When tragedy strikes, the media goes into a feeding frenzy and always come to the conclusion that video games are the cause. Of course, our gaming culture knows better than that, but whoever really listens to us? Who is going to listen when we say the Grand Theft Auto series has some of the best storytelling out there, when one report tells our parents that we play it to get points for killing civilians (thats right, points! Good research CNN!). Who is going to listen to us when California senator Leland Yee says us gamers have no credibility in the violent media argument? I would have to disagree: millions of us game and the culture is worldwide. If all of us are the crazed lunatics the media would like to think we are, Im pretty sure the world would be nearing that post-apocalyptic state we virtually visit so often. The argument is always geared at kids, yet they fail to realize these games are mainly aimed at adults. Oh, thats right, no adults play video games, right? This is strictly a kids medium, am I right? They always say we need to take action to keep these out of kids hands. I believe the action has been taken. I must present my I.D. to purchase any game with that big fat M rating on the cover - some retailers even scan my drivers license. If a parent wants to scan their I.D. to buy the game for their kid all the power to them (my parents sure did till I reached that ripe old age of 17). It all comes down to parenting which is a whole new tender subject. They obviously trust their kid enough to separate fantasy from reality - if they made a poor judgment that does not mean an entire industry needs to be scrutinized for one persons actions. The worst part about these reports on games is how completely wrong the facts that they present about these so-called murder-simulators are. It is as if they have seen no hands-on preview, no gameplay footage - and they definitely havent seen a damn story trailer. Instead, they see the violence ensue in the montage the team has put together and pull horrible things out of thin air that make society question our sanity. So without further ado, lets look at 5 games that have been wrongly accused in news reports for years (and 5 games that could change the media's minds about video games).
5 Video Games The Media Always Gets Wrong...
5. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
We all know that infamous mission: No Russian. Everybody and their brother know about that mission. Your mother watched the horrific report on the news about No Russian, but does that mean she knows a thing about No Russian? No uh, Russian (sorry, had to). The media would like you to believe you are a terrorist who is forced to gun down innocent civilians in an airport. Truth is, that is technically true, but they forgot some very important points: 1. In no way are you forced to do this mission. In fact, you are continuously given the option to skip this mission all together. You are asked when you start this game if you want to skip the controversial material - if you say no the game once again asks you are you sure. 2. Once again you have the option to skip this mission. If you decide you are okay with the content and then are absolutely horrified by the chaos ensuing before you, all you have to do is pause the game. There at the bottom of all the text options on the side is the option to skip mission. This is not on the menu at any other point in the campaign. 3. You do not have to fire a single shot! You can calmly walk right through the chaos without pressing a button once, without drawing any suspicion from your colleagues. In this interview with Fox and Friends (you can already tell it is going to be good, right?) a gaming blogger tries to get these points across about this game, unfortunately he stumbles while the other guest (who is obviously against said games) smirks with pleasure. Take a look for yourself: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pE-nOCy7FfE
4. Mortal Kombat
Advertisement
This game is extremely gruesome, and I mean extremely gruesome: have you seen Noob Saibots fatality? It is pictured above with an awesome and accurate reaction shot from the crew over on Video Games Awesome. Enough said. However, is it really worthy of all the hate? Of all the games on the list it is absolutely the most unrealistic. The game responsible for creating the ratings system is always prominently featured in those violent video game montages, while reporters voice-over words like horrific and the always favorite stealing our childrens youth and innocence." Nevermind the fact that no children should be playing this game in the first place. In all honesty, does anybody in their right mind, kid or not, think they can rip someones spine clean out of their body, or rip someone completely in half? And if by some miracle your kid manages to do so, call the government - there is something in your water that has clearly made your kid a superhuman. Here's that amazing reaction in real time at around the 7-minute mark. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=15rzDILThNk
3. Bully
Advertisement
Bully came under a lot of fire before it was even released, just because of the subject matter of being a kid in school, and the name of the little company that was developing it: Rockstar Games. It was predicted to be a Columbine simulator. Jack Thompson went rampant trying to get this game to never hit the shelves even though he had no plot synopsis, no rating for the game, only a few screenshots that he thought the near sight of by children would turn them into raging Hulk killers. In the end, Bully was released with a teen rating, which besides the likes of the Midnight Club series was rare for a Rockstar game. It was lighthearted, hilarious, and - in Rockstar tradition - very tongue in cheek. It has become a cult classic among gamers, and there is still a dedicated group wishing for a sequel (Which was recently hinted at by VP of Creativity at Rockstar, Dan Houser himself! Fingers crossed!). It may not have been the demonic hate generating monster Thompson hoped to destroy all over the news upon release, but this little interview on G4s Attack of the Show is worth a view. Keep in mind this was before Bully was released.... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Q6kJ1xftIc
2. Every Game Ever Accused Of Being A Training Tool
You have all heard the argument They used these games as a training tool. How good of a training device are these pixelated works of fiction? Speaking from personal experience, if I was ever handed a gun, I wouldnt know what to do with it - I wouldnt know how to shoot it, and unless a square manages to pop into my line of sight telling me to reload, Im not going to know how to do that either. Hell, I would be lucky to even point out the trigger (okay, that may be a tad dramatic but you get my point). How someone can train to cause a tragedy by sitting on a couch holding a 4-inch controller to then walking into a building wielding big assault rifles is quite a stretch. There are clearly far deeper things at work here but blaming video games is easier, obviously... look at how many people listen to these false reports and back the gibberish flowing out of news anchor's mouths.
1. Grand Theft Auto IV
The Grand Theft Auto series has been under scrutiny since its humble beginnings. More than ten years later, the series is still the prominent feature of every discussion about violent video games. I picked GTA IV in particular because this game was so highly publicized, so highly inappropriate, so highly rated, and ultimately because its the first game I ever bought for the very first console I ever owned (and Im pretty sure Im not the only one who bought a new console just for this game). It is one of the most popular series of all time by one of the most popular developers and everyone just had to have it. While every news outlet out there had to let parents know just what they were buying their kids, did they actually know what game they were reporting on? Nope. In this interview with Glen Beck and Jack Thompson, the duo let parents out there know just what sickness is programmed into that sixty-dollar disc you just bought for your children. Clearly they didnt bother enough to actually play the game to relay accurate information as he goes on to state what you can do with a chainsaw in GTA IV. Now unless I missed out on one awesome cheat code there is no chainsaw in GTA IV.You thought it was over, then - after all there hasnt been a Grand Theft Auto game in going on five years now - but that didnt stop CNN from bringing it up in a recent interview. Here news anchor Erin Burnett goes on to explain how you get points for killing civilians in GTA. You are never rewarded points for killing civilians in GTA! The video game bit starts around 2:18... just watch and cringe for yourself. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=blH3Shg3nX8
Advertisement
5 Games That Could Change Their Minds...
Still bearing with me after all that ranting? Good. Now, clearly, there are very few games that grace those ever-delightful news reports, so lets talk about the ones that dont. The ones we love, the ones that reinstall our love of this art form. Some are violent, some are not, though they never make it to the headlines, maybe because they arent that horrific after all. Or maybe its the fact that everyone in the English speaking world knows what Grand Theft Auto is and couldnt name a single other video game but something affiliated with Mario, its time to get more games in the headlines (and with any luck these just might have a positive headline).
5. (Actually Play) The Grand Theft Auto Series
It is obvious from the videos shown above no one protesting this game has ever actually played any of the games. They always mention the killing of innocent civilians but do they know that is not the point of the game. Did they know you can walk through the entire game without taking the life of one NPC? They need to realize the reason we play this series is for the incredible stories, the unforgettable missions, the unbelievable set pieces, the beautifully recreated time periods, and the amazing soundtracks that occupy them. They need to experience what it is like to find the best car in the game, cruise it around the neon drenched streets of Vice City all while Billie Jean by the late great Michael Jackson plays in the background. Or fleeing across the desert on a six star wanted level all while Americas A Horse With No Name chimes over the sounds of the engine. Maybe they could grow just a little bit of respect for the series, or at the very least appreciate Rockstar's incredible taste in music.
4. Portal/Portal 2
Advertisement
Now. here are some games that are rated E for everyone, so you may be wondering what they are doing in a debate about violent video games. The point for these games being here is they are some of the most beloved titles among gamers developed by beloved company Valve. These games truly are for everyone: great for children (since it is all about puzzle), extremely original, humorous, and - most importantly - many mature gamers have the same respect for these games as they do for their murder-simulators. It seems the media likes to think we turn up our nose to games that have anything but a mature rating. That is not the case - its not the violence that sells a game (well, I certainly hope not) but rather the story and the content. All we could hope for is the media to take a break from trying to convince our parents we are sociopaths and recognize there are several titles we hold dear that are not rated mature.
3. Journey
Advertisement
Wondering what another non-violent game is doing in this argument? Allow me to explain, for many of the same reasons the Portal series is here this game came out of nowhere and has taken the gaming world by storm. It just recently swept the 16th Annual D.I.C.E Awards and leads the pack in nominations for the Video Game BAFTAs. Not to mention it has been one of the few games to break out of just video game related awards and was nominated for a Grammy for its incredible score. When talking to non-gamers, this is the game often brought up. This game also shows a new aspect to multi-player, though the media most likely believes its just a run-and-gun world where everyone goes guns-crazy and kills friends and strangers. Unfortunately, that description is absolutely right, but this game shows there can be a beautiful experience to be had that includes zero violence. Instead you are paired with a complete stranger who you wander around with, the player may be brand new like you, or maybe he is an expert who is there to guide you to safety while showing you all the secrets to the world that he has uncovered along the way. You know nothing about the person you are traveling with and if you don't know what you are doing there is no fear of being cursed out. It is truly glorious and an experience worthy of being enjoyed by almost everyone, almost.
2. The Walking Dead
Everyone knows about The Walking Dead, whether its the TV series, the comic books, or the game that shocked and surprised everyone last year. Even with its comic book look and feel the game still managed to be one of the goriest games of the year. However, rather than cheering on the violence like one would do for Mortal Kombat you often find yourself just as disgusted as Lee and little Clementine. For a mature rated title, one might assume this game would be all guts, guns, and glory, but in a shocking turn of events, it's more about story, your dialogue choices, building relationships with the colorful cast of fellow survivors, and most importantly keeping Clementine safe. I cant imagine anyone who wouldnt feel a connection to Lee and Clem. Lee is the cliché everyday hero with a dark past, and Clem proves that not every kid in the apocalypse is annoying and inadvertently screws everything up. Lee and Clem are awesome, the game is awesome, and it showcases that gamers do have emotions. We dont just sit there with our mouths gaped open glaring with blank stares of hatred (well, not always). That is why it is a top choice for a lot of awards shows and websites as the best game of last year.
1. Red Dead Redemption
Advertisement
Finally, the game that could redeem the industry in the eyes of the media. Developed by Rockstar games, the same company responsible for the devilish GTA series, this game is often dubbed as GTA but in the West. That is true, considering its the same company, the same mechanics, another glorious open world, and the typical amazing anti-hero protagonist but in reality the game is much deeper than that. GTA punished you for committing crimes, but not really - you escape your wanted level and suddenly no one remembers you. In Red Deads world you truly are punished. You gain a bounty on your head, you lose your honor, you can no longer help strangers that cross your path, and people run in fear whenever you stop by town. This game rewards you for being a hero, helping strangers is fun while riding across the gorgeous world, you get discounts in stores in dusty towns, strangers know your name and introduce themselves with enthusiasm, and playing as a hero makes the story that much better. Rather than the gritty Niko Bellic you play as John Marston, who is arguably as gritty but those days are behind him. Now he is a family man who would much rather just heard his cattle, raise his son away from a life of crime, all while respecting the vows of marriage (thats right media no sex with prostitutes in this game). Of course, he gets dragged unwillingly back into the world of crime in order to save his family. The story is great, the characters are even better, and John Marston has to be one of the greatest protagonists to grace this generation. If the media cant gain respect for this game knowing its from the same minds of the GTA games they hate so much, then I suppose nothing will change their minds. At the very least, maybe it will remind them of their Clint Eastwood-watching days and they can get some enjoyment out of that. Rant over! What other games do the media consistently get wrong in the reports? What games do you think just might change their minds? Let us know in the comments.