5 Lessons The AEW Video Game Can Learn From Previous Wrestling Games
And not just 'Give us a modern day No Mercy'.
With Kenny Omega confirming at Starrcast that there will be something announced about a potential AEW game by the end of the year, fans have yet another reason to get excited about a reasonable alternative to WWE's monopoly.
Many have criticised the yearly offerings by 2K and with long-time series stalwart Yuke's parting ways with the company, it has led to speculation and hope that the developer responsible for some of the most beloved WWE games will have a hand in creating AEW's first foray into the gaming world.
Whoever ends up developing the game will certainly have a lot of material to draw inspiration from. There has been well over 100 licensed wrestling video games released over the years from MicroLeague Wrestling on the Commodore 64 all the way to this year's WWE 2K19. In amongst this plethora of pixelated pro wrestling there has been some truly amazing and innovative design choices... as well as some not so amazing decisions. What the AEW game decides to draw from could determine the success or failure of this fledgling product.
5. It's OK To Not Go AAA
Although a lot of people will be expecting an AEW game to directly rival WWE's 2K series, there's a lot to be said for titles that fill their own niche. If anything, games like the Spike Chunsoft developed Fire Pro Wrestling series prove that when it comes to an authentic wrestling experience, gameplay really is king.
On the surface, the graphics might be a bit off putting for some and the control scheme can be a little confusing. Just beyond this however, is some of the deepest gameplay you’ll find in any wrestling game. Each wrestler has specific AI behaviours and an extensive move list so that everyone wrestles exactly as they do in real life.
This attention to detail has ensured that Fire Pro Wrestling has a dedicated fan base, one which includes top star Kenny Omega - who just so happens to be involved in some capacity in the decisions on the AEW game!
4. Don't Ignore The Online Modes
For years, fans of wrestling video games have been left consistently disappointed with the quality of online modes. Terrible playability has always plagued the 2K WWE games with reports of lag, disconnections and even de-syncing resulting in people in the same match experiencing different gameplay. This has ensured that playing these games online has been the last thing on the minds of the generally loyal fanbase of the series.
In an era where so many people love playing games online with both friends and strangers, it seems silly that there isn't a robust wrestling offering. There are endless possibilities. How about a ranked mode in which you play through an elimination tournament to earn the right to play in an online pay-per-view? And higher ranked players get to face off against each other for championship titles?
In a world in which battle royale modes are all the rage, isn't it odd that the sport synonymous with the stipulation hasn't put its hat in the ring?!
3. Better Representation
We've come a long way in both wrestling and gaming. Gone are the days where games like Rumble Roses are released aimed at pleasing the fantasies of teenage boys. Gone are the days in which women in wrestling were made to face off in bra and panties matches for the viewing pleasure of creepy old dudes like Jerry Lawler.
Wrestling games have been improving the representation of women in line with the division being more respected in the product. This is evident in Becky Lynch being made the cover star of the upcoming WWE 2K20 (even if she is sharing the honour with Roman Reigns) but progress has been slow. It's taken WWE this long to include the option to play as a female wrestler in the MyCareer mode and fans have been asking for this for a while.
AEW seems to pride itself on its diversity and its focus on all types of wrestling. It seems unlikely that the game to go along with the product won’t reflect this.
2. The Customisation Capabilities Are Key
One of the greatest pleasures in wrestling games is being able to create your own wrestler and place them into your favourite wrestling company. That way, you get to live out the fantasy you've always had of Swanton Bombing Brock Lesnar through a commentary table from the relative safety of your own home. It's always been great being able to do this in the WWE games.
Pair this with the other creative modes that have popped up in the series like creating Entrances, Move Sets, Arenas, Championship Titles, Finishing Moves and even Stories at one point and you have a nice platform for being creative.
The only real downside to the WWE creation suite is that it has grown a bit stale. It uses the same assets every year so despite there being a lot of choice, it's a lot of choices we've already made. With the focus on having something for everyone shown by AEW it would be great to see a deep and varied creation suite to suit all kinds of players.
1. Wrestling Fans Want Stories, Not Simulations
Speaking of living the fantasy. For a while there 2K was running the risk of making a fatal error with its created player focused career content. Obviously well versed in sports simulations, the company tried providing what can only be described as a Sports Entertainer simulator, especially in the last few entries before 2K19.
Instead of playing your created character through interesting story arcs, you were forced to grind in meaningless matches and slowly walk about backstage. Most of the interactions in this area were you talking to road agents about how much Triple H didn't like you. He still didn't in 2K19 but at least it focused more on a "kayfabe" story angle.
The SmackDown vs. Raw series certainly wasn't perfect but the career modes in those games had a lot of fun moments. The branching story paths meant that big wins and losses really mattered, and you really felt that your character was an important part of the roster.
Most fans respect wrestlers for the exhausting lives they lead just to entertain us, but we watch wrestling for the stories and play the games for fun. Nobody would pick up a Game of Thrones game and expect to have to control the actors as they traversed filming the show!
Hopefully with how playful AEW is with the concept of kayfabe they can produce a career mode that has just as compelling a story as some of their early on-screen products already have.