15 Video Game Mysteries Answered Years Later
These video game mysteries baffled players until years after their initial release.
Video games are a treasure trove of secrets and mysteries just waiting to be discovered. With the advance of technology and social media, its pretty common for players to share secrets they've found tucked away in their favourite games with the wider community. This then triggers plenty of speculation and discourse, often widening a game's lore and sending players down rabbit holes that can sometimes be surprisingly deep.
So deep, in fact, that some of these puzzling quirks don't actually get solved until years later, if at all. For the 15 entries on this list, it took years for players to finally figure out the meaning behind these mysteries....
15. Banjo-Kazooie: Stop N' Swop
Banjo-Kazooie and its sequel Banjo-Tooie remain some of the greatest 3D platformers ever made. Dense with secrets from start to finish, the original game sees you exploring a witch's castle hunting for Banjo's kidnapped sister. It's not an easy game to complete, and it's even tougher to 100% with the amount of collectibles on offer.
For those that did 100% it, they were shown a mysterious sequence involving two coloured eggs and an ice key hidden away in the game's numerous worlds in unreachable areas. This led players to ask an obvious question: how the heck were they supposed to collect these items? It turns out that there were a total of six coloured eggs and the ice key hidden away, with hackers eventually discovering codes that allowed players to access them.
Eventually, years later, one of Rare's developers Paul Machacek explained they had designed 'Stop N Swop' as a way for N64 games to communicate with each other. The idea was that players would swap cartridges while their N64 was still running (likely after collecting those items), quickly swapping it for the sequel, Banjo-Tooie, fast enough that information would be retained and used between the two games. Unfortunately, this was far more ambitious than the technology would allow, so it became an urban myth until years of investigation and Rare's later comments during interviews revealed the true plans.
14. Final Fantasy VII: Who Was Zack Fair?
The original Final Fantasy VII is an absolutely HUGE JRPG packed to the brim with characters, secrets and mysteries to uncover. As the protagonist Cloud Strife's backstory is slowly told through a series of flashbacks and interactions, players find themselves with a bunch of questions to ask. However, not all of these questions are answered by the time the credits roll. One of the main enduring mysteries for fans who picked up the game in the late 90s was, who is Zack Fair and what role did he play in Cloud's backstory?
Cloud's fragmented memories initially showed him as a part of an elite faction known as SOLDIER- or at least he thought he was. In these flashbacks, his own body kept switching with the mysterious Zack's, leaving fans wondering what was going on.
10 years later, Final Fantasy VII: Crisis Core was released, a game that put Zack front and centre and finally told his story in full. It turns out that Zack was actually the SOLDIER, a man who befriended Cloud and Aerith before eventually being kidnapped, and escaping only to be gunned down by Shinra troops. Before dying, he had asked Cloud to carry on his legacy, giving him the infamous Buster Sword. This trauma had caused Cloud to adopt elements of Zack's identity, muddying the timeline and leaving players initially confused after the original game's 1997 release.
13. Mortal Kombat II: Who Was Noob Saibot?
Mortal Kombat has one of the most memorable and recognizable character rosters in any fighting game ever made. The likes of Goro, Scorpion and Raiden are easy to identify thanks to outlandish costume designs and sometimes hideous appearances. The second mainline instalment introduced several new faces when it released in 1993. Characters like Kitana and Kung Lao made their debuts, and went on to have long legacies in the franchise.
One of the strangest new additions to the cast of Mortal Kombat II was the character of Noob Saibot, a mysterious ninja who could be fought after racking up 50 consecutive wins in two-player mode, although some home versions reduced this to 25. Initially, no one knew anything about this character at all, leading to plenty of speculation. In an interview with one of the game's creators, John Tobias, it was explained that 'Noob Saibot' was simply the names Boon and Tobias spelled backwards, referencing the aforementioned Tobias and co-creator Ed Boon, who had added the character to the game as an easter egg.
Thanks to the mystery surrounding him, the character's popularity meant this was far from a one-off appearance, and he has continued to appear in multiple Mortal Kombat titles. In 2004's Mortal Kombat: Deception, over a decade since his debut, it was finally revealed that Noob Saibot was actually the reanimated form of Bi-Han, the original version of Sub Zero who was killed by Scorpion in the original tournament.
12. Super Mario 64: Was Luigi in the Game?
Few video games have had a bigger impact on the industry than Super Mario 64. Mario's first 3D outing ever changed the landscape of gaming and opened up a world of possibilities for developers. When the game was initially launched in 1996, fans of Mario noticed a glaring absentee: his brother, Luigi, was nowhere to be found in Peach's giant castle in which the game takes place.
However, it wasn't long before something was discovered. On a plaque beneath the star statue in the castle's courtyard was some blurry writing that many believed read 'L is real 2401', something that could well have been a clue pointing to the clumsy younger brother's existence somewhere in the game. For years, players searched for ways to unlock him, going so far as to collect every single item in the game or even performing bizarre stunts around the castle, but nothing seemed to work.
Decades later, in 2020, the widely-documented Nintendo leak revealed previously unseen development material for Super Mario 64, and it revealed an unused Luigi model as well as other unused assets. So even though he wasn't hiding in the castle, he was at least considered to appear in the game at some stage of development. There's no proof that the 'L is real 2401' was linked to this, though. Could it just have been a coincidence?
11. Halo 3: Who Was Lauren?
Released in 2007, Halo 3 is widely regarded as a high point for Bungie's first person shooter series. The third outing for the legendary Master Chief is praised for its killer soundtrack, action-packed campaign, and groundbreaking multiplayer mechanics. Years after its release, during Bungie's 2012 Mail Sack Q&A, one of their employees revealed he had hidden an easter egg in the game that had yet to be found, that only appeared on a certain day. This understandably sent the community off on a mission to try and find it.
Despite their efforts, though, nobody found it- until 2014, around 7 years since the game originally launched. A YouTuber known as Lord Zedd finally discovered that if you press and hold down both thumbsticks on the campaign loading screen, the camera zooms out to reveal the Halo ring with text on its surface stating ''Happy Birthday, Lauren!''- which was a tribute added by Bungie programmer Adrian Perez for his wife. The kicker was that this only appeared on December 25th, the day of her birthday, which went a long way to explaining why it hadn't been found for so long!
10. Grand Theft Auto 3: Why Did Shooting the Moon Make it Change Size?
The third mainline instalment in the GTA series was the one that really put the franchise on the map. One of the first truly ambitious 3D 'open-world' games was a true force to be reckoned with and is regularly cited as an inspiration even to this day, 25 years after its release. The game was packed full of things to see and do, and it also contained a couple of bizarre secrets and glitches. One in particular seemed completely pointless- players discovered that if you shoot the moon with a sniper rifle, it actually changed size, cycling between 3 different versions.
What did this mean? Did it unlock a cheat? Was it Rockstar's way of secretly communicating with fans? Was it just a glitch? The answer would eventually come decades after the game's release, when Rockstar North technical director Obbe Vermeij revealed the explanation. This blog explained that, during development, four of Rockstar's artists couldn't agree on how big the moon should be in the game. Two wanted it smaller and more realistic, whereas the other two wanted it larger and more cinematic.
As a solution, Vermeij suggested making the moon's size temporarily changeable via a sniper rifle shot, allowing the artists to decide which version looked better. However, the artists never came back to him, meaning this temporary mechanic was bizarrely left in the final version of the game.
9. Donkey Kong 64: Was There Another Rainbow Coin?
Has there ever been a game with more collectable items than Donkey Kong 64?
Short answer: no.
The game holds the Guinness World Record for the most collectable items in a platform video game, with a whopping 3821 items officially counted. Part of these collectables are Rainbow Coins, special coins that grant all 5 playable Kongs 5 Banana Coins each (so 25 in total). For years, fans believed there to be 15 of these Rainbow Coins in total.
However, in a game so dense with collectables and secrets, there will always be speculation about things potentially undiscovered. Many fans wondered if there may in fact be more Rainbow Coins tucked away somewhere in Donkey Kong 64's world waiting to be found. 17 years after the game was released, speed runner Isotarge discovered a previously unknown 16th Rainbow Coin. This coin was hidden in tall grass, completely undetectable by players unless they knew specifically where to look. Isotarge discovered it while examining the game's save data and using analysis tools to track down the missing collectible.
No official word on this 16th coin ever materialized from developer Rare, so it is unknown if this was accidentally placed somewhere with barely any visual clues, or if it was a deliberately sneaky hidden easter egg.
8. Destiny: Who Was the Exo Stranger?
Bungie's popular FPS title Destiny made a huge impression when it blasted its way onto the scene in 2014, building one of the most active, consistent communities in the genre. The nature of the game's multiplayer mechanics, and its drop-in, drop-out co-op, meant that players were always discovering new things and discussing theories.
Initially, one of the most mysterious elements was the Exo Stranger. This elusive character appeared during the story, guiding you towards your next objective, while hinting that she knew far more about the game's events than she was letting on. With fans theorizing about who she really was, the Exo Stranger's identity remained a mystery for six years.
2020 marked the release of Destiny 2's major expansion, Beyond Light, and with it came major answers about this mysterious character. This DLC saw the return of the Exo Stranger, who finally revealed her true identity: Elsie Bray, a time traveller who was the granddaughter of the famous Clovis Bray whose tech projects players had seen dotted throughout the world. Her appearances in the original game were her attempts to alter the timeline and prevent the disastrous future she'd seen.
7. Sonic the Hedgehog 3: Was Michael Jackson Involved With the Game's Soundtrack?
One of the weirdest gaming mysteries to have risen its head over the years was undoubtedly the speculation around whether or not the legendary Michael Jackson had a hand in Sonic the Hedgehog 3's soundtrack. Fans of the lightning-fast hedgehog and the king of pop had spotted similarities between MJ's music and several tracks in the 1994 threequel since the game's initial release, but with Jackson's name not appearing in the credits, it remained a point of contention.
In the years after the release, these rumours persisted, and actually started to gain more traction as people involved with the project began talking about it more openly. Jackson was known to be a Sonic the Hedgehog fan and had worked with SEGA for his Michael Jackson's Moonwalker video game, so the link was already established. Several people involved with Sonic 3's development have since said that Jackson worked on the soundtrack, and his keyboardist Brad Buxer stated in 2009 he and Jackson had composed music for the game, giving the long-running theory its strongest evidence yet.
However, to this day, it has never been solidly confirmed by SEGA themselves, with some accounts suggesting that, even if he was involved initially, any work he did was removed before the game was properly released.
6. The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past: Who Was Chris Houlihan?
The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past is one of the most influential SNES titles ever released. Playing as Link, you're tasked with rescuing Zelda from her imprisonment at the hands of an evil sorcerer. Along the way, you encounter plenty of classic Zelda-esque puzzles to solve and baddies to overcome.
Throughout the game Link can often fall down holes, which transports him to a cave directly beneath wherever the hole was. Occasionally, however, players reported being teleported to a completely different room with no explanation. This small, square room was filled with 45 blue rupees and a message reading ''My name is Chris Houlihan. This is my top secret room.'' The existence of this room, and that message, baffled players worldwide for years, as they wondered who exactly Chris Houlihan was and what the room was meant for.
It turns out, it was a failsafe room that would only be found if the game couldn't internally determine Link's destination. After a whopping 33 years, in 2025, Chris Houlihan's identity was seemingly revealed when YouTuber Kevin Hainline investigated and found that Chris' father had initially won a Nintendo competition, with the prize being the winner's name to appear in a future Nintendo game, although his father apparently asked for his son's name to be used instead. The Chris Houlihan room in A Link to the Past was then named in his honour, potentially ending a mystery that spanned over 3 decades.
5. The Legend of Zelda: What is the Official Timeline?
Sticking with The Legend of Zelda, for years fans had wondered what the official timeline of events surrounding Zelda and Link were. With so many games and branching narratives, it was far from easy to piece together into one cohesive timeline, particularly when compared to other popular long-standing IPs that had more straightforward narrative paths.
Each game featured similar elements like Link, Zelda, Hyrule and Ganondorf, but it wasn't really explained when these games were taking place, or how they fit together. 1998's Ocarina of Time had introduced the concept of time travel and branching timelines, which complicated matters even more, further muddying the waters.
Finally, in 2011, to celebrate 25 years of The Legend of Zelda, Nintendo published Hyrule Historia. This official Zelda book finally contained the chronological timeline, putting to rest years of speculation and theories. It turns out that Ocarina of Time had created 3 distinct timelines, with every Zelda game fitting on one of them, allowing fans to have a full picture of events for the first time.
4. Super Mario Sunshine: What Does the Mysterious Language Say?
2002's Gamecube title Super Mario Sunshine sees the titular Italian plumber vacationing on the sunny Isle Delfino. This rare downtime for Mario is rudely cut short with the arrival of a shadowy figure who looks suspiciously like him. This mystery character wastes no time covering Isle Delfino in graffiti, along with a toxic goop that Mario has to clean up.
While exploring the island, players can spot weird, swirling symbols on buildings, signs, and other objects. This at first appears to be complete gibberish, with no obvious explanation for it. The rest of the game uses a mixture of English and Italian text, so this gibberish felt a little out of place. For years, fans wondered why this was there, and what it meant.
Finally, in 2024, a YouTuber known as 2CPhoenix seemingly solved this mystery. The symbols are actually a secret alphabet/cipher, with each one corresponding to an ordinary letter from A to Z. Using this, he was able to decipher many of the symbols scattered around Isle Delfino, with words like 'BAR GELATO' and 'PARCO' uncovered, ending a mystery that had lasted more than 20 years in the process.
3. Battletoads: What Was That Screenshot on the Box?
Battletoads was a tough side-scrolling co-op title that originally launched on the NES that saw you playing as anthropomorphic toads fighting your way through action-packed levels. It was a notoriously punishing game that precious few players got to actually finish before the days of memory cards, save files and emulators.
When it launched in 1991, one of the screenshots on the box displayed something that wasn't actually in the game. It depicted the toads on motorbikes driving through a fiery section. Those who were skilled enough to roll credits quickly realized this section was nowhere to be found throughout the entire thing. For over 30 years, this mystery was never solved, with many wondering how the absent motorbike part could be played.
In 2025, programmer Jordi Gutierrez Hermoso discovered footage of a Beta version of Battletoads uploaded to YouTube by former Tips & Tricks editor Chris Bieniek. In this version, the fiery motorbike section was clearly shown, during level 7. It turns out that this never actually made it into the final game, yet somehow, a screenshot of it made it to the box!
2. Metal Gear Solid 3: Who Was Eva's Voice Actor?
The legendary Metal Gear Solid series is no stranger to easter eggs, with creator Hideo Kojima notoriously fond of leaving secrets and paper trails for fans to find as they play through his games. 2004's Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater, which many consider to be the pinnacle of the series, was packed full of secrets and weird quirks for players to find. Snake's love interest in the game, Eva, was voiced in English by someone credited as 'Suzetta Minet'. However, no such person seemed to exist, leaving fans wondering just who voiced the seductive spy, and why it was kept a secret.
Fans investigated this for years, with many convinced she was actually voiced by Jodi Benson, the voice of Ariel in Disney's The Little Mermaid, but there was no official confirmation of this other than the striking similarity. 20 years later, Konami released an episode of its Metal Gear Solid Legacy series, in which the truth was finally revealed: it was in fact Jodi Benson.
Benson herself was seen discussing her role as Eva in the episode, confirming Suzetta Minet was a pseudonym, and finally putting to bed the rumours and speculation. It turns out that a member of Konami's production team, voice director Kris Zimmerman Salter, was keen to seperate Benson's family-friendly image with the heavily sexualized character of Eva, so it was agreed that a pseudonym would work best, with Benson happy to oblige.
1. Dark Souls: What Was the Pendant For?
FromSoftware's first Dark Souls title was nothing short of revolutionary. Its success was such that it even managed to spawn an entire sub-genre, the Soulslike, with dozens of new titles swelling its ranks on a yearly basis.
In what has now become customary in this series, Dark Souls players get to choose from a bunch of in-game items to help them on the start of their arduous quest. These range from things like the Black Firebomb which gives players an additional consumable weapon to use, to the Master Key that can be used to unlock alternative areas. However, one item in the original game stuck out as particularly strange right from the get go. The Pendant. Its description stated ''A simple pendant with no effect. Even so, pleasant memories are crucial to survival on arduous journeys'', so its use was a mystery to say the least. What really piqued players' interest was when FromSoftware's president, Hidetaka Miyazaki, was asked in an interview which starting item he would choose, and he confirmed he'd go for the Pendant.
This sent the internet fanbase down a massive rabbit hole as thousands of players tried to establish the item's true use, but despite the efforts, this was completely in vain. Nobody could find what it actually did. Over a year after the game's release in 2011, Miyazaki admitted in another interview that this was a prank on his part. He recommended the Pendant simply to send players on a wild goose chase, confirming it had no special use in the actual game.