Currently most of the gaming world's focus is on the massively popular and successful GTA V, and while I personally have not yet bought or played the game, I know what brilliance Rockstar are capable of thanks to 2010's Red Dead Redemption. The Wild West game took a huge step forward in the storytelling of video games, crafting characters who were expertly written and who add significantly to the story. The brilliant writing ensured important characters in RDR were never entirely perfect or dull, meaning that the characters feel more human and relatable. Ultimately of course, it is the protagonist John Marston who is RDR's strongest character. By travelling with him, understanding his difficult position and empathising with his frustration at the government, the player grows to adore him. But as much as John is the reason for the player's connection to the game, it is important to acknowledge the other characters John encounters on his travels, and how important they too are. These characters help to bring to life the world of RDR and provoke a wide array of different responses from the player, sometimes on an emotional level. This article will focus on five characters who stand out on their own in RDR for their magnificent dialogue, uniqueness and unforgettable characteristics. SPOILERS will be present throughout.
Honourable Mention - Abigail Marston
Some players may have found John's wife a boring character, possibly because she appears in the less exciting and memorable missions, but with Abigail it is her history and will to change that define her character. She is referred to as having once been a whore before the player meets her; Dutch even claims the whole gang used to 'have her' when she rode with them. Although we get no actual vision of what Abigail was like in her youth, the player gathers that she has tried, like John, to become a new person. When the two are reunited she says "we tried to change", highlighting that her redemption has been equally as difficult as John's. Whilst she remains faithful to John her real challenge lies in bringing up Jack. She wants to give Jack a proper upbringing but with John being forced back into his shooting boots she is weighed down with all the problems that single mothers face. Of all the characters in RDR, Abigail shares the deepest connection with John. She has known him the longest, both as the outlaw he was and the man he has tried to become; she is not afraid to stand up to John and reminds him of his duty to his family. When John is gunned down she is left distraught, all that she has tried to build with John for years is shattered. She follows him into the grave and while no specific cause of death is given, there's no doubt she was overcome with grief.
5. Luisa Fortuna
Luisa Fortuna is a rebel who openly opposes Colonel Allende and is willing to suffer or die for the revolution. When John meets Luisa, the two have conflicting opinions on the revolution. She is young and has a fiery passion for revolution, in contrast to John's feelings on the concept, which is captured when Luisa labels John as "a man who has lost his soul", he has lost his passion for fighting for a cause and Luisa cannot comprehend why. One can understand her view, she lives under a tyrannical Colonel and witnesses other peasants being massacred and young vulnerable women being raped. To merely sit back and ignore it all could be called cowardice and Luisa is nothing if not extremely brave. Unfortunately Luisa's characteristics are also her downfall: she is an innocent young girl who honestly believes that Reyes will make her province the 'New Paradise' it was intended to be. John attempts to convince her that "as long as there are guns and money there won't be any freedom," but she still fails to understand how he can be so pessimistic. John is a man who has fought for a cause like Luisa, but he has endured the crushing realisation at how lost and empty that cause was, whereas Luisa has not. She has much potential but she places all her hopes on Reyes, honestly believing that he loves her and that he will craft a just and free Mexico. Ultimately, Luisa sacrifices herself for Reyes, the man who cannot even recall her very name and only valued her for sexual pleasure. What makes her death even more tragic is that all she suffered and died for was not worth it, as Reyes ends up being as worse a dictator as the one he overthrows. Luisa is left another forgotten soul of conflict.
4. Nigel West Dickens
Nigel West Dickens is one of a kind. At face value his characteristics are all negative: Mr West Dickens lives his life by lying to the unsuspecting and innocent that he can give them body enhancing and immortalising tonics. He is greedy and willing to cheat as many people as he can in order to increase his profit., but there is something perversely likeable about Mr West Dickens. Maybe it is his humorous conversations with John, or his continued determinism to achieve his goals, or the fact that he is basically such a loveable coward. The wagon he uses to carry his merchandise from place to place comes to characterise the man, like all good fraudsters he is never in one place too long. It would be fair to say that initially John has little love for this man, John sees through his deception and repeatedly threatens to end West Dickens' activities permanently. The interaction between John and Mr West Dickens is some of the best in the entire game. John is frustrated that he has to cooperate with a fraudster to capture Bill, while West Dickens acts like they are off on an adventure. The cynical and honest gunslinger mixed with the optimistic and falsifying businessman made for one hell of a companionship. West Dickens has a way of using his charm and wits to escape what would otherwise be fatal situations. He is one of the smartest characters in the game, he may not use his brains for good measure but he knows how to outwit other characters. Mr West Dickens does, however, stay true to his word in helping John. From despising the man John goes to befriending Mr West Dickens and shows his gratitude when releasing him from custody later in the game. Usually Nigel West Dickens is the sort of character you would want to get his comeuppance, but strangely enough he turns out to be a character you want to survive.
3. Seth Briars
Seth is driven mad by a quest for wealth, he has an unhealthy obsession with the dead and an unpredictable psychotic nature. The first time the player witnesses Seth he appears as a dirty, half-feral and broken man in the process of grave robbing in the pursuit of treasure, but he is more than just a lost soul, in his desperation and despair Seth has come to love the corpses he roots through and despise the living. Of all the characters John has to ally with, Seth is arguably the one John is most uncomfortable assisting. It is difficult not to mention 'Undead Nightmare' when concerning Seth, as he is a character who thrives with the rotting dead rather than the active and civilised living. It is hard to imagine Seth having a normal life with a wife and children, but he claims he had it all and sacrificed it in his pursuit of treasure. He is a man overwhelmed by hatred and frustration at the world for not rewarding him with the riches he has so long desired, though the continuous searching could merely act as justification for him to go on rummaging through corpses. Yes he is furious when he discovers the glass eye but he does not suddenly return to being an ordinary man, he is just as crazed and twisted as before. Having distanced himself too far away from normality the corpses and graves are all he has left. As with West Dickens, Seth's characteristics make him memorable and unique, even if for all the wrong reasons.
2. Edgar Ross
I imagine many will question this selection: after all, how could I claim the ruthless Federal Agent who shot John in cold blood is a well written character? Put simply, Edgar Ross is one of those characters you love to hate. For the player, the worst thing about Ross is that he is the one character that John would love to kill but one who he cannot. Although Ross does not really feature heavily until near the game's conclusion the player learns that he is the one who is using John to wipe out his old gang, so it's easy to hate him quickly. Perhaps the quote that sums up why we players hate Ross is "when this over you'll probably get a medal. I know I will." We know immediately that Ross will take all the credit for the task John is forced to complete. The villain loves possessing power over John, making our hero believe that he'll cut the puppet strings before he brings them back in again to force John to do more government work. Most games end with the player defeating the villain, so to have Ross standing over John casually smoking a cigar whilst John dies was heart-wrenching to watch. The player has toiled alongside John so naturally feels the betrayal and hates Ross for it. Though the 'Remember My Family' mission was arguably not needed, it did show about Ross however, is that to his family he is not the evil and brutal man he is in John's eyes. The mission offered a new way of perceiving Ross, by having Jack meet Ross' family it made him seem more human and less like a monster.
1. Dutch Van Der Linde
RDR is a tragedy and aside from John, Dutch van der Linde is undoubtedly the most tragic character in it. He is the one character John struggles to confront as he serves as a reminder of his past and the man who taught him everything. Dutch accepts he must die with the Old West while John insists he can change and create a new life. Dutch does not belong in the New America that is stamping out the lawlessness and freedom of the Old West so he chooses to fight to the death against the law. Whereas Bill Williamson and Javier Escuella were merely out for themselves by the time RDR begins, Dutch still claims to fight for something, though what exactly that is even Dutch cannot explain. The tragic thing about Dutch is that he knows he has lost, but as he can't "fight own nature" he carries on living the only way he knows how, by fighting and killing. The mission in which the player assaults Dutch's fortress to take him down is the most thrilling mission in the game. The verbal sparring as John and Dutch ascend up the mountain provides the most significant quote that captures all of RDR's story when Dutch says to John -"you can't change who you are". This is the central theme of the game and the one thing John desperately wants is to change. But as John kills more people in the game's missions it proves John, like Dutch, seems unable to stop spilling blood, it is in their very nature. His finest moment comes when John and Dutch face-off on the mountain top. Instead of a deadly shoot-out immediately, Dutch drops his gun and laments his whole life, and how he has been trapped in an endlessly perpetuating losing battle. While the speech is a strong moment for Dutch, it also foreshadows the events of John's own story, confirming that after Dutch is gone "they'll just find another monster" to kill, and that monster is John. Who do you think is the greatest Red Dead Redemption character aside from John? Share your own thoughts below.