5 Things To Learn From The Aliens: Colonial Marines Debacle

By Patrick Dane /

certain sites, you may have noticed that Aliens: Colonial Marines [A:CM] and Gearbox Software CEO Randy Pitchford have caused a bit of a stir recently. It has been a roller coaster ride charting the course of the game's coverage in the press. From euphoric hype, to hugely disappointed reviews and now a confused and angry aftermath, the whole debacle has been fascinating to watch. If you have no idea about any of this, this should at least give you a taste. In truth, it is a sad reality that in the end: an anticipated game turned out bad. Nobody likes reviewing bad games, nobody likes making them and nobody likes dealing with the anger afterwards. But the whole situation his really kicked up some issues about the industry as a whole and in reality, no one has come out unscathed. Journalists, game developers, PR companies, audiences, they are all licking their wounds. As some one who has been kicking around as an online journalist across film and games, I think there is lots to take away from the whole mishap. So much so that I thought you might get value out of preparing them in list form.

5. We Should Hold Developers More Accountable For Their Products

Frankly, the phobia of corporations ends a lot of worthwhile arguments prematurely. I have heard the phrase, "EA/Activision/Ubisoft/Nintendo ruined " so often that it has become totally meaningless. Publishers are so often blamed for a game falling short of expectations that we have forgotten to hold developers accountable for the content they create. The idea of shady figures sitting behind big desks smoking their cigars and thinking about ways to screw us out of money is a dated image. Well, sort of. The games industry gets away with a lot of questionable business practice down to Season Passes, paid for DLC and microtransactions. But a game's artistic content is far too often blamed on a major publisher rather than the people actually making the artistic choices. If I may present a case study, look at Dead Space 3. The game has actually been praised in most areas, with many citing a weak story as its downfall. Now sure, it is possible EA proposed the franchise become more action orientated, but there are certainly parts of that game's story that aren't down to EA's sway over creative choices. My point being that maybe, as consumers, we should step back and consider our brand and franchise loyalty. It is easier to blame the 'suits' than the artists of a game but sometimes we should be asking the hard questions of the creators. Not out of malice, but out of love of video gaming. Gearbox's handling of A:CM looks more and more questionable by the day. This was a publisher that has had similar experiences with Duke Nukem Forever in the past, but is generally loved for its Borderlands games. However, it looks as if A:CM is the their fault more than Sega's at this point. I think this all goes hand and hand with understanding the value of bad art. Bad art is important to progress the whole form further, and challenging bad art is important for creators to build upon their previous efforts. Loyalty to Bioware, Double Fine, Lionhead Studios, Blizzard and indeed Gearbox doesn't help anybody. Least of all your developer of choice.

Advertisement

4. Maybe Journalists Can Do A Better Job

Playing the blame game Russian roulette, allow me to now point the gun at my own head. Well I didn't cover the game, so I guess I can go unscathed, but that doesn't mean that A:CM hasn't left me in deep reflection about my own work. Much of the mismanaged hype can be laid on to the media's shoulders and not looking past what PR teams wanted them to see. Sometimes at a press event, you walk a very tight rope. Pushing for more information is essentially the crux of a journalist's job and controlling the information is the PR's job. It is a relationship that is bound to create friction, especially as the PR can decide whether or not to invite the journalist again for future events. However, in the case of A:CM especially, the press were regurgitating exactly what the PR wanted them too and I didn't see too many articles where the creators of the game were pushed for hard and concrete answers about what they were promising. Now, I sympathise with journalists who feel like they were lied too to their face. When someone tells you a lie and you report it, it can make you look brash, unreceptive and worst of all, unprofessional. The truth it, there isn't a lot you can do about it. But it does usually mean that there was a line of questioning that was ignored such as pushing for more details on a promised feature. But possibly the thing to do better is figure out how a game has been packaged for a preview and figure out if that has any real meaning. How much game time did a journalist get with the game? Was it hands on? Was it controlled? And how far into development is the game? All of these things matter, even if it seems like they don't at the time. If I was on a film junket and they just showed a short fizzle reel with unfinished special effects two weeks before release, the alarm bells would be ringing I really am not trying to call anyone out on this. The whole situation is a mess for everybody, and I certainly am not trying to get on a high horse to suggest I would have done anything differently. But it should allow us to sit back and consider the way we do things in the future.

Advertisement

3. Game Developers Need To Deliver On Their Promises

No one sets out to make a bad game and mislead their audience. Every developer wants to go into a new project and do new and exciting things. Wanting to dbe ambitious and deliever a great product should be high on the priority list of any developer creating a new game. But being mindful about what you can achieve and what you are on target to complete is very important. Because if you don't, you could find that you have alienated your audience. For as much as I like him, Peter Molyneux is a common offender of such a crime. He will often promise the world and end up delivering a very stripped version of said world. I believe that when Gearbox showed the demo footage for A:CM, they had every intention of achieving that standard, but for what ever reason, it just didn't come off. The result has left fans feeling lied too, when really it may have just been a failed ambition. I am sure no one at Gearbox had the intention of misleading customers so incredibly, but that is what has happened, and it is possible that it is all due to failed ambition. Of course, coming out to explain that some of what the fans feel like they were promised may not make it into the final game may have helped to not exacerbate the problem though...

2. Audiences Really Need To Think About Pre-orders

The game industry is a very strange market for consumers. Consumers are asked to lay down their money for highly priced new games. On top of that, there might be day one DLC to pay fort, further DLC expansions, microtransactions, activation codes and S on top of all that, season passes for content that allows you to get discounts on content that hasn't even been conceived yet. It is a dangerous wilderness for gamers and their money out there. So it is a wonder why so many consumers are so eager to part with their money before a game has even been able stand on its own two feet. It of course is apart of our consumer culture that we want the new thing, and we want it now, but personally I think the problem goes deeper. It is not always about getting your hands on a game as early as possible, but instead about allegance. This the same basis for console wars between fans. It is about putting your money down and picking a team, the rationale being, 'I must be a bigger fan, because I have already bought it.' But A:CM has shown that it can be very easy to be misled by advertising. Customers may begin to think twice about their purchases, or at the very least, reconsider preorders. As a consumer, you may miss out on the odd bit of digital or physical paraphernalia, but you also will be buying a product that has been proven and you know you want, as opposed to an item you think you know you want.

1. Endlessly Hyping A Game Can Be Hurtful In The Long Run

I have no issue with PR people whatsoever. I have only had pleasant dealings with them. I understand it is there job to get people excited about a product and showcase it in the most positive light. But A:CM has really proven that endlessly hyping a game to the press, that you know is almost certainly going to face a level of backlash in the end, is a harmful strategy. Sure, the release date sales maybe great but it won't last long, and in the long term you are garnering long term resentment and distrust that could hurt future titles. Instead, managing hype for a game could be a really useful tactic. This is by no means an easy thing to do, with no instructions on how to promote a game while down playing it at the same time. However, allowing journalists time with a game, instead of inventing demos for them to hype, could go some way to allow damage control. Some might say some hurtful things about the product, but it allows an audience to adjust their expectations. Sometimes you just have to let a bad game be a bad game.