When Nintendo revealed the final rendering of The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker in 2001, the cel-shaded visuals caused quite a stir within the fan community. Some were pleased with the new art style, most were skeptical, and nearly everyone was surprised at the drastic departure from the realism they grew so fond of in Ocarina of Time and Majora's Mask. Despite all the hubbub, Wind Waker went on to smash expectations and became hailed by critics as the greatest Zelda game of all time. Even today, after more than ten years after its release, it is still considered by many to be the strongest, most dynamic entry in Nintendo's cherished series. The original game spawned two moderately successful spin-off games for the Nintendo DS, and by all accounts, Nintendo has moved on from the aquatic, post-Hyrule world of Wind Waker. But should it have? Sure, Wind Waker got the ol' "HD Treatment" that Nintendo has become so fond of, but it added nothing more than a little gameplay tweaking and a lot of bloom lighting. This article is going to explain why it would be in Nintendo's best interest to revisit the highly-stylized and dearly loved Wind Waker universe with a full-blown sequel for the Wii U.
5. The Art Style
Best to start off with the most obvious, right? Wind Waker's initial point of contention was its vivid and exaggerated cel-shaded art style. It was immediately likened to a cartoon, with detractors referring to the game as "Celda". However, like any great underdog story, Wind Waker's success forced the critics to eat their words. The reason this style would work so well in a Wii U sequel is because the Wii U cannot handle cutting-edge graphics, period. It's not capable of competing with the hyper-realistic content that's featured on the PS4 or Xbox One. So, instead of beating the competition at their own game, Nintendo should think outside the box (which is something they used to be renowned for) and release a game that looks totally unique. The Wind Waker universe would be a great platform for this approach, and even the Wii U is capable of making a stylized game look amazing.
4. The Story
One of the most refreshing things about Wind Waker was the story. It wasn't the tired tale of "predestined hero thwarts maniacal, power-hungry villain". In fact, Link spends the first half of the game just trying to rescue his kidnapped little sister. Perhaps the most interesting facet of Wind Waker's story was Ganondorf, or more specifically, his motives. Ganondorf isn't hell-bent on destruction or conquering the world, unlike his previous incarnations. Simply put, he was the king of a desert kingdom adjacent to the verdant Hyrule. His people were dying due to the harshness of the environment, and he wanted to take over Hyrule in order to save his people from dying out completely. You feel for the guy, and in a way, you want to see Hyrule restored to its former glory, too. He actually has a personality, and he uses the evil power of nostalgia to speak to players who once ran across the fields of Hyrule themselves. Nintendo has some deep storytelling chops, but you wouldn't know it if you examined its most recent offerings. Even Twilight Princess and Skyward Sword had predictable, mundane exposition that painted good and bad as black and white. The Ganondorf in Wind Waker operates in the grey area between those shades. If Nintendo were to bring a powerful, complex narrative back to the Great Sea, the response would be overwhelmingly positive.
3. The Gamepad
Like many (most? all?) people, I think the Wii U Gamepad is fat, useless, battery-sucking gimmick that attempts to solve problems that don't exist. However! I will admit that using the Wii U Gamepad while playing the Wind Waker HD is actually pretty comfortable. Equipping items without pausing is very refreshing, and using the gyroscope to aim is almost easier than using a joystick. I'm convinced that Wind Waker HD is the only game that *should* be played with the Gamepad. Nintendo did a great job designing the interface for the HD version, and should definitely take advantage of the Gamepad before gamers swear it off completely. A Wind Waker sequel would show consumers that the Gamepad isn't totally cumbersome, and actually works quite well within the Wind Waker world.
2. The Nostalgia Factor
Nintendo should take a page from Ganondorf's book and use nostalgia to its advantage. Enough time has passed since Wind Waker's release that the golden sheen of pleasant memories has descended onto it, enhancing its pluses and obscuring its minuses. Nintendo has done a very nice job of reminding players that Wind Waker exists, too. Whether he's featured as a fighter in Super Smash Brothers or starring in the HD remake of his own magnum opus, the cel-shaded adventurer has managed to stick around long enough to make players think (or hope) that he may appear in another original game. The duration of time between sequels has a huge impact on the anticipation of the players, and now is the perfect time for a full-fledged sequel. If Nintendo were to capitalize on the fond memories players associate with Wind Waker and release true-to-form sequel, they'd be raking in the cash.
1. The Failure Of The Wii U
Not to state the obvious, but the Wii U is floundering in mediocrity. Underpowered hardware, unintuitive software, and an uninspired library of games to choose from makes for a veritable perfect storm for the poor console. Nintendo has gotten out of the habit of creative thinking and instead have been handing out half-assed bargain bin fodder almost from the outset. That's not the type of thinking Nintendo was founded on, and if the company is ever going to get gamers to take it seriously again, it needs to consider bringing out the big guns. IE, putting out games with established fanbases. I'm not talking about another "New Super Mario World 6" or whatever, I'm talking about a beefy, original game with plot and strategy and memorable characters. A sequel to Wind Waker would be the perfect flag bearer for this return to power for several reasons. Firstly, the HD version already looks amazing, and like I said earlier, unique, stylized games are Nintendo's forte. Secondly, people loved Wind Waker. Any Google search for "best Zelda game" turns up surveys and forums with Wind Waker leading as the favorite more often than not. The sequel would essentially sell itself, which saves Nintendo big bucks on marketing. Finally, a Wind Waker sequel would make 2014 a golden year for Nintendo. The company is already bringing out games like Super Smash Brothers and Mario Kart 8 later this year, and if there turned out to be a Wind Waker sequel in the works, Nintendo would blow people's minds all over their faces. I hope you enjoyed my article. I'm a huge fan of Nintendo, and it's hard to see them struggle like they have recently. As much as I'd like to see a Wind Waker sequel rendered in beautiful HD, I don't really think it'll happen. Thanks for reading, and constructive commenting is welcome.