20 Video Games With Cut Content That Change EVERYTHING

Would you believe Halo 2 and Mass Effect 3 nearly had a different ending?

By James Egan /

Even when a video game is overstuffed with content, it's likely a whole batch of levels, mechanics, and storylines ended up on the cutting room floor. A lot of hard work is put into every game, so it's disappointing when any part of it gets the chop.

Advertisement

Of course, content being removed isn't necessarily a sign it was bad. Elaborate characters, intricate side-quests, and ambitious gameplay may get scrapped due to time constraints, technical limitations, or narrative pacing. 

Now, if a random boss or subplot gets axed, it shouldn't be a big deal. However, there are certain discarded features that would've drastically affected how the game turned out if they remained.

Occasionally, traces of these lost ideas make it into the final product, giving players a glimpse into what might have been. Through data-mining and interviews with developers, the curtain is pulled on the creative process, showing how certain titles almost went into a totally different direction.

For better or for worse, the 20 entries on this list could've been perceived in a whole new way if the developers stuck with the original plan.

20. Insects - BioShock

One of that many aspects that defined BioShock is its focus on relationships and inner conflicts. You get so invested in these characters, you genuinely care when you're betrayed, learn the truth about the protagonist, or have to execute an innocent person.

Advertisement

Ironically, BioShock almost went into the opposite direction, since it was going to focus more on monstrous characters rather than human ones. Although Splicers and Big Daddies would've been a part of this model, arthropods called Aggressors would've also been a prominent enemy. The protagonist would encounter giant insects called Queens, which could generate other nasty creatures.

Now, one critter-themed element that made the cut was the sea slugs, since they're the source of ADAM, which fuels your power. At key points, you need to decide how much ADAM to extract from the Little Sisters, giving you a choice whether to save or kill them.

But originally, the Little Sisters were the sea slugs. However, the developers worried players wouldn't connect with slimy molluscs, compelling them to tweak them into something more presentable. They toyed around with making the Little Sisters resemble monkeys, chipmunks, frogs, and even crippled dogs, before finalising on a more human design.

19. Kenny Snaps - The Walking Dead: Season Two

Though The Walking Dead: Season Two is rife with emotional moments, one that stands out is when our heroine, Clementine, reunites with Kenny, a survivor she encountered in the first game. After the death of her parents and her guardian, Lee, Kenny is the closest that Clementine has to a paternal figure.

Advertisement

Even though it's a big moment when Kenny is revealed to be alive, there was another idea that would've hit harder. After Clementine reunites with Kenny, they're captured by a tyrant called William Carver, who rules his community with an iron fist.

As has been discussed during the OMG!Con Q&A in 2015, Clementine was meant to discover Kenny was alive... when he was revealed as the barbaric leader of the survivalist community. 

As shocking as this revelation would've been, it's not too hard to believe Kenny would snap. Kenny watched his wife and son die in The Walking Dead: Season One, causing him to grow disillusioned and violent. He ordered the team to desert survivors on multiple occasions, highlighting his loose moral compass. 

Although Carver was repurposed as the villain, there are plenty of moments where Kenny behaves antagonistically, including toward Clementine. Nevertheless, it would've been intriguing to see Kenny go full supervillain.

18. Iorweth - The Witcher III: Wild Hunt

Depending on your choices in The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings, Geralt of Rivia encounters a mistrusting elf called Iorweth. Initially seeing Geralt as a tool for the humans rulers, Iorweth later views the white-haired warrior as one of his few true friends. Due to the character's positive reception, fans were miffed when the wary elf didn't feature in the follow-up.

Advertisement

But not only was Iorweth planned to return in The Witcher III: Wild Hunt, he was meant to appear in various quests, primarily one centred around the lethal Catriona plague. In this section, Geralt would be forced to make an unsteady alliance with Iorweth, Roche, and others to locate a cure. A rudimentary but playable build of this questline exists, indicating it was dismissed late into production.

Despite his absence, Iorweth's legacy endures in The Witcher III, since he's mentioned in dialogues and pops up as a Gwent card. Nevertheless, it was disappointing to see Iorweth be physically absent, considering several threads from the previous game surrounding his character remained unresolved.

17. Aging NPCs - Fable

Early in his career, gaming designer, Peter Molyneux, garnered a reputation for promising revolutionary mechanics that never materialised. Fable was perhaps the defining example, since Molyneux made several wild claims that never came to be.

Advertisement

One of the most memorable aspects of the fantasy RPG is how the main character ages throughout the main campaign. Although this was an incredible mechanic for its time, Molyneux and the Lionhead team envisioned the world aging alongside the hero. The plan was that if you planted a seed as a child, you would see it become a tree as an adult. NPCs would physically age over time, similar to how the protagonist develops wrinkles and grey hair.

But it doesn't stop there. The flow of time would've caused NPCs' roles in the world to constantly change. Over time, a blacksmith might retire and be replaced by an apprentice. Villagers might pass away, forcing their children to take over their homes, jobs, and responsibilities. People would get married, have children, and die, creating a consistently evolving world.

Considering these mechanics still haven't been implemented into the franchise, despite massive technical improvements over the last 20 years, it goes without saying that Molyneux's vision was profoundly unrealistic.

16. Source Of The Blackouts - Heavy Rain

Though Heavy Rain was praised for its focus on character conflicts, emotional storytelling, and its jaw-dropping twist, there's one element that remains inconsistent.

Advertisement

After his son dies in a car accident, protagonist Ethan begins to suffer from blackouts, causing him to wake up in strange locations. These fainting spells occur while a child murderer called the Origami Killer is active in the area, hinting that he and Ethan are one and the same. But since the killer is eventually revealed to be somebody else, it seems like the blackouts were thrown in solely to mislead players.

But the blackouts have a higher purpose, or at least, they did. In the original script, it was eventually revealed Ethan had a psychic link with the Origami Killer. When he "blacks out", Ethan is actually using his supernatural powers to follow the murderer's trail. Director, David Cage, believed the psychic element was thematically inconsistence with the Heavy Rain's grounded tone, leading to its removal.

Ethan’s blackouts remain in the plot, but are never fully explained, causing them to become one of the most criticised aspects of the game.

15. Almost Half The Game - Secret Of Mana

It's a miracle Secret of Mana turned out as well as it did, considering Square's gorgeous RPG was designed for a console that doesn't exist. Despite being released for the Super Nintendo, Secret of Mana was tailored for the SNES CD-ROM add-on, which was an abandoned project between Nintendo and Sony.

Advertisement

When this system was cancelled, the developers realised that up to 40% of material would have to be tossed out to fit on a SNES cartridge. This news was upsetting for the developers, to the point where they strongly considered walking away from the whole thing.

There were meant to be multiple routes throughout the main campaign, which would've led to several endings (an idea that did make it into the sequel, Trials of Mana). Several dungeons and towns were discarded, and whole chunks of the plot were eliminated, which is why many story elements in the second-half feel rushed.

Although the 3D remake had the opportunity to add the excised elements, 2018's Secret of Mana was in essence the same game. This was a huge pity, as it would've been a dream come true to see how the original version could've turned out.

14. Oscar Of Astora - Dark Souls

Dark Souls opens with a mysterious knight offering you a key, allowing you to escape from your prison cell. When the warrior is found mortally wounded shortly after, he bequeathes you with the Estus Flask and the Undead mission.

Advertisement

Despite his brief appearance, this knight's role is crucial, since this little interaction kickstarts the protagonist's entire quest. For this reason, it would've been nice to see this mystery man play a much bigger part.

But at one point, that was the idea. Unused files show the knight, who's actually called Oscar of Astora, was meant to accompany the player deeper into Lordran. Based on cut dialogue, the Astoran knight would've served as a summonable character in battle.

Despite being your ally, things eventually take a dark turn. During the third act, Oscar would confront you after his faith and purpose had been completely eroded, forcing you to put him down for good.

FromSoftware never gave an official explanation why this intriguing quest line was taken out, but it's possible they found Oscar's expanded role redundant since Solaria already fit the role of the hero's companion.

13. The White House - Deus Ex

Ion Storm's futuristic title, Deus Ex, was considered ahead of its time, due its genre-bending gameplay, branching narratives, and complex themes involving transhumanism and AI.

Advertisement

And yet, there were a few ideas deemed too ambitious to make the cut. In early development, JC Denton was going to conduct missions in the White House, Russia, and onboard a space station. Though the last two were scrapped early in development, a demo build of the White House was completed, giving players a reasonable understanding how this section would've played out.

Denton would venture to the White House to rescue President Mead's daughter and confront major antagonist, Walton Simons. The mission aimed to tie together earlier events, such as the New York and Paris missions, by revealing Mead had been replaced by a clone under Illuminati control.

Even though The White House was among the first areas developed, it was removed due to speed issues.

This one is so sought after by some fans that The White House can be accessed in the fan-made mod, Deus Ex Nihilum, (although, of course, it plays out differently than how the original game proposed).

12. Atlantis - God Of War II

With so many Greek myths to pull from, it's no surprise to learn a whole plethora of content was drafted for the God of War series before it was cut.

Advertisement

One of the most interesting aspects to be expelled from the franchise has to be Atlantis from God of War II. Level design documents detail a massive submerged city, blending ancient Greek architecture with fantastical underwater elements. Kratos was supposed to travel to Atlantis to seek the aid of the Titans and uncover more about his destiny.

Atlantis would've required complex water mechanics and new traversal systems, including underwater combat. At the time, the PlayStation 2’s hardware was already being pushed to its limits, so it's possible these features were too daunting or time-consuming to include.

Although Atlantis was reworked into God of War: Ghost of Sparta, there were elements sketched for God Of War II that didn't survive, such as a boss battle against the Titan of the Ocean, Oceanus. Based on how epic the Poseidon battle was in God Of War III, it would've been awe-inspiring to see Kratos face a water deity that was arguably more powerful.

11. Half The Game - Legacy Of Kain: Soul Reaver

Legacy of Kain: Soul Reaver is such an airtight title, it's hard to believe the PSOne classic is but a snippet of what the developers were aiming for.

Advertisement

Several areas were either abandoned entirely or left in an incomplete state, like the mountain retreat, the lighthouse, and the subterranean city. Not only can many of these structures and environmental puzzles be found in the game's files, they are accessible in the 2024 remaster. A citadel was also brainstormed, which would've explored humanity's feud with the vampire clans more deeply. On top of that, several mechanics were axed, including advanced teleportation, soul sucking, fire projectiles, and possession.

Because Raziel has five brothers, players found it odd how he only fights four of them. Originally, Raziel would've clashed with his fifth sibling, Turel, before duking it out with Kain, which would've been more elaborate than the anticlimactic showdown we received.

So, what happened? Well, director Amy Hennig realised in the eleventh hour that her team had over-designed the game, saying:

"The epic story we wanted to convey was too ambitious for a single product". 

As a result, many ideas were deserted or repurposed for the sequel.

10. Put Your Face In The Game - Perfect Dark

Even though GoldenEye 007 raised the bar for first-person shooters in the late 1990s, Perfect Dark was deemed a worthy spiritual successor. The futuristic FPS was commended for its voice acting, advanced enemy AI, elaborate missions, and multi-purpose weapons.

Advertisement

However, one of the game's most creative ideas ended up on the chopping block. Up until late development, Rare intended to have a feature which allowed players to scan their faces onto in-game character models in multiplayer. This feature relied on the Game Boy Camera, an accessory that plugged into the N64 via the Transfer Pak.

Despite claims Rare struggled with this mechanic due to technical difficulties, it was fully operational. Unfortunately, Nintendo had concerns over its misuse, particularly in light of real-world events. After the Columbine High School massacre in 1999, there was heightened sensitivity about realistic depictions of violence in video games.

Nintendo and Rare also feared that allowing players to map real faces onto characters could promote bullying, generate negative press, or lead to legal problems.

Despite the fact this face-mapping mechanic could've been a trailblazer, it's understandable why the creators and publishers agreed to put it to bed.

9. Ada - Resident Evil: Village

Based on Resident Evil Village concept art and the official art book, it's clear Ada Wong was suppose to serve as a mysterious helper to Ethan Winters, similar to how she rescued Leon in Resident Evil 2.

Advertisement

Now, this shouldn't be that much of a shock since the femme fatale shows up unannounced at random intervals throughout the series.

But this would've been a very different version of the character. Rather than being adorned with her traditional scarlet dress, Ada would've worn a plague doctor outfit, including a bird-like mask, in order to blend in with the gothic setting. Her mission was to investigate the village independently, perhaps implying she was working for her usual shadowy employers (or possibly herself).

It's hard to say how far along this idea got and may have simply been a concept rather than something that wound up in the scripting stage of the game, but it's likely that we'll never know.

Although it would've been nice to see Ada return, the unlockable concept art in Village does at least say that Capcom believed her subplot complicated the main narrative. RE8 already had multiple overlapping plot lines, so throwing in another could've disrupted the pacing.

8. F-Stop - Portal 2

Even though Portal 2 is considered to be among the best sequels in gaming, it didn't start off as a sequel at all. Stranger still, it wasn't initially going to utilise portals. 

Advertisement

In the beginning stages, the project focused on a photographic mechanic called F-Stop. Players could take pictures of objects with this device then place them into the real world, effectively "copying" them. The mechanic allowed for resizing, rotating, and repositioning captured objects, enabling players to solve puzzles by altering the environment in creative ways. Playtesters liked the F-Stop mechanic, but were disappointment by the lack of portals, encouraging Valve to make a more traditional sequel.

Though Portal 2 incorporated new elements, such as Propulsion Gel and Hard Light Bridges, there were other proposed concepts. Valve considered different types of portals that could slow down objects or alter gravity. There was also going to be an Adhesion Gel, which Chell could stick to, opening up all sorts of puzzle possibilities. Damage Gel was also considered, which would serve as an additional obstacle while navigating around turrets and pits.

Although these ideas were complex, they didn't necessarily improve on the puzzle flow, leading to their expulsion.

7. Many Extra Levels - Sonic The Hedgehog 2

After the monumental success of Sonic the Hedgehog, Sega got to work on a sequel that was designed to be bigger and better in every way. And boy, did they deliver, since Sonic the Hedgehog 2 allowed Sonic and his new buddy Tails to venture through 11 innovative zones, almost twice the amount as its predecessor.

Advertisement

Despite the fact Sonic 2 was brimming with material, prototype ROMs and archival materials prove the beloved sequel was intended to have far more levels.

Wood Zone was going to be the second stage but was repurposed into Sonic & Knuckles' Mushroom Hill Zone. Two desert-themed levels were designed, Dust Hill Zone and Sand Shower Zone, before getting canned. An industrial area called Genocide City Zone was also considered as well as a water-themed region called Ocean Wind Zone, and a futuristic landscape called Cyber City.

The most interesting of the lot has to be Hidden Palace Zone, which would've explained the origin of the Chaos Emeralds and allowed our speedy hero to turn into Super Sonic. Though this level was cut, it was restored in the 2013 remaster.

Although some levels can be accessed through unconventional means, they range from glitchy to unplayable.

6. Most Of The Game - Dragon's Dogma

Despite the staggering creativity behind Dragon's Dogma, the developers were constantly at odds with their budget. When their funds were sliced further in late development, the creators had to dump a whole bunch of material.

Advertisement

It's hard to know where to start when looking at deleted content, since nearly every aspect of Dragon's Dogma was impaired in some way. The world map has blocked-off roads and unfinished terrains, hinting that more explorable zones were devised. Data-miners found references to “Frontier Lands” and other unused location names, suggesting additional towns and wilderness areas were contemplated.

Many mechanics were partially developed but ultimately rejected, such as destructible environments, complex Pawn bonding, and horseback battles. (Ironically, horses didn't make it into the game at all.) 

Based on the abrupt ending, players won't be surprised to learn the climax got hacked down too. Concept art and leftover dialogue implies a branching or choice-driven finale after the final boss is defeated. 

Capcom's vision was compromised so badly, the 2024 sequel feels like a do-over, since the creators were finally able to make Dragon's Dogma the way they wanted to.

5. The Tiny Villages - The Legend Of Zelda: Breath Of The Wild

With countless developers working tirelessly on Breath of the Wild over a period of six years, you can bet there was a multitude of ideas that were concocted but never completed. Luckily, some of the abandoned content managed to see the light of day since they were eventually added to the DLC, including The Master Trials and The Champions Ballad.

Advertisement

However, one idea that didn't see it through was a race of tiny people, reminiscent of the Minish from The Legend of Zelda: The Minish Cap. These miniature beings would have inhabited small towns scattered across the land of Hyrule. Due to their petite size, Link could only access these areas by shrinking down to their level.

Even though the director, Hidemaro Fujibayashi, found the idea appealing, it was difficult to find a logical way for these diminutive creatures to fit into Breath of the Wild's structure (which feels weird since Nintendo didn't have any qualms with giving Link his own motorcycle).

Despite the fact the sequel, Tears of the Kingdom, offered even more innovative ideas and unique characters, the Minish-like race were still nowhere to be seen.

4. Civil War - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

Despite how mind-bogglingly gigantic The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim is, it could've been even bigger. 

Advertisement

At one point, the Dragonborn can get involved with a Civil War between the Imperial Legion and the Stormcloaks. As memorable as this mission is, the Civil War was intended to be significantly more complex.

The player was supposed to actively participate in major battles, with the war effort visibly affecting Skyrim’s cities, forts, and population. Instead of the mostly static skirmishes we see in the released game, the war would unfold in phases, with territory changing hands, depending on quests and battles won or lost.

In the finished product, the Civil War culminates with the opposing faction being defeated. However, cut content suggests alternate fates for key NPCs, depending on who won, making the players' decisions more impactful. There’s evidence the Dragonborn could've raised troops and influenced battles beyond the scripted quests, making the war feel organic.

As fascinating as this idea was, it might've been too performance-heavy for consoles. Alternatively, the developers may have wanted to prioritise the central story between the Dragonborn and Alduin, encouraging them to revise the Civl War into a side-quest instead of a war simulator.

3. The Stop 'N' Swop - Banjo-Tooie

Even though Rare were renowned for their ambition, the British company bit off more than they could chew when it came to the Stop 'N' Swop mechanic in Banjo-Tooie, originally released for the Nintendo 64.

Advertisement

Rare came up with this idea after learning RAM data remained on the N64 for a few seconds after it was powered off. With this in mind, the developers believed it was feasible to transfer the lingering data to another game if a cartridge was quickly swapped out for another. 

By switching between Banjo-Kazooie and Banjo-Tooie, players could theoretically access hidden content in both titles, most notably, the coloured eggs and the Ice Key teased in the first game's secret ending. Such a system had never been done before, so fans were deeply curious how Rare would pull it off. 

Little did Rare know Nintendo had revised N64 hardware, shortening the RAM retention time, making the Stop 'N' Swop idea impractical. Nintendo also worried this technique could irreparably damage the console's hardware, pressurising Rare to abandon it entirely. 

Fortunately, a revised version of the mechanic was utilised when Banjo-Kazooie and Banjo-Tooie were re-released on the Xbox Live Arcade, allowing Stop 'N' Swop to finally come to fruition.

2. The Original Ending - Halo 2

Despite the praise Halo 2 received, the cliffhanger ending attracted the ire of many. After fighting through Covenant forces, Master Chief boards the Prophet of Truth's vessel in order to "finish the fight". With no warning, the screen cuts to black, leaving the battle for Earth unresolved.

Advertisement

But at one point, Halo 2 was supposed to have a definitive ending. Master Chief was meant to return to Earth and lead a full-scale assault on the Truth's forces. Players would fight a climactic mission in New Mombasa, including large-scale battles between the UNSC, The Covenant, and The Flood. Though the Covenant is at odds with humanity, their leader, The Arbiter, would join forces with MC during the final mission. 

The main campaign would wrap up with a showdown against the Prophet of Truth, setting up Halo 3 more cleanly. Though the Truth escapes, this version of Halo 2 would've had far more resolution since it doesn't abruptly end in mid-mission.

Although several elements made their way into the follow-up, it's a wonder how things would've turned out if Halo 2 stuck with the original idea and how this would've impacted the next game in the series.

1. Dark Energy - Mass Effect 3

It's fascinating how one cut plot line from Mass Effect 3 would've recontextualised not just the story, but the overarching narrative of the whole trilogy.

Advertisement

During Tali's loyalty mission in Mass Effect 2, Veetor mentions a certain star is dying far faster than should be possible. According to Mass Effect 2 writer, Drew Karpyshyn, this line foreshadows how Dark Energy is prematurely destroying stars, which will inevitably render the galaxy uninhabitable. 

Instead of trying to wipe out advanced species, the Reapers were secretly harvesting them to reverse this star massacre. This plot line would reframe the Reapers from genocidal villains to tragic figures who perform atrocities for the greater good. During Mass Effect 3's climax, Shepard would have to sacrifice populations and alter the laws of the universe to prevent the galaxy from collapsing.

Sadly, Drew Karpyshyn didn't stick around for Mass Effect 3, causing the remaining writer, Mac Walter, to go in a direction with the plot.

This decision led to the infamous colour-coded ending, which we can all agree was about 5,000 times worse than what we would've got if Karypyshyn stayed on.

Advertisement