4 Reasons Why Gaming Must Be Used in Education

Games are everywhere and it's time they were brought into the classroom

By Edward Owen /

According to a 2009 study by the American Life Project, 97% of teenaged Americans play some form of videogame, be that on the computer, the internet, on a handheld or on a console. Games are everywhere, and they€™re here to stay. On the flip side of that coin, a 2006 educational report by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation entitled The Silent Epidemic identified that upon questioning large stratified sample of US high school drop-outs over why they hadn€™t received their high school diploma. 47% of the interviewees cited their main reason for a lack of success as €˜classes not interesting.€™ If we correlate this with a separate study by the Alliance for the Excellence in Education which puts the amount of drop-outs each year to be around 1.2 million, we can make a reasonable case for there being around 600,000 drop-outs who just couldn€™t find themselves motivated by the educational system in its current guise, and that€™s just in the US alone. I believe there must be a link between these two seemingly disparate facts. They simply can€™t be a coincidence: gaming has surely done something to the education system, and it€™s not necessarily a good thing. Please don€™t misunderstand the article - this won€™t be an attempt to debunk gaming as something that corrupts innocent young minds; the educational €˜problem€™ gaming presents goes much deeper than such a shallow reading of events. In essence, I€™m hoping to address the problem not in terms of what we engage with, but how we engage with it, and how videogames and technology in general has changed this all-important trait. But one thing is clear- there certainly has been a change. We€™ve adapted our thought processes to fit our digital lives, and that€™s bad news for the education system. Yet we shouldn€™t despair. Whilst this article will argue that the current education system has been found wanting by the advent of gaming, it will also argue that the solution for these problems come from the games themselves.

Advertisement

Advertisement

4. Technological Familiarity Has Outmoded the Classroom

Did you know that over 28 million of us play Farmville every day, and there are over 5 million people who play World of Warcraft for 40 hours a week? More to the point, does that even surprise you? If no, there€™s a good reason why. Gaming, or technology on the whole, has effectively moved the goalposts of modern life. Since the turn of the 20th century, we€™ve undergone a digital revolution; our pockets can now store the equivalent of an arcade machine, a stereo system, a room full of music and an entire office€™s worth of personal admin, on something we can fit in a pocket. Our games consoles are more powerful than some satellites. If we couple such progress with the invention of the internet, we can now say we live in a world where technology is utterly ubiquitous; everyone is connected to something, and we don€™t even need the wires. Hell, you wouldn€™t be reading this article if this wasn€™t true. Consequently, it is possible to argue that in light of this 24/7 exposure, the way we process information has been utterly changed. Whereas before the advent of the internet our sources of interaction were limited- newspaper, the phone, television etc., we are now exposed to an absolute gamut of conflicting information merely by turning on our computers. As a result, we have become more discerning consumers of information, rather than the passive spectators we used to be. The presence of a gigantic morass of information requires us to be more active in what we choose to take on board, and thanks to technology we can make these choices almost instantaneously. This phenomenon of becoming intellectually more active has been actively stoked in younger demographics by the presence of gaming. Think about it; unlike any other medium, gaming is completely defined by its interactive nature- it€™s a unique selling point that distinguishes it from more passive media such as films or TV. But not only does it encourage the need to be intellectually active, it requires the participant to be active at pace. Ever since the days of arcades, the need for twitch-speed decision-making has often been the deciding factor between success and failure, and as the gaming phenomenon has grown in popularity more and more individuals are being exposed to this cognitive quickening. This veritable omnipresence (again, that 97% stat comes to mind) cannot be underestimated- whether consciously or unconsciously technological ubiquity has made students much more adept at processing information, but more importantly, they expect it to come at them quickly. Yet when a student enters the modern classroom, all this progression is lost. They are confronted with a system that has barely moved since the 1950s. The active engagement drummed into them by today€™s modern world is dropped for intellectual passivity, as they hand over their autonomy to a teacher who might occasionally ask them a question. This absurd classroom situation has baffled industry experts- Jason Ediger (the Director of iTunes U and Mobile Learning at Apple) likens it to being on board an aircraft insofar as you must turn off all devices and stay in your seat. All pace is dropped, all empowerment is dropped, and unsurprisingly, pupils become bored and disengaged. The classroom simply lacks the rapid interactivity and becomes instantly demotivating as a result. Minds wander, and results suffer. But why hasn€™t the classroom simply moved on? Read on to find out.

3. Mistrust and Misuse of Technology by the Teaching Generation

Advertisement
As I€™ve already established, the modern student is very much at ease with technology. They€™ve been brought up in a world where digital devices are a natural part of life, and have acted as primary tools for socialising. They check Facebook, traipse WhatCulture and play video games without a sense of wonderment; it€™s entirely natural for them. They live on the internet; they€™re digital natives. By contrast, many adults teaching today (although I€™m keen to stress not all of them) weren€™t brought up in the shadow of the digital age. Whilst they can work a computer, they do so in a manner akin to an acquired skill, like learning to knit or speak a new language. It€™s had to be learnt, and thus isn€™t natural. As such, they retain a vestige of old-world, slower thinking from days before the digital revolution, and therefore the twitch-speed thinking that comes as a consequence. As a result, there is an educational schism based on how these two opposing camps view technology. Students view technology as utterly neutral; they are tools to be used. You might play Angry Birds on your iPhone, but you can also use it to learn- half of the hundred top selling apps have educational purposes, often being targeted at nursery and primary school children. The technology itself is a means to an end, representing a paradigm shift from slower analogue thinking into quicker digital possibilities. However, older teachers are inherently distrustful of technology precisely because of this freedom it offers. What they see is the potential for distraction and a disruption of the integral classroom relationship between pupil and teacher. They don€™t see educational possibilities- having lacked the ubiquitous influence of technology in their formative years, many feel ill-at-ease utilising it now, and are often ill-equipped to innovate adapt their methods. Because they don€™t know how to do it, they don€™t want to do it. It doesn€™t help that experiments to introduce technology on the terms of the teachers have often yielded mediocre results- whilst many schools in North America have been given laptop grants, the impact they have had on grades has been minimal. This relative lack of success clearly doesn€™t help break down this preconception that digital, wireless technology is only adept in a leisure capacity, and it becomes even more frustrating when one could argue that this conclusion isn€™t based on a fair representation over the scope of its use. Much like you wouldn€™t play football with a tennis racket, the use of tools shouldn€™t be measured by those unfamiliar with how they operate. Such unfamiliarity leads to the continued use of technology in a slow way. It appears that the absolute zenith of school innovation on the whole is the implementation of Microsoft Powerpoint into a lesson plan. Yet, one could possibly argue that this is just a continuation of the same problem. Whilst Powerpoint is technologically advanced, it is only in a nominal sense. The thought processes behind it are not much changed from the passive student-active teacher model, insofar as the teacher has direct control over what the pupil is seeing and how long they€™re seeing it for. All this is arguably based on a misunderstanding. As study after study has proved, students are inherently demotivated when the tools to learn are external to them. They are oppressive. The internal life of a student is a much busier place these days thanks to technology, and as such can be trusted with much heavier intellectual loads and responsibilities. They don€™t need to be led. Potentially, they can lead themselves, if given the right direction. Effectively, the advent of ever-present electronic media has meant that students these days are speaking an entirely different language to their teachers. Their minds, honed and quickened by their exposure to technology, are capable of taking on information at great speeds. Yet they find themselves in the slow lane, in a schooling environment that doesn€™t acknowledge these new developments. Their natural voracity for information is stunted in the classroom, creating this very modern sense of boredom. However, this could change in the future, as crops of teachers who have been brought up in the digital age and wholly familiar with interactive mediums become teachers. But this remains to be seen.

2. The Quiet Bat-People Hypothesis

This is going to be quite unorthodox, but I€™d like you to imagine Batman. Don€™t pretend you can€™t. You€™re on WhatCulture, for God€™s sake. We live and breathe Batman up here. Ok, now you€™ve imagined your own Batman, imagine his constituent parts; what makes him up. Make no mistake, Bruce Wayne is composed of multiple, separate identities. He€™s a billionaire, a son, the chairman of a corporation, a friend and last but not least, the frickin€™ Batman. Each one of these roles has unique pressures, and requires him to don different personas based on different situations. He can€™t walk into the boardroom dressed as Batman any more than he can fight crime whilst acting the playboy. He is capable of being different people, all at the same time, whilst still existing as a unified whole. The point of this is that a person isn€™t just one simple thing; they are lots of different things, and these identities are juggled based on what situation in which the individual find themselves. So in this way, you are similar to the Batman. But don€™t get too excited- so is everyone else. With this in mind, it€™s possible to argue that when a teacher steps up to take a class, they are entering a room full of Bat-people, if one were to replace the desire to fight crime with an urge to dick about instead. They too possess duplicitous identities; they are pupils, siblings, children and they might belong to an extra-curricular activity, but this identity adoption is dependent upon the context- for example, in the classroom, the teenager would take on the identity of a pupil. However, the relentless march of technology is wearing down these old certainties. Whereas in the 1950s one would have no choice but to adopt the student identity, the discreet presence of technology in the classroom has inexorably linked the student to the world outside those four walls. Nowadays, just because a pupil is present in the classroom doesn€™t necessarily mean that they are engaged in the motions- when one has the ability to buy items, communicate with friends, check the news and of course, play games on an item no bigger than a slice of toast, the temptation to chuck the student identity out in favour of these social or fantasy ones can be over whelming, especially if given the correct motive (read: ennui) to do so. For example, I used to have a history teacher who wasn€™t terribly interesting. His lessons were dull, and he didn€™t engage us at all, and those who passed the exam did so by constantly reading the textbook. But one day, after numerous read-throughs, I became bored of that same old set-up, so under the guise of doing more work, I took my laptop out of my bag, hid the screen and started playing Football Manager. This wasn€™t an isolated occurrence, and it was only through resourcefulness and bare-faced lying that I was able to get away with my charade. The point of that little aside is this; technology is incredibly destructive when you€™re bored. It cost me a grade on my History A-level, and this was in the days before wireless was in all classrooms and smartphones were as formidable as they are now. These days, one can be much more subtle, and that€™s a terrifying thought for educators everywhere. Loading up Angry Birds on your iPhone is much more discreet than whacking a laptop on a desk and making excuses. Such a capability makes it mandatory to engage with these jaded learners on their own terms, if only for the consequences of not doing so. This advancement of technology has led us to an ultimatum; innovation has led to the point where technology can be distracting yet discreet enough to require a radical rethink about its use within the current educational context. We need new ways of incorporating these €˜new-thinking€™ people into the framework, or run the risk of losing them forever. Make no mistake, this problem isn€™t going away, and it will only get worse with technology€™s continued progress. N.B- If you got the The Thick Of It reference, well done you.

Advertisement

1. The Ease of Transferring Gaming's Fine-Tuned Motivational Mechanics

Advertisement
As has already been established, technology has changed the cognitive pace of a generation who now view them as natural tools. The most crucial aspect of this paradigm shift is a fundamental alteration in an educational concept called contiguity. Contiguity is a behaviourist concept- everybody knows of behaviourism in some form, and probably at its most simple level; conditioning. For those who don€™t know, the school of behaviourism espouses that it is possible to condition certain behaviours through the use of rewards. For the sake of this article, we€™ll start off with the use of the operant conditioning chamber, also known as the Skinner box. The idea of operant conditioning was that you could make somebody more amenable to certain actions by giving them immediate consequences to their behaviour, or to give them their proper name, re-enforcers. Case in point, the Skinner box. A rat in a box pushes a button, and gets a food pellet. As a result, the rat becomes more amenable to pushing that button. To put this in formulaic terms, it looks something like this: Antecedent (the box) --> Behaviour (the button push) --> Consequence (the food pellet) Contiguity is the point between the behaviour and the consequence, the action and the re-enforcer. It is vitally important in motivational terms; its length establishes how effective a re-enforcer is going to be. For example, if we commit an action and don€™t get a reward until two weeks later, it€™s devalued as a result- you won€™t necessarily associate the reward with an event that happened a fortnight ago. But if the result is as immediate as possible, you€™re onto a whole different story. The twitch-speed of today€™s technology has arguably changed the parameters of contiguity; where once students would€™ve gladly waited a week to get an essay grade back, today€™s learners are born into an environment of digital immediacy, and find it harder to be motivated by an alien environment working at a much slower pace. Thanks to their time spent in front of screens playing videogames or even just browsing the internet, they are much more active in their interactions- the passive role of a pupil in a classroom, with its relative paucity of any kind of all-encompassing re-enforcer (grades are often few and far between, and actual feedback is only available if the teacher chooses to acknowledge you) alienate them in a similar manner to giving the rat a pellet three weeks after it pressed the button. It€™s simply not enough. Oddly enough, contiguity is where computer games specialise. A game will consistently offer you rewards for even the most unremarkable thing. Nothing embodies this more than Call of Duty€™s multiplayer; falling 10 feet? Have some XP! Blow up some cars? Have some XP! The game rewards you for anything and everything. But this isn€™t lazy game design. In fact, it€™s quite the opposite. As Microsoft games researcher and expert on motivation John Hopson once told Gamasutra; €˜€The short answer (for motivation) is to make sure that there is always a reason for the player to be playing.€™ Video game reward schemes offer the perfect counterpoint to the educational system entirely due to their acknowledgement that their proposed consumer needs constant encouragement. This isn€™t a slight on our generation, it€™s just simply a by-product of our technological lives. We possess a capacity for contiguity that is much smaller than previous generations, and videogames acknowledge this trait. But it€™s actually a bit cleverer than that. Games actively go out of their way to seize upon the contiguity stage of your processing, and make it their own private property. After all, this is where the profit margins lie. Games designers can actively stagger the contiguity phase, creating a situation where you are not going for one big reward/re-enforcer, but multiple smaller ones, capable of motivating like the big one by resembling it. Again, Call of Duty provides a perfect example; whilst you have the main levelling up system, a big part of that comes from the smaller levels contributing to this larger number- how many people you€™ve killed with a certain rifle, how many overall games you€™ve won, etc. These smaller accomplishments feed into a much larger one, becoming identified with that much larger reward. As a result, you keep on playing, knowing that your big accomplishment (levelling up) is just another small task away. This motivational mechanic is what€™s known as a variable ratio reward; the computer-game idea that we can create a consistent motivating effect through the use of smaller, more easily attainable accomplishments. What is so crucial about these mechanics is that its tenets can be just as easily applied in education. Whilst we need only look at the behemoth that is Call of Duty to comprehend the effectiveness of this stratagem on a gaming level, we can see a similar effect in Lee Sheldon€™s study of the Mark Tree High School in Arkansas. In 2009, Sheldon took a struggling class and replaced their archaic grading system a point system akin to World of Warcraft€™s levelling up process. The result of adopting smaller points, rather than overarching grades, led to a 36% increase in the passing rate and a 26% increase in students averaging a B or better. All of this was put down to marked increases in motivation- by taking away the slow-contiguity system, and replacing it with the more immediate points, pupils were instantly more engaged. Sheldon effectively proved that railing against the education system was no longer similar to shouting into the wind. Whilst many people were at their wits end trying to motivate an increasingly apathetic generation of schoolchildren, Sheldon, and others like him, have arguably proved that a solution exists. We can have an education system in which this new-minded generation can actively participate in a similar manner to the one instilled in them by videogames. The comparative ease of implementation, learnt from computer game motivational methodology, shows that whilst gaming can certainly be distracting, it can be motivating in the exact same way. Much as it can find a way to make sure the player is always playing, it can also make sure that the learner is still learning. And whilst all the other problems featured in this article are still relevant, it€™s nice to end on this optimistic note. Agree or disagree? Want follow-up literature? Feel free to comment.