5 Great X-Men Video Games & 5 That Sucked

Merging X-Men and Quake into one video game? What could possibly go wrong?

By Nick Dauk /

With the first X-Men films ushering in a new world of superheroes on the big screen, it can be easy to forget that these mutants have had plenty of outings via video game platforms over the last 30 years.

Advertisement

Believe it or not, there are nearly 30 titles with a primary focus on the X-Men and over a dozen other Marvel video games featuring Professor Xavier's team. Sadly, it's been ages since we've had a AAA X-Men game, but that doesn't mean we can't look back at the ones we do have.

Though not all X-Men games have changed the industry or even entertained gamers enough to increase replayability, there are a number of entries that brought Marvel's mutants to life in spectacular fashion on everything from traditional arcade systems and the Sega Genesis, to the Game Boy Advance and mobile phones.

Imagine ruthlessly ripping through hordes of thugs as Wolverine, pitting X-Men head-to-head in classic versus modes, and even teaming up with three of your friends in a co-op quest to take on the coolest villains in the X-Men's rogues' gallery.

Unfortunately, there are also a few games in this history that don't warrant the phrase "mutant and proud". Poor graphics, clunky mechanics, and downright bad ideas made a handful of these potentially exciting games miserable to play through...

11. Great - X-Men 2: Clone Wars (Sega Genesis, 1995)

Ask fans to name the greatest X-Men video game and there's a high probability they'll list X-Men 2: Clone Wars as one of their all-time favorites. A significant improvement in terms of manageable difficulty over its predecessor, X-Men 2: Clone Wars is still a treat to play today.

Advertisement

The game may only have a handful of levels, but they deliver a challenge with awesome boss battles. The escape from the Sentinel factory, the face-off with Apocalypse and a finale in which you have to face clones of your playable characters — it's no surprise why this game is so highly regarded.

Decent graphics, easy controls, and no limits on the mutant power bars made X-Men 2: Clone Wars a memorable game that still offers a more enjoyable playing experience than even subsequent titles released on next-gen systems.

10. Sucked - X-Men (Sega Genesis, 1993)

Any gamer born in the eighties or nineties will admit that there are a handful of Sega Genesis games that feel nearly impossible to beat — as children then and as adults now. X-Men was one of those games.

Advertisement

Released in 1993, the game had a decent cast of characters but only afforded the player to select Cyclops, Nightcrawler, Wolverine, or Gambit for primary play. Characters like Storm and Iceman could only be called in for special assists.

The boss battles were frustratingly difficult, which can be reasonably expected. But when the simple act of jumping is just as hard, there's no excuse.

Couple these problems with the maddening "reset" trick required to continue after the Mojo level and you've got a title that most fans decided to rage quit.

9. Great - X2: Wolverine's Revenge (Multiple Platforms, 2003)

Hugh Jackman will always be Wolverine to many fans, but one can't help but relish Mark Hammil's inclusion as the titular character in X2: Wolverine's Revenge.

Advertisement

A tie-in to the movie that boasted its own original story, Wolverine is unleashed like never before with violently sweet combos and situation-specific combat strikes.

Aside from the basic thugs who you can sneak up and impale, boss battles include encounters with the Sabertooth, Wendigo, Juggernaut, Magneto, and Lady Deathstrike.

Fun collectibles and a decent story — with appearances from other characters like Omega Red, Rogue, and a Patrick Stewart-voiced Charles Xavier, X2: Wolverine's Revenge is definitely one of the finest X-Men games in the archive.

8. Sucked - X-Men: The Official Game (Multiple Platforms, 2006)

When a video game tie-in is released for a film, it's instinctual to feel a little nervous. While some titles take a successful movie and elevate it to new heights on a game system — Spider-Man 2, for example — others don't quite rise to the occasion.

Advertisement

X-Men: The Official Game was released in 2006 to act as a storyline bridge between X2: X-Men United and X-Men: The Last Stand. On the plus side, actors like Hugh Jackman, Alan Cumming, and Shawn Ashmore lent their voices to their playable characters and the plot was interesting enough to warrant its development.

However, the downsides to this game are a little more glaring. After a few levels of bouncing back and forth between characters, the game begins to lose its speed, potential, and enjoyment. An explanation for Nightcrawler's absence is interesting, but the hours spent playing the game for small tidbits of canon would have been put to better use crafting a novelisation instead.

7. Great - X-Men Legends II: Rise Of Apocalypse (Multiple Platforms, 2005)

The Marvel: Ultimate Alliance games may be seeing a contemporary resurgence, but the real heroes of those titles are the X-Men. X-Men Legends released by Activision in 2004 was the template for future UA games.

Advertisement

This action role-playing that met critical acclaim was only made better in its sequel, X-Men Legends II: Rise of Apocalypse.

Better cutscenes, online multiplayer capabilities, and a phenomenal cast of playable and non-playable characters from the X-Men, Brotherhood, and Marvel lore created one of the best X-Men games to date.

The success of the two X-Men Legends titles had a direct and positive impact on future Marvel video games. Unfortunately, X-Men fans would have to settle for limited X-Men inclusion in the subsequent Ultimate Alliance titles.

6. Sucked - X-Men: The Ravages Of Apocalypse (PC, 1997)

As we've seen countless times in the comics, not all super-powered team-ups are successful. X-Men: The Ravages of Apocalypse proves that joining two popular and powerful forces together doesn't always work in the video game world either.

Advertisement

X-Men: The Ravages of Apocalypse was an official expansion of the Quake PC game. Still retaining its first-person shooter gameplay style, players were tasked with taking down cyborg clones of the core X-Men.

A unique premise, but not the mutation that players wanted in the next evolution of X-Men games. Who wants to slay X-Men with guns? Evidently, not many. The game failed to bring the X-Men fanbase into the Quake universe and remained simply a fun modification to the existing game.

5. Great - X-Men: Mutant Academy 2 (PlayStation, 2001)

Paradox released a trio of X-Men games that provided an experience countless gamers and mutant lovers wanted — a classic versus mode featuring our favorite characters.

Advertisement

Although the Marvel vs. Capcom games are fantastic in their own right, Paradox's X-Men trilogy stands tall on its own, too. X-Men: Mutant Academy got the gameplay right and X-Men: Next Dimension, the third title, offered an amazing roster of characters (including Sentinels) to choose from, but most agree that X-Men: Mutant Academy 2 was hit the sweet spot.

MA2 expanded on the successes of the first game, included more playable characters, and added new gameplay via Academy Training and a Survival mode.

4. Sucked - X-Men: Destiny (Multiple Platforms, 2011)

At first glance, X-Men: Destiny seems like a refreshingly exciting game. Instead of choosing from the same line-up of playable X-Men characters, players had the opportunity to essentially create their own mutant and lead them through a series of choices that would align them with either the X-Men or the Brotherhood.

Advertisement

Sadly, that's where the excitement stops. The idea was solid but the execution was not, leaving players underwhelmed and desiring more. Even repeated plays of the game to explore different storyline scenarios is not enough to redeem it.

Most choices had no bearing on the outcome of the game until it was time to choose a side. Diverse character cameos were a plus, but the overall game felt hollow. It lacked consequence and didn't give players an incentive to become fully engaged in the game.

A great concept, no question. A great game? Far from it.

3. Great - X-Men Origins: Wolverine (Multiple Platforms, 2009)

Loosely based on the film of the same name, X-Men Origins: Wolverine the video game does what its cinematic equivalent could not — entertain hardcore and casual fans alike.

Advertisement

The modifications to the movie storyline were welcomed, but it was the gameplay itself that captivated fans. Taking a violent page out of games like God of War, this M-rated romp through the world let Wolverine loose in all his glory.

Special attention to small details, such as the increased temporary visibility of his muscle tissue and adamantium skeleton when taking massive amounts of damage, distracted from the levels that may have otherwise felt too repetitive at times.

The Uncaged Edition of this game only enhanced its playability, offering players additional levels full of bad guys to rip apart.

2. Sucked - X-Men II: The Fall Of The Mutants (DOS, 1990)

Paragon Software had a short but arguably successful run when it comes to creating Marvel video games. Operating in the late 80s and early 90s, they put together five games in the span of three years featuring the likes of Spider-Man, The Punisher, Captain America, and the X-Men.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, this is a case where quantity doesn't substitute for quality.

Their first title, X-Men: Madness in Murderworld birthed a sequel X-Men II: The Fall of the Mutants — and fall did it ever.

Granted, the game does offer a diverse selection of 15 X-Men to play as, but the play itself is less than exciting. Scrolling around the screen with an overhead viewpoint, The Fall of the Mutants is more adventure-based than action-packed — envision Pokemon crossed with X-Men characters and let that disappointment sink in.

1. Honorable Mention: Deadpool (Multiple Platforms, 2013)

Let's face reality — it was only a matter of time until Deadpool broke out of his comic book confines and leaped into another medium. Debuting in his eponymous video game years before he graced the silver screen, 2013's Deadpool was hilarious, highly engaging, and worth subsequent playthroughs just to catch all of the jokes.

Advertisement

As great of a game as it was — and still is during our drought out X-Men related titles — a case can be made to not include Deadpool among the other X-Men video games.

Similar to how his films existed in their own world that was loosely tethered to the main X-Men cinematic outings — thus, making his films hard to fairly rank against the others — it feels slightly unnatural to try and shoehorn him into a ranking of other X-Men video games.

An opinion that's open to dispute, all gamers can at least agree that Deadpool was great and that it sucks that we were left with such a sweet but short game.

Advertisement