4 Pokémon Spin-Off Games Worth Playing (And 4 To AVOID)

23 years, so many games, but which are worth your time?

By Alex Antliff /

Pokémon is a franchise that continues to go from strength to strength. Whilst it will likely never ascend to the ubiquitous heights of its mainstream heyday at the turn of the Millennium, it continues to be one of Nintendo’s most successful and lucrative properties, with the strength of the games backed by the ongoing anime show, trading card game and countless merchandise ranges.

Advertisement

The last five pairs of games in the series (Ruby & Sapphire, Diamond & Pearl, Black & White, X&Y and Sun & Moon) have each consistently sold between 16 and 18 million copies worldwide, not including remakes such as Omega Ruby & Alpha Sapphire, or ‘third’ titles such as Emerald and Platinum that added even more to these totals.

The recently announced Sword & Shield will kick off the eighth generation of the series, and they will most likely be just as successful, with their release complemented by a selection of spin-offs.

Throughout the years, such spin-offs have been a mixed bag, quality-wise.

Some have been incredible gameplay experiences, others have been cheap cash-ins that would’ve quickly become bargain bin fodder were it not for the strength of the brand. Here we’ll look at four of the best and four of the worst.

8. AVOID - XD: Gale Of Darkness

For many years, Pokemon fans have been clamouring for a proper home console take on the series’ traditional formula, allowing them to explore huge lush worlds and catch every Pokemon in full 3D. Sword & Shield will be released on the Switch, but it is expected that they will be similar to style to the seven handheld pairs that came before them rather than something huge and Skyrim-esque.

Advertisement

There have been several home console releases in the franchise, but only a handful of them worth shelling out for. Pokemon XD: Gale Of Darkness was certainly not one of them, largely recycling content (including almost all of the game world) from Pokemon Colosseum. The number of available ‘Shadow Pokemon’ that could be snagged was almost doubled (83 vs Colosseum’s 48), but the lack of new features made it feel more like an expansion pack than a standalone game in its own right.

There were some redeeming qualities – combat in 3D is always a joy to behold, particularly the endeavour of 100 gradually more difficult fights at Mt. Battle, whilst the opportunity to trade exclusive Pokemon to handhelds was always a plus for those wanting to complete their Pokedex.

However, given how many of Nintendo’s other franchises had some of their greatest outings on the GameCube (a hugely underrated console), however, it is disappointing that neither of the Pokemon games that were made for it are worth remembering.

7. PLAY - Pokemon Go

Mobile games, particularly those supported by microtransactions, should usually be avoided at all costs given that they are typically designed solely to squeeze every penny from their player base, rather than provide an enjoyable gameplay experience.

Advertisement

Pokemon Go is different, despite the presence of some irksome ‘pay to win’ elements that give those with bottomless pockets an advantage over those with mere patience.

The game took over the world in the summer of 2016, with seemingly everybody, even those who hadn’t followed the series since its heyday, walking endlessly around parks and city centres glued to their phone screens, catching Pokemon in augmented reality and living our their childhood fantasies of being Pokemon trainers.

The drop-off was sharp after just a few months, with people understandably tired of seeing nothing but Pidgeys and Rattatas for miles on end and bored of having nothing to do but hatch eggs and take part in a battle mode that lacked any form of strategy or enjoyment.

Many of these flaws have been addressed by developers Niantic though, with the game now offering legendary raids, trading and objectives to complete, amongst other things.

It’s still a very basic and repetitive game, but one that continues to suck in a considerable player base, addictively dangling the carrot of a complete Pokemon collection comprising Kanto, Johto, Hoenn and Sinnoh generations now available to seek out.

6. AVOID - Pokemon Let's Go: Pikachu & Eevee

Pokemon Red, Blue & Yellow were the games that launched the franchise into the stratosphere, but after twenty years of improvements to the core formula they don’t exactly hold up today. Much like all manner of classic games, we love them for the sake of nostalgia rather than the timelessness of their gameplay.

Advertisement

Pokemon: Let’s Go Pikachu & Eevee sound like excellent concepts on paper – remakes of the trio made on a modern console with updated graphics and features. Their marketing relied heavily on both this and the nostalgia factor, contributing to impressive sales to date of over 10 million units.

There is no doubting that they are enjoyable, but they are largely superfluous and skippable given that they bring nothing new to the table.

When assessed against the core series, the main criticism of the games is that they have been ridiculously oversimplified.

For starters, Pokemon are no longer battled, but caught using the same motion mechanics as Pokemon Go, acceptable and ergonomic on a phone but unnecessary on a Switch controller. Other features copied from Go include Combat Power and Candies, making battling and raising Pokemon much less strategic than usual.

All in all, Let’s Go Pikachu and Eevee serve little purpose other than demonstrating the Switch hardware and whetting appetites for Sword & Shield. Waiting for them is a much better option than dropping £100 on games that aren’t even the best remakes of Red and Blue (FireRed and LeafGreen being much more engaging).

5. PLAY - Pokemon Trading Card Game

Chances are that if you got sucked into the Pokemon games and anime during the series’ peak, you also became engrossed in the Trading Card game, simply collecting the cards or putting together competitive decks to take part in tournaments.

Advertisement

Any child in possession of a shiny Charizard instantly became the most popular person in the school playground, whilst market stalls did a roaring trade selling the latest cards from huge plastic folders.

It is still going strongly today (albeit confined mostly to specialist gaming cafés and store) exemplified by the fact that it is still the top-selling strategic card game with sales of over 25 billion cards since its inception. 75 different sets are now available in the English language, with 9184 individual cards to collect.

The Pokemon Trading Card Game on the Game Boy Colour capitalised on the game at the peak of its popularity, offering a massively enjoyable virtual representation with 226 cards from the original Base, Jungle and Fossil sets to collect. The format of the RPG games was also copied, with 8 gym leaders and an Elite Four to conquer.

Hugely engrossing, the game offered all the fun of the tabletop game, including the ability to play against friends, without the expense or the need for a sizable play area. It’s quite surprising that Nintendo have never released a follow-up (a Japan exclusive sequel that added the Team Rocket set nothwithstanding).

Stay away from Imakuni though. That guy is weird...

4. AVOID - My Pokémon Ranch

The Pokemon series had a fairly torrid time on the original Wii. Two Pokepark games got a critical mauling for their repetitiveness, tasking players solely with a handful of fetch quests and overly basic minigames. They are masterpieces compared to My Pokemon Ranch, however, which is perhaps the most blatant cash grab that the series has ever churned out.

Advertisement

Costing 1000 Wii points ($10), the game offered no functionality other than to store up to 1000 Pokemon from Diamond & Pearl, which (perhaps deliberately) only had an in-game storage capacity of 540.

This seems like a plentiful amount, but was actually quite restricting for players wanting to catch all 493 of the available monsters and amass a collection of competitive battlers, shinies and/or event Pokemon, which became more prolific with the addition of global trading to the series for the first time.

The ‘game’ was marketed on providing the opportunity for players to see and interact with their Pokemon in full 3D, but the models utilised were hideously blocky and unappealing, contrasting horribly with player Mii models that have looked out of place in every game they’ve been featured in (such as Mario Kart and Super Smash Bros.).

It was a concept that Nintendo had explored before (with Pokemon Box on the GameCube), but thankfully one they haven’t repeated again from Black & White onwards.

3. PLAY - Pokemon Stadium 1 & 2

4 Pokemon spin offs were released in Japan a five month period between December 1998 and April 1999, gradually making their way to the West in the year that followed.

Advertisement

Two of these were nothing special – Hey You, Pikachu was a Tamagotchi (remember those?) clone that tasked players with using voice commands to raise the series’ mascot over a 365 period, whilst Pokemon Pinball was a run-of-the-mill (and often frustrating) affair that didn’t translate particularly well to Game Boy controls.

The other two, however, stand out miles above the myriad of other spin-offs that followed. Pokemon Stadium was the last of the four to launch, but undoubtably had the most longevity and biggest following. In its original guise, offering just 42 Pokemon, it was only available to Japanese players, with a follow-up extended to America and Europe that offered all 151.

It was a sight to behold creatures that had only previously been crudely seen on Game Boy screens in 64-bit, whilst the gameplay experience, which allowed players to transfer their captures from Red/Blue/Yellow to participate against Gym Leaders and in tournaments of up to 80 battles, was sensational. It also enabled the emulation of the Game Boy games on a TV (cue eye strains/headaches!)

Pokemon Stadium 2 improved massively upon proceedings, incorporating all of the Pokemon from Gold/Silver/Crystal, but the Nintendo 64 was on its last legs by the time it arrived in North America in Europe. Sadly we’ve never seen a ‘proper’ third outing…

2. AVOID - Pokemon Battle Revolution

Pokemon Battle Revolution could technically be considered to be either the third outing for either the Stadium series or the Colosseum/XD series, given that it incorporated features from both.

Advertisement

Its core appeal was the offering of online play, but this was a barebones affair with just two choices, letting players test their mettle against either a friend or a random person in a single match. Without the presence of tournaments or other novelty match options, these got dull and repetitive very quickly and soon resulted in a dead community, with fans flocking to the online offerings of Diamond & Pearl to get their combat fix.

The offline gameplay was similarly limited, with there being no RPG mode in the vein of Colosseum/XD. The different arenas, each of which came with different parameters (such as team battles or battles where the Pokémon of the player and their opponent are randomly allocated to each other), were enjoyable enough, but quickly beaten with minimal challenge.

All in all, the game felt more like a expensive 3D expansion to Diamond & Pearl rather than a fully fledged game in its own right, as without connecting these it was very limited - only six Pokemon can ever be used if none are transferred over, for example.

Just over a million copies were sold worldwide, meaning that we haven't seen another Stadium-style title since.

1. PLAY - Pokemon Snap

Almost every interest, art, craft and passion has been turned into a game at some point, with varying degrees of success. Many games have incorporated photography in some shape of form - Final Fantasy XV made it the 'skill' of one of the four playable characters and Red Dead Redemption 2 allowed you to take selfies in 1899, to name but two. In-game photography is now an art form in its own right because of the likes of these, but very few games are wholly centred around it.

Advertisement

Pokémon Snap is one of the few, having released at the height of Pokemania back in 1999. Despite featuring just 63 of the original 151 creatures across its 7 on-rails levels, it was hugely addictive, necessitating several runs with expert timing and item usage (to lure certain types to you or to get them to evolve) to get the best shots.

Somewhat sluggish when played through the Virtual Console today, it nevertheless holds up as well as any other game from the era.

The appeal of photography in the real world, wildlife photography in particular, is getting one in a million shots. Snap and its virtualisation of this accomplishment with fictional creatures is definitely worthy of being replicated now that there's 809 Pokémon. Challenging players to find all of these in a huge in-game world, whether free roaming, on rails, or both, would be a hugely immersive and rewarding experience.

If only David Attenborough could narrate.

Advertisement