos, preventing their potential loss should you die.

This seems like the perfect deal for safekeeping a ton of hard-earned Geos for the moment when you need them the most. However, Millibelle shows signs that she’s not the most trustworthy bug, such as the fact that she hides your stuff inside her shell instead of a vault.

If you ignore these signs and deposit over 2,000 Geo into her business, when you return to her “bank” later, Millibelle will be gone and the building will turn out to be a cardboard cutout.

Thankfully, you can find the thief in a pleasure house later in the game and regain all of your Geo, but if you needed it at a specific moment and Millibelle was nowhere to be found, the mistake can ruin your run.

13. Getting Drunk - Deep Rock Galactic

Deep Rock Galactic is a co-op shooter in which you and your friends play as sci-fi dwarves extracting precious ores from a planet crawling with giant space bugs.

Advertisement

True to their fantasy counterparts, Deep Rock dwarves love to drink ale, but getting wasted on company hours isn’t really advisable, especially if your job is being sent on suicide missions where it’s pretty useful to be able to shoot straight.

The Abyss bar in the game allows the player to buy drinks with the money they get from completed missions. While some of these drinks can actually provide useful buffs that carry over to your next gig, drinking too many of them can lead to your character’s vision getting heavily obscured… which can also carry over to the mission sections of the game—for their entire duration.

Although the drunk effect is pretty hilarious while you are in the hub area, once you descend to the mines to start your job, being unable to shoot or see upcoming bugs can lead to a total mission failure.

A drunk dwarf (or an entire drunken crew, for that matter) can even cost you an important mission that you won’t be able to repeat.

It’s time for an intervention.

12. Selling Your Flagship's Core - Highfleet

Highfleet is an indie strategy game set in an alternate reality dystopia where a climate disaster has led humanity to wage wars against each other using giant methane-powered airships.

Advertisement

You play as the commander of an entire fleet of these flying metal tombs with oversized turrets, and your goal is to capture the city of a rebel terrorist group before their forces grow too big to stop them.

The most important ship in your air navy is your starting flagship. If it ever gets destroyed, you get an instant game over, which is why you should rarely send it into combat and make extra sure that it's protected from enemy attacks.

Or your own stupidity, for that matter.

You don’t actually have to send the flagship into battle to put it at risk. You can also get an instant game over by accidentally dismantling the ship yourself.

Since customizing and upgrading your ships takes place in real time and it allows you to move any part of the ship you're editing, you can accidentally detach the flagship’s core, which will immediately cause it to drop to the ground and trigger a game over.

And that’s why you don’t mess with expensive equipment unless you’re a professional.

11. Cheating - Banjo-Kazooie

Banjo-Kazooie features a secret cheat room inside the Treasure Trove Cove map where the player can input codes to gain unfair advantages, but it’s also very clear about you not wanting to use it.

Advertisement

The first time you enter a cheat, the game will inform you that you will not be allowed to save with cheats enabled. The second time you do it, Bottles the mole will come in to warn you that if you continue and add a third cheat, the game will punish you by erasing your save file.

This seems like a pretty fair warning, considering what’s at stake here, and yet despite this, some players may still feel tempted to ignore the message and add more cheats anyway.

And that's how they get the taste of Grunty’s Code Vengeance.

As soon as you enter the third cheat, the evil witch Gruntilda will suddenly pop up on your screen, punishing you for ignoring Bottles' warning by irreversibly erasing your save.

If you’re far enough in the game, Grunty's curse can really sting, but at the same time, you can’t say they didn’t warn you.

10. Romancing Yennefer And Triss At Once - The Witcher 3

The Witcher 3 features two romance options: Geralt’s old flame Yennefer and Triss Merrigold, who had a short-lived affair with the legendary monster slayer after he temporarily lost his memory.

Advertisement

The game features special side quests that lead to a romance with one of these two powerful sorceresses, expecting you to pick one to be your lifelong companion.

However, since completing the romantic side quest of one woman doesn’t prevent you from doing the other, some players might have the “brilliant” idea to woo Yennefer and Triss at the same time.

Going with this plan will seem good at first, as the game actually features a side quest, “It Takes Three To Tango,” that is specifically about romancing both sorceresses together. However, although the quest begins with what looks to be a magical threesome in Geralt’s bedroom, both of the women quickly leave Geralt naked and humiliated, and the game permanently removes your ability to romance either of them.

Once you reach the end of the game, and Geralt is still lonely inside his Beauclair mansion, you’ll curse yourself for being a greedy Casanova.

9. Give The Hag Your Eye - Baldur's Gate 3

Baldur’s Gate 3 has a ton of dialogue options that leave a tangible impact on your game.

Advertisement

Just remember that this also applies to the bad choices you make, especially the ones that are blatantly terrible, such as giving your eye to a nefarious hag.

In Act 1, your adventuring party can stumble upon an evil hag known as Auntie Ethel.

Despite using illusions to make herself look like a sweet old lady and her swamp like a postcard from a fairy tale, it’s actually very easy to tell something isn’t right with Ethel, on account of her openly abusing her guest, Mayrina, or her knowing about you being infected with a mind flayer parasite.

Still, whether you see through her illusion or not, the hag will offer to remove the parasite from your head in exchange for your eye. And if you take the deal, it goes about as well as any promise from an evil fey.

Aside from Ethel being unable to cure your condition, the eye she takes from you grants a permanent disadvantage on perception checks and on attacks against hags.

If you’re dumb enough to trust a hag, you deserve to be unable to hit one.

8. Shooting Seagulls - Metal Gear Solid 2

Metal Gear Solid 2 puts you in the shoes of Raiden as he participates in his first espionage mission against dangerous terrorists.

Advertisement

As a member of FOXHOUND, you’re supposed to eliminate bad guys only, but as is usually the case with bored players, your trigger finger might start feeling itchy when your gun is pointed at innocent creatures instead.

The many seagulls that appear in the game can be shot, although the game will make a very quick point about the questionable morality of this decision. As soon as you take down one of the birds, Colonel Campbell will contact you to scold you for abusing helpless animals, and even your girlfriend Rose will chime in to call you a monster.

The two of them make it very clear that you shouldn’t kill seagulls, but if you continue doing it anyway, the game will punish you for your disobedience.

Not only will the seagulls eventually retaliate and attack you, but when you try to save the game, Rose will refuse to let you do it, as she is too appalled with your wanton cruelty.

At this point, your only option is to reload the game and remember to pay seagulls their due respect.

7. Sit And Wait - Furi

Furi is an unforgiving bullet hell where you go up against a progressively more ruthless gauntlet of bosses.

Advertisement

Each fight seems to be getting harder than the last, which is why whenever you defeat a boss, that short period of time when you walk up to the next arena feels like exactly what you need to unwind and relax.

Just make sure you don’t do it too much when you’re about to fight the Song, as this mistake can cost you everything.

The Song is an empathetic boss that offers the protagonist to stay with him and keep him company inside the prison if he just gives up his fight for freedom.

It’s easy to disregard the Song’s proposition as a bit of flavor dialogue, but in reality, if you actually wait long enough in front of her arena, you’ll trigger a secret ending where your character actually decides to stay with the Song.

And while this may sound like a fun easter egg, if you were planning on finishing the game, the secret ending actually erases your save file, forcing you to start all over.

Next time, pick your resting place a little more carefully.

6. Siding With The Kuei-Jin - Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines

Vampire: The Masquerade—Bloodlines is an RPG where you’re put in the role of a fledgling vampire trying to find their place within the bloodsucking community.

Advertisement

Throughout the game you have to decide which vampiric society you’re going to support. Your most obvious choices are the two major vampire sects in Los Angeles, although you can also secretly join a third group… and immediately regret not picking up on their obvious red flags.

The Kuei-jin are the mysterious vampires from Asia that serve as the third side of the imminent vampire war in Los Angeles. Their leader, Ming Xiao, tells you several times that their kind doesn’t get along with Western vampires, but in the final act of the game, when your character is hunted by the Camarilla, you can ask them for help anyway.

This will let you play through the final act as normal, but in the final cutscene, the Kuei-jin take over the city.

Your reward for helping the people who openly called you inferior to them is, quite obviously, getting stuffed inside a sarcophagus and then dropped into the bottom of the ocean.

And if you want to fix this outcome, now you have to backtrack all the way to the start of the final act. Great.

5. Helping Playboy X - Grand Theft Auto IV

Grand Theft Auto IV tells a gritty story of Niko Bellic’s rise to the top of Liberty City’s criminal underbelly.

Advertisement

Niko's employers are rarely reputable people, but there is one situation when the game will actively punish you for naively trusting the wrong side of the conflict.

During the mission where you have to settle a dispute between the rising drug dealer, Playboy X, and his old mentor, Dwayne, who was recently released from prison, Playboy will ask you to assassinate Dwayne out of fear of losing his empire.

If you followed the story, you’ll realize that Playboy is an especially greedy and selfish person, and the only reason why he’s as successful as he is is because he betrayed Dwayne and took over his drug business after cutting all contact with him.

If you still trust Playboy after learning this, your reward for killing Dwayne is a measly $25,000, and Playboy immediately removes you from his contacts list.

On the other hand, if you help Dwayne instead, you get permanent access to Playboy’s mansion that you cannot obtain otherwise, and Dwayne becomes your friend for the rest of the game.

Who knew trusting a self-serving coward would be a rip-off?

4. Mole-Rat Disease - Fallout 4

The quest “Hole in the Wall” from Fallout 4 has you uncover the secrets of Vault 81 to save a young boy named Austin from a seemingly incurable mole rat disease.

Advertisement

However, if you’re not careful, you might end up catching something permanent yourself in the process.

During the mission, you discover a hidden research facility underneath Austin’s underground home. It turns out that Vault-Tec built Vault 81 to secretly develop cures for viral diseases by releasing them on the bunker's population. The scientists died before they could finish their research, leaving the hidden wing abandoned and crawling with a horde of highly infectious mole rats.

Now, since Austin was infected due to one of these oversized rodents biting him, the smart player will do their best to avoid the mole rats' attacks.

However, if you don't, the rodents will infect you with their disease without the game informing you about it, giving you a permanent debuff to your health.

The only way to cure this condition is to use the cure you were supposed to recover for Austin, and if you didn’t bother to check your stats, chances are, you’re going to give it to the kid or sell it before you realize you need it.

Enjoy your incurable disease!

3. Blappy's Offer - Super Paper Mario

Super Paper Mario is a cheeky RPG that loves to toy with the player. Most interactions in the game are either a hidden joke or a prank, so you'd be wise to learn to anticipate the next punchline at some point.

Advertisement

Otherwise, you might pay the literal price for your ignorance with Blappy.

Blappy is one of the aliens from Planet Blouble who offers to sell Mario the Ancient Clue that will lead him to the “Big Treasure of Space” (in reality, it’s one of the Pure Hearts, which you collect as part of the main story).

The price of the clue is quite steep, as Blappy wants 1,000 coins for it. However, if you decline his offer, the alien will actually lower the price.

Just make sure you don’t overdo it, because even though refusing the offer once will lower the price to 100 coins and doing so again to just 10 coins, if you get greedy and fall for the game’s bait, the third time around Blappy will get angry at you and irreversibly leave the price at 1,000.

Unless you want to cough up an insane amount of coins, learn to cash out at the right time.

2. Complete Kara's Brainwashing - Detroit: Become Human

The story of Detroit: Become Human is determined by choices, both deliberate and accidental. Failing a QTE can often impact your game just as much as a self-made decision.

Advertisement

In fact, failing one of the easiest QTEs in the game can permanently cost you one of your playable characters.

When playing as Kara and Alice, you eventually reach a point where the two of them visit Zlatko, a human smuggler who supposedly helps deviant androids cross the US border to Canada.

While inside Zlatko's house, it quickly becomes obvious that the man isn’t who he claims he is, and he actually preys on desperate androids, brainwashing them and then using them as toys for torture.

The player is supposed to pick up on this so that when Kara is placed inside Zlatko’s brainwashing machine, they immediately try to escape it.

However, if you weren’t paying attention, or you somehow failed the sequence’s incredibly easy QTEs, a cutscene will play showing Kara becoming Zlatko’s personal slave, and then the android will be removed from the list of playable characters for the rest of the game.

Seriously, this is the most avoidable death in the game.

1. Forgetting About President Myers - Cyberpunk 2077

Cyberpunk 2077 delivers a rich and engaging story, but with this said, it is also a mostly linear experience. It’s almost impossible to not finish every mission in the game if you just explore enough of Night City, although there is one pretty big exception.

Advertisement

The DLC content.

Owning Phantom Liberty is only half of what it takes to play it. The other half is making sure that you don't forget to do the one thing that enables you to start the expansion's main storyline.

The plot of Phantom Liberty is triggered by the mission “Dog Eat Dog,” in which a mysterious netrunner called Songbird contacts V, asking them to help her rescue the President of the New United States from a crashing plane.

The call is obviously urgent, but following video game logic, you might assume that the plane falling out of Night City’s sky will magically suspend itself in air until you get to dealing with it.

Well, think again, because if you ignore the mission for too long, eventually President Myers’ plane will crash, instantly failing the mission and preventing you from experiencing Phantom Liberty’s content, along with all of its unique rewards, for the rest of the game.

Advertisement