When reviewing games I have been guilty of using words like cinematic and filmic as adjectives and, perhaps wrongly, compliments. Games like Resistance 3, Uncharted 3 and Asura's Wrath have all had this weak and uninspired comment thrown their way. By me. Guilty as charged. "So what's wrong with that?" I do not hear you say, but I imagine it. Well, it dawned on me just recently that perhaps games trying to be like movies is a bad thing, and that perhaps it will be the downfall of the entire industry. Maybe even the world. It wont. Here are five reasons that I think games shouldn't be like films:
5. They Are Always Too Short!
To give a game a cinematic feel takes an awful lot of work. Take Uncharted for example, the cut scenes are meticulously animated, voice acted and lip synced to be absolutely perfect and just as engrossing as a real movie. This is all well and good but the other side of the coin is that the Uncharted games, though very good, only take about 8 - 10 hours to finish (not including multi-player). The highly polished and cinematic Modern Warfare takes more like 4 hours to complete. The difference between huge games like Skyrim and Uncharted is games like Skyrim are like an adventure park. There are tons of things to climb on, slide down and get wet jumping in. You will gaily laugh and skip as you tire your self out by playing there all day. Uncharted is like a roller-coaster. You can't chose where you go, but by gosh the ride is spectacular. Minute for minute the roller-coaster is more exciting but in terms of extended happy faces, it's the adventure park every time. These super cinematic games spend too much time and money on looking swish, that they forget to make sure to include enough play time to warrant the £40 price tag. Click "next" below to read the next entry...
4. All The Best Bits Are Out of Your Hands!
We play games because we want to play games, not watch animation rendered in woeful graphics. Current generation game engines look great right?! Of course, but not compared to a frickin' animated movie they do not even compare. So why do I want to spend 2 hours watching Old Ass Snake chat to Big Deal Boss in a grave yard. It isn't compelling narrative because it can't get to the point and it isn't cinematic because a film lasts as long as this stupid conversation. The real kicker is when a game looks cooler in the cut scenes than when you are in control. A classic example is Devil May Cry 3. Yes, a bit vintage now, but there's an HD Collection so deal with it. In the cut scenes Dante surfs missiles, fights demons with their own weapons (that happen to be skewering his limbs) and has a bat shit crazy sword fight with Virgil. Grated, Dante looks pretty bad ass in the gameplay but you don't do any of those things! The fight with Virgil is actually an exercise in dodging not standing toe to toe like some sort of demonic Jake LaMotta. I want to be the guy who pulls off the coolest moves with my thumb dexterity, not the guy that makes characters look "ok I guess." Click "next" below to read the next entry...
3. Random Events Aren't Random The Second Time! You know what I hate? When I'm climbing up the side of a shaky looking surface and suddenly my hand or foot hold breaks and I think I'm gunna die right.....but then I don't. The first time this happened I was like "woah, that was crazy, I thought that was the same as these other luminous yellow hand holds that are protruding from this old Italian villa.....but it turns out.....it wasn't." After the 3rd Uncharted game full of such events...lets just say the excitement had worn off. See, I'm happy with the contrived game design that allows platforming, it's not realistic but it is a game, no one with tits that big can grab a ladder while falling and chest plant into a wall without screaming bloody murder. Realism isn't what games are about. The problem is that cinematic games are so bloody realistic and blockbustery that they try and be like a movie, and look all real. Except, the gamer doesn't know what he can and can't climb up so, hand holds still need to light up with a neon sign....but now you don't know which is safe or not. However unexpected these things are, they never kill you, unless you are completely brain dead and don't actually jump on when your hand hold crumbles. War games are the same, you get these cool war movie moments where a wall will blow out into your face with no warning. Unless of course, you finished the ten minute campaign and are replaying in some sad hope to make the game value for money, then you know it is coming and it just slows you down. Click "next" below to read the next entry...
Advertisement
2. Things That Are Cool in Movies Aren't Cool in Games (and vice versa!) Hollywood and now sadly gameywood still haven't figured this out yet. Things that are really awesome in films, like stunts, fights, shootouts, car chases and boobies are all cool because they feature real people doing things we can't. Like when Bruce Lee beats up 10 men, or Bruce Willis shoots 10 men, or Bruce Campbell cuts off his hand and replaces it with a chainsaw and kills 10 of his possessed friends. However, when a game character does something like that you go "meh, it's made up." The reason you feel less excited is because while it is just like a movie, unlike a movie the game character could have done anything. Like, absolutely anything. It could have killed 10 men by turning into a giant spider and eating their heads. Bruce Lee can't do that! Of course the same is true in reverse, the limitless potential for crazy shit in games does not translate well to film. Just look at Res Evil. In the game world we are ok with the fact that in the middle of a city under zombie siege there is a hot Asian woman in a red dress who knows a thing or two about kung fu. In a film, this is just so stupid you are afraid to even call it stupid because you are worried it is actually mentally disabled and you don't want to be politically incorrect. Click "next" below to read the next entry...
Advertisement
1. They Are Always Too Long (for the story)! Oh man, I love a good long game. Like a Final Fantasy (X and prior) or something. Something with a big bold story full of great characters who over 60+ hours I come to love. What I don't love is a game with a cinematic story (ie. 90 - 120 mins of story) stretched out over 5 - 12 hours. Crysis 2 is a great example of this. It's like a 15 minute short movie stretched out over a series of really boring city levels. Top and tailing these levels are a bit of crap giving your yet another reason to change direction. Of course, every now and then a scripted event will happen, usually in the distance and you'll go ohhh and ahhh like a baby who's seen its first penguin. Cinema is a finely honed art. It has been honed over the last 100 or so years and let me tell you, they have the narrative beats down to a science. People have written books about it. Don't read them. Games, through necessity, can't follow these tried and tested narrative formulas so instead they just bloat out the travelling and fighting. For a start, the hero can't refuse the call to action (thus building suspense) because if he did that you'd have nothing to do. The heroes also rarely fail and require a good mentor because lets face it, failing in a game is game over. What you get 9 times out of 10 is a game with a weak and contrived plot that is just a series of expensive, well animated, but ultimately pointless set pieces that take the game out of your hands. A game needs the equivalent of a whole novel worth of writing just to stretch to 10 hours and have a decent story with good dialogue. Games like Final Fantasy 7, or Skyrim could probably fill a whole saga. Click "next" below to read our final part, "The Exception"...
Advertisement
The Exception! Every rule has an exception (that is a total lie) and so does this list. In my opinion, the only successful crossover between the mediums of gaming and film is Red Dead Redemption. Here's why: Red Dead is first and foremost a game. It is based on a tried and tested gaming model, the GTA franchise, and features missions rather than linear narrative development. The reason it works as a filmic game is because it takes the visual codes and conventions of the western genre, and lovingly uses them to design a 3d playground. It doesn't try and give you a movie experience, it gives you a really great gaming experience and bases it on classic moments from movies.