4 Ways to Fix the Broken FPS Genre

They say that this year's E3 presentation was just a string of presenters showing them the exact same ultra-realistic, modern anti-terrorist, psuedo-cover based, red dot scoped FPS game with different skins on top of the levels.

By Clayton Ofbricks /

These days, I hear a lot of people complaining about the state of the First Person Shooter genre. They say it has devolved into an indistinguishable amalgmous mass of samey goo. They say the genre is on its way out unless it gets kickstarted. They say that this year's E3 presentation was just a string of presenters showing them the exact same ultra-realistic, modern anti-terrorist, psuedo-cover based, red dot scoped FPS game with different skins on top of the levels. They say all of that in line to buy a copy of Battlefield of Modern Honor 35. Well, it's easy to complain that other people are screwing up and not give a better solution, but it's a hell of a lot harder to actually think up a way to fix a problem. But not so hard that I can't do it. Why? Because I am absolutely amazing, that's why. Don't try this at home.

Advertisement

4. Cowboys and Aliens

I don't necessarily mean the movie, though a Cowboys and Aliens game would kick ass. Actually, no. A game based on High Plains Invaders, the movie Cowboys and Aliens totally ripped off, down to the very last minute plot point. The point is, blockbuster FPS games all look the same, because they are ostensibly about the same thing. The vast majority of our powerhouse shooters are the same anti-terrorism crap we've been seeing since Modern Warfare first hit the scene. Those that do stand out as being a little different are Borderlands 2, Bioshock Infinite, XCom: Enemy Unknown, and Halo 4. Did you notice a trend? The only games that are different, are the sequels to existing intellectual properties: we've reached a point of videogame narrative saturation so high that it rivals Hollywood. We now find ourselves in the unfortunate situation of being forced to swallow the leftovers of FPS pie that wasn't all that great the first time. Yes, annoying indie fan guy I hear you. You play games that are VERY different. Well I have something to say to you - I don't mind indie platformers, and I get that there are indie shooters available that challenge the mold, but I want high production value in my shooters. I want the kind of production value that put's chips in the stylized wood grain of my AK-47. However, I want diversity. I want to aim that AK-47 at a dinosaur with a rocket launcher for a face and chainsaw feet, because not even John McClane has slain as many ethnically ambiguous bad guys as I have.

3) Less Checkpoints and 2) Death to the Hide and Heal Mechanic

OK, so it might be bad form to combine two items on a list of only four items, but it had to be done to serve the greater good. Let€™s look at this from an objective standpoint by analyzing the philosophy of challenge for the two dichotomous approaches to the genre. Today:
Your modern shooter is based on a series of intense challenges, each with a save point immediately before or after. The player starts the challenge with full health, beats the challenge after however many attempts it takes, and eventually reaches the next checkpoint, where the cycle starts over. The end result is a game that is broken into thousands of mini-levels, each to be faced with full health and no penalty for failure. The main difficulty here is that the individual challenges are near impossible, and the player cannot save at a time or place other than those designated by the game. Use to be:
You started the level with whatever health or ammo you had. You then had to get through the whole level without dying. Oh sure, you could save whenever you wanted, but that didn€™t really help that much. Instead of being based on individual encounters, the challenge was focused on surviving a long term conflict, in which your health was slowly whittled away. Players had to scrounge for ammo and health, because not doing so could easily leave you with low health, making it impossible to beat a level boss or whatever. I liked the first 2 Halo games. They were fun and creative. The idea of being able to heal yourself between fights gave a new pace and feel to the game. The new pace/mechanic was the perfect vehicle for encouraging multiplayer campaign modes, and reinventing the way we think about FPS death matches. However, that doesn€™t mean every game in the world had to follow suit. The resulting flood of €œhide and heal€ games with 8 million checkpoints per level killed the overall challenge of the FPS genre. No longer does an FPS game present a singular task that you may or may not be able to beat. No no. That would be too fun. Instead, the player of the modern shooter is asked to mindlessly blunder through the same hallway full of flying bullets, dying thousands of times, until they finally succeed on advancing the 15 feet necessary for a checkpoint by sheer force of statistical eventuality. That€™s not a game. That€™s Hell.

1) Mobility and Physics

This is the one that really breaks my heart. The lack of physical mobility and physics in general in modern shooters kills me, because the technology is available. Brink, Bethesda€™s failed online shooter, provided an environment and the necessary controls to allow players to create vantage points and exploit terrain in a dynamic way. It was a shit load of fun, even if the game itself was not. On the other hand, Half Life 2 provided us with (albeit simple) physics puzzles and physics games that made it clear that we could have somewhat realistic physics in a shooter.
The technology exists, but simply isn€™t being utilized. Instead of being flung through the air, jumping off of moving vehicles, sliding under rails, hoping fences, ramming down cardboard walls with our shoulders, blowing shanties apart with mines, or any million other amazing things that we could be doing, we are stuck negotiating an endless maze of face high walls. The resulting loss of mobility forces us into a specific path, or at best a choice of two paths. It undermines our ability to innovate. It undermines our ability to play creatively. It undermines the very foundation of gaming, free choice. Maybe I€™m just being a drama queen. It wouldn€™t be the first time. But maybe game developers are just being lazy. It wouldn€™t be the first time for that, either. If the technology to create more advanced and dynamic games exists, let€™s see it in use. They can design the games that allow total freedom of movement, so why the hell am I still moving only in a horizontal line?