6 Beloved Video Game Franchises That Died In 2017

They're never coming back.

By Scott Tailford /

Bioware

Take a step back and analyse the games industry right now, and you'll find it's one hell of a brutally efficient beast. Or at least, it certainly tries to be.

Advertisement

Yes, games get released buggy as hell, pre-order bonuses are tacked onto even the most threadbare of projects and every other title is a shooter, but each move is calculated years in advance. Thanks to the rise of social media, widespread consumer feedback and the sheer fact that with constant online connections, developers and publishers can literally monitor which parts of their games are being interacted with the most, it's resulted in thousands of video games that SHOULD (and that's the key word here) fly off the shelves.

You see the same thing in Hollywood. Movies like King Arthur, Pixels, Jurassic World - all combinations of "surefire" successful elements resulting in soulless, synthetic, forgettable nonsense.

Advertisement

Back to gaming, and that pursuit of the focus-tested "perfect product" has resulted in far more IPs getting their most recognisable and cherished aspects gutted or heavily modified.

When the mandate is "please everyone", no one is truly satisfied...

Advertisement

6. Need For Speed

EA

On track to be the next Burnout, Need for Speed: Payback looked very promising before launch. Developed by the newly-minted Ghost Games (comprised of people from Criterion, Black Box and Playground), there was more than enough combined talent to produce a glorious return to form for the arcade racing genre.

Advertisement

Actually play Payback though, and you'll find something that handles like trying to guide a piece of bread through treacle. And why? Because of course, the game now has a loot grind, locking every part of a car's individual components behind a number generator.

Now, this wouldn't be enough to kill a franchise outright (though the horrifically cringeworthy "story" and "characters" might), but also factor in that NFS had another reboot back in 2015 - one that nobody played.

Advertisement

2017's edition was also prey to the backlash from Battlefront 2's microtransaction controversy, seeing EA attempt to tweak the numbers and make the experience more palatable.

At this stage, after so many years of trying to be Fast & the Furious in everything but name (and charm, characters or appeal), EA would be far better served approaching Vin Diesel and his team over at Tigon to do something instead.

Advertisement

5. Mass Effect

Bioware

Right from the get-go, something felt "off" about Mass Effect Andromeda. Even the name not being a numbered instalment brought about questions of "... but why?", rather than anything more purposeful.

Advertisement

Following that, a complete lack of trailers or gameplay demos was a terrible way to go, leading to a 4K tech showcase that focused on some "next generation" lighting models, only for the EA Origins early demo to tank the entire thing. Within minutes the whole world was seeing unfinished animations, broken and buggy combat, and just a supreme lack of polish.

It was disastrous.

Advertisement

The script had "mass-market comedy" written all over it, with both male and female character options crowbarring jokes into every possible exchange. Even post-release there was no letup, as it turned out months' worth of infighting between EA's studios resulted in nothing being finished, and EA's big-wigs actively told coders to focus on the multiplayer instead.

And what was inside the multiplayer? Microtransactions! Now at least that part of this makes sense...

Advertisement

4. Shadow Of Mordor/War

Warner Bros.

It's already one problem when a franchise can't even lock down a name.

Advertisement

Back in 2014/2015 this was going by its full title of "Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor", only to drop the first half on various digital storefronts, and then have something of a rebrand for the sequel.

Most annoyingly, was the reality of seeing publisher meddling at war with developer intent in the game. Whoever coded the microtransaction marketplace to have an orc gleefully rubbing his hands together is some sort of rebels-infiltrating-the-Death Star genius, as you'll go from solid, enjoyable combat to protracted loot grinds-requiring-better-gear-and-orcs-from-blind boxes the next.

Advertisement

Ultimately it feels like you're engaging with slot machines and number generators rather than more of the Tolkien fiction-twisting fun that was Shadow of Mordor. Any progress made (and there is a lot) with how many dynamic encounters can come from orc nemeses are constantly undercut by being overly grindy and repetitive overall.

Here's hoping Shadow of... Whatever can think of something, because this was a poor, poor showing.

Advertisement

3. Titanfall

Respawn Entertainment

Three words: "Bought by EA".

Advertisement

Yes, Titanfall was always published by EA, but until last year, Respawn remained an independent developer - something that was obliterated when EA purchased them entirely for $400 million.

And do you know what happens to literally every studio EA buys? They die. They die, after having been bled dry by their corporate overlords.

Advertisement

It happened to Bullfrog, Pandemic, Maxis, Dreamworks, Blackbox - it even happened to Visceral back in October.

EA have a godawful track record with this sort of thing, and as we saw across 2017 with Need for Speed, Battlefront 2, UFC and Mass Effect, microtransactions/blind boxes will be prioritised, and quality will go right down the sh*tter.

Advertisement

Titanfall 3 is still coming, but the soul and spirit that was present in those first two games? That is long gone.

2. Saints Row

Deep Silver

Saints Row became of those franchises you didn't know the developers had no idea what to do with... until they didn't. That's a maligned statement, but after the magnificent Saints Row The Third, part four was fine if not more of the same, and Gat out of Hell was... terrible.

Advertisement

Following this we were told Volition would be starting up a whole new cast of characters with Agents of Mayhem, set in a specific strand of time that fractured off from the end of Saints Row 4.

Come launch and all our worst fears were confirmed. Clearly publishers Deep Silver were seeing just how much money blind boxes were making, and Agents was stuffed with RNG number-grinds, generic upgrades and bland, mass-market characters.

Advertisement
Deep Silver

Even the inclusion of Johnny Gat showed the devs hadn't a clue how to showcase the best parts of why so many fell in love with Saints 3, leaving a product that bombed critically, commercially and culturally.

Yes, there could be a return to Saints Row in the future, but when the first two games are so demonstrably different to the following three, this reboot has failed and there's no meaningful identity to pick back up -can it really happen?

Advertisement

1. Halo

Bungie

The only release Halo saw in 2017 was Halo Wars 2, though there are more factors to Halo kicking the bucket than just one RTS spin-off not selling well.

Advertisement

Firstly, of course yes, this sequel selling 150k units in its first week is disastrous considering the original broke a million, but take that alongside the fact that Halo 5 was - and still is - the worst-selling numbered instalment so far.

2017 saw Microsoft announce that 343 Industries would finally fix the Master Chief Collection (which has remained broken and unplayable since 2014), resulting in the mildest mouse fart of celebration, yet most disastrously is the Halo Championship 2017 which was a shell of its former self.

Advertisement

Halo used to be so big, the launch of Halo 3 actually shut down Times Square. Developers wished they could have the same communities as Bungie had with its fans, and we all loved pouring thousands of hours into the multiplayer.

Halo 4 dealt a mortal blow, 5 put it on life support, and Halo Wars, the complete lack of fanfare and a naff Championship Tournament finished it off.

Advertisement

R.I.P.