Video games, more than in any other medium, are defined by the villains in the story. Because you, as the player character, are often fighting the bad guys directly, you tend to pay attention to them as much or more than the other characters on the player's side. And when the stories often revolve around stopping the villains, either temporarily or permanently, it's hard not to notice when the bad guys are sucking the fun out of games. Let me be clear archetypes aren't bad, if used creatively and executed well. For each and every example on this list, you can probably come up with tons of examples that counter my assertions (especially since I'm going to be sticking to examples from games from the last 13 years). And in sandbox games, some of these archetypes are great as the canvas to the paint brushes of your weapons or special abilities. But these archetypes are on this list for pretty good reasons, especially since they tend to keep cropping up in some of the biggest games out there. And keep this in mind, too you can have some of these archetypes overlap, which can make for a truly horrible combination. With that said, here are the 5 worst villain archetypes in video games as of today, starting with...
5. Insane Corporations
Notable Examples: CELL, Umbrella Corporation (and most other companies in Resident Evil), Armacham Insane corporations are the mad scientists of our time. They engage in morally dubious actions for questionable profits and wind up endangering tons of people, if not the whole world. Many times they come across as unimaginably stupid, even by the low standards of real life corporations, for missing the obvious warning signs that their actions might cause huge catastrophes (like the fact that using an alien sleeping under New York as a power source might wake up). For me, the insane corporation is a big neon sign shouting "Turn off your brain." It tells me that the writers either couldn't come up with a good villain or thought that making a company evil counts as social commentary (Crysis 3 is a good example). An old franchise like Resident Evil or Syndicate gets a pass, because the archetype hadn't been run into the ground when they started, but these days, it feels like a vestige of cyberpunk that never grew up. Yeah, corporations are big monolithic entities, but even they know that blowing up world isn't good for the bottom line... and neither is holding on to their private armies.
4. Ancient Evils
Notable examples: The Reapers, every Halo villain that isn't the Covenant, every villain in Devil May Cry (except DMC 4) Ancient evils are a staple of science fiction and fantasy games, and they work in fantasy stories pretty well, because magic and/or fighting ability can be enough to beat the menace, depending on the story. Even if the bad guys are too hard to beat with widely available magic or the player character's initial strength, you can quest for a rare, secret solution, or work your way through enemies to gain strength until you can beat the villains. In general, the ancient evil archetype isn't a game killer in fantasy. In science fiction games? Totally different story. Why? Because most science fiction stories involve technology using factions, there are three options for a writer: give the ancient evil superior tech to the existing factions, the bad guys have tons of soldiers and ships, or both. The first isn't too bad, because there are several options to beat the bad guys depending on the game and its story using superior numbers to make up for inferior tech, diplomacy, and stealth missions, to name a few. But what we usually get is option two or three, which means a deus ex machina is needed to save the day, because when sci-fi writers give the bad guys the edge in numbers, they tend to go overboard with it. How overboard? Try hundreds of thousands, at the low end. To be fair to the writers, going with the huge numbers does help establish that the heroes are up against long odds to win the day. But for savvy players, it's hard not to think ahead and wonder: "What BS plot device will solve the problem?", which isn't something a good writer wants. And to be honest, it's kind of depressing to see ancient evils shoved into sci-fi stories as the primary villains, when there are more interesting antagonists around. It's one thing to have a backstory villain that shaped the universe and then died Star Trek and Star Wars had tons of those. It's another to have factions with relatable or comprehensible motives and behavior get overshadowed by villains that reduce the main conflict to a black and white affair. And game publishers/developers - when 4chan's video game board has its front page covered in threads mocking your use of the ancient evil archetype, it's time to put them to bed.
3. Faceless Aliens/Robots/Monsters
Notable examples: The Ceph, Prometheans Personality-less might be a better name for these guys, because some of them actually do have faces. But it says a lot when you can't even tell if your opponents have faces at a distance. Even if they're well crafted from a technical standpoint, it can be hard to get pumped while fighting these guys. Sure, they react to what you do, but it's usually a generic roar, charge, or lunge. After while, the subtle variations in shape and color (if there are any) just start blurring together, as you fight through wave after wave of enemies. Sometimes the only thing that makes these opponents memorable is your frustration at beating them, and not the work the developers put into them and show in the game. What's really depressing about this is the fact that it seems like enemy game design dropped off a cliff sometime in the last decade. Part of this has to be blamed on focus testing, since it's been publicly stated that Insomniac's Overstrike (a colorful, humorous co-op third person shooter) was rebranded as Fuse and was given drabber content based on the results of focus tests of adolescents. But a lot of it feels like the pursuit of realism has sucked the fun out of these less than realistic opponents. Gone are the days when Bungie could put in short aliens in bright colors that sounded silly when they shouted - and gaming is worse off for it.
2. Terrorists/Mercenaries/Foreign Armies
Notable examples: Almost every first or third person shooter set in the past 70 years It was really hard for me to pick which order to put the last two entries on this list. In many ways, both are creatively bankrupt and uninspired. And ultimately, I picked the order based on which was more reasonable, had potential for new ideas/better execution, and was less exhausting to contemplate. That said, I hate the current crop of shooter bad guys. There's nothing really wrong with them, per se. Their looks and functions are reasonable, and they do their job of shooting at the player character well. They just have very little character and distinguishing features. While games like Uncharted give mercenary leaders a bit more time in the spotlight thanks to a bigger focus on story than the average shooter, it's hard to deny that shooter enemies have the depth of a piece of paper. For me, it's really hard to care about or even remember bad guys if all they do is fight and die. And in a way, that might be the idea for the likes of Call of Duty, Battlefield, and the rest of the modern military shooter games. The lackluster villains might be there to encourage players to jump into multiplayer to get a more entertaining experience. But as a single-player kind of guy, that really doesn't do anything for me and even though sandbox shooters do offer a bit more gameplay flexibility to offset the generic enemies, generic enemies make the entire genre feel stale and uninteresting.
1. Zombies
Notable examples: Clickers, the Flood, Husks, every zombie game in existence Zombies are a blight. They are everywhere in games. No matter what genre you play, you will likely encounter at least one game that has zombies as a major or minor antagonist. You can avoid them, but sooner or later, they'll pop up in a game you like, whether they're a necessary element or not. Zombies are a loathsome archetype because they are easy to make and can fit into just about any story or genre. Zombies don't have any character elements beyond a motivation (usually eating brains or attacking people for whatever reason), which is why they are uninteresting and generic enough to fit anywhere. That means they will show up where they are least needed, often hidden away by the PR flacks under the guise of avoiding spoilers. Sometimes they're just there to justify including a shotgun in the game's arsenal (like in Halo). Even worse are the times when producers and PR guys insist that their zombies are not zombies, like what happened during The Last of Us's press junkets (yes, I know it's a fungus, but the end result is pretty much the same). Unfortunately, we're in what feels like a decade long (and counting) stretch in zombie popularity. There have been so many zombie games or games with zombies in them over the past few years that blur together, even worse than FPSes do. Story or creative gameplay gets lost in the never ending, sledgehammer to the face "This is a zombie game" advertising that these games or zombie themed DLC employ to rake in the money from the masses that haven't burned out on zombies. Part of me knows that zombies keep being used because they're non-controversial (unless you show them attacking a kid or something). That doesn't keep me from wishing they'd be dumped in that hole with all those Atari ET copies for the next decade or so, though. Disagree with this list? Have your own candidates for worst archetypes? Let us know in the comments below.