20 Stupid Decisions That Destroyed Their Franchise

We'll never forgive these terrible choices for killing classic video game franchises.

By Jordan Blum /

The gaming industry has made a lot of bad choices over the years, such as letting the routinely abysmal LJN publish games during the NES era or forcing shoddy motion-sensing peripherals on players throughout the 2000s and 2010s. However, such disastrous moves rarely result in the complete annihilation of an entire franchise.

Advertisement

It does happen, though, and with increasing regularity and foolishness as creators and businesses bet on outdated and/or misguided trajectories with little awareness of – or concern for – how the interests and sensibilities of gaming enthusiasts have changed.

These transgressions can occur both within and outside of specific projects as well.

For instance, developers and publishers might: alter essential gameplay mechanics and perspectives; shift the series’ personality and tone; deliver a detrimentally broken experience; or greedily rely on trends that either don’t fit with a given title’s legacy or arrive long after said trend has become unappealing and oversaturated.

Regardless, and as the 20 cases on this list prove, it takes only one erroneous decision to destroy a franchise. Granted, the games themselves might not be bad, but the choices surrounding them did such irrevocable damage that their respective franchises have yet to recover.

Obviously, you might have mixed feelings about some of these examples, which is all the more reason to dive in and see how you feel about the arguments ahead!

20. A Live-Service Pivot - Ghost Recon Frontlines

Premiering with Tom Clancy’s Ghost Recon in 2001, the Ghost Recon series offered a broader and more strategic/militaristic alternative to Rainbow Six’s close-quarters tactical tension. As with any long-running video game venture, its commercial and critical results have fluctuated since then, but the franchise nonetheless remained a worthwhile pursuit for Ubisoft.

Advertisement

Then came 2019’s Division-esque Breakpoint, which embraced one of the industry’s worst modern fads: live-service hijinks. That inclusion – plus forced NFTs, repetitious missions, copy-and-paste open-world design, and a lack of a central identity – led to disappointing sales and abandonment from discouraged players. True, the backlash against microtransactions eventually forced Ubisoft to remove some of them, but the damage was done.

Rather than reverse their increasingly formulaic direction and recapture their singular allure with their next attempt, they chose to fully jump the shark with the free-to-play live-service MMO battle royale monstrosity of Ghost Recon Frontline.

It was announced in October of 2021, and early glimpses drew disheartened comparisons to Call of Duty: Warzone, thereby highlighting how much Ghost Recon had moved away from its roots. The criticism intensified after footage of the early 2022 beta test leaked, and by July, Ghost Recon Frontline was canceled and the Ghost Recon name was further tarnished.

A new title might be on the way, but as the saying goes, seeing is believing.

19. Moving The Devs To Deadpool - Transformers: Rise of the Dark Spark

Successfully turning movies and TV shows into video games – and vice versa – is notoriously difficult.

Advertisement

As letdowns such as 1997’s Beast Wars: Transformers and 2007’s Transformers: The Game exemplify, the Transformers brand is no exception. That said, High Moon Studios cracked the code with their early 2010s trio: War for Cybertron, Dark of the Moon, and Fall of Cybertron.

Okay, 2011’s Dark of the Moon got mixed-to-negative reviews, but 2010’s War for Cybertron was a vast improvement over what preceded it and 2012’s Fall of Cybertron was even more adored. In fact, it’s frequently seen as the best Transformers game of all time, with a tempting cliffhanger that saw both the Autobots and Decepticons going to Earth.

Obviously, publisher Activision should’ve let High Moon conclude their Cybertron trilogy with equivalent levels of narrative and gameplay quality. Instead, they forced High Moon to work on 2013’s mediocre Deadpool while having Edge of Reality and WayForward Technologies churn out a lackluster conclusion – Rise of the Dark Spark – that prioritized connecting to the live-action Transformers films.

Unsurprisingly, its poor reception prevented additional Cybertron entries, and although WayForward were able to keep pursuing fresh projects, High Moon have been relegated to supplemental Call of Duty duties. As for the now-closed Edge of Reality, Rise of the Dark Spark was their swan song.

18. Any Activision IP That Isn't Call of Duty - Activision Switches All Studios to Call of Duty

Speaking of Activision moving developers to Call of Duty, High Moon are one of numerous studios who’re now forced to help keep Activision’s main cash cow going.

Advertisement

For instance, Raven Software – who worked on the Soldier of Fortune, Star Wars: Jedi Knight, and X-Men Legends games – have been tied to Call of Duty since 2010’s Black Ops. Whether directly or indirectly, that might explain why those other properties haven’t resurfaced.

Similarly, Treyarch crafted several Spider-Man and extreme sports titles in the early 2000s before Activision put them on 2005’s Call of Duty: Big Red One. They were able to work on extra projects in the late 2000s, yet they too became permanently stuck to Call of Duty with 2010’s Black Ops.

More recently, Beenox took charge with Spider-Man and Skylanders in the 2010s but were moved to Call of Duty with 2016’s Modern Warfare Remastered.

Yes, they had a hand in 2019’s Crash Team Racing Nitro-Fueled and 2020’s Crash Bandicoot 4, but the latter title’s failure to meet Activision’s financial expectations is another reason why Activision and their studios – which also include Infinity Ward and Sledgehammer Games – aren’t straying from Call of Duty.

Ironically, the surprisingly low sales of Black Ops 7’s could suggest that Call of Duty is overstaying its welcome and Activision should pivot toward other IPs again.

17. Not Knowing When To Quit - Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six Siege

Debuting in 2015, Tom Clancy’s Rainbow Six Siege began as the series’ savior, with its online-only tactical multiplayer focus breathing new life into the license after the cancellation of the intriguingly atypical Rainbow 6: Patriots. Thus, it was the first mainline installment since 2008’s Rainbow Six: Vegas 2, and fans couldn’t get enough of it.

Advertisement

Ironically, however, Siege’s towering triumph has motivated Ubisoft to continually milk it with new changes and features for over 10 years instead of giving Siege a proper follow-up.

Ubisoft’s approach has spawned dozens of seasonal DLC to sustain Siege’s relevancy within the esports space. Last year, the company celebrated the game’s 10-year anniversary with its “largest and most transformative update” – Siege X – which introduced a new 6v6 mode called Dual Front alongside extra maps and various aesthetic and functional upgrades.

In December of 2025, creative director Alexander Karpazis told GameSpot that Siege 2 isn’t happening because they don’t want players feeling like they got “the rug pulled out from under them” with “changes.” He added: “There's also an element of, this is an amazing legacy we're building—why would we want to throw that away?"

Yes, console spin-off Rainbow Six Extraction showed up in 2022 and there’ve been a couple of mobile offshoots since then, but clearly there’s no new mainline title on the horizon.

16. Switching Tones - Watch Dogs: Legion

Despite netting mostly positive review scores and selling well, 2014’s Watch Dogs fell short in several areas. Chief among them was its superficial yet overly serious tale of hacking, spying, murder, and revenge set within the dark underbelly of Chicago in autumn.

Advertisement

It’s no wonder, then, why Ubisoft Montreal brightened their 2016 sequel both visually – changing the setting to the San Francisco Bay Area – and tonally – with more lighthearted characters and storytelling – to produce greater results. Luckily, their plan succeeded, with Watch Dogs 2 eventually earning comparable sales while almost universally being seen as superior to its predecessor.

That brings us to 2020’s Watch Dogs: Legion, a game that was detrimentally at odds with itself.

On one hand, its major new mechanic – inhabiting countless NPCs in the open world – encouraged amusingly incongruous experimentations because said NPCs included senior citizens, magicians, beekeepers, beatboxers, furries, and people suffering from flatulence. Legion’s British humor and extensive character customization options also lent themselves to the game's potential ludicrousness.

At the same time, its dystopic future London backdrop and prophetically Orwellian threads of terrorist bombings, mass surveillance, populism, human trafficking, automated technologies, and human obsolescence directly conflicted with those goofier attributes.

Legion’s tonal dissonance was extremely divisive, ultimately hitting Ubisoft where it hurts – their wallet – and leaving the Watch Dogs IP in limbo.

15. Sidelining Stealth - Splinter Cell: Conviction / Blacklist

If there was any stealth-action franchise that gave Metal Gear Solid a run for its money in the 2000s, it’s Tom Clancy’s Splinter Cell.

Advertisement

Across the decade, fans received four extremely enjoyable console entries – the self-titled original, Pandora Tomorrow, Chaos Theory, and Double Agent – that put more weight on complex covertness, sensible plot beats, and enticing gadget flexibility compared to MGS. Even the main protagonist/voice actor pairing of Sam Fisher/Michael Ironside offered a markedly different but arguably equivalent experience to MGS’ union of Solid Snake/David Hayter.

Like virtually all worthwhile continuations, each one brought new things to the table without sacrificing the essence of Splinter Cell’s winning formula. Well, that is until 2010’s Conviction and – to a much lesser extent – 2013’s Blacklist sidelined being sneaky.

Conviction was designed to welcome newcomers by moving away from what the creators felt was too “hardcore” about past chapters. That meant introducing new features such as “Mark & Execute” and “Last Known Position,” respectively, so gamers could shoot multiple targets at once and avoid alerted guards by seeing their silhouettes. Accordingly, stealth mechanics such as hacking, lock picking, whistling and hiding bodies were removed.

Predictably, this upset a healthy portion of the audience, which is why the improved but underappreciated Blacklist – which controversially lost Michael Ironside – underperformed financially and put Splinter Cell on ice.

14. Going Live-Service – Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League (Batman: Arkham Series)

Honestly, Rocksteady’s initially impeccable Batman: Arkham saga started faltering long before 2024’s Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League delivered its death blow.

Advertisement

For one thing, main trilogy finale Arkham Knight underwhelmed with weaker storytelling, irritating Batmobile sections, and a plethora of PC issues. Furthermore, the mixed reception of prequel Arkham Origins and spin-off Gotham Knights – neither of which was developed by Rocksteady – cemented the Arkham series’ diminishing status.

Nevertheless, Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League was the final nail in the coffin. Sure, it looked great and had entertaining cinematics, but its moment-to-moment monotony, egregious glitches, uninvolving narrative, and lack of cultural cachet – emphasizing characters who’d recently failed twice to sufficiently charm moviegoers – meant that it was dead on arrival.

Its biggest sin, though, was tapping into a trend it had no business exploiting: live-service shenanigans.

On the surface, it maintained the Arkham games’ identity, but digging deeper revealed a significantly blander and less distinguished core plagued by the usual tropes: early access greediness; premium in-game purchases with multiple currencies; tedious looting, grinding, and crafting with multiple weapon classes; obnoxious menus and statistics; and overly familiar four-player looter shooter co-op.

Throw in the usual slow drip of dull post-launch content and it’s obvious why Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League ended up murdering the Arkham franchise's future instead.

13. Ditching Single-Player - Overwatch 2

2016’s Overwatch was hugely successful and beloved, bolstering the hero shooter subgenre with its lovably energetic gameplay, characters, and personality. In fact, it remained so popular that when its sequel was announced in late 2019, many players dismissed it as wholly superfluous.

Advertisement

However, preliminary promises of new modes, heroes, maps, and a greater focus on story assuaged some fears and garnered more interest from the community. In particular, the prospect of single-player content – plus a hefty PvE (Player versus Environment) co-op mode designed to foster a connected narrative with cutscenes and unique character agency – seemingly legitimized Overwatch 2’s existence.

After all, past multiplayer-only FPS titles drew criticism for not giving solo players enough to do, and making the follow-up to an immensely fashionable IP would’ve been the perfect time to rectify that.

Of course, Blizzard scrapped those schemes before launch to prioritize refining Overwatch 2’s PvP (Player versus Player) systems. Understandably, much of the fanbase felt deceived by pre-release marketing and journalism while also feeling less confident that the game would sufficiently differentiate itself from its predecessor.

Eventually, Blizzard promised that the PvE content would arrive post-launch, but despite a few missions subsequently appearing, they largely abandoned their vision. By the time story-less single-player mode Hero Mastery emerged in late 2023, the brand’s reputation was already seriously weakened.

12. Shifting Art Direction - Killzone: Shadow Fall

Killzone: Shadow Fall is an interesting case of a good thing becoming a bad thing.

Advertisement

Arriving at the end of 2013 as a launch title for the PlayStation 4, it was touted as the best technical showpiece for Sony’s latest console. Indeed, its draw distances, particle effects, and volumetric lighting alone made people’s jaws drop, and it still looks superb nearly 15 years later.

That said, once the dust and debris settled – or, rather, the lack of dust and debris – it was easy to see that by showcasing a brighter and more vibrant future, Shadow Fall substantially deserted the gray griminess that defined the war-torn dystopia of its ancestors.

A cursory comparison of images and videos between Shadow Fall and the original trilogy is all that’s needed to see how severely developer Guerrilla Games shifted the series’ art direction.

True, the first three titles’ uniformly gray dreariness left little room for variety or awe-inspiring spectacle, but it was a huge part of the initial trio’s idiosyncratic allure. In contrast, Shadow Fall’s radiant colours lacked that same distinctive oppressiveness and ominousness amid inviting comparisons to other FPS flagships such as Far Cry and Crysis.

Shadow Fall also looked a bit like Guerilla Games’ next venture – Horizon Zero Dawn – and neither they nor another studio seem interested in resurrecting Killzone’s bleak universe.

11. Archaic Design – Shenmue III

1999’s Shenmue is among the most influential video games of all time, with its innovative use of QTEs; realistic storytelling; and rich open-world Japanese immersion – including flexible day/night cycles and weather systems alongside advanced NPC programming – revolutionizing the medium.

Advertisement

Naturally, 2001’s Shenmue II largely improved upon its predecessor, leaving diehard fans salivating for the trilogy’s final chapter.

Sadly, the series’ poor sales meant that Shenmue III’s future remained uncertain and in development hell until creator Yu Suzuki announced a Kickstarter crowdfunding campaign for it at E3 2015. Endearingly, it met its $2 million goal in fewer than 12 hours – with a final total of $6.3 million – and backers expected it to conclude the saga in a satisfyingly nostalgic yet modernized way.

That’s the opposite of what happened, though, as Shenmue III was seen as a staggeringly archaic misstep when it hit physical and digital store shelves in 2019.

Specifically, Shenmue III was notably slammed by the gaming press for being a relic of a bygone era due to its technical issues and recycled and/or regressive mechanics, locations, writing, and music. We’re talking stationary NPCs, disruptive QTEs, sloppy dialogue, diluted narrative beats, subpar visuals, and reused songs from Shenmue II.

Evidently, Shenmue III was too faithful to its roots, and consequently, Suzuki’s planned Shenmue IV hasn’t gathered much steam.

10. Rushed and Shoddy Development – Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 5

It’s nearly impossible to overstate the cultural impact of the original Tony Hawk’s games. Not only did they revolutionize and popularize the extreme sports subgenre, but they also shaped the personalities, fashion, and music tastes of their target teenager demographic.

Advertisement

Regrettably, the yearly grind to put out new titles began backfiring in the mid-2000s, with unfocused but still solid offerings eventually devolving into uninspired obligations and/or overly expensive, broken, and gimmicky messes.

Admittedly, the series already fell from grace when Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 5 released; yet, it was marketed as a proper return to the revered Pro Skater brand, so many longtime fans expected tons of nostalgic feels and fun from it.

Unfortunately, it was created by the unreliable Robomodo as a blatant cash grab before the licensing deal between Tony Hawk and Activision expired, resulting in a rushed, shoddy, and massively disappointing disaster.

Everything about Tony Hawk’s Pro Skate 5 – from its outdated graphics and gameplay to its bland levels, wrecked physics, repetitious goals and lackluster roster – felt like a slap in the face to fans and Tony Hawk’s legacy.

Unsurprisingly, it was a critical and commercial catastrophe, and despite how awesome the recent remakes of the first four Pro Skater games are, Pro Skater 5 killed the chances of there being a entirely new Tony Hawk’s experience.

9. Reductive & Rhythmic Combat – Def Jam: Icon

Hip-hop often involves rivalries between rappers, so it’s both logical and ludacris – pun intended – to pit them against each other in virtual worlds. Developers AKI Corporation and EA Canada knew that well, which is why they struck gold twice with 2003’s Def Jam Vendetta and 2004’s Def Jam: Fight for NY.

Advertisement

Not only did the duo collectively feature major artists such as DMX, Method Man, Snoop Dogg, Lil’ Kim, Busta Ryhmes, Flavor Flav, and Ice-T, but they also embraced the larger hip-hop culture through authentic locales, fashion, personalities, and storytelling. This meant that both titles appealed to hip-hop lovers and fighting/wrestling game lovers alike.

When developmental duties switched to EA Chicago for Def Jam: Icon, however, so too did certain mechanics that ended up angering fans and irrevocably derailing the Def Jam train.

Basically, Def Jam: Icon diminished the series’ attractively absurd wrestling DNA and introduced interactivity between the soundtrack and gameplay by synching environmental hazards to the rhythms of the music. Additional damage was done if a fighter’s moves matched the beats or if their song was playing as well, and players could even spin the right analog stick like a turntable to manipulate tracks.

Clearly, the more grounded Def Jam: Icon was too much of a remix, which is why many returning brawlers outright rejected it.

8. Going 3D – Earthworm Jim 3D

The first two Earthworm Jim journeys didn’t measure up to their Sonic the Hedgehog and Super Mario Bros. counterparts. Yet, their solid gameplay, imaginative level design, appealing art direction, and boldly bizarre humor made them cult classics of the 16-bit 2D run-and-gun platformer era.

Advertisement

Developmental duties for the third title shifted from Shiny Entertainment to VIS Interactive, though, whose only prior creation – 1998’s H.E.D.Z. – garnered negative reviews. Still, VIS Interactive could’ve redeemed themselves with their second effort, especially because they were attempting to give Earthworm Jim the same successful leap into 3D that Mario got with Super Mario 64 three years earlier.

Sadly, Earthworm Jim 3D ended up resembling the ugly and monotonous dumpster fire of 1996’s Bubsy 3D instead, and 30 years later, both are considered among the worst 3D platformers of all time.

The game went through development hell, leading to open levels and boss fights whose lifelessness and repetitiveness were in stark contrast to the continually imaginative and robust offerings of Earthworm Jim 3D's mainline precursors. The wonky camera was unbearable, too, among many other issues.

Consequently, little of what came out afterward did well, and multiple titles were canceled. There hasn’t been a new Earthworm Jim adventure since 1999’s Earthworm Jim: Menace 2 the Galaxy, either, so he'll almost certainly never come out of retirement.

7. Lost Sight of Prehistoric Scares – Dino Crisis 3

Video game history is full of misguided attempts to change something fundamental about a long-running and treasured horror property. The drastic departures of Resident Evil 5/6 and Dead Space 3 – from terrifying survival horror endurance tests to excessive action blockbusters – are the most infamous instances, but Dino Crisis 3 deserves as much disgrace for its wrongdoings.

Advertisement

Specifically, it ditched the island/jungle destinations of Dino Crisis and Dino Crisis 2 for the ludicrous locale of a space station. As the Hellraiser, Leprechaun, and Friday the 13th film franchises previously proved, going into space is the clichéd sign of creative bankruptcy in the horror world.

Granted, the silliness of having dinosaurs terrorize a crew of armed cosmic explorers could work in a self-aware B-movie kind of way. But, the game is completely genuine with its preposterous premise, and either way, going so sci-fi is inherently antithetical to what Dino Crisis should be.

Dino Crisis 3 took place several hundred years after Dino Crisis 2, too, so it couldn’t bring back protagonist Regina or have strong ties to its predecessors in other ways. Its janky camera, unfair difficulty, and outrageously enormous environments only added salt into the wound as well.

There have been talks of rebooting the Dino Crisis brand – whether with a sequel, spinoff, or remake – but nothing’s gotten off the ground.

6. The Dystopic Direction - Bomberman: Act Zero

For the first 25 years or so of its existence, the Bomberman series stuck to its sturdy formula of having cute characters face-off with bombs in mazes to either eliminate each other or be the first to reach the stage’s exit.

Advertisement

No matter how the gameplay and graphics adapted over time, the franchise retained its adorable and unmistakably Japanese look. Sure, sales fluctuated along the way, but the triumphs of entries such as the Nintendo DS’ Bomberman Land Touch! and Bomberman 2005 illustrated that people still loved the little guy.

What players demonstrably didn’t want was for Bomberman to transform into a run-of-the-mill dystopic future shooter with a bleak tone and gritty presentation. Bafflingly, though, that’s exactly where Hudson Soft took gaming’s most endearing explosives enthusiast with Bomberman: Act Zero.

By swapping the series’ signature childlike charm for a gustier and more realistic ripoff of other robot/alien aesthetics – Halo, Mega Man, and Metroid, anyone? – Bomberman: Act Zero abandoned the core of what makes Bomberman so enchanting and amusing. For god’s sake, the female version is sexualized like a Soul Calibur or Mortal Kombat combatant!

The addition of a new mode called First-Person Battle cemented how far Bomberman: Act Zero strayed from its reliable roots, and while other Bomberman games came out afterward, the franchise hasn’t reclaimed to its former glory.

5. Out of Touch Humor – Duke Nukem Forever

By and large, people react quite differently to toxic masculinity and offensive comedy today compared to at the end of the 20th century. After all, the 1990s were all about edgy entertainment, counterculture fashion, and other markers of youth defiance and individuality.

Advertisement

That’s why the original Duke Nukem trilogy’s crass humor – centered around parodying 1980s action/sci-fi movie machismo and misogyny – amused fans. In fact, 3D Realms’ ridiculous but innovative Duke Nukem 3D helped popularize the first-person shooter subgenre in 1996. So, the next logical step was to produce and ship its sequel, Duke Nukem Forever, by the end of 1998.

Well, that was the plan, anyway.

In actuality, the title faced legendary delays as it combated significant changes in direction, game engines, and staff sizes. Ultimately, it took almost 15 years for Duke Nukem Forever to arrive, and when it did, its contents and reception were less than ideal.

The real nail in the coffin was the game being outdated mechanically, narratively, and tonally due to its corny pop culture references, sexist depictions of women, and – per Destructoid – representation of the titular badass as “a vile, callous, thoroughly detestable psychopath.”

Duke Nukem may’ve been awesome decades ago, but he was clearly antiquated and abhorrent in 2011, and if his gimmicks no longer worked back then, they definitely wouldn’t work now.

4. Mandatory Motion Controls – Star Fox Zero

Despite being a second-tier Nintendo mascot, Star Fox stayed relevant throughout the SNES, Nintendo 64, and GameCube eras. That’s due as much to his cool visage and lore as it is his great mainline voyages and guest appearance in other places.

Advertisement

Commendably, if divisively, his GameCube outings – 2002’s Star Fox Adventures and 2005’s Star Fox: Assault – mixed his trademark on-rails shooting with 3D action-adventure platforming, combat, puzzle-solving, and the like. Overall, people enjoyed them, but there was still a desire for Star Fox’s simpler days of exclusively shooting bad guys in his Arwing ship.

After waiting over a decade for a console sequel, Star Fox devotees were given 2016’s Star Fox Zero on Wii U. It should’ve been precisely what those fans wanted, but in practice, it was marred by several issues that held it back. Like countless other titles of the time, its biggest flaw was its egregious and awkward use of motion controls.

Numerous journalists chastised Nintendo for requiring players to divide their attention between their TV screens and the Wii U gamepad. Plus, the game controlled poorly anyway, and although it may’ve made sense for the company to embrace the ongoing motion control trend while showcasing their new hardware, they did it the wrong way.

Nintendo are doing their best to bring back Fox with an appearance in the Super Mario Galaxy Movie and a remake of the Nintendo 64 game, but the scars of the previous attempt to revitalise the series are still there even a decade on.

3. Generic Approach – Bionic Commando (2009)

A staple of late 1980s gaming, the first Bionic Commando was a highly respected and influential action/adventure platformer.

Advertisement

In particular, its lack of a jump mechanic and emphasis on grappling directly or indirectly inspired successors such as Earthworm Jim, Axiom Verge, Just Cause, Shadow Complex, Tomb Raider, and Katana Zero.

True, only a handful of follow-ups arose over the subsequent 20 years, so Bionic Commando wasn’t exactly an A-list franchise throughout the 1990s and 2000s. Yet, 2008’s upgraded remake of the original pioneer – Bionic Commando Rearmed – was big enough to reignite interest. 

Consequently, Capcom decided to create a fresh entry to bolster that momentum. Regrettably, though, 2009’s Bionic Commando had the opposite effect.

By deviating from a 2D sideview to a 3D over-the-shoulder perspective – and by allowing protagonist Nathan Spencer to jump – the game lost its specialness. Beyond that, its storyline – which saw Spencer killing terrorists to save his wife – was unusually humorless and bland.

Spencer’s redesign – from comic book cool and colourful to realistically drab and dirty – didn’t work, either.

Bionic Commando was such a misfire that it hurt the development and reception of 2011’s Bionic Commando Rearmed 2 and partially led to developer Grin declaring bankruptcy in 2009. With no one else taking over, the series has been silent for 15 years.

2. Vehicle Construction Over Pure Platforming – Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts

The 1990s was arguably the heyday of 3D platformers, with key entries in the worlds of Super Mario Bros., Rayman, Donkey Kong, Spyro the Dragon, and Crash Bandicoot continuing to delight nostalgic players. Of course, the self-titled quirky romp starring gaming’s eminent bear-and-bird duo, Banjo-Kazooie, is right there alongside them.

Advertisement

Released in 1998, Banjo-Kazooie remains revered for nailing many prerequisites of the subgenre, including a distinctive tone, gratifying collectibles, creative worlds, likeable characters, and fun challenges. Honestly, it’s on par with everything else that came out back then, and despite being more experimental, direct sequel Banjo-Tooie retained the spirit of what made its predecessor so beloved.

All developer Rare had to do with the long-awaited third chapter in their saga – 2008’s Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts – was sustain the same magic. Instead, they foolishly removed the, well, nuts and bolts of the recipe – exploration-focused platforming – and confused their loyal fanbase with a vehicle construction simulator that too few people wanted.

Whereas many critics enjoyed Banjo and Kazooie’s retooled adventure to some degree, just as many consumers were disinterested and disappointed by it – if not outright enraged – and they showed their distain by ensuring that Nuts & Bolts stumbled commercially.

Unsurprisingly, the series’ reputation was permanently damaged, leading Rare and parent company Microsoft to focus on other projects moving forward.

1. A More Generic & Safe Direction - Saints Row (2022)

However polarizing it became, the Saints Row series’ penchant for ridiculous characters, absurd plotlines, self-aware humor, and lovingly juvenile weaponry – including sex toys and guns that launch sharks and mollusks – was as inherent to its identity as its overt Grand Theft Auto inspirations.

Advertisement

Sure, the games probably got too mindless after 2011’s Saints Row: The Third, but there was still a decent amount of interest from the press and public in seeing the Third Street Saints’ future shenanigans.

Unfortunately, returning developer and publisher Volition and Deep Silver, respectively, screwed up royally with their 2022 reboot. 

How? By replacing Saints Row’s trademark brazen edginess and ludicrousness with a safer, blander, and more cringe-inducingly serious reimagining.

The game attempted to recall the shock and silliness of yesteryear, but it landed with the try-hard corniness of millennial aunts and uncles making “six-seven” references to their Gen Alpha nieces and nephews. Naturally, that performative lameness – coupled with bugs, dull missions, unlikable hipster protagonists, generic graphics, and narrative inconsistencies – resulted in an almost complete rejection of the experience.

As of this writing, Saints Row 2022 has a 3.3 user score on Metacritic, and with a huge hit to overseer Embracer Group’s stock price after its arrival, it’s fair to say that the Saints won’t come marching in again anytime soon.

Advertisement